karma

  • Thread starter Thread starter quixotic
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Q

quixotic

Guest
hi there…
was just wondering what you guys think about karma.
thanks… am a little confuse
i know that you reap what you sow, but isnt our god a forgiving god??
 
which guys are you asking? isn’t this a Buddhist or Hindu concept?
 
lol everyone out there…
i know it is a non christian belief but am just a tad confuse
have to write a paper on my religion class…
 
then you better google the topic, since you won’t get the info on a Catholic forum you need for homework on a non-Christian religion topic. It is not a Catholic concept.
 
i did…
i just need support for it. i know it is not… am reading the new advent…
am trying to see why it is not a catholic point of view
 
lol everyone out there…
i know it is a non christian belief but am just a tad confuse
have to write a paper on my religion class…
Would it be too late to read
*False Gods Counterfeit Spirituality in an Age of Anxiety *by Michael Whelton
 
“Karma” simply means “action”. And all actions have consequences, as we all know. Consequence is termed “vipaka”.

“Karma” need not be associated with the idea of reincarnation, nor rebirth. “Christian karma” is simply “Christian action”.
 
well, since there are good and bad spirits, it may be assumed they give off good and bad karma…its simply an outward expression of negative or positive energies…some dont understand karma, and i ceratinly dont completley…so just believe what u want on this one. i doubt you’ll go to hell for beleiving in positive enrgy…🤷
 
“Karma” simply means “action”. And all actions have consequences, as we all know. Consequence is termed “vipaka”.

“Karma” need not be associated with the idea of reincarnation, nor rebirth. “Christian karma” is simply “Christian action”.
I’m trying to find my books on this; one by Whelton, the other by the late Fr.Seraphim Rose, but from recollection they wrote similar about karma and how it denies free will - because some things act upon you from previous actions, tc.
 
right now i feel that karma is kinda like tit for tat.
thanks so much for the feedback 🙂

can anyone help me with Galatians 6:7 “Don’t delude yourself: God is not to be fooled; whatever someone sows, that is what he will reap.”

is that a little karma??? what goes around, comes around??
 
I’m trying to find my books on this; one by Whelton, the other by the late Fr.Seraphim Rose, but from recollection they wrote similar about karma and how it denies free will - because some things act upon you from previous actions, tc.
The Buddha addressed this 2500 years ago. Your past actions (karmas) have consequences (vipakas), yes, but these consequences don’t prevent you from exercising your free-will. If you ate too much chocolate cake last night, then, yes, you will suffer, but your suffering can’t prevent you from choosing to eat sensibly next week.
 
lol. i think i am in troble for that as well… mine was too many a slice of pizza and coke… 😛
 
The Buddha addressed this 2500 years ago. Your past actions (karmas) have consequences (vipakas), yes, but these consequences don’t prevent you from exercising your free-will. If you ate too much chocolate cake last night, then, yes, you will suffer, but your suffering can’t prevent you from choosing to eat sensibly next week.
just got me thinking again. what bout purgatory?? isnt that like paying for our sins??? aarrggg… ignorance is bliss.
 
As normally cited, karma refers to the principle that “what goes around comes around.” It’s spiritualized in Eastern religions, of course, with the good karma, bad carma, having some interesting effects.

Stepping back, we can see where the concept came from. It came from simple observation. Just as surely and frequently as time heals all wounds, time wounds all heels. So incorporating that into spiritual beliefs is not at all inappropriate, because it appears as an ubiquitous principle.

Christianity goes Eastern religions one better (in my view) on this one. Christianity, through St. Paul, told us that we reap what we sow, a statement that is parallel to the general statements about karma. But St. Paul made it clear that he was not talking about some impersonal force or principal. He gave a reason for it: God will not be mocked.

Blessings,

Gerry
 
As normally cited, karma refers to the principle that “what goes around comes around.” It’s spiritualized in Eastern religions, of course, with the good karma, bad carma, having some interesting effects.

Stepping back, we can see where the concept came from. It came from simple observation. Just as surely and frequently as time heals all wounds, time wounds all heels. So incorporating that into spiritual beliefs is not at all inappropriate, because it appears as an ubiquitous principle.

Christianity goes Eastern religions one better (in my view) on this one. Christianity, through St. Paul, told us that we reap what we sow, a statement that is parallel to the general statements about karma. But St. Paul made it clear that he was not talking about some impersonal force or principal. He gave a reason for it: God will not be mocked.

Blessings,

Gerry
A good post 👍
 
hhmm i dont understand about god being mock. how are we mocking god? or what was happening at that time that st paul wrote the letter. i re read the chapter a few times and from what i understand, he is asking us to do good and god will reward us with the consistency of the good work we do…
 
The Buddha addressed this 2500 years ago. Your past actions (karmas) have consequences (vipakas), yes, but these consequences don’t prevent you from exercising your free-will. If you ate too much chocolate cake last night, then, yes, you will suffer, but your suffering can’t prevent you from choosing to eat sensibly next week.
Excepting that your previous actions put you in a position where you’d be tempted by the chocolate cake

Your lack of progression, or perhaps even a regression in the reincarnation process has placed you there.
 
hi there…
was just wondering what you guys think about karma.
thanks… am a little confuse
i know that you reap what you sow, but isnt our god a forgiving god??
Karma is false, and it is unmerciful.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top