Let's talk about Star Wars!

  • Thread starter Thread starter buzzoff1031
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Han was the only one who got a shot off in that scene. The book is clear that Greedo had his gun pointed right at Han’s chest and it’d have been impossible for him to miss at that distance even if he had fired simultaneously w/ Han.

I don’t think I liked a single change made to the original trilogy from the way they were when I first saw them (waiting years in between episodes).
 
My concern with “Star Wars” is that people literally ascribe to the religion of “The Force” as the highest power, exactly what is given as the religion of the Anti-Christ in Daniel.
 
No mention of the Easter Eggs when the Millenium Falcon is flying through the asteroid field?
 
I’m not seeking to offend you but you’re wrong in that you bought into George Lucas’s line of BS for changing Sebastian Shaw into Hayden. Remember the whole “prophecy of the Chosen One” that will “bring balance to the force?” Well if you want to make sense out of a non-sensical GL line of BS look at it this way, Darth Vader reverted back to Anakin Skywalker when he saved his son by killing the Emperor at the end of ROTJ. But if anyone simply wants to accept what GL feeds you at face value I’ll be glad to play George Lucas apologetics with you.

GL has added in an obscene amount of useless **** to the Special Editions and DVD editions of the OT, in this instance it was a tie-in to Hayden’s Anakin in the then upcoming Revenge of the Sith movie.

It also plays into GL’s money grubbing obsession to make any minor change to justify the re-release of the movies. Here’s what I can think of off hand:

Star Wars OT on CBS-Fox VHS in 80’s
Star Wars OT on THX Enhanced VHS in 90’s
Star Wars Special Edition OT on VHS in 90’s
Star Wars DVD OT in 2004 (Special Edition with more **** added)
Star Wars OT on Blu Ray (2004 DVD edition converted for Blu Ray)
Star Wars OT (Original Theatrical Edition) on DVD
Star Wars OT (Original Theatrical Edition) on Blu Ray

Now we’re getting the Prequels in 3D, BTW The Phantom Menace 3D was a box-office flop. I’m at the point where I’ll just keep my unaltered OT VHS tapes and watch them while getting rid of all the other altered OT and Prequel stuff I was stupid enough to buy.
No, I don’t really buy into it at all (that’s why I didn’t know exactly what the rationale was). GL does do anything possible that will make him a buck. So does pretty much everyone else in Hollywood. I do, my a large margin, prefer the OT unaltered to anything else put out by Lucasfilm. The EU (books and comics, and KotOR 1) would be second. However, the other stuff (other than the terrible, terrible holiday special) is good too, IHMO, because it’s still SW. It’s nowhere near as good as the OT…not even close. But I can’t say I hate it.
 
This link will list and describe the Easter eggs that can be found on the asteroid field, plus those found in other scenes. The asteroid field is a very interesting place!

eeggs.com/tree/1781.html

DGB
Well, as if I didn’t have enough reasons to be obsessed with these darn movies…LOL. Thanks though. I’ll definitely check it out.
 
My son just gave me the neatest bumper sticker. It looks like a political campaign sticker and says:

OBI-WAN KENOBI 2012 Our Only Hope
 
Well just found this thread. I am a Star Wars fan no doubt. Mostly the movies not really all the books and such.
And I can’t decide if I like that change or not. I think, and please someone correct me if I’m wrong, that when there are apparitions in SW it is from when they were last light side. At least that’s the explaination for why they changed to Hayden. Still not sure if I like or not though…
I dislike the change. Why would Anakin suddenly look younger, why not Obi Wan and Yoda, why does he get the young body lol. Luke wouldn’t even recognize him.

The excuse seems to be is this is Anakin form before he turned evil, still I don’t like changes, leave the movie be. Besides Anakin was already messed up in Episode 3. If they wanted innocence they should have showed him from the first film lol. I don’t like to associate the original trilogy with the prequels either way.
You know what I always hated? The dumb ewok song at the end of Return of the Jedi, when they were celebrating the end of Darth Vader.

