Looking at Women

  • Thread starter Thread starter crdgz
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Respectfully, on what basis can any Catholic “admire” a woman’s breasts or rear end? Even married couples - I don’t know of any husbands who “admire” their wive’s breasts or rear end - which is what OP is asking about.
You don’t know of any husbands who admire their wives’ breasts or butt? Uh…really? I’m a married man and I certainly like looking at my wife’s body. What exactly is wrong about me feeling physical attraction for my wife? If someone only admired their spouse for their physical characteristics instead of the totality of their person, then, sure, that would be objectifying and wrong. But there’s nothing wrong with physical attraction being a component of love.

To get back to the OP, it’s a judgment call and there is a line. Certainly it’s totally natural for single young people to notice attractive members of the opposite sex. That’s typically how couples form: with an initial spark of physical attraction. That said, you can’t go overboard and reduce the person to an object for you to ogle. So if you’re at school, OP, and you see an attractive girl, great. It’s totally fine for you to notice that she has a nice figure. If you’re attracted to her, maybe strike up a conversation with her and ask if she wants to get coffee.

You just have to be careful that you don’t become so focused on her physical characteristics that you forget she’s a fully fledged human being, not simply a nice set of curves.
 
Last edited:
I stand by my comments. I have zero tolerance for sexual harassment, and I do not understand why it’s so problematic to simply tell the OP that what he’s doing (admiring a woman’s butt and breasts) is sinful when in fact it is a sin and would need to be confessed. If OP wants to be a “creep” and grow up to be a sexual harasser, that’s his prerogative - please don’t belittle me for helping a fellow guy when we should stick together and stand together against sexual harassment. (And, yes, if it’s unwelcome and uninvited, then it’s harassment by any reasonable definition of the word.)
 
Last edited:
I stand by my comments. I have zero tolerance for sexual harassment, and I do not understand why it’s so problematic to simply tell the OP that what he’s doing (admiring a woman’s butt and breasts) is sinful when in fact it is a sin and would need to be confessed. If OP wants to be a “creep” and grow up to be a sexual harasser, that’s his prerogative - please don’t belittle me for helping a fellow guy when we should stick together and stand together against sexual harassment. (And, yes, if it’s unwelcome and uninvited, then it’s harassment by any reasonable definition of the word.)
You’ve been reported for saying the OP wants to be a creep, and wants to grow up to be a sexual harasser.

This expressly uncharitable and against forum rules.
 
You’ve been reported for saying the OP wants to be a creep, and wants to grow up to be a sexual harasser.

This expressly uncharitable and against forum rules.
That was MrsAngela’s post #12 (see above), which I agree with.

You can’t report someone for stating correct, and factual, information that what the OP is describing constitutes sexual harassment. I’m the one being charitable here - he’ll thank me when he’s older.
 
I stand by my comments. I have zero tolerance for sexual harassment, and I do not understand why it’s so problematic to simply tell the OP that what he’s doing (admiring a woman’s butt and breasts) is sinful when in fact it is a sin and would need to be confessed. If OP wants to be a “creep” and grow up to be a sexual harasser, that’s his prerogative - please don’t belittle me for helping a fellow guy when we should stick together and stand together against sexual harassment. (And, yes, if it’s unwelcome and uninvited, then it’s harassment by any reasonable definition of the word.)
I have zero tolerance for sexual harassment too. What the OP is describing is not sexual harassment. It’s just not. No legal system defines it this way. There is a world of difference between a momentary glance and a creepy guy following a woman for six blocks, staring at her butt and salivating. You’re overstating by a factor of ten.
 
Last edited:
No legal system defines it this way.
Actually, if “admiring” a woman’s breast and butt creates a “hostile work environment” - or “hostile school environment,” as the case may be - for the woman being “admired,” EVERY legal jurisdiction accepts that definition of sexual harassment.

Meanwhile, the hate squad wants to report me for helping the guy out before he gets to “creep” status.
 
40.png
BoomBoomMancini:
No legal system defines it this way.
Actually, if “admiring” a woman’s breast and butt creates a “hostile work environment” - or “hostile school environment,” as the case may be - for the woman being “admired,” EVERY legal jurisdiction accepts that definition of sexual harassment.

Meanwhile, the hate squad wants to report me for helping the guy out before he gets to “creep” status.
To be clear, I didn’t report you and don’t think you should have been reported.

But yes, I totally agree: IF a guy is staring at a woman’s breasts while she is working and making her uncomfortable, of course that’s not appropriate. But that’s not what we’re talking about. We’re talking about a momentary glance on the sidewalk, not OP camped out like a pervert in the bushes.
 
OP’s original message (message #1): “but some on here have said that it is okay to look/glance at a (fully clothed) womens beasts or rear end, as long as we don’t imagine having intercourse with her, or make her seem like just an object.”

Who, pray tell, would have told this kid that it’s ok to look at a woman’s butt or breasts as long as there’s no lustful thoughts? THAT’S NEVER OK - AND ESPECIALLY NOT OK FOR A CATHOLIC GUY.

And, I’m the one being “uncharitable” here for calling a spade a spade? Maybe the hate squad should report whatever CAF member gave the OP a wink-wink on being a “creep” and sexually harassing women?
 
Last edited:
40.png
1Lord1Faith:
You’ve been reported for saying the OP wants to be a creep, and wants to grow up to be a sexual harasser.

