Macy's stores boycotted for replacing 'Christmas'

  • Thread starter Thread starter swampfox
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

swampfox

Guest
The chutzpah of a company that profits mightily from Christmas but disses Christians
Effort punishes ‘Miracle on 34th Street’ icon, claims chain offending millions of customers

Posted: December 1, 2004
1:00 a.m. Eastern

© 2004 WorldNetDaily.com

Immortalized in a 1947 Christmas movie classic, Macy’s is now the focus of a boycott campaign protesting the department-store chain’s replacement of “Merry Christmas” with politically correct greetings.

1947 Christmas classic “Miracle on 34th Street” featured Macy’s department store

A group called the Committee to Save Merry Christmas says Macy’s and its umbrella Federated Department Stores have ignored several requests that “Merry Christmas” signs be returned and that its advertising acknowledge the time-honored phrase.

“It’s the height of hypocrisy for a corporation to make tens of millions of dollars selling Christmas presents, yet coldly refuse to acknowledge Christmas,” said the group’s chairman, Manuel Zamorano, in a statement. “What’s the holiday all about, anyway? Politically correct phases like ‘Seasons Greetings’ and ‘Happy Holidays’ are no substitute for the real thing.”

Macy’s was featured in “Miracle on 34th Street,” the Maureen O’Hara and Natalie Wood film set in the department store’s celebration of Christmas. The flagship store in New York also is famous for its elaborate Christmas-season window displays.

Zamorano says Macy’s and its affiliated stores have been “systematically” removing references to “Merry Christmas” over the past several years.

“This is offensive to the sensibilities of millions of average Americans,” he said. “Eliminating ‘Merry Christmas’ is plain wrong. It’s time to remove Macy’s and Federated from the Christmas shopping list.”

Federated Department Stores, Inc., operates more than 450 stores in 34 states under names such as Bloomingdale’s, Bon-Macy’s, Burdines-Macy’s, Goldsmiths-Macy’s, Lazarus-Macy’s and Rich’s Macy’s.

Zamorano, a Sacramento, Calif., media consultant, expects his campaign to take several years before it gets results.

One year ago, he wrote to Federated’s then-chairman, James Zimmerman, saying he hoped a boycott could be avoided.

“We find this to be personally, culturally and traditionally offensive when it is known by everyone your company actively solicits our patronage and purchasing of gifts for the Christmas celebration, and now refuses to acknowledge Christmas in your stores,” Zamorano wrote.

The boycott was launched in May when new Chairman Terry Lundgren did not respond to a follow-up letter.

A Macy’s spokeswoman did not return WND’s call requesting comment, but the company told Citizen magazine earlier this year it believed Zamorano had unfairly singled out Federated, because other stores have the same practice.
 
40.png
swampfox:
The chutzpah of a company that profits mightily from Christmas but disses Christians
Effort punishes ‘Miracle on 34th Street’ icon, claims chain offending millions of customers

A Macy’s spokeswoman did not return WND’s call requesting comment, but the company told Citizen magazine earlier this year it believed Zamorano had unfairly singled out Federated, because other stores have the same practice.
Maybe they would not like to “celebrate” Christmas around the cash register this year? What do they think people are buying gifts for? Winter Solstice? Kwanzaa? Give me a break!
Lisa N
 
Lisa N:
Maybe they would not like to “celebrate” Christmas around the cash register this year? What do they think people are buying gifts for? Winter Solstice? Kwanzaa? Give me a break!
Lisa N
Frankly, I’ve noticed this trend over the last decade or more and have been taking my Christmas shopping business to stores that understand and demonstrate they understand the reason for the season. If all Christians did that, you’d see these merchants cave in a New York minute.
 
Marshall Field’s abandoned their manger scene in the famous windows display years ago. This year they are doing Snow White, but they refuse to call the “7 men” “dwarves”.
 
I can tell you that I won’t be shopping at Macy’s this year.

