*This is what I am experiencing right now. I “feel” so blindsided right now because I never thought forgiving anyone anything could ever be a selfish act.
I guess I will just go and ponder the whole thing some more.
*
I’m interested in hearing how you think forgiving can be selfish. Please forgive me if you’ve explained it and I missed it.
To me, “selfish,” or perhaps “self-directed,” is not necessarily a bad thing. If I forgive, it benefits me because my unforgiveness keeps me at arm’s distance from the Lord. So it’s selfish, in that it’s beneficial to me. But removing obstacles between the Lord and me is a selfish act that has good benefits. And not just to me. If I’m closer to God, then I will be better company for everyone else too, including the one who sinned. So I forgive, which helps me and which helps me be a “better me” for God and others, and if I do it so the sinner knows I’ve forgiven, then that says that you will not hold distance from the other person (and consequently Jesus – whatsoever you do … ) which is unifying to the entire Body of Christ.
So is it selfish? Depends – if you mean does it help me and is that the reason I do it? If so, then I’d say yes it’s selfish – a good kind of selfish. Right up there with proper nutrition and exercise is selfish.
If you have another context of “selfish” that is bothering you I’d like to hear about it.
One thought I did have is how do you believe it would differ if you were an actual victim?
No problem; I love to share thoughts when people are interested in hearing them.

If I am an actual victim, then “hating the sin” takes on a more personal context. If a kid throws a snowball at me and hurts me, I now have pain … and I’m thinking (brainstorming really I never tried to write any of this down) that I have to decide, “do I hate the fact that I’m feeling pain at the hand of that person?” I’m inclined to say, “no.” Because as far as the pain goes, it was from contact with the snowball without regard to how it was thrown at me. So yes, I suffer temporal pain from the snowball. Do I “hate” the pain? Well what if the kid and I were in the middle of a fight and having fun? I feel the pain, but I can still laugh about it. But if it was an unexpected attack from someone who was trying to hurt me, how does that increase the pain, or morph the pain into something that I now Must Hate?
I still don’t see “hate” as a requirement in dealing with all this. “Don’t like,” maybe, but not “hate.” I can dislike something without it causing me anxiety and anger, but can I hate without it? When I hear, “I hate it when that happens,” I normally take it to mean, “I dislike it when that happens,” most of the time. But for me, when it becomes “true” hate, it is destructive to the soul and causes anxiety. Anxiety is not from God; it’s from the hate.
The other thing I associate with “hate” is “revenge.” In the case of the snowball, if it’s friendly you say, “I’ll get you back” and you try to return the jocularity. If it’s hostile you might say, “I’ll get you,” and harbor ill feelings and wish to return the pain. So it isn’t the damage I inflict, but my thoughts about the one inflicting it, that make the difference in whether I experience what I call “true hate.” The kind of hate that makes your stomach churn.
Wow, this is such a wide topic I could go any number of directions with this. Hopefully something in there will provide some framework for further discussion.
Alan
PS my thoughts about “true hate” agree with the first definition of it as
dictionary.com: “to dislike intensely or passionately; feel extreme aversion for or extreme hostility toward; detest: to hate the enemy; to hate bigotry.”
Jesus did say “love your enemy.” Maybe this was His way of saying the hate is never required? That if we do have hate, we should do something to negate it?