Lying to Yourself - Affirmations

  • Thread starter Thread starter BHL_20
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
B

BHL_20

Guest
The Catholic Church teaches that any lie is sinful. Affirmations are basically lying to yourself, however the only thing you’re deceiving is your subconscious mind which isn’t really a person. So since no one is being deceived, would that make this kind of lying ok?
 
I don’t lie to myself, like I don’t say, “oh this doesn’t bother me so much,” when I think it is. That’s just denial. Or if I do say it, there is a strategic social reason for doing so and then I don’t feel bad about it; the issue then becomes whether it had the desired impact or avoided an undesired response from others. It’s not lying, because if I speak from my own preference rather than I am my sole arbiter of how much I think it bothers me (whether others think I’m in denial or not) and limited by my communication ability. I can think “well it bothers me a lot but there is no reason to discuss it at this time.” And of course there is always “it could be worse” which I don’t like but from a logical/dualistic situation whether it is a lie, it is always true. If I’m alive and healthy enough to type this, then it could have been worse.

So these are “Barnum Statements.” Statements that don’t really say anything but are true. Like, “well all we can do is go on from here.” Yes, until we have perfected time travel, that is a fact.

Sometimes I’d rather overstate it and get it done with. I used to have bipolar disorder and now I’m very stable but one thing I’ve learned is it can be fun to state drastic things in a “deadpan” and “sterile” way because then they don’t lock you up for saying it. Some who know me even enjoy going stupid with me like, "oh myyy gosh I dropped the milk. Not only am I going to cry, but now I’m sure my life has no meaning at all. I have no reason to live … " or they might say, “I don’t know how you can go on after doing this…” And then we laugh at how silly it is, and get out the cleanup equipment. (I wouldn’t use this technique around certain do-gooder wannabes; people get locked up for much less.)

Meanwhile go about wiping it up, so we still have to clean it up and lose the milk, but we don’t have to cry over it except cries of joy that we live and breathe as a part of God’s creation.

Kind of like Mary Poppins and a Spoonful of Sugar. You do your work while thinking different thoughts. Being angry or anxious doesn’t help the current task, even if it is not pleasant.

What I have used that’s kind of like what you might be thinking, is what I call “reality overlays.”

They are a different story for the same set of perceptions at any given point, that may lack the part which defines a problem.

Like if I’m already behind schedule and hemmed in helplessly by cars on all sides, I can use my “like a child” imagination to either think of how awful it is that I’m late and how helpless I am to do anything about it except continue toward my inevitable punishment for something I’m doing everything I can about.

Or I can think, “I’m being escorted and protected by this formation of drivers. As long as I stay centered in this little opening they have for me, they will take me toward my destination.”

Personally I like to go totally silly. Like “I’m in the Blue Angels and I’m formation flying to my office.” or “This motorcade is bringing me to where I can do good for someone else besides myself in this world.” or “I’m watching myself from 200 feet up, I’m just one little speck in the driver in this little toy car going down the toy track.”

Pretty soon, it’s my exit which I arrive no later, but without having given power to anxious energy, so I’m not all jazzed up and freaked out in addition to being late. Only if I have to pretend to be freaked upon showing up in order to seem sincere, is that to my advantage in any way whatsoever.

I told my Psychology of Personality teacher about this, and she called it “cognitive reframing.”
 
The Catholic Church teaches that any lie is sinful. Affirmations are basically lying to yourself, however the only thing you’re deceiving is your subconscious mind which isn’t really a person. So since no one is being deceived, would that make this kind of lying ok?
I think it depends on the reasons a person might be using affirmations. If someone has had a very negative upbringing and has a poor self image, then I don’t see the problem with using affirmations to change their image of themselves so that they start to become more positive.

After all the negative upbringing they had was really a series of negative affirmations eg. “Love a duck, can’t you do anything right??”, “You get more stupid as you get older!”, “If all you do every time you open your mouth, is make a fool of yourself, then don’t open your mouth in the first place.” etc. etc. And I’m writing from experience because that’s the sort of stuff I got every day from my father. And I mean every day.

Now I don’t use affirmations as it happens, but I fail to see why someone should not use affirmations to re-train their subconscious mind to be a more positive person. Why should they go on believing a negative lie, due to someone else’s stupid and evil accusations and affirmations?
 
