D
dfp42
Guest
My question is on sin. I’ll use an example.
If a fallen away Catholic doesn’t know that missing Mass on Sunday was a mortal sin, and you explain (in love) to them that it is and show them various documents CCC etc, Do they now know? Are they know responsible for this obligation going forward if they continue to miss Mass on Sundays?
I’m having a hard time with this is the answer is “no” because it would seem that then everything educators of the faith teach -by telling and showing could somehow be bliss because that person could get off on the sin by saying they really didn’t understand and have full knowledge. It like saying to someone 1 + 1 = 2 and regardless of what you say that’s the answer. Most people would agree because the truth is what it is. But lets just say there really is someone who thought it was 3 instead. Is it still not their fault because they didn’t really know even if you told them a million times that 1 + 1 = 2?
I think of this also with things written in the natural heart like killing or taking a life. We all know this is wrong don’t we? But say a mental insane person didn’t know, is this a good excuse for killing?
I’m just trying to figure out more about speaking the truth to people when technically the person isn’t held responsible anyway out of their own ignorance.
If a fallen away Catholic doesn’t know that missing Mass on Sunday was a mortal sin, and you explain (in love) to them that it is and show them various documents CCC etc, Do they now know? Are they know responsible for this obligation going forward if they continue to miss Mass on Sundays?
I’m having a hard time with this is the answer is “no” because it would seem that then everything educators of the faith teach -by telling and showing could somehow be bliss because that person could get off on the sin by saying they really didn’t understand and have full knowledge. It like saying to someone 1 + 1 = 2 and regardless of what you say that’s the answer. Most people would agree because the truth is what it is. But lets just say there really is someone who thought it was 3 instead. Is it still not their fault because they didn’t really know even if you told them a million times that 1 + 1 = 2?
I think of this also with things written in the natural heart like killing or taking a life. We all know this is wrong don’t we? But say a mental insane person didn’t know, is this a good excuse for killing?
I’m just trying to figure out more about speaking the truth to people when technically the person isn’t held responsible anyway out of their own ignorance.