G
Gift_from_God
Guest
See, here’s what I like about being Canadian; we have two official languages; English and French (mainly in Quebec though). The only mandatory language classes in Ontario where I live is French
Students ought to have a good command of English before moving on to a second language.In the US, it Spanish is more useful!
Its required to be offered in the curriculum in order to get federal funds.The phrases “required language”, “Arabic classes would be mandatory” lead me to think otherwise at last at two of the schools.
I can understand offering it, and requiring X amount of foriegn language, by why require a specific foriegn language??
Maybe so, but I would take a power of convincing to make me think so. The perceived importance of particular languages comes and goes. (Who studies Russian anymore?) But even during the heyday of a particular language’s seeming importance, one has to ask just how many people are actually going to learn it and for what purpose?.
However, I would think studying Arabic would be important for us as a nation. The more we know about Arab culture and language, the better off well be in terms of security and more importantly, dialog with the Middle Eastern Arab nations.
Jim
Actually, in learning a second language one learns more about one’s language than one would in studying only one’s own language. It’s a paradox, but it’s true. I learned a LOT about English when I took French in High School. I forgot most of the French, but I am fluent in Spanish now.Students ought to have a good command of English before moving on to a second language.
To some people Arabic = Islam.I think this would be better placed in the News forum, since Arabic isn’t a religion.
So you don’t want people to study Arabic if that means that they will be studying the Qur’an?Texas FLAP over Arabic classes in schools
Arabic studies include language acquisition, culture, government, art, traditions and history. MISD has been awarded a total of $1.3 million over a five year period to promote learning. Mansfield ISD graduates will possess the language proficiency and cross cultural communication skills to compete in the 21st century. Our students will be at an advantage in an increasingly diverse and economically global society.
speroforum.com/site/article.asp?idCategory=34&idsub=127&id=48226&t=Texas+FLAP+over+Arabic+classes+in+schools
So, now your federal govenment is making American Students to study the koran.
I think it would depend on the language as well. I was surprised to find, in studying French, that no only is a very significant part of English derived from French, but that much of the structure and even some of the idiomatic expressions are the same.Actually, in learning a second language one learns more about one’s language than one would in studying only one’s own language. It’s a paradox, but it’s true. I learned a LOT about English when I took French in High School. I forgot most of the French, but I am fluent in Spanish now.
I wish I would have been exposed to something like that in school.Texas FLAP over Arabic classes in schools
Arabic studies include language acquisition, culture, government, art, traditions and history. MISD has been awarded a total of $1.3 million over a five year period to promote learning. Mansfield ISD graduates will possess the language proficiency and cross cultural communication skills to compete in the 21st century. Our students will be at an advantage in an increasingly diverse and economically global society.
speroforum.com/site/article.asp?idCategory=34&idsub=127&id=48226&t=Texas+FLAP+over+Arabic+classes+in+schools
So, now your federal govenment is making American Students to study the koran.
I’m currently reading the book, “Mother Tongue: English & How It Got That Way,” by Bll Bryson.I think it would depend on the language as well. I was surprised to find, in studying French, that no only is a very significant part of English derived from French, but that much of the structure and even some of the idiomatic expressions are the same.
I have never studied Spanish, but just looking at it, there is a lot of similarity between it and French.
I recall having read that English is about 1/3 Teutonic, 1/3 French and 1/3 (more directly) Latin in origin, with bits and pieces of Scandinavian languages here and there, a trace of Gaelic structure (though almost no words) and “one shot” word borrowings from everywhere. I would think, though, that one would not learn a great deal about English by studying some language that had none of those origins, particularly one that is not Indo-European at all.
If these classes are mandatory—and just because of some ‘government grant’—there is every reason to object.So you don’t want people to study Arabic if that means that they will be studying the Qur’an?
Your objection makes no sense. Arabic is one of the major languages of the world. It is extremely important that American students learn it. I wish I had done so. Don’t you want to see a generation of Americans who are able to read Arabic websites for themselves? Can’t you see how effective that might be in detecting terrorist plots, for one thing?
And what’s bad about knowing the Qur’an? Do you share the view of Muslims that the Qur’an is so beautiful and so compelling that anyone who studies it will want to become a Muslim? If you do share this view, why aren’t you a Muslim? Do you think that Satan has somehow given the Qur’an a magical power?
Isn’t it more likely that studying the Qur’an will make young Americans better informed about Islam–and isn’t that a good thing? Won’t it make either ignorant prejudice or naive whitewashing less likely?
Note: I am more realistic than the above sounds. I’m aware that most people who study a language aren’t functional in it, and that most who do have some knowledge are not going to be spending a lot of time reading texts in it. But those who do have an aptitude for languages need to be exposed to some of the non-Western languages that are spoken by millions of people, represent ancient and influential civilizations, and continue to shape the world we live in for good and/or ill.
Edwin
So it’s all about money?Indeed. I live in a city with a few couple world famous hospitals, and we alway have sultans, shahs, and Middle Eastern oil barons coming here to get treatment. Translators therefore are in high demand at the hospitals, and the hourly rate for interpreters is quite impressive. Certainly worth learning a language or two.
Do you have a basis for this opinion? I’m not at all sure that this is sound pedagogy, though I’m willing to be shown wrong (and admittedly I’m skeptical about research in education anyway–it seems even less reliable than in other fields).Students ought to have a good command of English before moving on to a second language.
My favorite is “alot.” I’ve seen that in so many places, written by so many people. Also the apostrophes which are inserted to indicate a plural number of nouns. So I see: “Alot of the rabbit’s ran down the holes and were saved to.” Why are the words “rabbit’s” and “holes” being used in the same sentence? “There are to cat’s and three dogs and their hungry alot.” Uh huh, right. I’ve started seeing that in ads now. I think the English language has developed into “High English” and “Low English.”These students are being taught a marketable skill-they could become “Peggy” on the phone to those in the Middle East.
This is sad. Especially when English isn’t mastered. To/Two/Too, There/Their/They’re…etc…
Wow.
God Bless you.
+Jesus, I Trust In You!
Love, Dawn
Would you object to mandatory Chinese classes? Or mandatory Spanish classes? Or just Arabic?If these classes are mandatory—and just because of some ‘government grant’—there is every reason to object.