Love the sinner, hate the sin?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Lady_Love
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
+JMJ+

What I am trying to say is that what I keep on reading in this thread comes from the viewpoint of being sinned upon instead of loving the sinner. That is what I mean by being “selfish”.

Let me put it this way. The attitude I keep getting here is: “I hate the sin because that sinner hurt me, but I will love the sinner anyway.” No; the attitude we should have is “I hate the sin because it is hurting the sinner, whom I love, more than me.”
Thank you for clarifying that and I believe I see your point. I wonder if it is because we somehow see our sins as hurting Jesus…do you believe our sins hurt Jesus?
 
Thank you for clarifying that and I believe I see your point. I wonder if it is because we somehow see our sins as hurting Jesus…do you believe our sins hurt Jesus?
We have to remember that we’re human beings. We can only speak about the divine using human language. To a certain extent, we have to use anthropomorphism when speaking about God.

God does not have emotions like we do. He certainly does not have a physical body capable of pain like we have. It’s impossible for us to emotionally hurt Jesus or to physically hurt him.

The term is used to mean that when we sin, we betray him and we ignore his love for us.

If we stop to think about it, that’s big. We certainly don’t handle betrayal well and we want others to accept our love.
 
+JMJ+As always, G.K. Chesterton has the answer to this, and the basic thing is, I think all of us are looking at “Love the sinner, hate the sin” wrongly, i.e. like a pagan:

Take another case: the complicated question of charity, which some highly uncharitable idealists seem to think quite easy. Charity is a paradox, like modesty and courage. Stated baldly, charity certainly means one of two things – pardoning unpardonable acts, or loving unlovable people. But if we ask ourselves (as we did in the case of pride) what a sensible pagan would feel about such a subject, we shall probably be beginning at the bottom of it. A sensible pagan would say that there were some people one could forgive, and some one couldn’t: a slave who stole wine could be laughed at; a slave who betrayed his benefactor could be killed, and cursed even after he was killed. In so far as the act was pardonable, the man was pardonable. That again is rational, and even refreshing; but it is a dilution. It leaves no place for a pure horror of injustice, such as that which is a great beauty in the innocent. And it leaves no place for a mere tenderness for men as men, such as is the whole fascination of the charitable. Christianity came in here as before. It came in startlingly with a sword, and clove one thing from another. It divided the crime from the criminal. The criminal we must forgive unto seventy times seven. The crime we must not forgive at all. It was not enough that slaves who stole wine inspired partly anger and partly kindness. We must be much more angry with theft than before, and yet much kinder to thieves than before. There was room for wrath and love to run wild. And the more I considered Christianity, the more I found that while it had established a rule and order, the chief aim of that order was to give room for good things to run wild.

Orthodoxy
Chesterton, as always, puts it brilliantly.
 
+JMJ+
Thank you for clarifying that and I believe I see your point. I wonder if it is because we somehow see our sins as hurting Jesus…do you believe our sins hurt Jesus?
Yes, I do of course believe our sins hurt Jesus, but in that every sin is an insult towards His Crucifixion for us, in which He died that we may be saved from our sins.
 
To put a different spin on the “Love the sinner, hate the sin” statement…

One thing I do like about this statement is it makes a clear definition between the sinner and the sin. That the “sin” is separate from the sinner, that the sinner is not therefore defined by his/her sin, that the sin is not the identity of the person. According to this statement wouldn’t it be wrong to identify someone as “a thief” or “gay” or “adulterer” etc.?

…or maybe it is EXACTLY right to identify the sinner with the sin? Are we not identified by what/who we love? Are we not the children of our God and if our God is sin maybe we should be identified with the sin?

…or maybe what God wants is for us to find our identity in Him and not our sin?

What do you think? Can anyone offer me some clarity?
I think it’s wrong to wrap up our entire identity in one particular attribute of ourselves. To make, say, being “gay” or “straight”, or “alcholic” or whatever central to our being. We are greater than the sum of our parts!

One of the most important steps to overcoming sins, is learning to love ourselves in spite of our particular sinful propensities and temptations. We have to look ourselves in the mirror and realize that this is an integral part of our makeup, and though we have these evil propensities, we also have great good in us as well. Both are intrinsic to our makeup and both are inseparable from us until we die.