On a personal note, I make it a point to respond “Merry Christmas” whenever someone wishes me a “Happy Holiday” or gives me “Season’s Greetings”. I wish my Jewish friends and neighbors a Happy Channukah because that is the holiday that they are celebrating. (I don’t deal in Kwanzaa because of its socialist roots. Besides, no one I know takes it seriously.)
 
40.png
swampfox:
The chutzpah of a company that profits mightily from Christmas but disses Christians
Effort punishes ‘Miracle on 34th Street’ icon, claims chain offending millions of customers
Anyone who boycotts these stores, more power to their left elbow 😉

They don’t want Christ, but they don’t mind taking Christians money.
 
40.png
condan:
I can tell you that I won’t be shopping at Macy’s this year.

On a personal note, I make it a point to respond “Merry Christmas” whenever someone wishes me a “Happy Holiday” or gives me “Season’s Greetings”. I wish my Jewish friends and neighbors a Happy Channukah because that is the holiday that they are celebrating. (I don’t deal in Kwanzaa because of its socialist roots. Besides, no one I know takes it seriously.)
I agree with this post 100%. I will not shop at Macys or Bloomingdales and I always respond to people with a Merry Christmas or Happy Channukah, even at work. It’s time political correctness goes the way of the berlin wall.
 
40.png
condan:
I can tell you that I won’t be shopping at Macy’s this year.

On a personal note, I make it a point to respond “Merry Christmas” whenever someone wishes me a “Happy Holiday” or gives me “Season’s Greetings”. I wish my Jewish friends and neighbors a Happy Channukah because that is the holiday that they are celebrating. (I don’t deal in Kwanzaa because of its socialist roots. Besides, no one I know takes it seriously.)
Oh I agree totally. I always point out to the secularists who use Happy Holiday that Holiday is HOLY DAY. Takes them for a loop I tell ya! This whole “We won’t acknowledge Christmas but we want your money” disgusts me.

Lisa N
 
I wonder what kind of message people leave for the “Harrison’s Family” guy in return for his quickly said "Happy Holidays"on the cell phone plan with few minutes?

Happy holiday, happy holiday
While the merry bells keep ringing
May your ev’ry wish come true

Happy holiday, happy holiday
May the calendar keep bringing
Happy holidays to you
 
40.png
condan:
I can tell you that I won’t be shopping at Macy’s this year.

On a personal note, I make it a point to respond “Merry Christmas” whenever someone wishes me a “Happy Holiday” or gives me “Season’s Greetings”. I wish my Jewish friends and neighbors a Happy Channukah because that is the holiday that they are celebrating. (I don’t deal in Kwanzaa because of its socialist roots. Besides, no one I know takes it seriously.)
When I’m greeted with the ubiquitous “Happy Holidays”–I ask what holiday is that?
 
It is what ever holiday you choose to celebrate. Whether it is Chanukah, Christmas or Kwanza. There are also people who choose not to recognise any holiday. I do not see how someone saying “Happy Holidays” hurts you in any way.
 
40.png
Mac6yver:
It is what ever holiday you choose to celebrate. Whether it is Chanukah, Christmas or Kwanza. There are also people who choose not to recognise any holiday. I do not see how someone saying “Happy Holidays” hurts you in any way.
The great majority of people are out shopping for gifts for Christmas. the name of the federal holiday is Christmas. I don’t understand how “Merry Christmas” hurts anyone in anyway. Why change now?
 
40.png
swampfox:
When I’m greeted with the ubiquitous “Happy Holidays”–I ask what holiday is that?
That’s a good one! I hope you don’t mind if I use it.
 
40.png
Mac6yver:
It is what ever holiday you choose to celebrate. Whether it is Chanukah, Christmas or Kwanza. There are also people who choose not to recognise any holiday. I do not see how someone saying “Happy Holidays” hurts you in any way.
I’ll explain it then. We give gifts in December in commemoration of the gifts of the Magi to the Christ child. That is why Macy’s and Bloomingdales make money during that month. If it weren’t for our celebration of the Christian holy season, the only thing they would sell is gloves in the Northeast.

