Luther v. Modern "Protestants"

  • Thread starter Thread starter Randy_Carson
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A COUPLE OF POINTS

Luther
.Lutheran was not the founder of Protestantism, as Jan Hus, Peter Waldo and others preceded him. His distinction is that he was the first Protestant to lead a highly successful wing of the Reformation.These early reformers were largely killed off. Hus, for example, was burned at the stake for ‘heresy’. Luther would have suffered the same fate had he not support among powerful forces within Germany which protected him.
There may have been a few who had similar ideas, but no one seriously questions that Protestantism ignited by and was largely led by Luther.
Real presence. The claim of one poster that Anglicans and Methodists believe in the real presence is false. Methodism 18th article, borrowed from the 39 articles of the Church of England, says in part: “Transubstantiation, or the change of the substance of bread and wine in the Supper of our Lord, cannot be proved by Holy Writ, but is repugnant to the plain words of Scripture, overthroweth the nature of a sacrament, and hath given occasion to many supersititions.”
I was given a copy of the document outlining the Methodist view of the ‘Lord’s Supper’ by my father who is still Methodist, and my casual reading leads me to believe that Methodists are free to believe whatever they want…the denomination has taken no firm stand.
Nature of Protestantism As one of millions of liberal Protestants, I do not feel bound to either the traditions of Catholicism nor of the Reformation. I believe in the ‘big tent’ - a tolerant faith community that has room for different opinions. The reality is that God and this mysterious universe are beyond our understanding, so different views are quite acceptable.
Sorry, while this sounds warm and fuzzy, it is a cop-out. God does not lead men to contradictory and conflicting truths. Unfortunately, the myriad of Protestant “denominations” teach opposing things about baptism, regeneration, the real presence in the Eucharist, the ordination of women, etc. - while at the same time they all claim to be led by the Spirit into all truth.

Sorry…the “big tent” is the one, holy, catholic and apostolic Church founded by Jesus Christ upon Peter, the rock.
 
Intended? I do believe God is in control Mr. Carson. We either have to believe the reformation happened in spite of His plan or because of it. I understand you believe the former.
I do wish that we were one. But that one would be fundamentalist churches that follow the Bible.
I see.

Tell me…does you reading of the writings of the earliest believers (Ignatius, Clement, Irenaeus, Justin Martyr, etc.) lead you to the conclusion that these people were “fundamentalist” in their theology?
 
Real presence. The claim of one poster that Anglicans and Methodists believe in the real presence is false. Methodism 18th article, borrowed from the 39 articles of the Church of England, says in part: “Transubstantiation, or the change of the substance of bread and wine in the Supper of our Lord, cannot be proved by Holy Writ, but is repugnant to the plain words of Scripture, overthroweth the nature of a sacrament, and hath given occasion to many supersititions.”
Your comment on the Anglican 39 Articles deals with Transubstantiation in particular not the Real Presence in general. Denial of Transubstantiation doesn’t equate to denial of the Real Presence. Don’t believe me? Ask any of our Lutheran, Anglican or Methodist brothers and sisters who frequent this forum. Here is the part of the Anglican 39 Articles that you failed to mention:
XXVIII. Of the Lord’s Supper.
The Supper of the Lord is not only a sign of the love that Christians ought to have among themselves one to another, but rather it is a Sacrament of our Redemption by Christ’s death: insomuch that to such as rightly, worthily, and with faith, receive the same,** the Bread which we break is a partaking of the Body of Christ; and likewise the Cup of Blessing is a partaking of the Blood of Christ.**
Transubstantiation (or the change of the substance of Bread and Wine) in the Supper of the Lord, cannot be proved by Holy Writ; but is repugnant to the plain words of Scripture, overthroweth the nature of a Sacrament, and hath given occasion to many superstitions.
The Body of Christ is given, taken, and eaten, in the Supper, only after an heavenly and spiritual manner. And the mean whereby the Body of Christ is received and eaten in the Supper, is Faith.
The Sacrament of the Lord’s Supper was not by Christ’s ordinance reserved, carried about, lifted up, or worshipped.
From the United Methodists:
Jesus Christ, who “is the reflection of God’s glory and the exact imprint of God’s very being” (Hebrews 1:3), is truly present in Holy Communion. Through Jesus Christ and in the power of the Holy Spirit, God meets us at the Table. God, who has given the sacraments to the church, acts in and through Holy Communion. Christ is present through the community gathered in Jesus’ name (Matthew 18:20), through the Word proclaimed and enacted, and through the elements of bread and wine shared (1 Corinthians 11:23-26). **The divine presence is a living reality and can be experienced by participants; it is not a remembrance of the Last Supper and the Crucifixion only. **
gbod.org/worship/thisholy…y/parttwo.html
Pour out your Holy Spirit on us gathered here,
and on these gifts of bread and wine.
Make them be for us the body and blood of Christ,
that we may be for the world the body of Christ
,
redeemed by his blood.
revneal.org/communionlit1.html