Thank God they put in that new song…there is singing in it too, but it was not like that horrible first song

Old ewok song:

youtube.com/watch?v=np6vAuS0KNs

New Song (Victory Celebration by John Williams) :

youtube.com/watch?v=oGM0vbRIDnc
Honestly I think the old song fits the film better. The ewoks were silly and childish and the song fit them. The whole movie was just a step down from the first two. Han had lost his charm, the Deathstar battle just felt like a re-hash. The only thing I really liked was the parts when the Emperor, Vader, and Luke were together. Those scenes were pretty fantastic. The rest of the film was lacking though.

I like the new song but it just doesn’t save the film or any of the parts with the ewoks in it. 😃
 
Well just found this thread. I am a Star Wars fan no doubt. Mostly the movies not really all the books and such.

I dislike the change. Why would Anakin suddenly look younger, why not Obi Wan and Yoda, why does he get the young body lol. Luke wouldn’t even recognize him.

The excuse seems to be is this is Anakin form before he turned evil, still I don’t like changes, leave the movie be. Besides Anakin was already messed up in Episode 3. If they wanted innocence they should have showed him from the first film lol. I don’t like to associate the original trilogy with the prequels either way.
I agree–part of the whole point of the ghost scene was to show that he had been redeemed at the end, which was when he died during Episode 6.
Honestly I think the old song fits the film better. The ewoks were silly and childish and the song fit them. The whole movie was just a step down from the first two. Han had lost his charm, the Deathstar battle just felt like a re-hash. The only thing I really liked was the parts when the Emperor, Vader, and Luke were together. Those scenes were pretty fantastic. The rest of the film was lacking though.
I like the new song but it just doesn’t save the film or any of the parts with the ewoks in it. 😃
Well, I disagree about Han losing his charm, and the death star redux felt too deja vu and that was before I knew that it supposedly took 20 years to complete death star 1 and then 3 years to get the bigger version done (not to mention WHY after death star 1 gets blown up). The new song is nice enough, but the original one is a kick-up-heels-and-dance celebration. I also don’t buy everyone in the galaxy suddenly wanting to celebrate–the news wouldn’t travel that fast and I rather imagine that there were plenty of people actively on the side of the Empire who wouldn’t celebrate the emperor’s death and other people who quite frankly don’t care who’s in power as long as they can live their lives as always.
 
I agree–part of the whole point of the ghost scene was to show that he had been redeemed at the end, which was when he died during Episode 6.

Well, I disagree about Han losing his charm, and the death star redux felt too deja vu and that was before I knew that it supposedly took 20 years to complete death star 1 and then 3 years to get the bigger version done (not to mention WHY after death star 1 gets blown up). The new song is nice enough, but the original one is a kick-up-heels-and-dance celebration. I also don’t buy everyone in the galaxy suddenly wanting to celebrate–the news wouldn’t travel that fast and I rather imagine that there were plenty of people actively on the side of the Empire who wouldn’t celebrate the emperor’s death and other people who quite frankly don’t care who’s in power as long as they can live their lives as always.
Yea the news definitely wouldn’t spread that fast and its not like the empire would just be gone just because the Emperor died.

The thing about Han is his smuggling bad boy character was gone. He was just the good guy now. It seemed to me they were using him for comic relief.
 
Wasn’t there speculation in one of the book series, “Heir to the Empire” or other one, that said the Emperor was using the Dark Side to “mind control” a lot of the people under him and worlds. Doubt he was THAT powerful, but I vaguely remember something to that effect. If that were the case, then perhaps once the control was lifted, those that were under the mind-control would be freed thus having the cause to celebrate.

There were those that sought to regain control the Empire, my favorite being Grand Admiral Thrawn.
 
True, not entirely over-bearing as Palpatine but evil nonetheless.
It’s been a while since I read that trilogy, but am I correct in that he was the only non-human to achieve his rank. I vaguely remember something about the Emperor not allowing non-humans into upper echelons of leadership.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top