Last rites may be denied to Catholics seeking death, says archbishop

  • Thread starter Thread starter saintjohnxxiii
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

saintjohnxxiii

Guest
But, last rights could be given and then let God decide what to do next! Nobody should be denied this sacrament surely?
 
But, last rights could be given and then let God decide what to do next! Nobody should be denied this sacrament surely?
God is the one to do the deciding !! But for the priest to co-operate in someones sin is not right at all. I am so thankful that these serious moral situations are not up for grabs by those of us that think they have all the answers. We don’t automatically have a “right” to the Sacraments. They are gifts from God that must be welcomed and received in true Faith. God Bless, Memaw
 
But, last rights could be given and then let God decide what to do next! Nobody should be denied this sacrament surely?
I would think theologically Priest would not give absolution for a sin you were intent on committing. Acknowledging it needs absolution shows you know it is mortal, planning on completing it shows lack of remorse. Therefore I would think it would be problematic.

Both you and the Priest would answer for it on judgement day.
 
Well, Jesus gave peace to the sinner on the cross next to him. I am sure Jesus wants us to give peace too. At the end of the day, only God can decide what is right.
 
Well, Jesus gave peace to the sinner on the cross next to him. I am sure Jesus wants us to give peace too. At the end of the day, only God can decide what is right.
And that is why HE gave us His Church to guide us in all truths. We do not have the final say and we would be wise to follow His Church guided by the Holy Spirit!! The “Good Thief” was a repentant sinner! The other thief was not and he wasn’t given the same promise by Jesus as the “Good Thief” was. Let’s don’t forget that!!! God Bless, Memaw
 
Well, Jesus gave peace to the sinner on the cross next to him. I am sure Jesus wants us to give peace too. At the end of the day, only God can decide what is right.
He gave peace to the man on the cross next to him because that man repented, something that is required for forgiveness. The person intent on assisted suicide is not repentant, so he can’t receive absolution.
 
Well, Jesus gave peace to the sinner on the cross next to him. I am sure Jesus wants us to give peace too. At the end of the day, only God can decide what is right.
He gave the repentant thief absolution because he asked for it. Notice that the thief who mocked Jesus and told him to save himself did not receive the same assurance.

The problem in the case of someone who is intent on committing suicide is that the priest already knows they are intent on committing a mortal sin (self murder). So even if they gave them last rites, the person seeking death would immediately lose sanctifying grace by the commission of a mortal sin.

The purpose of last rites isn’t to give someone peace. It’s purpose is to prepare a soul for Heaven through the remission of sin. Assuming the Apostolic Pardon is given it also remits temporal punishment. So to what purpose is the remission of sin when someone will knowingly commit another sin?

On top of that, offering last rites to someone committing suicide can be construed as implicitly accepting that it is an acceptable way to end one’s life. The Church grieves for God’s children that take their own lives, but She cannot condone that it is a Godly thing to do.
 
lifesitenews.com/news/canadian-archbishop-no-last-rites-for-catholics-planning-assisted-suicide
Since suicide is a “grave sin” — being contrary to the 5th commandment against murder — it would be in “direct contradiction” to Catholic values for a person intent on assisted suicide to demand last rites, that is the Sacrament of Anointing of the Sick, stated Archbishop Terrence Prendergast of Ottawa.
“Asking to be killed is gravely disordered and is a rejection of the hope that the rite calls for and tries to bring into the situation,” the archbishop stated in an interview with Canadian Catholic News last week.
Any person who requests assisted suicide “lacks the proper disposition for the anointing of the sick,” he added…
 
Makes perfect sense to me. It could be a deterrent. That statement from the bishops alone could save lives.
 
He gave the repentant thief absolution because he asked for it. Notice that the thief who mocked Jesus and told him to save himself did not receive the same assurance.

The problem in the case of someone who is intent on committing suicide is that the priest already knows they are intent on committing a mortal sin (self murder). So even if they gave them last rites, the person seeking death would immediately lose sanctifying grace by the commission of a mortal sin.

The purpose of last rites isn’t to give someone peace. It’s purpose is to prepare a soul for Heaven through the remission of sin. Assuming the Apostolic Pardon is given it also remits temporal punishment. So to what purpose is the remission of sin when someone will knowingly commit another sin?

On top of that, offering last rites to someone committing suicide can be construed as implicitly accepting that it is an acceptable way to end one’s life. The Church grieves for God’s children that take their own lives, but She cannot condone that it is a Godly thing to do.
I agree and I believe the person asking for the Last Rites under those circumstances, KNOWS what they are about to do is seriously WRONG. Asking for the Churches Blessing before doing such a sinful act is a Sacrilege and presumption and would do more harm to them than they probable can imagine. God Bless. Memaw
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top