Mars Rover Detects Simple Organic Compounds

  • Thread starter Thread starter EmperorNapoleon
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
E

EmperorNapoleon

Guest
NASA’s Mars rover Curiosity has detected several simple carbon-based organic compounds on Mars, but it remains unclear whether they were formed via Earthly contamination or whether they contain only elements indigenous to the planet.
Speaking at the American Geophysical Union annual meeting in San Francisco, Curiosity mission leaders also said that the compound perchlorate—identified previously in polar Mars—appeared to also be present in Gale Crater, the site of Curiosity’s exploration.
The possible discovery of organics—or carbon-based compounds bonded to hydrogen, also called hydrocarbons—could have major implications for the mission’s search for more complex organic material.
It would not necessarily mean that life exists now or ever existed on Mars, but it makes the possibility of Martian life—especially long ago when the planet was wetter and warmer—somewhat greater, since available carbon is considered to be so important to all known biology.
This is exciting news. 🙂
 
This is exciting news. 🙂
So they found more of something they already knew was on Mars (it had previously been found in the polar regions)? A substance than can form from natural exposure to ultraviolet light, and doesn’t necessarily imply life? Even if it is native to Mars it doesn’t mean much.

This is not just non-news, it’s 30 year old non-news (percholrates were first discovered by the Viking landings). :o

Peace and God bless!

P.S. Misread the article, and thought that the discovery was just about perchlorate. Might be interesting to see what these organic compounds are. 👍

That said, “organic” in this context just means “carbon based”, and doesn’t imply life. It’s still pretty much non-news.
 
Yes, but exciting nonetheless. I’m optimistic that these compounds are native to Mars.
Why the optimism? Has there been life on Mars or perhaps something that could have developed into it? It is a scientific question with a yes or no answer. I can understand the interest in a given scientific question generating excitement (if someone was to prove P=NP or N not = NP in computer science, I would get excited about it). But why the desire (reflected by your optimism) for an answer either way?
 
If there’s no complex organic compound on Mars, it is a none event. Meh. There are trillions of ton of organic compound and amino acid on Titan and Kuiper belt. Some DNA and RNA monocules have been detected or found in the Kuiper belt region of the solar system.
 
If there’s no complex organic compound on Mars, it is a none event. Meh. There are trillions of ton of organic compound and amino acid on Titan and Kuiper belt. Some DNA and RNA monocules have been detected or found in the Kuiper belt region of the solar system.
I’ve never heard about DNA and RNA being found on Titan and the Kuiper belt; I don’t believe we’ve sent the kind of equipment out there that could even detect such things.

That said, I’m betting this discovery is nothing more than some very basic amino acids at most. They’re organic, but they’re nowhere close to life. I’m not opposed in any way to the idea of life having been on Mars, but judging by the wording of this “leak” I don’t think we’re anywhere close to that discovery yet. Even my geekdar isn’t getting beeping with this one. 😦

Peace and God bless!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top