Life among the wokescolds

  • Thread starter Thread starter JimG
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

JimG

Guest
The famous Times Square kiss by a sailor at the news of the end of the war has been in the news lately.

But this professor’s students didn’t like it. She didn’t consent. It was an assault. Right there in public. Well, today she probably would have started a movement and a Twitter war. Back then, she just slapped him. But the photo still made the cover of Life magazine.

The prof worries that his students are not only scolds, but clueless, humorless, and puritanical.

 
I’m possibly in the minority, but I wasn’t a fan of that article. I don’t think it’s fair the professor labelled the girl’s point of view as “crazy ravings”. She’s right that the woman in the photo didn’t consent to being suddenly kissed and it’s understandable from her point of view she doesn’t see it as a “photo of joy”.
 
I think that he dismissed her comment because he’d heard so many exactly like that from the same young woman–I’m sure she would not appreciate your calling her a girl and would let you know how demeaning that is at length.

Anyway, the writer of that letter totally has a point. I have met people like that, and now I know why they are like that. They can not lighten up. You make jokes and from time to time they will smile… slightly.

They also often miss literary techniques: allusions, plays on words, idiomatic expressions. To me, that is just weird, but also very sad. They are missing the best part of our language!

The literalness is astounding. You can see it here on CAF.
 
Sorry but I disagree with the professor and Dreher.
Am I a wokescold? No. A Puritan? Well, I do share some of their Reformed theology (excludes the floggings they did, which could have been applied in this case), so…
 
Last edited:
I’m sure if the professor and/or author was grabbed on the street and forcibly kissed by a larger and stronger man, they would feel differently.
 
I’m sure she would not appreciate your calling her a girl
That’s a fair point, genuinely. I should have called her a woman.
Anyway, the writer of that letter totally has a point.
Perhaps so, but the example he gave wasn’t a good one. If the woman sees the image as showing a sexual assault, there’s no way she’s seeing joy in that. And the professor demeaning her opinion of it as “crazy ravings” only exemplifies that she’s right to not find joy in the photo.
 
Well, the girl did slap the sailor and then moved on, as did the sailor. Eisenstadt, the photographer didn’t get a chance to get their names.

Today, of course, it would have started a new and different kind of war. But this was VJ day in Times Square, and everybody was celebrating.

Come to think of it, did any of the women involved in the MeToo movement take the trouble to slap their attackers? In any case, the photo made the cover of Life. We are no doubt much more civilized today.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top