It is a very inadequate article. There is no reference to what the diocesan sex ed program is. This is the crux of the issue!
If it is one of the awful, secular programs prepared by non-catholics from a fundamentally non-catholic worldview and then dressed up at the end with a few catholic window dressings, then the school is in the right.
In my diocese, kids are required to participate in the “Talking about Touching” program for abuse prevention. Sounds great until you start hearing the rumors. Rumors such as, the program was originally developed by a group called “COYOTE” (Call off your old tired ethics) which was a support group for prostitutes that sought to reduce the prevalence of sexual abuse in children of hookers! Ya THINK there might be some fundamental incompatibility in a program developed by such a group? Might it NOT be better to develop a program from scratch BY and FOR catholics who believe that catholic teaching on the meaning of human sexuality is divinely revealed?
The article is woefully short on critical information.