This expressly uncharitable and against forum rules.
That was MrsAngela’s post #12 (see above), which I agree with.

You can’t report someone for stating correct, and factual, information that what the OP is describing constitutes sexual harassment. I’m the one being charitable here - he’ll thank me when he’s older.
MrsAngelala said nothing of that sort. Your defamation of her is incredible, and also reportable.
 
MrsAngelala said nothing of that sort. Your defamation of her is incredible, and also reportable.
Please keep your hateful comments to yourself. The OP should be sending me a thank you note. You’re the one violating forum rules.
 
OP’s original message (message #1): “but some on here have said that it is okay to look/glance at a (fully clothed) womens beasts or rear end, as long as we don’t imagine having intercourse with her, or make her seem like just an object.”

Who, pray tell, would have told this kid that it’s ok to look at a woman’s butt or breasts as long as there’s no lustful thoughts? THAT’S NEVER OK - AND ESPECIALLY NOT OK FOR A CATHOLIC GUY.

And, I’m the one being “uncharitable” here for calling a spade a spade? Maybe the hate squad should report whatever CAF member gave the OP a wink-wink on being a “creep” and sexually harassing women?
So do you think it is per se sinful for a single person to look at a member of the opposite sex and feel physical attraction? Where do you think all those Catholic couples at Mass came from? They just magically appeared in the choir loft?

It’s normal for men and women to notice one another and feel attraction. That’s how they usually pair off. Of course it’s wrong to leer and stare, but for a man to notice a woman has a nice figure (or for a woman to notice a man is well built) and feel a spark of attraction is completely innocuous. You keep conflating it with “being a creep” for some reason that eludes me.
 
MrsAngelala said nothing of that sort. Your defamation of her is incredible, and also reportable.
1Lord1Faith, your hateful and uncharitable comments were flagged and reported. Stop violating forum rules.
 
So do you think it is per se sinful for a single person to look at a member of the opposite sex and feel physical attraction? Where do you think all those Catholic couples at Mass came from? They just magically appeared in the choir loft?
No. Of course not. That’s silly.

What is sinful is to “admire” a woman’s butt and rear end. That’s called being a “creep,” it’s sexual harassment, and I’m not aware of any Catholic couple who ever met because the guy hit on her by complimenting her butt.
 
I didn’t flag it. I said it was reportable.
Well, I flagged and reported your posts. Enough with the hateful and uncharitable comments when I am complying with the forum rules. STOP VIOLATING FORUM RULES. This isn’t the old CAF, and don’t expect me to take people’s hateful, uncharitable attacks anymore without some push back.
 
40.png
BoomBoomMancini:
So do you think it is per se sinful for a single person to look at a member of the opposite sex and feel physical attraction? Where do you think all those Catholic couples at Mass came from? They just magically appeared in the choir loft?
No. Of course not. That’s silly.

What is sinful is to “admire” a woman’s butt and rear end. That’s called being a “creep,” it’s sexual harassment, and I’m not aware of any Catholic couple who ever met because the guy hit on her by complimenting her butt.
You keep moving the goal posts. No one is suggesting that a man go up to a woman and go, “Hey there, you sure have a tight ass. Let’s see a movie.” Obviously not: that would be rude and inappropriate and low class.

But a woman’s body is part of her physical appearance as much as her hair or her eyes. If a man notices a woman’s curves and feels attraction, how is that different than him noticing that she has pretty eyes or something? Obviously, he shouldn’t stare and fixate on her butt, but we’re talking him simply noticing, not staring and drooling like a dog looking at a pork chop.
 
40.png
randomuser888:
40.png
BoomBoomMancini:
So do you think it is per se sinful for a single person to look at a member of the opposite sex and feel physical attraction? Where do you think all those Catholic couples at Mass came from? They just magically appeared in the choir loft?
No. Of course not. That’s silly.

What is sinful is to “admire” a woman’s butt and rear end. That’s called being a “creep,” it’s sexual harassment, and I’m not aware of any Catholic couple who ever met because the guy hit on her by complimenting her butt.
You keep moving the goal posts. No one is suggesting that a man go up to a woman and go, “Hey there, you sure have a tight ass. Let’s see a movie.” Obviously not: that would be rude and inappropriate and low class.

But a woman’s body is part of her physical appearance as much as her hair or her eyes. If a man notices a woman’s curves and feels attraction, how is that different than him noticing that she has pretty eyes or something? Obviously, he shouldn’t stare and fixate on her butt, but we’re talking him simply noticing, not staring and drooling like a dog looking at a pork chop.
To expand on this, we all acknowledge that staring at a person, eyes fixated on her breasts or rear (or his groin or what have you), is morally wrong. Nobody’s trying to justify that, or justify loopholes in the logic. What we are trying to do is to educate the original poster (AND ANY OTHER READERS OF THIS THREAD) on the topic in a way that doesn’t encourage scrupulosity or the impression that simply noticing another person’s features and finding them attractive is sinful. We have a lot of scrupulous inquirers on this board. Maybe not the thread creator, but certainly others who may read this topic.
 
Last edited:
Good heavens, I never said the OP was a creep or a harasser! I thanked him for thinking carefully and stated how I would feel, as a woman, on the receiving end of the choices he’s asking about. The kid is just asking some questions. They’re real questions. Maybe we could cut him some slack? You seem to be very upset; I hope you’re able to find some peace.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top