Let's talk about Star Wars!

  • Thread starter Thread starter buzzoff1031
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Ok, so I saw a posting about collections and it got me to thinking that I’d like to talk about my love of Star Wars. I hope others here can share in that, because I love that galaxy far, far away. I watch the movies all the time (yes even the prequel trilogy–PT), I read the books, I watch the Clone Wars animated series…I’m absorb as much as I can. What about you guys?
Luv star wars
 
Agreeing with Simon Pegg, I think George Lucas betrayed what creative vision he had.

Like a 6 year old with a painting, he keeps adding adding, and “fixing” his work until he ends up with a murky mess.

In refusing to listen to other people with better story telling sense we end up with the “eh” episodes 1-3. We have to endure endless bloated CG “action” sequences, “wire/bungee fu” and the most hoary, ever-repeated cliches.

By the way, Han shot first.:cool:
 
True, not entirely over-bearing as Palpatine but evil nonetheless.
It’s been a while since I read that trilogy, but am I correct in that he was the only non-human to achieve his rank. I vaguely remember something about the Emperor not allowing non-humans into upper echelons of leadership.
I like this new direction…🙂 Yes, the Thrawn trilogy mentions that the Emperor loathed non humans. Can’t remember if those books state that he was the only non human Grand Admiral, though it would stand to reason. Those books by Zahn are my fave in the EU.
 
Agreeing with Simon Pegg, I think George Lucas betrayed what creative vision he had.

Like a 6 year old with a painting, he keeps adding adding, and “fixing” his work until he ends up with a murky mess.

In refusing to listen to other people with better story telling sense we end up with the “eh” episodes 1-3. We have to endure endless bloated CG “action” sequences, “wire/bungee fu” and the most hoary, ever-repeated cliches.

By the way, Han shot first.:cool:
Haha that is a very good anology. I think maybe people just put to much trust in Lucas after the succes of the first movies. He definately isn’t the greatest screen writer. 😃
 
Haha that is a very good anology. I think maybe people just put to much trust in Lucas after the succes of the first movies. He definately isn’t the greatest screen writer. 😃
Indeed not. And he’s also a terrible director (American Grafitti, anyone). No, Lucas’ strength lies in editing and story creation. Seriously, Indiana Jones and Star Wars are literally my two favorite franchises in pop culture. Good stuff in those things.
 
big fan so you can add me to the list;) anyone know of the planned live action tv series that george wanted to do, thats supposed to take place between the 2 trilogies?
 
I believe, since most of this time period is dealt with in the EU, they decided to 86 this idea.
 
Indeed not. And he’s also a terrible director (American Grafitti, anyone). No, Lucas’ strength lies in editing and story creation. Seriously, Indiana Jones and Star Wars are literally my two favorite franchises in pop culture. Good stuff in those things.
Agreed! I would still welcome more Star Wars films if he got someone else to direct and co-write it.

A live-action Star Wars TV show would be cool. I don’t mind cartoons at all though. The clone wars was pretty good.
 
The thing about Han is his smuggling bad boy character was gone. He was just the good guy now. It seemed to me they were using him for comic relief.
Maybe I’m just biased because my schoolgirl crush was Han Solo. (I remember being practically the last kid to see Star Wars in my town, and all the girls were gushing about Luke, but I found him rather ho-hum looking and developed a crush instead from the first sight of Han Solo in the cantina.) So I took changes to good/responsible guy as character development … after all, there were years in between episodes and video wasn’t quite so prevalent to allow watching over-and-over way back then (though I did have the novelizations).
 
I like this new direction…🙂 Yes, the Thrawn trilogy mentions that the Emperor loathed non humans. Can’t remember if those books state that he was the only non human Grand Admiral, though it would stand to reason. Those books by Zahn are my fave in the EU.
Zahn’s were my favorites as well. I wanted so badly to like Shadows of the Empire, but just really couldn’t. Mainly, I didn’t like Perry’s writing style, and I had issues with some of the way he portrayed some of the original characters. Plus Dash Rendar; he was an unneeded character.
 
Zahn’s were my favorites as well. I wanted so badly to like Shadows of the Empire, but just really couldn’t. Mainly, I didn’t like Perry’s writing style, and I had issues with some of the way he portrayed some of the original characters. Plus Dash Rendar; he was an unneeded character.
Agreed. Zahn is far and away the best writer, so far, for the SW EU. However, have you had a chance to read the Han Solo trilogy by A.C. Crispin? She’s a darn good writer as well, apprently. I thoroughly enjoyed those books and it made the Han we see in Ep. IV make sense. Good stuff.
 
Agreed! I would still welcome more Star Wars films if he got someone else to direct and co-write it.