We need to learn to accept ourselves as we are and in so doing we come to let God love us not because of the balance of our faults and qualities, but because God’s love is infinite. It’s hard to let someone love you when you hate yourself.

When we can learn to come to know ourselves intimately, to accept that this is who we are, and to strip away the false masks and to present ourselves to God and the world as-is, where-is, then we stop projecting onto others the hate we feel for our own shortcomings.

And that’s when we come to surrender to Him, and when we start to be able to overcome our sins… not for fear of hell, but because we want to so much reciprocate the love He has shown us.

That’s also when we stop using the “love the sinner, hate the sin” to really project the hate we feel for our own propensity to sin. Because we realize that we’re no better than the poor sinner we are pointing the finger at, because in reality, “love the sinner, hate the sin” often comes out sounding like the Pharisee saying “thank God I’m not like that poor sinner over there”. In reality, we are! When we finally open up to who we really are, warts and all, we can identify with the other’s sin, and instead of feeling “hate” for his sin (and in so doing attempting to condemn him), we feel empathy and a form of solidarity in prayer for him. Then we can show him the perfect hospitality that Jesus showed sinners and win him by love, not by condemnation.

There but for the Grace of God go I…
 
God does not have emotions like we do. He certainly does not have a physical body capable of pain like we have. It’s impossible for us to emotionally hurt Jesus or to physically hurt him.
.
I find this interesting. Being that God is not bound by time but yet came in time to suffer and die, didn’t what sins we currently commit transcend time to the moments He was alive in His un-glorified body? Didn’t all past and future events culminate in His passion, death and resurrection? So even though Jesus does not die again for our present sins, didn’t He suffer them on the cross? Even still, doesn’t Jesus say to Paul, “Why are you persecuting me?” Doesn’t Jesus suffer in, with, and through us as though it were done to Him? Aren’t we the mystical body in which He suffers still?
 
I find this interesting. Being that God is not bound by time but yet came in time to suffer and die, didn’t what sins we currently commit transcend time to the moments He was alive in His un-glorified body? Didn’t all past and future events culminate in His passion, death and resurrection? So even though Jesus does not die again for our present sins, didn’t He suffer them on the cross? Even still, doesn’t Jesus say to Paul, “Why are you persecuting me?” Doesn’t Jesus suffer in, with, and through us as though it were done to Him? Aren’t we the mystical body in which He suffers still?
Not in a physical sense. The Mystical Body is exactly that, mystical. It is not physical, even though it has physical members. Remember, the saints are also part of the Mystical Body. They don’t have a physical body, at least not in our time. They live outside of time and space. For all we know, they have already experienced the final resurrection. But that’s for apologetics.

At the Incarnation, Christ does become fully human. He feels pain, hunger, gets tired, sleepy and all those things that are part of being human. When he’s asleep in the back of the boat during the storm, he was not faking it just to look human. He was literally sleeping. He must have been a very deep sleeper, because he was sleeping through a storm. I live in FL and I can’t sleep when there’s a hurricane. That too is another story, better for the Weather Chanel.

However, at the cross, Christ enters into total darkness in which he comes face to face with sin, that is the sin of all humanity, from creation to the final judgment. In other words, he faced sin at a specific moment in history in a specific place in history and in a very specific way.

It’s not the crucifixion that moves forward in time. It’s effects extend beyond the year 27 in Jerusalem. Our sin contributed to the crucifixion. The crucifixion itself takes place at a specific point in history in a very specific place.

We don’t add to the pain of the cross when we sin. When we sin, that pain has already been factored in, because the cross extends beyond space and time. The case here is that we must choose, to sin or not to sin. God already knows and has factored our choice into his plans.
 
+JMJ+

Yes, I do of course believe our sins hurt Jesus, but in that every sin is an insult towards His Crucifixion for us, in which He died that we may be saved from our sins.
So if Jesus forgives us hurting Him, anthropomorphism speaking as Br.Jay said,and as you seem to be saying too. In following Him, are we not supposed to forgive others who have hurt us like He forgives us hurting Him? It is in the Our Father that we pray forgive us as we forgive those who trespass against us. What are we forgiving others of in this prayer if we are not supposed to be seeing others sins as not only hurting themselves but as hurting us also? I am sorry if I sound confused but right now in some ways I am so if you could reconcile this with what you said in your last post it might help and it would be greatly appreciated.
 