Channukah is a minor holy festival in the Jewish tradition. It has become more popular in response to the Christmas season.

Kwanzaa is an ethnic festival with socialist roots. It isn’'t a holy period since it doesn’t recognize anything of religious significance.

Saying “Happy Holidays” hurts because by ignoring the fact that the Christian holy season exists, you are denying the existence of my God.

Now let me turn it around. When did saying “Merry Christmas” hurt anyone? Since when is loving one’s neighbor like himself a bad thing? How about “peace on Earth to men of good will”? How does that detract from lighting of the Menorah? I can tell you that none of my Jewish friends hesitate to wish me a Merry Christmas. They know only too well what happens when you deny someone the right to their faith.
 
40.png
Mac6yver:
It is what ever holiday you choose to celebrate. Whether it is Chanukah, Christmas or Kwanza. There are also people who choose not to recognise any holiday. I do not see how someone saying “Happy Holidays” hurts you in any way.
Christmas is the national holiday unless you care to change it. It is particularly galling to hear happy holidays from another Christian who knows I am a Christian, but people have been so conditioned not to offend (saying Christmas equals hate speech in the eyes of so many politically correct nonbelievers) that they deny their own Faith and traditions.
 
40.png
condan:
That’s a good one! I hope you don’t mind if I use it.
Not at all, that’s why I posted it. It’s an ice breaker that I’ve used often. Even when I don’t use it, I’ll respond “Merry Christmas” and have often gotten a “Merry Christmas” back from the store employee who had just used “Happy Holidays” Most times, they seem relieved to be able to say “Merry Christmas” In any event, the only thing that will really work to stem the tide of political correctness and the denial of our Faith tradition is to not buy Christmas gifts in stores that clearly refuse to indicate the reason for the season. If Christians stuck together on that, “Merry Christmas” would once again ring throughout the land.
 
40.png
condan:
I’ll explain it then. We give gifts in December in commemoration of the gifts of the Magi to the Christ child. That is why Macy’s and Bloomingdales make money during that month. If it weren’t for our celebration of the Christian holy season, the only thing they would sell is gloves in the Northeast.

Channukah is a minor holy festival in the Jewish tradition. It has become more popular in response to the Christmas season.

Kwanzaa is an ethnic festival with socialist roots. It isn’'t a holy period since it doesn’t recognize anything of religious significance.

Saying “Happy Holidays” hurts because by ignoring the fact that the Christian holy season exists, you are denying the existence of my God.

Now let me turn it around. When did saying “Merry Christmas” hurt anyone? Since when is loving one’s neighbor like himself a bad thing? How about “peace on Earth to men of good will”? How does that detract from lighting of the Menorah? I can tell you that none of my Jewish friends hesitate to wish me a Merry Christmas. They know only too well what happens when you deny someone the right to their faith.
Also, Kwanzaa was started by a Black separatist and criminal who was convicted of torturing a woman.
 
40.png
swampfox:
Also, Kwanzaa was started by a Black separatist and criminal who was convicted of torturing a woman.
I have asked all my friends and continue to ask people this time of year if they celebrate Kwanzaa. Please keep in mind I live and work in NY. I have not come across a single person that celebrates this holiday, not one. When I ask my black friends they laugh. I’m not sure who’s trying to shove this down our throat.
 
No one is denying any of you the right to say “Merry Christmas”. You are all free to wish anyone a “Merry Christmas”. However, you do not get to decide the policies of the stores in regards to their greeters.
 
40.png
Mac6yver:
No one is denying any of you the right to say “Merry Christmas”. You are all free to wish anyone a “Merry Christmas”. However, you do not get to decide the policies of the stores in regards to their greeters.
But we get to decide if we want to shop there.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top