A live-action Star Wars TV show would be cool. I don’t mind cartoons at all though. The clone wars was pretty good.
The Clone Wars are excellent! However, I agree with you that a live action show would be awesome! (Mostly because Lucas wouldn’t have the time to tinker it to death…)
 
Agreed. Zahn is far and away the best writer, so far, for the SW EU. However, have you had a chance to read the Han Solo trilogy by A.C. Crispin? She’s a darn good writer as well, apprently. I thoroughly enjoyed those books and it made the Han we see in Ep. IV make sense. Good stuff.
I haven’t read the Han Solo Trilogy, Might have to pick those up. With the exception of the Bounty Hunter Wars and Shadows of the Empire, the books I’ve read are New Republic era.
 
I haven’t read the Han Solo Trilogy, Might have to pick those up. With the exception of the Bounty Hunter Wars and Shadows of the Empire, the books I’ve read are New Republic era.
I hear you. I like the story to continue as well. However, I do like to go back and learn the “history” of how we got to the OT.
 
Reboots seem to be all the rage these days (Batman, Spiderman, Star Trek, etc.). I wonder if Lucas would attempt to continue the Star Wars live action movie saga with new actors recast as Luke, Han, etc.

I shudder at the thought of trying to retell episodes IV through VI with new actors and a new vision. But new blood might be able to create sequels to tell the story after Return of the Jedi. The Zahn trilogy (Heir to the Empire, Dark Force Rising…) could be a lot of fun on film, but I don’t exactly trust Lucas to pull it off.
 
It was quite legitimate self-defense. Greedo had him at blaster point and had just announced his intention to kill Han.

Of course, can we ever forget the abomination that is Jar Jar Binks?:crying:
 
Maybe I’m just biased because my schoolgirl crush was Han Solo. (I remember being practically the last kid to see Star Wars in my town, and all the girls were gushing about Luke, but I found him rather ho-hum looking and developed a crush instead from the first sight of Han Solo in the cantina.) So I took changes to good/responsible guy as character development … after all, there were years in between episodes and video wasn’t quite so prevalent to allow watching over-and-over way back then (though I did have the novelizations).
Yep…I had a horrible crush on Han Solo as well…lol :o
 
Reboots seem to be all the rage these days (Batman, Spiderman, Star Trek, etc.). I wonder if Lucas would attempt to continue the Star Wars live action movie saga with new actors recast as Luke, Han, etc.

I shudder at the thought of trying to retell episodes IV through VI with new actors and a new vision. But new blood might be able to create sequels to tell the story after Return of the Jedi. The Zahn trilogy (Heir to the Empire, Dark Force Rising…) could be a lot of fun on film, but I don’t exactly trust Lucas to pull it off.
Unless I’m mistaken, Lucas has said definitively that he will not make any more movies (however, infintely tinkering with what he already has made until they’re no longer recognizable is a different story…).
 
Reboots seem to be all the rage these days (Batman, Spiderman, Star Trek, etc.). I wonder if Lucas would attempt to continue the Star Wars live action movie saga with new actors recast as Luke, Han, etc.

I shudder at the thought of trying to retell episodes IV through VI with new actors and a new vision. But new blood might be able to create sequels to tell the story after Return of the Jedi. The Zahn trilogy (Heir to the Empire, Dark Force Rising…) could be a lot of fun on film, but I don’t exactly trust Lucas to pull it off.
Lucas would NEVER use the Zahn trilogy as a basis for a sequel trilogy if there was one…why? Because its NOT “His” Vision to have Luke NOT be a hermit (I am pretty sure that he said that Luke would probably end up being an Obi-Wan Kenobi like figure and never get married). I LOVE the Zahn trilogy…I remember when I first learned about Heir to the Empire…a classmate of mine had read it for a book report in 7th grade…that summer I went and purchased a copy in paperback.

Anyway…I would prefer Lucas NOT make a sequel trilogy because he has also been known to say that only the droids would be the characters in it that we would recognize…everyone else would be dead or something. Plus, I don’t trust him to write a good story anymore…as I said, the prequels to me were weak…I hated the way he killed off two of my favorite characters in Episode 3 + the horrible scene…well, not saying, but I was upset at that…very upset…he didn’t actually SHOW it…but still it was very upsetting. Plus, we get only ONE tiny little glance at Alderaan! ONE!
 
Maybe I’m just biased because my schoolgirl crush was Han Solo. (I remember being practically the last kid to see Star Wars in my town, and all the girls were gushing about Luke, but I found him rather ho-hum looking and developed a crush instead from the first sight of Han Solo in the cantina.) So I took changes to good/responsible guy as character development … after all, there were years in between episodes and video wasn’t quite so prevalent to allow watching over-and-over way back then (though I did have the novelizations).
Hehe, nothing against Han. He is certainly one of the most enjoyable charactors, I just was dissapointed with the charactor in Episode 6. I was dissapointed with that episode as a whole though. Harrison Ford is a great actor though.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top