Majority doesnt want Obama re-elected

  • Thread starter Thread starter Stjudeprayforus
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
How so, please?

I see Mr Stupak, as a last minute / down to the line…, sell - out. AND he didn’t need to. Had he stuck to it…Health care would have been passed…and some reverence for ALL life been included

Do you really expect me to believe that had he held the line…health care would have sunk? It was too precious to the Democrats.🙂
Makes you wonder if he knowshow Stupak voted??? The health care vote put a stake through the heart of the myth of the pro-life democrat congressman once and for all.
 
I am hoping that Pope Benedict has more influence on the Catholic vote than George Soros had on the last election.
😃 Me too…but with the problems in the Church right now, I am highly doubtful that anyone but serious Catholics would listen to him. Besides that,abortion seems not to be the most important issue with a substantial amount of “Catholics”, unfortunate as it is. If Republicans gain the White House in 2012, I am not convinced you would see any reduction in the abortion rate. It would take a miracle to turn things around. To me, even if Republicans give pro life issues only lip service, it is better than voting for someone who is so proudly pro abortion. We are told by the Church to do just that. But then again, I think obedience is a big deal…others feel they need to vote for what THEY BELIEVE is right. Pride can be very insidious.

As distasteful as it is, we are called on to VOTE even if we do not like either Candidate. ( I do think it is interesting that the Clintons seem to be distancing themselves from this President;))
 
The health care vote put a stake through the heart of the myth of the pro-life democrat congressman once and for all.
I think there are some conservative democrats in the south who are still pro-life…No, I’m not 100 percent sure, but maybe Gene Taylor or someone is a pro-life democrat. You certainly can be. I’m very pro-life, and not a democrat, but I think you can be both.
 
I’m going to make what would be a long post very short.

I don’t want to speak in generalities here but I know no other way around it. Why do those who claim to be Catholic and pro life (including a sizeable segment of politicians) magically seem to forget Pope John Paul II’s words on Catholic social teaching?
“Flowing from the right to life is another fundamental human right, namely the right to means enabling one to live life with dignity. The right to life means that every person on this planet has the right to a share of earthly goods sufficient for oneself and one’s family. Every person has the right to adequate food, clothing, housing, health care, education, employment and a safe environment. One cannot speak of the right to life without acknowledging the right to live that life in a manner that reflects the dignity of creatures made in God’s image.”
 
I’m going to make what would be a long post very short.

I don’t want to speak in generalities here but I know no other way around it. Why do those who claim to be Catholic and pro life (including a sizeable segment of politicians) magically seem to forget Pope John Paul II’s words on Catholic social teaching?
You highlighted “health care” in your quote. But one has to ask what the Democrat party has really done to make health care more available or affordable to those to to whom it is either unavailable or unaffordable. I don’t think anybody would disagree with the proposition that healthcare is a proper societal goal. The real question is how to get that done in a manner that actually comes closest to achieving the goal.

Most Americans already had healthcare coverage. The healthcare bill is actually a health insurance mandate and subsidy. What it really does is shift the cost of insurance from one segment of the middle class (most of whom had insurance already) to another segment (which might lose it as a result of the bill). Nobody knows whether any greater (or lesser) number of people will be covered as a result of this bill.

Nothing this one-party government did actually reduced any healthcare costs or increased its availability. It did, however, reduce funding for those receiving Medicare.
 
I’m going to make what would be a long post very short.
**Flowing from the right to life **is another fundamental human right, namely the right to means enabling one to live life with dignity. The right to life means that every person on this planet has the right to a share of earthly goods sufficient for oneself and one’s family. Every person has the right to adequate food, clothing, housing, health care, education, employment and a safe environment. One cannot speak of the right to life without acknowledging the right to live that life in a manner that reflects the dignity of creatures made in God’s image."
I don’t want to speak in generalities here but I know no other way around it. Why do those who claim to be Catholic and pro life (including a sizeable segment of politicians) magically seem to forget Pope John Paul II’s words on Catholic social teaching?
No question, a sizable segment of the population and politicians magically forget that the right to life is fundamental to Catholic social teaching, I agree. Especially Catholic politicians that deny the right to life to our most vulnerable innocents.
 
I’m going to make what would be a long post very short.

I don’t want to speak in generalities here but I know no other way around it. Why do those who claim to be Catholic and pro life (including a sizeable segment of politicians) magically seem to forget Pope John Paul II’s words on Catholic social teaching?
Hopefully you are not suggesting that a canidates solutions for social problems is in any way comaparable to their views on abortion, The Church categoically rejects that. All rights are irelevant if the right to life is denied. Regadless of how a candiate may posutre about caring for the poor he is unfit for the Catholic vote if he supports abortion.
 
