Keep gutting the UN

  • Thread starter Thread starter Boatswain2PA
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Trump isn’t an isolationist. I don’t think he really ever projected himself as one. His logo was “Make America Great Again”. Basically this was to put America first and foremost in economy and other endeavors. I am personally disappointed that he has been as much of an interventionist as he is, although he is far less so than his recent predecessors.

The future of America being “one of the crowd” may be prophetic if they continue the costly quest of world policeman. I don’t see it’s demise in the near future, but there is an insurmountable cost that comes with being the “Big Dog” and a continuing spreading of itself thinner and thinner around the world.
 
May I assume that you may be also anti-birth control? If not, then you may applaud its efforts to reduce runaway population growth in nations where that problem leads to starvation and disease in the hundreds of thousands, and not by abortion as much as by simple birth control.
Killing people to prevent starvation and disease is not the answer. I am supportive of efforts to improve maternal and infant health care.

One reason the Church is opposed to birth control is because artificial contraception (pills) are primarily abortifacient. This means that they prevent the fertilized embryo from implanting in the uterus. For us, the embryo is a human being, and starving/killing it by removing a safe place to thrive is as much murder as it would be removing the infant from the mother and exposing it on the top of a snowy mountain a day after birth.

I agree, UNICEF has done some good things, and I also agree that it is not just “one issue”. that being said, if we cannot start by identifying and protecting life itself, how can we move forward? How can we deal with hunger and disease when we cannot recognize when a human being exists?

This is what I told the Obama supporters when they said the same thing. They came to my door, and tried to talk about other issues like education. I said “come back when Obama has figured out who the citizens are he is here to serve. If he cannot recognize a human being, there is nothing left to discuss”. I know it sounds harsh, but it is a non-negotiable.
 
If they need to cut $285 million perhaps a wiser choice would be to cut down the moving castle that is paid for by the U.S. taxpayers every time President Trump moves his people to Mara Lago since we’d be talking about well over 100 million to date, not to mention the real wastes occurring via the efforts of our current administration, the one wanting to cut the U.N. budget.
I agree, one trip to Mara Lago can pay for a whole years of Meals on Wheels for Seniors.
 
Mutual economic inter-dependency promotes peace, historically
But is it true? There is a lot of economic inter-dependency between the U.S. and China, and yet China appears to be still supporting North Korea. There was plenty of it before WWI and WWII as well.
 
If France and Germany had been as reliant on each other in 1914 as they are now, war would have been unthinkable. China and the US have nowhere near the economic interdependence as, say, the EU, or even the NAFTA members.
 
I should have known the paragraph at the end of your entry 26 regarding Trump’s cost for trips to Mara Lago was actually more important to you than the “big picture” UN issues. I see someone else has responded to your comment about saving money by cutting out Trump’s vacation expenses. I thought the direction of the thread was intended to address the wastefulness or usefulness of the UN and the US involvement in financing it, but it has to come down to another left sided Trump dig. May I remind you that excessive vacation expenses was also an issue under Obama, where it was estimated his personal trips for he and his family amount to more than 100 million dollars. This thread can be turned into another left-right insult session I suppose about Trump. However, it sounds like there is room for your concerns about unnecessary expenditure and alleged Trump financial waste for personal vacations to best be addressed in another thread. Why don’t you start one on that?

Trump did make some promises in his campaign about the UN, and lessening the US financial involvement and that it should be shouldered more by other nations. Personally, it doesn’t matter to me which party is in power in regard to the UN. Both parties have fully supported the UN up to this point and don’t want to relinquish their grip on it. From my understanding, the US involvement in the UN and the lion’s share of finances has historically been carried primarily by the US… I think Trump may be the first president in a long time to remotely address this. He feels there needs to be more balance between nations on this issues.

Once again, my personal preference would be that the US would leave the UN completely, but I don’t see that happening. I realize I am a minority on this, so my thoughts fall on deaf ears.
 
It’s mostly true. Of course there are no hard and fast rules but, in this issue, it’s historically verified much more than not. Exceptions will occur, sadly. But even in those few cases, war avoidance is more motivated when economics of this type work.
 
It should be noted that, by having the U.N. in the U.S., there are many economic advantages that work to offset the expenses, to whit: the diplomats consume services and products with the inherent sales taxes, jobs, etc.
 
Not “more important” as, rather, a comparative point having to do with the perspective of relative importance, meaning, the expense of Trump’s moving around (not necessarily for vacations by the way) is far more expensive than they should be and made worse by the noise he generates regarding U.N. expenses, if one can take his statements on this subject at his word.
 
40.png
guanophore:
I agree, one trip to Mara Lago can pay for a whole years of Meals on Wheels for Seniors.
. . . which should be funded by voluntary private charity, not with money confiscated from unwilling citizens.

D
Do you have some evidence that a majority of citizens are against funding Meals On Wheels through taxes?
 
Do you have some evidence that a majority of citizens are against funding Meals On Wheels through taxes?
I don’t need such evidence. There is no basis in the Constitution that would make such funding legal.

D
 
Are you talking about the trips to Mar a Lago?
I was responding to (and quoted) guanophore’s post. I didn’t say anything about the Mar-a-Lago trips; therefore, I wasn’t talking about them.

D
 
I was responding to (and quoted) guanophore’s post. I didn’t say anything about the Mar-a-Lago trips;
Huh?

Your quote:
I agree, one trip to Mara Lago can pay for a whole years of Meals on Wheels for Seniors.
i was just wondering which of the two items that are paid by taxpayers, and, contrary to your disclaimer, was mentioned in the quote, were you objecting to?
 
Last edited:
40.png
niceatheist:
Do you have some evidence that a majority of citizens are against funding Meals On Wheels through taxes?
I don’t need such evidence. There is no basis in the Constitution that would make such funding legal.

D
Neither does the constitution forbid it. There’s an old common law notion that the Founding Fathers would have been very aware of; “that which is not forbidden is permitted”.

But really, that’s not what you said. You said the money was “confiscated from unwilling citizens”, so keeping in mind that the Constitution does not forbid Congress or the several states from raising taxes, nor does it forbid Congress or the legislatures of the several states from earmarking such revenues for many purposes, let’s deal with your claim that the citizens are unwilling.
 
Take another look at #52. What you give as a quote from me is actually from guanophore.

Edit: Ah, I took another look, and I see where you got confused. I should have bolded the Meals-on-Wheels part of guanophore’s quote.

D
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top