Man from ministry bans Potter

  • Thread starter Thread starter K-McD
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
SILVERNAME said:
What? You mean you didn’t hear jk herself say that many kids were calling her and asking her about witches and witchcraft and how to be one?
Click to expand...
I’m disappointed she didn’t answer their question as Id like to know the answer myself. My life’s desire to become teacher of dark arts at Hogwarts
Well that did happen, JK herself admitted it, and now she says that dumbeldore is a homophile, who was looking for a man.

Some who has homophile desires and is looking for someone from the same sex for “love” ( yeah right more like perversion)
IS is a practicing homophile/sodomite, contrary to what the liberal homophile coddling potter-lovers might claim.
Click to expand...
Well he wasn’t exactly looking for a man. He foiund him and proceeded to beat the snot out of him in a Magic duel and throw in jail for the rest of his life.
And yes it is in the books, although it was subtle, but not anymore, so now when children who know about that sodomite reads the books, they now have a different understanding of what that immoral story is talking about.
Click to expand...
There are children’s book to teach much worse lessons than this. Please check out the thread "I was wrong about Harry Potter "
Harry Potter promotes witchcraft, we have known that for a very long time, and now we know that it is also promoting disent against the teachings of the Church especially with regards to homophilia.
Click to expand...
And you forgot to add that the Pope condemned this book, I believe on the same day he declared the Iraq war unjust and commanded us to continue praying statues.
Harry Potter truly is a piece of trash that should be banned from all Christian schools and libraries.

Let the secularist homophile coddling libraries and schools stock that garbage if they want to, but Christian schools and libraries should be kept free from such occult and homophilic filth.
Click to expand...
Gee Silvername ,tell what you really think about homosexuals
That man from ministry did the right thing, the Christian thing, he should be commended for his righteous act.
Click to expand...
I think you just did. I am wondering however, if you’re really Catholic or if you actually belong to a Baptist Church in Topeka?
 
Brendan said:
So Nohome, is it your belief that characters in a childrens book can do an immoral act, and it’s justifiable simply because the characters are fictional?
Click to expand...
So Brendan, is it your belief that all children’s books need to be sanitized and void of reality?

Nohome
 
Nohome said:
HP is fantasy!

Nohome
Click to expand...
So was A Goddess Arrives and High Magic’s Aid by Gerald Gardner
which led to Wicca that leads others away from Christ. Evil has crept in by fiction.
By the same token, with books like Lion Witch and the Wardrobe and The Lord of the Rings good also is presented.
 
adrift said:
So was A Goddess Arrives and High Magic’s Aid by Gerald Gardner
which led to Wicca that leads others away from Christ. Evil has crept in by fiction.
By the same token, with books like Lion Witch and the Wardrobe and The Lord of the Rings good also is presented.
Click to expand...
No doubt about it. All books should be banned becuase you never know where the evil might lurk.
 
The only thing that evil needs to triumph is for the good to do nothing. It is interesting to me that snide remarks are replacing reason. But then when you have no reason:shrug:
 
adrift said:
The only thing that evil needs to triumph is for the good to do nothing. It is interesting to me that snide remarks are replacing reason. But then when you have no reason:shrug:
Click to expand...
It is interesting to me the gross overreaction many people have to series of fantasy books . It also bothers me that many of these people claim to have some kind special insight into the catholic faith that reveals to him that all the rest of us are wrong Kinda reminds me of what they used to say about the Puritans-always worried that somewhere someplace someone might being enjoying themselves.

In my opinion denying one’s children reading the Harry Potter books is child abuse. How’s that for gross overreaction?
 
estesbob said:
It is interesting to me the gross overreaction many people have to series of fantasy books . It also bothers me that many of these people claim to have some kind special insight into the catholic faith that reveals to him that all the rest of us are wrong Kinda reminds me of what they used to say about the Puritans-always worried that somewhere someplace someone might being enjoying themselves.

