I have heard just the opposite – from a priest. Fr. John Riccardo whose talks air on EWTN radio had addressed this subject and stated that he cannot tell the degree of a person’s culpability in confession. If you look at para. 1735 of the CCC, it doesn’t even list all the reasons for reduced or nullified culpability.
If para 1735 didn’t mean anything, that every “grave” matter is moral sin, then the CCC wouldn’t need para 1735.
Fr. Mitch Pacwa has interpreted 1735 very narrowly. For example, he says that the psychological basis for reduced culpability means what we hear described as a person being criminally insane. I disagree that this is the intent of 1735, because it pushes the definition of psychological factors to a standard outside of the Church, namely the varying legal definitions from place to place of what constitutes criminal insanity. So, Fr. Pacwa’s explanation sounds good on TV, but it doesn’t explain as much as it sounds like, and it makes 1735 almost an obscure footnote to the deposit of faith.
Likewise, Fr. Pacwa remarks about “habit” as reducing one’s culpability, but he quickly retorts that it is still sinful to develop a habit in the first place. So, he changes the subject.
Privately, by email, I received a reply from EWTN that Fr. Pacwa considers 1735 too complex a subject to discuss on TV.
Likewise, I wrote the USCCB to obtain guidance on para. 1735 and received no response at all. I had asked for a fuller explanation of it and/or a reference to papers or books on the subject – and got no response.
In a series on the catechism, Fr. (Patrick?) O’Connor essentially skipped over para. 1735.
1735 is one of the paragraphs cited in Amoris Laetitia that has drawn a lot of differing responses from different bishops of the world.
The most frequent response in the previous and current forums is to confess everything and let the priest sort it out. Somehow, I believe 1735 is about God’s mercy, not legalisms and definitions. Finally, I would point out that a careful reading of 1735 in its present form describes reduced culpability for inadvertent sins and for intentional “sins.”
Judaism is known for “building a fence” around the Torah – making up rules so that we don’t even get close to committing an offense against God. The CCC and Judaism advised regular reading of scripture to raise our awareness of what IS a sin, at least potentially, and learning to hate sin and to flee from it.
Judaism advises its followers to be very sober when confronting evil, and like Catholic teaching, to be aware of what is right and wrong. The idea is to decide IN ADVANCE, not in the heat of the moment, to avoid the sin. Have your mind made up IN ADVANCE that you will dismiss this temptation and what you will take the place of performing that forbidden act.