This is an ugly issue on many levels although, in the end, it is quite simple. As a male that has chosen not to sleep around, I will attempt to situate some of the issues you are encountering without BSing you. You seem to have encountered enough of that at this point.
- You are not a virgin. You have been loose/promiscuous/wild in the past. This is a major warning bell for guys like myself (few of us that are left anyway). Past behavior is the single best predictor of future behavior. Something in your past/upbringing tainted your values and ways of viewing yourself and the world. Most men or women with your past sexual promiscuity are unlikely to change their values and behave in a moral fashion. The myth is that people change; they rarely do.
In your case, you also have a rape background which accounts for a great deal of your past actions.
For this first point, you have to realize a few things. Only a foolish man would date you, learn about your past, and simply overlook it because you claim to be on the straight and narrow. This works in reverse too. You would be foolish to date a guy with a loose background and simply overlook his past because he was “born again” or “found himself.” It is unlikely that a person like yourself would really change.
However, as a Christian, we are called to accept the possibility of forgiveness and true change via Christ/confession/redemption. This is the ugly part for people like myself that observe predictable destructive patterns of behavior among today’s women. Here’s the thing: If I were dating you, I would hope you would have great humility and shame about your past. If I sensed that feeling of honesty from you, I, and most decent men, would give you a chance. Considering your past, “a chance” means spending A LOT of time with you to make sure you are sincere. We’re talking a two-year minimum. This is always difficult in a relationship because the longer it goes on, the more the heart wants to rule the head. Again, you should want to spend a good deal of time with any future guy before marriage because your character background makes you more susceptible to the legions of players and snakes out there.
- You claim to be giving in to Catholics that want to sleep with you. These so-called Catholics are not even Christian. What’s the old saying? “Know them by their fruits”? They can sing in the choir and organize church activities all day long, but if they exploit fellow Christians/citizens, they will be in a for a rude awakening when they face their Maker. Their snake personalities, however, do not excuse your behavior. By your own admission, you are still sleeping around. If you wish to be taken seriously by a decent Christian guy, you have to walk the walk. Tell these so-called Catholic leaders to stick it and inform your priest/clergy about the issue. Wolves in sheep’s clothing have no business leading any church activities. Again, focus on your behavior. This world is a couple clowns shy of a circus, but you don’t have to be one.
- The third point is rather depressing because there is not a whole lot you can do about it. We are living in a morally bankrupt society. Men and women sleep around, divorce, have kids, live together, and call it macaroni. People have tattoos and piercings all over their faces and bodies. It’s train wreck central. Men sleeping with men, abortion, discarded babies from artificial insemination, it’s the new normal. Those of us that do not behave this way are a vanishing and increasingly alienated breed. What does this mean for you? It means it is incredibly difficult for anyone to find a traditional man/woman that shares old school Christian values and tries to live the life. I’m not advocating that we all are perfect, but sleeping around is a big deal or at least it should be. Your troubled past makes the few good guys out there hesitant because of the current cultural mindset. That’s not fair to you if you really are sincere and have turned your life around via Christ and morality. It is, however, a sad truth you should keep in mind.
I’ll summarize briefly what I recommend:
- Stop sleeping around.
- Tell those Catholic fakers to stick it. Don’t coddle evil.
- Stop sleeping around with anyone.
- Work on yourself for a while (a year maybe) until you are confident about fending off these types of snakes.
- Be brutally honest with any guy you like and be equally humble about it. Prospective spouses have a right to know about who you are and that includes a full accounting of your past. A good guy will give you a chance and probably be more forthcoming about his own issues even if they laughably pale in comparison to the trauma of your past. This sharing of your history will necessarily leave you a bit vulnerable but there is no avoiding it.
- If you have truly turned your life around and have ditched your old habits, don’t beat yourself up over it. You’re doing what God wants; that’s all anyone, including yourself, can ask for.