I think it depends on the reasons a person might be using affirmations. If someone has had a very negative upbringing and has a poor self image, then I don’t see the problem with using affirmations to change their image of themselves so that they start to become more positive.

After all the negative upbringing they had was really a series of negative affirmations eg. “Love a duck, can’t you do anything right??”, “You get more stupid as you get older!”, “If all you do every time you open your mouth, is make a fool of yourself, then don’t open your mouth in the first place.” etc. etc. And I’m writing from experience because that’s the sort of stuff I got every day from my father. And I mean every day.

Now I don’t use affirmations as it happens, but I fail to see why someone should not use affirmations to re-train their subconscious mind to be a more positive person. Why should they go on believing a negative lie, due to someone else’s stupid and evil accusations and affirmations?
I like your point. But you insinuate that it may not be acceptable under certain circumstances. However, no one’s upbringing was perfect, so mostly anyone can say they need to use affirmations to make up for some or other parenting deficiency.
 
If an affirmation is true, it’s not lying to yourself.
As well as, recognizing a weakness and stating it is not lying to yourself.

For example, in my case:

Strength: I can easily learn foreign languages.
Weakness: I can have a hard time learning math.

As far as affirmations go, we should acknowledge that our talents and gifts come from God. If I am good at learning languages, it’s because God has given me that ability. So any honor, glory, and gratitude belongs to Him. And if I have difficulty with math … well, how about this affirmation: If I study hard, I can improve my math skills to the best of my ability. Because being inherently weak in math is not an excuse to be lazy and simply give up without even trying.

Now it would be a lie (or at least an unlikely speculation) if I were to make an affirmation that I’m going to take a math class and get the highest score in class … (Unless some miracle happened, or unless the rest of the class happened to be even worse at math than I am, which would be highly unlikely.)

Humility is acknowledging the truth of who God is, and who you are.
Affirm the good, acknowledge the bad, and
give glory to God,
Who can manifest His strength in our weakness.

…
 
If an affirmation is true, it’s not lying to yourself.
As well as, recognizing a weakness and stating it is not lying to yourself.

For example, in my case:

Strength: I can easily learn foreign languages.
Weakness: I can have a hard time learning math.
The whole point of affirmations is not to confirm what you already know, but to change negative subconscious beliefs. For you, an example of what would be considered an effective affirmation would be: “I consistently get As on math tests” (or whatever the highest grade is in your country). Although it is a lie technically, if you repeat it regularly until you believe it, you will be much more motivated to study than by using your “I should try my best but I know I’ll do bad anyway”. You will probably get much better grades this way, because in general, it’s very difficult to keep putting work into something in the long-term by forcing yourself to do so.

Humility is great, but what if negative beliefs are hindering you from reaching your potential.
 
I have to use affirmations to get out of bed some days. I can’t list you off things that I feel that I am good at. Not one thing. Lying to myself makes me not suicidal and allows me to get through the day. Lying or suicide? Hmmmm totally choosing lying.
 
Affirmations never need to be lies.

You can say things you know are true, even if you aren’t yet able to accept them or put them into action in your life.

“I know God has a plan for me” for instance

Or for non religious affirmations if it is something that is still a stretch you can start it with a phrase that makes it true and opens you to receiving it.

“I know my life will improve when I stop drinking”

“Great things can happen when I move on from this relationship”

“Opportunities increase when I put effort into my education”

Which is true and more effective than “I speak French like a native!” (at least for most of us here in the USA)
 
Affirmations never need to be lies.

You can say things you know are true, even if you aren’t yet able to accept them or put them into action in your life.

“I know God has a plan for me” for instance

Or for non religious affirmations if it is something that is still a stretch you can start it with a phrase that makes it true and opens you to receiving it.

“I know my life will improve when I stop drinking”

“Great things can happen when I move on from this relationship”

“Opportunities increase when I put effort into my education”

Which is true and more effective than “I speak French like a native!” (at least for most of us here in the USA)
All of your examples miss the whole point of affirmations. Your examples are more like reminders or memos more than anything. Again, it’s the difference between pressuring yourself to put in effort versus creating a strong belief that you can succeed.

And the “God has a plan for me” one is more about building patience/trust than motivation or confidence.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top