+JMJ+

Yes, I do of course believe our sins hurt Jesus, but in that every sin is an insult towards His Crucifixion for us, in which He died that we may be saved from our sins.
*ok, so do we hurt each other when we sin?

I am leaning toward the understanding that we do. Some of the reason is because we pray in the Our Father asking for forgiveness of not only our trespasses but also of those who have trespassed against us. If we do not sin against each other what are the trespasses then?

From what I see you describing as being “selfish” is just coming from the understanding that sometimes we are wronged by others. Usually this wrongness is caused by our sinfulness. So in a way I guess I see it as having to forgive each other for being wronged or unjustly treated by each other that is a result of the sin. So I do not believe people are saying they hate the sin because of how they were wronged by it but that they hate the sin regardless of the wrongness done to them but they also forgive the wrongness that was a result of that sin because they understand that there for the grace of God go I.
What I am getting from what you are saying when you say that people are coming from the selfish understanding is that you believe it is wrong to forgive someone for offending someone and that we should not even think about the wrongness that was done to oneself and that we should only concentrate on the sin it’s self and just leave the wrongness that was caused form that sin alone.
If that is the case why do we even bother to pray for forgiveness or ask for forgiveness of God or others for having wronged them?
Sorry to go on about this but I guess I am just not really understanding were you are coming from with your statement. If my questions make any sense and you can reconcile it with what you said earlier about coming from a selfish point maybe it will help me see it more clearly and that would be greatly appreciated.*
 
We have to remember that we’re human beings. We can only speak about the divine using human language. To a certain extent, we have to use anthropomorphism when speaking about God.

God does not have emotions like we do. He certainly does not have a physical body capable of pain like we have. It’s impossible for us to emotionally hurt Jesus or to physically hurt him.

The term is used to mean that when we sin, we betray him and we ignore his love for us.

If we stop to think about it, that’s big. We certainly don’t handle betrayal well and we want others to accept our love.
When we are betrayed and our love is rejected is it ok to forgive this betrayal and rejection of others as God forgives us our betrayal or rejection of Him and His love?
Or are we supposed to just ignore the betrayal and rejection and not even see that it even happened?
Or is it that God does just ignores our betrayal and rejection so we should do the same of others?
The reason I am asking is because I am getting from what nuntym mentioned about how coming from a selfish point is wrong and that we should not be forgiving anyone or giving forgiveness and that is really confusing me.
If you can help me to understand what nuntym is saying it would be greatly appriciated.
 
+JMJ+

What I am trying to say is that what I keep on reading in this thread comes from the viewpoint of being sinned upon instead of loving the sinner. That is what I mean by being “selfish”.

Let me put it this way. The attitude I keep getting here is: “I hate the sin because that sinner hurt me, but I will love the sinner anyway.” No; the attitude we should have is “I hate the sin because it is hurting the sinner, whom I love, more than me.”
I* was thinking some more about this and maybe the answer is that in order for us to have the attitude of “I hate the sin because it is hurting the sinner, whom I love, more than myself” we first have to forgive any wrongness that was caused to us by the sinfulness of the other. Does that make any sense? *
 
I think it’s wrong to wrap up our entire identity in one particular attribute of ourselves. To make, say, being “gay” or “straight”, or “alcholic” or whatever central to our being. We are greater than the sum of our parts!

One of the most important steps to overcoming sins, is learning to love ourselves in spite of our particular sinful propensities and temptations. We have to look ourselves in the mirror and realize that this is an integral part of our makeup, and though we have these evil propensities, we also have great good in us as well. Both are intrinsic to our makeup and both are inseparable from us until we die.

We need to learn to accept ourselves as we are and in so doing we come to let God love us not because of the balance of our faults and qualities, but because God’s love is infinite. It’s hard to let someone love you when you hate yourself.

When we can learn to come to know ourselves intimately, to accept that this is who we are, and to strip away the false masks and to present ourselves to God and the world as-is, where-is, then we stop projecting onto others the hate we feel for our own shortcomings.

