When the High Priest and the Chief Judge saw the hardness of his heart, they would not make a reply to his words. They saw that he would revile even against God. They had him bound and delivered him into the hands of the officers. They sent him to Zarahemland, to be brought before Alma and the Chief Judge, governor over all the land.
When he was brought before Alma and the Chief Judge, he went on to blaspheme in the same way that he did in Gideonland. He spoke in great swelling words to Alma. He reviled against the priests and teachers. He accused them of leading the people after the silly traditions of their fathers. He accused them of using these teachings to glut in the labors of the people.
Alma said to him, “You know that we do not glut ourselves on the labors of this people. I have labored from the beginning of the reign of Judges. I have worked with my hands for my support. This is despite my travels in the land, to declare the word of God to my people. Despite the labors I have performed in the church, I have never received so much as even one senine for my labor. Neither has any of my brothers, unless in the judgment seat. Then we received compensation for our time, according to the law. We do not receive any thing for our labors in the church. What does it profit us to labor in the church, unless it was to declare the truth? We only wish to rejoice in the joy of our brothers. Why do you say that we preach to this people to get gain? You yourself know that we receive no gain. We only wish to give them the joy of salvation. Do you believe that we deceive this people? ”
Korihor answered him, “Yes.”
Alma said to him, “Do you believe that there is a God?”
he answered, “Nay.”
Alma said to him, “You deny again that there is a God. You also deny the Christ. I know that there is a God, and also that Christ will come. What evidence do you have that there is no God, or that Christ will not come? I say that you have no evidence. It is only your word. I have a testimony that these things are true. You also have a testimony to you that they are true. Will you deny it? Do you believe that these things are true? I know that you believe, but you are possessed with a lying spirit. You have put off the spirit of God, and it has no place in you. The Devil has power over you. He carries you about, that he may destroy the children of God.”
Korihor said to Alma, “Show me a sign, that I may be convinced that there is a God. Show me that he has power. Then, I will be convinced of the truth of your words.”
Alma said to him, “You have had signs enough. Will you tempt your God? You have the testimonies of all your brothers, and prophets. The Scriptures are laid before you. All things say that there is a God. Even the earth, all things on the face of it, its motion, and the planets that move in regular ways, all these things witness that there is a Supreme Creator. Yet, you go about, leading people away, testifying to them there is no God. Will you deny all these witnesses?”
He said, “I will deny, unless you show me a sign.”
Alma said to him, “I am grieved because of the hardness of your heart. You resist the spirit of the truth, and your soul may be destroyed. It is better that your soul be lost, than that you should be the means of taking many souls to destructions, by your lying and flattering words. You will become dumb, and will never open your mouth again. You will not deceive this people any more.”
Korihor said to him, “I do not deny the existence of a God, but I do not believe that there is a God. I say you do not know that there is a God. Unless you show me a sign, I will not believe.”
Alma said to him, “I will give you a sign. You will be struck dumb, according to my words. I say in the name of God, that you will be struck dumb. You will no more be able to speak.” When Alma said these words, Korihor was struck dumb. He could not talk.
When the Chief Judge saw this, he wrote to Korihor a note, asking him, “Are you convinced of the power of God? You asked Alma to give you a sign. Would you prefer that he put suffering on others, to show you a sign? Will you argue this any more?”
Korihor wrote, “I know that I am dumb, for I cannot speak. Nothing, except the power of God could do this to me. I also knew that there was a God. The Devil has deceived me. He appeared to me in the form of an angel, and told me to go and reclaim this people, for they have all gone astray after an unknown God. H taught me what to say. I have taught his words, because they were pleasing to the carnal mind. I taught them, and had success. I began to believe that they were true. Because of this, I resisted the truth, until I brought this curse upon myself.”
When he said this, he begged Alma to pray that the curse might be taken from him. Alma said to him, “If this curse would be taken from you, you would again lead away the hearts of this people. It will be as the Lord wills.” The curse was not taken from Korihor. He was cast out. He went about from house to house, begging for his food.
What had happened to Korihor was immediately published throughout all the land. The proclamation was sent out by the Chief Judge, to all the people in the land. It declared that those who had believed in the words of Korihor must quickly repent, or the same judgments would fall on them.