You highlighted “health care” in your quote. But one has to ask what the Democrat party has really done to make health care more available or affordable to those to to whom it is either unavailable or unaffordable. I don’t think anybody would disagree with the proposition that healthcare is a proper societal goal. The real question is how to get that done in a manner that actually comes closest to achieving the goal.

Most Americans already had healthcare coverage. The healthcare bill is actually a health insurance mandate and subsidy. What it really does is shift the cost of insurance from one segment of the middle class (most of whom had insurance already) to another segment (which might lose it as a result of the bill). Nobody knows whether any greater (or lesser) number of people will be covered as a result of this bill.

Nothing this one-party government did actually reduced any healthcare costs or increased its availability. It did, however, reduce funding for those receiving Medicare.
It should also be noted that the USCCB opposed the health care bill that was passed. You dont provide health care by killing people before they are eligible to get it.
 
You highlighted “health care” in your quote. But one has to ask what the Democrat party has really done to make health care more available or affordable to those to to whom it is either unavailable or unaffordable. I don’t think anybody would disagree with the proposition that healthcare is a proper societal goal. The real question is how to get that done in a manner that actually comes closest to achieving the goal.

Most Americans already had healthcare coverage. The healthcare bill is actually a health insurance mandate and subsidy. What it really does is shift the cost of insurance from one segment of the middle class (most of whom had insurance already) to another segment (which might lose it as a result of the bill). Nobody knows whether any greater (or lesser) number of people will be covered as a result of this bill.

Nothing this one-party government did actually reduced any healthcare costs or increased its availability. It did, however, reduce funding for those receiving Medicare.
I only bolded health care to illustrate that health care is just as much a right as the right to life (commonly understood as the “right to be born”). Wasn’t my intention to debate or support the merits of the bill that passed - let say I despise it. That still doesn’t abrogate the obligation of others (on the other party or wherever else they may be) to at least propose a package, comprehensive or piecemeal, that provides a right to healthcare for all; in fact it might even increase the burden. When you firmly believe the “other guys” are going to do the wrong thing it is your duty to put forth the best platform so that there’s a choice between “A” and “B” rather than “A” or nothing.
No question, a sizable segment of the population and politicians magically forget that the right to life is fundamental to Catholic social teaching, I agree. Especially Catholic politicians that deny the right to life to our most vulnerable innocents.
I agree wholeheartedly and I believe they’ll have some extra special answering to do - as prominent Catholics they’re supposed to be role models of a sort and I can’t think of one that I’d want to emulate.

EDIT: Whoops, missed a post.
Hopefully you are not suggesting that a canidates solutions for social problems is in any way comaparable to their views on abortion, The Church categoically rejects that. All rights are irelevant if the right to life is denied. Regadless of how a candiate may posutre about caring for the poor he is unfit for the Catholic vote if he supports abortion.
No, I don’t believe that. In fact, my roommate up at college in '08 - an extremely helpful guide when it came to the faith - explained that point numerous times to me. Non-negotiable. However, that doesn’t mean it becomes acceptable to support those who deny other forms of the right to life as well - at least the way I understand it. We’re all called to vote based on our (well-formed) conscience.
 
I only bolded health care to illustrate that health care is just as much a right as the right to life (commonly understood as the “right to be born”). Wasn’t my intention to debate or support the merits of the bill that passed - let say I despise it. That still doesn’t abrogate the obligation of others (on the other party or wherever else they may be) to at least propose a package, comprehensive or piecemeal, that provides a right to healthcare for all; in fact it might even increase the burden. When you firmly believe the “other guys” are going to do the wrong thing it is your duty to put forth the best platform so that there’s a choice between “A” and “B” rather than “A” or nothing.
Flowing from the right to life is another fundamental human right, namely the right to means enabling one to live life with dignity. The right to life means that every person on this planet has the right to a share of earthly goods sufficient for oneself and one’s family. Every person has the right to adequate food, clothing, housing, health care, education, employment and a safe environment.
The way I read the statement is the right to live one’s life with dignity FLOWS from the right to life. In other words, you can’t be pro-abortion, and then demand the right to social dignity. It’s an oxymoron.

I agree everyone has the right to adequate food, clothing, etc. Who defines adequate? Is the government responsible for this? My belief is that the government should allow for all these rights but not provide them. The government should not impeded on my ability to help my neighbor. The government can even make it easier for me to accomplish this by allowing tax deductions for charitable donations.

Correct me if I’m wrong, but my understanding is the charitable donation deduction is going to be greatly decreased under the new health plan.
 
As distasteful as it is, we are called on to VOTE even if we do not like either Candidate.
It is not necessary to vote for either major party candidate for any office. One needs not vote for a particular office (I thought Obama inexperienced and couldn’t vote for McCain because of Palin on the ticket, so skipped voting for President). Also, there are third party candidates, regardless of their chance of being elected.

The Catechism bids us vote; it doesn’t say that we have to pull the lever for every office being contested.
 