And that’s when we come to surrender to Him, and when we start to be able to overcome our sins… not for fear of hell, but because we want to so much reciprocate the love He has shown us.

That’s also when we stop using the “love the sinner, hate the sin” to really project the hate we feel for our own propensity to sin. Because we realize that we’re no better than the poor sinner we are pointing the finger at, because in reality, “love the sinner, hate the sin” often comes out sounding like the Pharisee saying “thank God I’m not like that poor sinner over there”. In reality, we are! When we finally open up to who we really are, warts and all, we can identify with the other’s sin, and instead of feeling “hate” for his sin (and in so doing attempting to condemn him), we feel empathy and a form of solidarity in prayer for him. Then we can show him the perfect hospitality that Jesus showed sinners and win him by love, not by condemnation.

There but for the Grace of God go I…
*Thank you so much for sharing this insight I really like it and I believe I agree with it. If I could I would like to add how I see this in myself. In the act or process of forgiving the wrongness or sinfulness of another I come to understand and see that I am no better than they are. I see how much of a struggle I have with sin and I feel for them and their struggles and yes it does make me feel empathy for them and a form of solidarity in prayer does come from this.

I am just having a hard time right now seeing what nuntym seems to be saying about how forgiving some one is selfish. Can you offer any insight into this? *
 
Hating a sin is optional. And I think giving ourselves the “excuse” to hate the sin is not a healthy thought exercise. Because if there is a sin, and we hate it, then by golly there must have been a sinner who caused what we hate. Further, the experience of hating can block our entry into the kingdom.

Temporal effects are what they are, so I’m not talking about that. In fact, I’m assuming that I’m not angry or hurt by temporal effects of the sin for this post. So I’m not a “direct victim” in the following comments.

Spiritually, the sinfulness of someone else sin does not hurt me directly, and only indirectly because of how I think about it. When another person sins, how it affects them against God I am not to know.

I’m not talking about denial, or about letting my sibling fall into sin. I can observe what appears to be sinful behavior and inform the sinner of what I saw and why it’s important. I can inform the sinner of what I saw, and even my concern that it could be sinful. I don’t have to undergo the “hate” routine in my mind to accomplish that.

Take it another way. Think of a baby in a high chair, learning to eat with a fork. It takes a couple bites, then throws a loaded fork on the floor. Not to make me mad, but because it doesn’t realize that’s wrong. So I pick up the fork, wipe the floor, clean the fork, hand it back to the baby and say “don’t throw your fork on the floor.” Maybe if it’s the third time in a row you think it needs a little attitude adjusting you can even speak in stronger terms. But HATE? Do you really have to HATE the dropping of the fork?

So you say, “yes but the baby is innocent, and didn’t intend to sin when it threw down the fork. It didn’t know any better” Well guess what, we don’t know anything more about why others do things we see as sins. We see what we see, and unless they’ve already testified to it (in which case we are no longer charged with having to inform them) we have zero knowledge of whether they have full knowledge or intent. Jesus said, “forgive them for they know not what they do,” when they knew – the ones in charge anyway – that they just crucified an innocent man. And I’m supposed to experience “hatred” if a friend of my listens to a song I don’t approve of? Since he isn’t a baby I’m supposed to assume he has complete knowledge and intent? Why can’t I say, “I think that’s a bad song,” without having to HATE anything at all?

Back to the baby and the fork, the only way you could get “hate” out of it, is if you define “hate” as a discrepancy, or gap, between the way something is and the way you wish something is. I wish the baby didn’t throw the fork on the floor, because I hated the condition of it being on the floor and had to change it. Kind of like engineers “hate it” when they see something they would like to fix but can’t. In a mystical sense I suppose you could say that “gap” is like a separation and because it’s a separation then it is like sin or whatever, but in an emotional sense there is no call for doing hate. So like if the baby is learning to walk, each time it falls down there is a “gap” and we may even help it up, but we don’t have to “hate” the falling down. You say, “there is no sin in falling down,” and I say, “perhaps not, but things aren’t how I want them. I want that child standing up,” and proceed to help it stand up. So neither sinfulness or temporal effects justify hate. Excuse hate in some people’s minds, but not justify.