God bless you
 
Intended? I do believe God is in control Mr. Carson. **We either have to believe the reformation happened in spite of His plan or because of it. I understand you believe the former. **
I do wish that we were one. But that one would be fundamentalist churches that follow the Bible.
Not necessarily. Perhaps it was God’s plan that got carried too far by men 🤷

Which one of the fundamentalists churches? My father in law is a leader of a fundamentalist church who, according to him, follows the Bible only. He also denies the Protestant doctrines of faith alone and *OSAS *because they are not in the Bible :eek:😃 Is this the one fundamentalist church we should all follow?

God bless you
 
I see.

Tell me…does you reading of the writings of the earliest believers (Ignatius, Clement, Irenaeus, Justin Martyr, etc.) lead you to the conclusion that these people were “fundamentalist” in their theology?
I have not read them exclusively to determine their theology on what we believe. Tell me Mr. Carson, which of these do they deny?

The inspiration of the Bible by the Holy Spirit and the inerrancy of Scripture as a result of this.
The virgin birth of Christ.
The belief that Christ’s death was the atonement for sin.
The bodily resurrection of Christ.
The historical reality of Christ’s miracles.

Premillennialism-oh this link might help direct you, sure its Wikipedia but its sources are solid
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Premillenialism

We can start with those.
 
I have not read them exclusively to determine their theology on what we believe. Tell me Mr. Carson, which of these do they deny?

The inspiration of the Bible by the Holy Spirit and the inerrancy of Scripture as a result of this.
The virgin birth of Christ.
The belief that Christ’s death was the atonement for sin.
The bodily resurrection of Christ.
The historical reality of Christ’s miracles.

Premillennialism-oh this link might help direct you, sure its Wikipedia but its sources are solid
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Premillenialism

We can start with those.
They would have been unfamiliar with the New Testament (as we know it) as scripture. They would also have disagreed (I believe) with pre-millenniallism since the Bible does not teach it and because dispensationalism is a modern invention.

Are these the sum total of what the earliest believers taught? Or have you left out a few things which they would have considered important?
 
Not necessarily. Perhaps it was God’s plan that got carried too far by men 🤷

Which one of the fundamentalists churches? My father in law is a leader of a fundamentalist church who, according to him, follows the Bible only. He also denies the Protestant doctrines of faith alone and *OSAS *because they are not in the Bible :eek:😃 Is this the one fundamentalist church we should all follow?

God bless you
Very good. He is half right on those two issues anyway. But lets talk about which Catholic Church is right. I know that officially the Catholic Church teaches one thing but I personally heard a homily in a Catholic Church where the priest said the Church was wrong to not have women priests. AND EVERYONE WAS NODDING YES. Well certainly most of them. It certainly appears this Catholic Church thought differently. Sitting in that church was a state senator that fought against outlawing partial birth abortions in our state. Now I know that you have officially unity, ie its not important what individual Catholics teach its what the CHURCH teaches. Well you see, official doctrine is useless if not borne out in the lives and teachings of the very ministers who serve that church.
Its against your offical teaching to have artificial birth control but how many do? Oh I know, it does not matter what they do it matters what the Church officially teaches.
Its the excuses that people make for a church that members do not practice what they preach.
 
Very good. He is half right on those two issues anyway.
Says you. By what authority to you make this statement? My father in law goes to the, “bible alone”.
But lets talk about which Catholic Church is right. I know that officially the Catholic Church teaches one thing but I personally heard a homily in a Catholic Church where the priest said the Church was wrong to not have women priests. AND EVERYONE WAS NODDING YES. Well certainly most of them. It certainly appears this Catholic Church thought differently. Sitting in that church was a state senator that fought against outlawing partial birth abortions in our state. Now I know that you have officially unity, ie its not important what individual Catholics teach its what the CHURCH teaches. Well you see, official doctrine is useless if not borne out in the lives and teachings of the very ministers who serve that church.
Its against your offical teaching to have artificial birth control but how many do? Oh I know, it does not matter what they do it matters what the Church officially teaches.
Its the excuses that people make for a church that members do not practice what they preach.
You ask questions then answer them yourself and all the while fail to answer mine. If this statement of yours is true:
I do wish that we were one. But that one would be fundamentalist churches that follow the Bible.
Which Fundamentalist church that “follows the Bible” is it?