In my opinion denying one’s children reading the Harry Potter books is child abuse. How’s that for gross overreaction?
Click to expand...
Thank you for proving my point about when you have no reason.
 
adrift said:
Thank you for proving my point about when you have no reason.
Click to expand...
You know I’ve seen the light and I really think we need to get Bambi banned also. Children should at least 18 to be exposed any kind of grief at all. And I think that the smart aleck attitude of thumper leads our children to misbehave and talk back to their parents.

In fact I think having read the Harry Potter threads its best we don’t even allow our children to learn the read until they are 18. After all we know that Satan is hiding just inside the covers of even the most innocuous book-just waiting to suck the souls out of our children. We simply cannot take that chance. We are extremely lucky to have such diligent parents like you to help us shelter our children from this evil.
 
Nohome said:
Good is not presented in Harry Potter? Have you read the books?

Nohome
Click to expand...
I have read the books. I enjoyed the books that does not mean that I do not see the danger in them. Wicca is not compatible with Christianity. I wasn’t implying that she read the books. What I was saying is that she got into it at 12 the age that this book is aimed at. The influence is yet to be known. There is a danger here that some make lite of. There is some good criticism especially by Brendan but instead of addressing that legitimate critique it is made fun of. I guess because, like me they enjoyed it, and they don’t want to look at the bad. I have already stated why the book bothered me.
 
:o
adrift said:
My Grandson’s Soul

Will we have more heartbreak like Grandson’s Soul? Her child started at 12 the age that these books are suppose to be for.
Click to expand...
So a kid embraces Wicca and even thoug there is no evidence that he has read Harry Potter or no evidence whatsoever that anything in Harry Potte promotes Wicca you post this i as if it is some kind of validation of your gross distortions of the Harry Potter books. Is there no tragedy you will not use to try to defend your indefensible position?
 
Brendan said:
Yes, Harry always has a good intent while he uses torture and enslavement spells.while robbing banks :rolleyes:
Click to expand...
So, am I safe to assume that you are equally outraged by the story of Robinhood? I mean, hey he robbed and caused misery to bad guys. Arrows are O.K. but magic wands are dangerous?

Nohome
 
Nohome said:
So, am I safe to assume that you are equally outraged by the story of Robinhood? I mean, hey he robbed and caused misery to bad guys. Arrows are O.K. but magic wands are dangerous?

Nohome
Click to expand...
It has been awhile but It seems to me that Robin only restored money that had been stolen.
 
adrift said:
It has been awhile but It seems to me that Robin only restored money that had been stolen.
Click to expand...
Dont you recal his motto was "rob from the rich and give to the poor.? Besides under the principal of the double effect harry was OK in robbing the vault as he intent was to free a blind Dragon and recover stolen property.🙂
 
This is going to be my last post as I believe everything and every ones position is clear.
I like Harry Potter. I have reservations about it and what is bad about it has been clearly stated. It is a shame that those objections are met with derision rather than reasoned discussion. I felt uneasy about some of the plot. I did not like the whole class of divination. It may bother me because when I was a teenager a friend got deeply involved with this type of thing. Some Demonic things happened around her. It was very scary and very sad. I never knew what happened to her. Could this book lead others to experiment with this stuff? I don’t know. The book does put the spin that there is little to it and I liked that about the book. However, it also indicated that sometimes it was true. I like that about the book. What I didn’t like was that this was considered the tools of the trade. That it may not be believable but it was acceptable which it is not.
One more incident in the series which surprisingly no one has mentioned, Mrs. Weasley upon learning her family is safe says “Thank God”. It strikes me that no one comments on it because this is regarded as a line we say all the time without really meaning it.
I don’t understand why this cannot be discussed without being attacked. It might have been enlightening. There are those who have been so acid in there comments which really under mind all that they have to say and they were so bad that I have put them on the ignore list.
To sum it up. This is not a book for children. The priest was right in pulling it from the library. Parents should be vigilant in the education of their children. When mine were young, I taped the show they liked and previewed them. They didn’t get to see everything they would have liked. That was my duty as a parent. I also kept from them books that I thought would endanger their soul. Judy Blume was one author that they could not read. There were other books that were equally enjoyable to them. God Bless to you all.:twocents:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top