Luke 4:6 from a newbie at studying Scripture

  • Thread starter Thread starter jgladwell
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

jgladwell

Guest
During the Temptation, why does Satan say “I shall give to you all this power and their glory; for it has been handed over to me, and I may give it to whomever I wish. All this will be yours, if you worship me.”

The references for this is Jeremiah 27:5 and Matthew 28:18
27:4 - and charge them thus: Tell your masters: Thus says the Lord of Hosts, the God of Israel: 27:5 - It was I who made the earth, and man and beast on the face of the earth, by my great power, with my outstretched arm; and I can give them to whoemever I think fit
Then Jesus approached and said to them, “All power in heaven and on earth has been given to me.”
Why would Satan be telling Jesus that he (Satan) has the ability to give anything to Jesus? Am I misreading this somehow?
 
During the Temptation, why does Satan say “I shall give to you all this power and their glory; for it has been handed over to me, and I may give it to whomever I wish. All this will be yours, if you worship me.”

The references for this is Jeremiah 27:5 and Matthew 28:18

Why would Satan be telling Jesus that he (Satan) has the ability to give anything to Jesus? Am I misreading this somehow?
As to why Satan says it, He is tempting Christ and as John 8:44 puts it: “for he is a liar and the father of lies” Satan hasn’t quite figured out the Trinity yet or he wouldn’t have bothered…
 
Satan can give Jesus all the secular things that Jesus preaches against. Men to follow Him. Money. Earthly praise. Power. Dominion. Of course all these are temporal things and not heavenly.

If Jesus sought these things from Satan, He would have had to turn away from His Mission and Satan would have prevailed.
 
During the Temptation, why does Satan say “I shall give to you all this power and their glory; for it has been handed over to me, and I may give it to whomever I wish. All this will be yours, if you worship me.”

Why would Satan be telling Jesus that he (Satan) has the ability to give anything to Jesus? Am I misreading this somehow?
Very good question but I don’t think anyone will be providing you with an adequate answer. I don’t think anyone, including academics, have a clue what it means that this particular authority had been given to Satan.

As to all power given to Jesus… first it actually says all authority, not power… secondly, Jesus is referring to what occurred after he rose from the dead… thirdly, read about “the prince of this world” or “ruler of this world” in the Gospel of John.
 
I am no scholar nor do I consider myself to be an expert on the bible. I read daily and spend at least part of every day and at least a couple of hours on Sundays reserching and trying to understand scripture. I think you might want to look at the Book of Job. In that Book, it clearly states that satan is given authority over the “world”. Which I take to mean the material world. In fact, if memory serves, the Book begins with a description of a meeting that takes place, seemingly periodically, between God and the Angels. Satan attends I assume because he started out as an angel. I think the passage is showing us that we should not be concerned with whatever “riches” this world may have to offer and instead choose the riches of salvation through Christ. Afterall, I am not a material being having a spritual experience. I am a spritual being having a material experience. I hoep this helps. And, if I got it wrong rebuke me gently please.😃
 
The best advice is to look for inspiration in scripture and don’t sweat the details. Inconsistencies are numerous. Here is one. In Matt the Holy Family flees from Bethlehem to Egypt then returns to Nazareth after Herod’s death.

In Luke Jesus is pressented in the temple on the 8th day of his birth and then Mary goes to the temple for purification. After these things were done the Family returns directly to Nazareth.

Examples like this are numerous. That’s why I think that the Church is correct in emphasizing that revelation is given through Scripture and Tradition.
 
jgladwell,
I am having the same problem, except it’s with matthew…I think 4 or 5.
Satan shows Jesus all the kingdoms of the world and says he can have them if he would just worship Satan.
Yeah, um, all of the kingdoms of the world are ALREADY His, so…
That’s like someone sitting on my front porch and offering to sell me my house for a dollar.
Good price and all, but I already own the place.
So, yeah, I don’t really get that.
Maybe Satan didn’t know Jesus was Lord? But then, who did he think Jesus was, exactly?
 
I’ve heard some speculation (I think a scholar or two even?) speculate that Satan didn’t really know that Christ was God at this point. Or at least may not have.

If Satan did know He was God then I think what this would be is about Satan tempting Christ’s human nature. How exactly that works with “God” I don’t know, but obviously Christ was subject to temptations even though He was God (otherwise He wouldn’t be fully human) so it’s also possible for Satan to tempt Christ with power even if logically speaking He had this “power” as God.

After all, Satan’s temptations aren’t always based on logic, sometimes it’s just their “appeal” that makes them tempting. Sin is “illogical” by nature after all.
 