God bless
 
None though they would have been unfamiliar with the New Testament (as we know it) as scripture.

Are these the sum total of what the earliest believers taught? Or have you left out a few things which they would have considered important?
You asked me if they were fundamentalists. Thats what we teach. Oh no, there are things they taught we do not agree with. But that is how we read the Bible differently. Corinth, Rome, the seven churches in Asia, all had doctrinal and moral problems and errors. Tell me Mr. Carson, is it not true that when the ante-nicene fathers agree with present Catholic doctrine it is cited, However, when they do not, they are not cited. it is true they were premillennialists? Of course they were.
You see appealing to the ante-Nicene fathers is a useless activity because what constitutes official doctrine in 120 AD is an exercise in futility from your perspective.
 
Very good. He is half right on those two issues anyway. But lets talk about which Catholic Church is right. I know that officially the Catholic Church teaches one thing but I personally heard a homily in a Catholic Church where the priest said the Church was wrong to not have women priests. AND EVERYONE WAS NODDING YES. Well certainly most of them. It certainly appears this Catholic Church thought differently. Sitting in that church was a state senator that fought against outlawing partial birth abortions in our state. Now I know that you have officially unity, ie its not important what individual Catholics teach its what the CHURCH teaches. Well you see, official doctrine is useless if not borne out in the lives and teachings of the very ministers who serve that church.
Its against your offical teaching to have artificial birth control but how many do? Oh I know, it does not matter what they do it matters what the Church officially teaches.
Its the excuses that people make for a church that members do not practice what they preach.
Your church might teach that dancing or drinking alcohol is wrong, but that doesn’t mean that a few of your members aren’t out at that local honky-tonk just over the county line on Friday nights. And I’m sure your denomination would agree that adultery is sin, but that doesn’t stop the pastor from running off with the organist from time to time - so don’t be so quick to point out the splinter in our eye, brother.

The difference here is that if that Church with every one nodding their heads in favor or women priests were PROTESTANT, the liberals would have split off long ago and formed a new congregation in a strip mall storefront on the other side of town. Some denominations would even “disfellowship” those folks. Y’all don’t like to talk about this Protestant version of excommunication, but it happens, doesn’t it?

As much as I’d like to give the “cafeteria Catholics” the boot, the Church (in her wisdom) doesn’t listen to me. 😛
 
Says you. By what authority to you make this statement? My father in law goes to the, “bible alone”.

You ask questions then answer them yourself and all the while fail to answer mine. If this statement of yours is true:

Which Fundamentalist church which “follows the Bible” is it?

God bless
I have not visited every fundamentalist church and cannot answer. You would have to visit them ourself. I would have to visit them. You see just because it says something on the door, ie Catholic, does not mean they are true to the teachings they profess. Same thing with Bible churches, I do not believe that you can tell until you check them out yourself.
I can tell you what I belive is the rule to appeal to: scripture. You can appeal to contradictory Sacred Tradition but look at where that got you guys. The church split along Oriental Orthodox and then
Eastern Orthodox lines due to disagreements over interpretation of Traditions and Scripture. It has always been that way. The thing that does not change is scripture. That is why I believe it is the rule of faith.
 
Your church might teach that dancing or drinking alcohol is wrong, but that doesn’t mean that a few of your members aren’t out at that local honky-tonk just over the county line on Friday nights. And I’m sure your denomination would agree that adultery is sin, but that doesn’t stop the pastor from running off with the organist from time to time - so don’t be so quick to point out the splinter in our eye, brother.

The difference here is that if that Church with every one nodding their heads in favor or women priests were PROTESTANT, the liberals would have split off long ago and formed a new congregation in a strip mall storefront on the other side of town. Some denominations would even “disfellowship” those folks. Y’all don’t like to talk about this Protestant version of excommunication, but it happens, doesn’t it?

