Interesting question.
A childhood favorite of mine was
The Greatest Story Ever Told, with Max von Sydow as Jesus Christ. The spirituality in it is somewhat more subtle than other films, and I always loved the scene where Christ heals the blind old man in Nazareth, the only one to treat Him kindly. You see Jesus approach him, He touches his eyes, and the man begins to speak to Him. Yet when the old man looks up, no one is there.
Another childhood favorite was
The Robe. When I saw it as a kid I sympathized with Richard Burton’s character, because his detest of the robe seemed to be what my own spirituality was, even into my adulthood - I knew of Christ, but this sensation of loving God was altogether new to me, and I didn’t know what to make of it. As an adult I love it even more, in particular the ending. As the two main characters are being led away to martyrdom, the Emperor Caligula is cackling madly, “They’re going into a better kingdom! They’re going to meet their king!” Words of mockery that are words of joy for those who believe.
During my Muslim days I saw
The Passion of the Christ, and although it didn’t convert me it had a big affect on me, and it still does to this day. I know many still criticize it for the violence, but I always defend it by saying it’s the “Saving Private Ryan of crucifixion movies.” What I mean by this is when a soldier got hit by a 50-caliber bullet in
Saving Private Ryan, the movie showed you what getting hit by a 50-caliber bullet looked like; similarly, when
The Passion shows the Roman scourging Jesus, they show you what scourging looked liked. I also greatly appreciate the human aspect that Gibson gave Christ and His mother - when I first saw the film I was crying at the scene where the Virgin Mary has the flashback of Jesus as a little boy and goes running to Him. It’s easy for us to read that the Theotokos was at the foot of the cross, but it’s difficult for us to imagine what it must have been like for a mother to see her son be mocked publicly, scourged, beaten, and then crucified.
One film that isn’t necessarily religious but which I think has a lot to say is
There Will Be Blood. Even though the only Christianity shown is a crazy Charismatic church run by preacher Eli (Paul Dano), I think there’s a lot to be said about the character of the oil baron Plainview (Daniel Day Lewis) and his experiences there. There’s a scene where he “confesses” before the whole church, and supposedly does repent in a later scene, but then in the very next scene is shown to have not changed at all - he repented outwardly, but not inwardly.
Some honorable mentions:
Children of the Corn and the original
The Wicker Man. Although these films probably aren’t going to be liked well by most Christians, what took me by surprise was that although both films dealt with the subject of religion, neither film seems to look at Christianity negatively. The kids in
Children believe a mockery of Christianity as taught to them by a demon, and the protagonist even tells them that they’re following a false faith, adding that any religion without love is not a real religion. As for
Wicker Man, the policeman who visits the island is a devout Christian who is shocked by the pagan rituals on the island, and although tempted he never loses his faith, right up to the surprising ending. I also couldn’t help but notice that the film seemed way ahead of its time: aren’t we now forsaking the Christian God for the pagan gods of old, who rely on pleasure and what we perceive nature to be?
Just some thoughts