I am no scholar nor do I consider myself to be an expert on the bible. I read daily and spend at least part of every day and at least a couple of hours on Sundays reserching and trying to understand scripture. I think you might want to look at the Book of Job. In that Book, it clearly states that satan is given authority over the “world”. Which I take to mean the material world. In fact, if memory serves, the Book begins with a description of a meeting that takes place, seemingly periodically, between God and the Angels. Satan attends I assume because he started out as an angel. I think the passage is showing us that we should not be concerned with whatever “riches” this world may have to offer and instead choose the riches of salvation through Christ. Afterall, I am not a material being having a spritual experience. I am a spritual being having a material experience. I hoep this helps. And, if I got it wrong rebuke me gently please.😃
Right you are about the book of Job. The evil one has been present since the foundation of this world. Since he is pure spirit and is outside of time, he waits until an “opportune time” (Luke 4:13). His first opportune time came early: he was present through the serpent in Eden, which was pure, undefiled earth before the fall. This was creation that, in God’s own sight, was “very good” (Genesis 1:31). It was without blemish of sin. Genesis 3:1-14 reveals that the serpent is the most “crafty”, or “subtle” of all the creatures. He was allowed to tempt Eve and Adam in God’s presence, since God is omnipresent and knows all things from everlasting to everlasting. Much the same occurs in Job 1:6-7. The evil presented himself before God “from roaming the earth and walking up and down on it” Thus, it is revealed that evil is ever-present upon this earth. God allows evil to tempt us (Job 1:8-12). In asking the evil one if he had considered Job, God was essentially throwing Job’s righteousness in the devil’s face. The devil demanded that Job be put to the test, and the Lord allowed this, as seen in verse 12. The evil one then “went out of the Lord’s presence”. In 1 Chronicles 21:1-8, we see that the devil “incited” even David. He did this even to the Lord’s handpicked servant, so his influence remains here. In Zechariah 3, we see Satan standing at the right hand of Joshua, to accuse him. Note the contrast here: we have Satan at our right side on earth to accuse us, and Jesus at God’s right hand in Heaven to intercede for us. The evil one’s ego is so great that he attempted (root word “tempt”) to cause the fall even of our Lord in the flesh (Matthew 4:1 and following, Mark 1:9 and following, Luke 4:1 and following). Later, our Lord would warn us that it is time for the judgment of this world and that the “prince of this world will be driven out” (John 12:31). Additionally, Jesus identifies the evil one by his title “prince of this world” in John 14:30 and John 16:11.

To address the OP, the evil one is the liar. Notice that he offered only earthly things: wealth, status, power. He could give only earthly things, which man desires and is susceptible to. But what he offers leads only to eternal damnation. Now, it remains to be seen whether the evil one truly knew Jesus’ status. However, he certainly was aware of the annunciation/incarnation, since it occurred in his princedom. It could be that he doubted that flesh, which was subject to him, could be powerful enough to resist even his best temptations. The One with two natures - true God and true man, was not only able to resist him, but was not even subject to him. In fact, the evil one was rebuked by Jesus - something even the Archangel Michael could not do.

So, the evil one has great intellect - far superior to our own. But, his fatal flaw is his ego, which clouds the perfect use of his evil intellect. For this we can be thankful. Amen.
 
That was agreat answer!! I think you knocked it out of the park. I had never really thought of the juxtaposition in joshua. Very good. I think you may be a scholar. Thanks for the enlightenment and for not hammering me.
 
I’ve heard some speculation (I think a scholar or two even?) speculate that Satan didn’t really know that Christ was God at this point. Or at least may not have.

If Satan did know He was God then I think what this would be is about Satan tempting Christ’s human nature. How exactly that works with “God” I don’t know, but obviously Christ was subject to temptations even though He was God (otherwise He wouldn’t be fully human) so it’s also possible for Satan to tempt Christ with power even if logically speaking He had this “power” as God.

After all, Satan’s temptations aren’t always based on logic, sometimes it’s just their “appeal” that makes them tempting. Sin is “illogical” by nature after all.
Very good explanation, God (in being Jesus) COULD be tempted as a human. God of course cannot be tempted but as he was in a different form, fully human God thus was god but no longer god in his form as God; in this human form God (Jesus) could be tempted and needed his Father (God’s) help to withstand that temptation. This is why Jesus as God prayed to his father in heavenly form as God for God’s spirit.

That power (or spirit) which was of course the 3rd person on the holy trinity, could NOT be tempted in any form (unless he materialised and was born as a human) thus he (the spirit) could strengthen God (Jesus in human form) to withstand temptation which normally he would not be subject to being God.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top