Maybe it's just time to go

  • Thread starter Thread starter Irish_Eyes_826
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Thanks everybody for the prayers and suggestions, I’ll be sure to try them 🙂
But right now, I still feel lost. I don’t what I am. A lot of people here say that I’m not Catholic because there is just so much I don’t believe in or struggle to believe. I think I’m Catholic, but only because that’s what I grew up as and don’t know how to be anything else. I have trouble grasping the concept of “God,” but I still think Jesus sounds like the coolest, kindest man ever, that Mary is my mother, and that St. Francis showed us how a real hippie rolls. But there are just many things that I cannot currently, and probably never will, believe, even though I try.
As far as my family and friends, as well as myself, I just don’t know how God could condemn us if they do the things we do. Most of the drug-users and alcoholics do what they do to numb their pain. Most women I know use contraception because they’re scared of what could happen if they didn’t. Many of the liars we’re lied to by everyone around them. We’re working with the cards we were dealt and God gave a lot of us some pretty difficult cards. It not like they actually want to do this, it’s that they don’t know any other way to cope. How could a loving God condemn them?
Hi Irish Eyes,
The ‘rules’ are there for our own benefit. You can’t just force yourself to follow the rules. You need grace. God can give you the desire to follow his ‘rules’. Religion is about getting to know God not about earning your own salvation by following rules. Focus on getting to know Jesus and ask him for help for yourself and your relatives and friends who can’t seem to follow the rules.
 
Everyone tells me that I think of God too legalistically. But I should- you either go to heaven or you don’t, end of story. There is a set way to get in, a set way not to. I just don’t know what way it is.
@Julia: I think you might be right, sometimes I get a little scared when I ask an innocent question and then get skewered in the replies. And honestly, it’s not a good thing, but I’m the first to admit about myself that I’m not a “good Catholic.” But hey, sometimes I think it may just beat being a self-righteous holy roller. :rolleyes:
God is like a lover. Think of it this way. What if you hadn’t yet met the man that you’re going to marry, and someone came along and told you, “Here’s what you have to do: you have to blush and act shy the first time he asks you out. The second time, you have to say “yes,” but make him meet you at a coffee shop where your girlfriends can check him out for you from a distance. Then, you have to feel all gushy, and write love poetry on his Twitter feed all day every day for like three months or something.”

What if someone gave you those as rules to follow? You’d probably take one look and say, “That’s insane, I can’t do that.”

But then when he actually comes along and you meet him for real, you actually just find yourself doing all these things, without even really thinking about it - it all just comes naturally.

It’s the same with God. Work on getting to know God, by praying. Get into a routine of praying to God whenever you think of it. The rest will come naturally. The rules won’t seem so bad, then - they’ll seem like the obvious thing to do, in fact. 🙂
 
@Neil: I know the rules, and I know I should follow. And guess I’m just like every other doubter in history who needs to know “why?”.
@jmcrae: I like this comparison. However, with that scenario I would say that’s crazy. And then I would ask God why he would ask me to meet Him through coffee, poetry, and twitter, three things I don’t even like. I guess I’m just playing hard-to-get with God:o.
In my theology class we just learned that Israel means, “Wrestles with God.” I liked this. It reminds me that I’m not the only one struggling with God.
 
One thing to remember is that the church has never taught that any specific person is in Hell. (With the possible exception of Judas…) Never.

Not Hitler.
Not Pol Pot.
Not Ghadaffi.
Not one of them does Benedict XVI point to and say “Yep, he’s in Hell.”

The legalistic idea of “meeting His standards” as if we’re all trying to get into a celestial “good guys club” melts away when you realize that He is calling to each and every one of us, every moment of the day. He wants us in heaven. None of us deserve heaven by our own merits, but God wants us there all the same. He’s not looking for reasons to keep us out – we do that ouselves by preferring other things to Him. In essence, God does not condemn anyone to Hell, I firmly believe. We choose hell by choosing to do that which offends God. Offended, he still loves us. I think the last thing a person sees at the judgement, assuming that they do end up going to hell, is not thunderbolts and lightning and a “begone, you wretched sinner, from my sight!” but instead God, looking at them with eyes of infinite sadness, saying “I wanted you, my beloved creation, with me for all eternity. But love includes letting you go on your own path.” And even at that last moment, the moment we draw our very last breath, he gives us that one last chance to say “I’m sorry, God. please forgive me. Let me return the love you have shown me” through a perfect act of contrition.
Unfortunately once you are at the Judgment Seat, it is too late. You cannot repent after you have died. Once you have died, it is too late to repent and go to Heaven.
 
@Neil: I know the rules, and I know I should follow. And guess I’m just like every other doubter in history who needs to know “why?”.
Hi Irish Eyes,
I feel like I didn’t get my point across. I wanted to say that you can’t follow the rules on your own, and its not about following the rules, its about getting to know God. Only with God’s grace will you be able to make progress. First you need to get to know God. Being close to God can transform and change your life and it can be so wonderful that you’ll finally understand all this stuff.
 
As far as my family and friends, as well as myself, I just don’t know how God could condemn us if they do the things we do. Most of the drug-users and alcoholics do what they do to numb their pain. Most women I know use contraception because they’re scared of what could happen if they didn’t. Many of the liars we’re lied to by everyone around them. We’re working with the cards we were dealt and God gave a lot of us some pretty difficult cards. It not like they actually want to do this, it’s that they don’t know any other way to cope. How could a loving God condemn them?
Hi Irish Eyes (I just love your username!),

God is fair, so I am not sure that He would condemn you, your family or friends. If we don’t want to be judged hastily, then I think we shouldn’t judge God either. How could we judge Him and think that He wouldn’t show mercy? Remember the bible story of the woman who was caught in adultery? People were ready to throw stones at her, but our Lord stopped them and said, “He who has no sin among you, let him throw the first stone.” Remember that?