As much as I’d like to give the “cafeteria Catholics” the boot, the Church (in her wisdom) doesn’t listen to me. 😛
The Catholic Church, if it is the first church, has done nothing BUT split Mr. Carson. Its like the elephant Catholics cannot see. The Oriental Orthodox were Catholic…they split. The Eastern Orthodox were Catholic…they split. There are hundreds of liberal Catholic groups with apostolic succession. You can disagree with them but their existence is proof that people split all the time. And they always have.
I do not belong to a denomination, although some contend it is a denomination of one church…that has been said.
I will point out that your official doctrine has no real impact on the lives of the vast majority of Catholics…in my opinion. On the other hand, a saving faith in Jesus Christ has radically changed lives…mine included.
 
I have not visited every fundamentalist church and cannot answer. You would have to visit them ourself. I would have to visit them. You see just because it says something on the door, ie Catholic, does not mean they are true to the teachings they profess. Same thing with Bible churches, I do not believe that you can tell until you check them out yourself.
I can tell you what I belive is the rule to appeal to: scripture. You can appeal to contradictory Sacred Tradition but look at where that got you guys. The church split along Oriental Orthodox and then
Eastern Orthodox lines due to disagreements over interpretation of Traditions and Scripture. It has always been that way. The thing that does not change is scripture. That is why I believe it is the rule of faith.
You still have not answered my question; which fundamentalist church must I join to be a part of the “one” Church you spoke of? if you don’t know, just tell me so.
I can tell you what I belive is the rule to appeal to: scripture.
So does my father-in-law. Those people who believe in OSAS and Faith alone are heretics and apostate Christians to him because they believe something that is not in the Bible… This of course coming from a fundamentalist preacher who you just told me was the one true Church. So who do I believe? You, who tells me to go the Bible alone and tells me to believe A B and C or my father in law who… tells me to go to the Bible alone and tells me to deny A B and C?
The thing that does not change is scripture. That is why I believe it is the rule of faith.
So does my father in law. So do all Fundamentalist Churches who teach conflicting doctrines. So which one do I go to find this unity that you spoke about here:
I do wish that we were one. But that one would be fundamentalist churches that follow the Bible.
Or are even the fundamentalist churches which follow the bible not one?

God bless
 
You asked me if they were fundamentalists. Thats what we teach.
And this is the crux of the problem. Who gets to decide what the "fundamentals’ are? You? Your pastor? The elders of your church? The leaders of your denomination?
Oh no, there are things they taught we do not agree with.
And you can bet that Peter, Paul and John along with their disciples, Clement, Irenaeus, Polycarp, and Ignatius, thought that these things were fundamental to the faith.

Do you seriously think that any of these men would feel comfortable in your church today stripped down as it is to an artificially imposed list of fundamentals that amounts to no more than “lowest common denominator” Christianity instead of the fullness of the Gospel that they themselves preached?

Hardly.

You’re like Apollos…preaching about Jesus accurately enough, but you need someone to invite you to their home and explain to you the way of God more adequately. (cf. Acts 18:26)

I’m glad you’re here for that. 👍
 
=Roman_Catholic;5434199]You still have not answered my question; which fundamentalist church must I join to be a part of the “one” Church you spoke of? if you don’t know, just tell me so.
I have answered your question. How can you say that? You may disagree with my answer but how can you say I have not answered it. I have never said “joining” a particular church will get you anywhere. The church will not save you Roman_Catholic. I can tell you names of lots of churches that follow the Bible. For that matter, I have never said that you have to leave YOUR church. I know that for over a thousand years the Bible was perserved by many faithful Catholics. I will not give out the name of my church; I have received enough harassment in PMs to do such over the last two years. Oh, not exclusively from Catholics either to clarify.
It is not the name on the door.
So does my father-in-law. Those people who believe in OSAS and Faith alone are heretics and apostate Christians to him because they believe something that is not in the Bible… This of course coming from a fundamentalist preacher who you just told me was the one true Church. So who do I believe? You, who tells me to go the Bible alone and tells me to believe A B and C or my father in law who… tells me to go to the Bible alone and tells me to deny A B and C?
You have already MADE a decision who to believe. But do not think it is the only choice. The Oriental Orthodox, the Eastern Orthodox, the Polish National Catholics, the SSPX have their views, and so do thousands of other churches. You made your choice. You believe you have your infallible interpreter. I understand that.
So does my father in law. So do all Fundamentalist Churches who teach conflicting doctrines. So which one do I go to find this unity that you spoke about here:
Or are even the fundamentalist churches which follow the bible not one?
God bless
I believe I have answered your questions. Blessings to you and may the grace of the Lord be with you as well my friend.
 