You may also object that the baby is just learning how to eat and the friend has lots of experience at listening to songs and should know better. Who has even talked to a psychologist about the word “should?” I have. It can be destructive. Don’t assume he knows better just because I think he should. I got into trouble when I was a little kid for things the teacher assumed I meant by what I said, when in fact they were in the suspicious mind of the teacher and totally blindsided me. At precisely what age should we assume that they no longer are innocent of what our “evil-knowing” minds believe they are? How about if the baby has been told three times not to throw the fork down, and maybe you even pat the back of its hand, and it thinks it’s a game – you look the other way and it did it again because it was amused at how you reacted last time. How does that differ materially from an adult sinning – it’s doing it to goad us into reacting? And yet only the unstable among us experience actual “hatred” when this happens.

The only way you can hate the sin is if you take it in the context that “it takes one to know one.” You see a person sinning because you know what sin is, and seeing it proves it to yourself. So in a mystical way, if another member of the Body sins, then so are you and I affected by the sin. Gosh I don’t know; that’s probably not even correct. I’m going out of my way here to find some contorted thinking by which hating is actually an obligation for a Christian.

Alan
 
Thank you so much for your post Alan.
I found it to be insightful and helpful in trying to wrap my brain around all of this.
This part of it spoke volumes for me:

You may also object that the baby is just learning how to eat and the friend has lots of experience at listening to songs and should know better. Who has even talked to a psychologist about the word “should?” I have. It can be destructive. Don’t assume he knows better just because I think he should. I got into trouble when I was a little kid for things the teacher assumed I meant by what I said, when in fact they were in the suspicious mind of the teacher and totally blindsided me.
*This is what I am experiencing right now. I “feel” so blindsided right now because I never thought forgiving anyone anything could ever be a selfish act.

I guess I will just go and ponder the whole thing some more.

One thought I did have is how do you believe it would differ if you were an actual victim?

You do not have to share your thoughts about it if you do not want to. I am just looking for some food for thought and thought I would ask… *
 
Thank you so much for your post Alan.
I found it to be insightful and helpful in trying to wrap my brain around all of this.
This part of it spoke volumes for me:


*This is what I am experiencing right now. I “feel” so blindsided right now because I never thought forgiving anyone anything could ever be a selfish act.

I guess I will just go and ponder the whole thing some more.

One thought I did have is how do you believe it would differ if you were an actual victim?

You do not have to share your thoughts about it if you do not want to. I am just looking for some food for thought and thought I would ask… *
I couldn’t help to read that you are questioning that forgiving someone could be selfish. Did i understood right. If so, oh good grace, if anything, it is an act of charity, love and totally an act of great love for God. We are to be merciful also, Jesus is clear in St Faustina dairy. Stick to the bible and Catholic teaching, seek your answer from the Holy spirit versus anyone pretending to know the truth. New age is very very tricky sweet heart, i am warning you.

We need to learn to forgive and stop over analyzing this but to trust.You are an amazing soul, please don’t allow any doubt anymore. You are on the right path and bravo for all of your accomplishment!
 
I couldn’t help to read that you are questioning that forgiving someone could be selfish. Did i understood right. If so, oh good grace, if anything, it is an act of charity, love and totally an act of great love for God. We are to be merciful also, Jesus is clear in St Faustina dairy. Stick to the bible and Catholic teaching, seek your answer from the Holy spirit versus anyone pretending to know the truth. New age is very very tricky sweet heart, i am warning you.

We need to learn to forgive and stop over analyzing this but to trust.You are an amazing soul, please don’t allow any doubt anymore. You are on the right path and bravo for all of your accomplishment!
Dear Chantal,
Thank you so much for reminding me of this:)…and your kind encouraging words. ok I am off to pray and ponder, my code word for stop over analyzing and trusting more, some more…and maybe clean the house or something.
 
I am presently experiencing a time when someone hates me. I am working on forgiving her as I have been forgiven. Every one of these posts have begun a healing in me. God bless all of you.
 
*This is what I am experiencing right now. I “feel” so blindsided right now because I never thought forgiving anyone anything could ever be a selfish act.