It is not necessary to vote for either major party candidate for any office. One needs not vote for a particular office (I thought Obama inexperienced and couldn’t vote for McCain because of Palin on the ticket, so skipped voting for President). Also, there are third party candidates, regardless of their chance of being elected.

The Catechism bids us vote; it doesn’t say that we have to pull the lever for every office being contested.
Nevertheless, failure to oppose abortion-supporting candidates is a failure to combat evil when we had the chance to do it, however limited a chance that is.
 
It is not necessary to vote for either major party candidate for any office. One needs not vote for a particular office (I thought Obama inexperienced and couldn’t vote for McCain because of Palin on the ticket, so skipped voting for President). Also, there are third party candidates, regardless of their chance of being elected.

The Catechism bids us vote; it doesn’t say that we have to pull the lever for every office being contested.
Frpm a practical standpoint when one who is pro-life who votes for non viable third party canidate is abetting the election of the pro-abortion canidate. Although a Catholic can do this one would have to ask why they are sitting on the sidelines when we are confronting the most serious issue to ever face this country
 
Frpm a practical standpoint when one who is pro-life who votes for non viable third party canidate is abetting the election of the pro-abortion canidate. Although a Catholic can do this one would have to ask why they are sitting on the sidelines when we are confronting the most serious issue to ever face this country
Some may be voting for a third party because they sincerely believe in it. The Constitutional Party was one such - pro-life and very much Constitutional originalists. A lot of their voters saw no appreciable difference between the GOP and the Dems and would not support either.
 
Some may be voting for a third party because they sincerely believe in it. The Constitutional Party was one such - pro-life and very much Constitutional originalists. A lot of their voters saw no appreciable difference between the GOP and the Dems and would not support either.
Nevertheless, generally speaking there is a difference when it comes to abortion; a very big difference. For a very long time, on my ballot at least, the difference has been quite dramatic.

I realize one might think he/she is making a statement in voting for something like the Constitutionalist Party, but one has to know he/she is throwing away his/her opportunity to oppose abortion in an effective way by doing so. It might make one feel good, but it is, in reality, a failure to oppose a very serious evil. In failing to oppose evil, we support its continuation.
 
Some may be voting for a third party because they sincerely believe in it. The Constitutional Party was one such - pro-life and very much Constitutional originalists. A lot of their voters saw no appreciable difference between the GOP and the Dems and would not support either.
The net effect being we have the most pro-abortion administration in History. if pro-life supporters dont make the tough decisions required to end abortion in this country it never will. We can not let the perfect be the enemy of the possible. although you may have felt havng sara Palin as VP was repugnant at least we would not now be funding abortions and forced sterilization overseas.
 
I realize one might think he/she is making a statement in voting for something like the Constitutionalist Party, but one has to know he/she is throwing away his/her opportunity to oppose abortion in an effective way by doing so. It might make one feel good, but it is, in reality, a failure to oppose a very serious evil. In failing to oppose evil, we support its continuation.
I think it goes beyond feeling good. People who vote for parties like the Constitutionalist feel very strongly about it, and would rather take a stand for what they believe in than compromise their principles. Besides, a vote for that party is a vote to oppose abortion.

I may be wrong about this point, but I believe that the CP is wholly anti-abortion “with no exceptions.”
 
I think it goes beyond feeling good. People who vote for parties like the Constitutionalist feel very strongly about it, and would rather take a stand for what they believe in than compromise their principles. Besides, a vote for that party is a vote to oppose abortion.

I may be wrong about this point, but I believe that the CP is wholly anti-abortion “with no exceptions.”
And by being absolutists they spilt the pro-life vote and the slaughter continues.
 
The Catechism bids us vote; it doesn’t say that we have to pull the lever for every office being contested.
So by your logic, you could just vote for something like your local dog catcher, leave everything else blank for every other office being decided that year, and claim that you were still technically following the Catechism’s exhortation to vote? :rolleyes: If not, then please explain why this whole thing isn’t really the huge rationalization it sounds like.
 
I think it goes beyond feeling good. People who vote for parties like the Constitutionalist feel very strongly about it, and would rather take a stand for what they believe in than compromise their principles. Besides, a vote for that party is a vote to oppose abortion.

I may be wrong about this point, but I believe that the CP is wholly anti-abortion “with no exceptions.”
I understand. But there is very little likelihood any political party will be on “all fours” with what I personally think about a wide variety of issues. So, ultimately, if it’s total agreement I’m looking for, I’ll inevitably end up voting for myself all the time.

I see no real difference between voting for some party that can’t win and voting for myself. Either one is basically a self-affirmation. I prefer to actually oppose the very serious evils of abortion and intentional fetal vivisection. That means supporting those who oppose those things and opposing those who favor them. At present, this means to vote Republican, on my ballot at least, since the lines are pretty clearly drawn.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top