Does God have more than one truth?
Islam says: No, Islam is the only true way to Allah and Jannah. (Chapter 3, verse 85) Christianity and Judaism were true until man came in and changed God’s truth and corrupted his scripture.

Catholicism says: Catholicism contains the fullness of the truth of Christ and Salvation. Nonetheless, other religions hold some portions of truth and salvation as well.

Hinduism says: Truth is One, though the sages know it variously. Truth comes in all different forms to different people. Many religions can contain fullness of truth.

Buddhism says: Only the eightfold path, as taught by the Enlightened one, can lead us out of suffering. Nonetheless, elements of enlightenment are found in other religions but only the eightfold path and four noble truths that the enlightened one taught will lead us out of suffering.

Bahai says: God reveals himself in many ways to different societies. Whereas Judea needed Abraham, Moses, and Jesus, likewise Arabia needed Mohammad and India needed Krishna. There are various ways to know God and we must be tolerant of them all.

Jainism says: Truth can come in many forms. No religion has all of the truth though. Some have more than others but none have the total truth.

Eastern Orthodoxy: Christianity comprises the only way to salvation.
 
And this is the crux of the problem. Who gets to decide what the "fundamentals’ are? You? Your pastor? The elders of your church? The leaders of your denomination?

And you can bet that Peter, Paul and John along with their disciples, Clement, Irenaeus, Polycarp, and Ignatius, thought that these things were fundamental to the faith.

Do you seriously think that any of these men would feel comfortable in your church today stripped down as it is to an artificially imposed list of fundamentals that amounts to no more than “lowest common denominator” Christianity instead of the fullness of the Gospel that they themselves preached?

Hardly.

You’re like Apollos…preaching about Jesus accurately enough, but you need someone to invite you to their home and explain to you the way of God more adequately. (cf. Acts 18:26)

I’m glad you’re here for that. 👍
I absolutely believe that they would not want to be comfortable but would instead be pleased with how we reach the lost with the Gospel of Christ. If they had any corrections, and they would of course, I would take it. You see, I read their words every day in my attempt to follow them. Thats what I try to do. I think they would recognize the simplicity of worship far more at my church than they would at any of your churches. My opinion…but you did ask.
 
The Catholic Church, if it is the first church, has done nothing BUT split Mr. Carson. Its like the elephant Catholics cannot see. The Oriental Orthodox were Catholic…they split. The Eastern Orthodox were Catholic…they split. There are hundreds of liberal Catholic groups with apostolic succession. You can disagree with them but their existence is proof that people split all the time. And they always have.
I do not disagree that some have split off from the Catholic Church or that this has been happening for a long time. It is unfortunate that these people are no longer in full communion with the Church that Jesus founded. However, despite these schisms, it is also true that more than a billion people today consider Benedict XVI to be the legitimate successor of Peter as head of the Church founded by Jesus Christ. Either one is in communion with the Church or not.
I do not belong to a denomination, although some contend it is a denomination of one church…that has been said.
I love it when you guys try to deny that you are a denomination or even Protestant. It’s solid evidence that the charge of separation sticks. Then you begin to twist yourselves into all sorts of contortions trying to explain how the “one church” promised by Jesus really can include formal doctrinal disagreements as espoused by the disparate groups who make up the allegedly “invisible, spiritual church”.
I will point out that your official doctrine has no real impact on the lives of the vast majority of Catholics…in my opinion. On the other hand, a saving faith in Jesus Christ has radically changed lives…mine included.
So, on the basis of your anecdotal evidence that Catholics believe women should be ordained or that most Catholics use contraception, we must conclude that Catholicism has no impact on the lives of most Catholics. :rolleyes:

And by your implication, are we to conclude similarly that most Catholics’ lives have NOT been changed by saving faith in Jesus Christ? Gee, I didn’t realize that I was so unusual in this regard…
 
I absolutely believe that they would not want to be comfortable but would instead be pleased with how we reach the lost with the Gospel of Christ. If they had any corrections, and they would of course, I would take it. You see, I read their words every day in my attempt to follow them. Thats what I try to do. I think they would recognize the simplicity of worship far more at my church than they would at any of your churches. My opinion…but you did ask.
Without the celebration of the Eucharist, they would not recognize it at all.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top