I guess I will just go and ponder the whole thing some more.
*

I’m interested in hearing how you think forgiving can be selfish. Please forgive me if you’ve explained it and I missed it.

To me, “selfish,” or perhaps “self-directed,” is not necessarily a bad thing. If I forgive, it benefits me because my unforgiveness keeps me at arm’s distance from the Lord. So it’s selfish, in that it’s beneficial to me. But removing obstacles between the Lord and me is a selfish act that has good benefits. And not just to me. If I’m closer to God, then I will be better company for everyone else too, including the one who sinned. So I forgive, which helps me and which helps me be a “better me” for God and others, and if I do it so the sinner knows I’ve forgiven, then that says that you will not hold distance from the other person (and consequently Jesus – whatsoever you do … ) which is unifying to the entire Body of Christ.

So is it selfish? Depends – if you mean does it help me and is that the reason I do it? If so, then I’d say yes it’s selfish – a good kind of selfish. Right up there with proper nutrition and exercise is selfish.

If you have another context of “selfish” that is bothering you I’d like to hear about it.
One thought I did have is how do you believe it would differ if you were an actual victim?
No problem; I love to share thoughts when people are interested in hearing them. 🙂 If I am an actual victim, then “hating the sin” takes on a more personal context. If a kid throws a snowball at me and hurts me, I now have pain … and I’m thinking (brainstorming really I never tried to write any of this down) that I have to decide, “do I hate the fact that I’m feeling pain at the hand of that person?” I’m inclined to say, “no.” Because as far as the pain goes, it was from contact with the snowball without regard to how it was thrown at me. So yes, I suffer temporal pain from the snowball. Do I “hate” the pain? Well what if the kid and I were in the middle of a fight and having fun? I feel the pain, but I can still laugh about it. But if it was an unexpected attack from someone who was trying to hurt me, how does that increase the pain, or morph the pain into something that I now Must Hate?

I still don’t see “hate” as a requirement in dealing with all this. “Don’t like,” maybe, but not “hate.” I can dislike something without it causing me anxiety and anger, but can I hate without it? When I hear, “I hate it when that happens,” I normally take it to mean, “I dislike it when that happens,” most of the time. But for me, when it becomes “true” hate, it is destructive to the soul and causes anxiety. Anxiety is not from God; it’s from the hate.

The other thing I associate with “hate” is “revenge.” In the case of the snowball, if it’s friendly you say, “I’ll get you back” and you try to return the jocularity. If it’s hostile you might say, “I’ll get you,” and harbor ill feelings and wish to return the pain. So it isn’t the damage I inflict, but my thoughts about the one inflicting it, that make the difference in whether I experience what I call “true hate.” The kind of hate that makes your stomach churn.

Wow, this is such a wide topic I could go any number of directions with this. Hopefully something in there will provide some framework for further discussion. 🙂

Alan

PS my thoughts about “true hate” agree with the first definition of it as dictionary.com: “to dislike intensely or passionately; feel extreme aversion for or extreme hostility toward; detest: to hate the enemy; to hate bigotry.”

Jesus did say “love your enemy.” Maybe this was His way of saying the hate is never required? That if we do have hate, we should do something to negate it?
 
*Hi Alan,

Thank you so much for that post. In so many ways it helped a lot with what I have been trying to wrap my brain around. Not sure I could explain it adequately but please know it did help a lot. I do not believe forgiving is selfish. I was just questioning what I understood someone else as saying. Sorry for the confusion.

On a side note, reading your posts reminds me very much of a story I used to read when I was a child and always loved. It is about the Wind and the Sun. I always liked that story and now I understand why.🙂 Thank you so much for sharing.

P.S. If you do not know the story I believe I could tell it in a condensed version.*
 
If you have another context of “selfish” that is bothering you I’d like to hear about it.
So I have been thinking about this some more and in talking with a friend this morning I can see that their can be an act of forgiveness that could be selfish. If we are forgiving for God and glorify Him by doing it that is good. When it becomes a selfish act would be when we do it for our own benefit and self glorification. It is something I find myself questioning all the time and I believe we all should be questioning. Are we doing what we are doing to glorify God or ourselves. Does this make sense?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top