So, I think that Jesus knows our weaknesses, and that He understands our humanity, because He himself was human. That said, it does not mean that He approves adultery, or any other kind of sin. In the bible, He often would show mercy and kindness to the sinner, but right after that He would say, “Go and sin no more.” That means, He was ready and willing to forgive those who repent and ask for mercy, but He did not want them to continue living in sin.

Therefore, as far as you are concerned, I think that you should throw yourself into His mercy and love, repent of any sin, and sin no more. True, you might sin again after that. If that happens, then go back to Him and ask for mercy again. Remember, it was He Himself who said that we must forgive our enemies not seven times, but seventy times seven. Why would He advise us to do that if He Himself wouldn’t do the same?

The truth is, we humans are often harder on ourselves than God Himself is. We expect too much from ourselves. God is more merciful than we are, and He is more willing to forgive than we sometimes will to be forgiven. That is why King David said that he would rather be punished by God than by men, because men punish only with justice, whereas His just punishments are tempered by mercy.
 
I just wanted to add one more thing, you said:
T… I still think Jesus sounds like the coolest, kindest man ever, …
That sounds like a good foundation. Maybe you need to run with that and take Him up on this offer:

“Behold, I stand at the door and knock. If anyone hears my voice and opens the door, (then) I will enter his house and dine with him, and he with me.”

This is real. You can know Him in a personal way. I think you said He seems impersonal. Why not spend time in prayer each day (for as many days or months as it takes) petitioning for Him to show himself in a personal way, like that promise in the bible verse above? I’m not just throwing metaphors around, this is real.
 
Thanks everybody for the prayers and suggestions, I’ll be sure to try them 🙂
But right now, I still feel lost. I don’t what I am. A lot of people here say that I’m not Catholic because there is just so much I don’t believe in or struggle to believe. I think I’m Catholic, but only because that’s what I grew up as and don’t know how to be anything else. I have trouble grasping the concept of “God,” but I still think Jesus sounds like the coolest, kindest man ever, that Mary is my mother, and that St. Francis showed us how a real hippie rolls. But there are just many things that I cannot currently, and probably never will, believe, even though I try.
As far as my family and friends, as well as myself, I just don’t know how God could condemn us if they do the things we do. Most of the drug-users and alcoholics do what they do to numb their pain. Most women I know use contraception because they’re scared of what could happen if they didn’t. Many of the liars we’re lied to by everyone around them. We’re working with the cards we were dealt and God gave a lot of us some pretty difficult cards. It not like they actually want to do this, it’s that they don’t know any other way to cope. How could a loving God condemn them?
Why are you so sure that God has condemn them? They’re not dead yet and even then there’s purgatory. I believe we are given opportunity after opportunity to save ourselves. Let’s suppose a person is in total denial of his sins and dies. He sees Christ and is totally overwhelmed by the LOVE and asks to be with Him. And he is told that he must first be made aware of all the sins he has committed and repent for them. And so he is sent to Purgatory until that is accomplished. Is that not fair?

Now what about hell. Terrible sinner dies and doesn’t cry out for the mercy of God. How does that happen? Because he has been totally taken over by the power of evil in this life and will not, because he has free will, admit his sins just like Lucifer would not admit his.

It isn’t just your family and friends who have had to deal with drugs, alcohol, lust, and all the deadly sins. Everyone reading this has been challenged themselves and know some family member or friend who has these problems. There isn’t anything wrong with a drug or having a drink if it is used appropriately for the intended purpose. It is when it is abused and used as a crutch for life’s difficulties that it becomes a sin.

Life is not easy for anyone. We were all, not just a lot, dealt difficult hands we don’t think we deserve. Everyone, rich or poor, has a cross. Sometimes the rich person has the biggest cross. Christ had His cross too and He cried in the garden because He didn’t want to do it either so we’re not alone in this. Just like Christ, I do not want to suffer. I don’t want to lose a loved one, have an incapacitating disease, be alone. But the stats are, I will experience all three. So like many others, I pray for strength.

Our Lady said to St. Bernadette that she could not promise her happiness in this world but could promise her happiness in the next.
 
Speak to a priest you trust or find one that you can talk to and tell him honestly of your concerns,I am sure he will be able to set you on the right road.

I am no expert,we are all just normal regular people from all walks of life.Don’t let some people put you off what is the church that Jesus established.Yes some things have gone badly wrong that is because we are human and susceptible to failure.They will be answerable for their actions to God.This is still the right church just human’s often fail.

May God bless you my friend and guide you
Don't give up! You're on the right path, you just need someone to guide you. Doubts, fears & questions are a normal (& scary) part of our journey. Many, many Saints went through a "dark night of the soul". You need a spriritual director, someone you can meet with on a regular basis one-to-one. In my humble opinion, I think you should concentrate all your efforts right now on finding this person. Don't get discouraged if you think you've found the right one & it turns out you haven't- keep searching! In the meantime, go to Mass every Sunday- don't worry if you don't feel anything or understand everything- God will do the work. Keep your prayer life simple & basic, but remember, you don't have to "feel" anything. Table your most serious concerns for now- put them on the back burner to be dealt with when you are stronger in the faith, & with the help of a spiritual director. Limit your Bible study to the daily readings for now, & don't take everything you see on the Internet as Gospel! I have put you on my prayer list.
 
Hi

I left the Church for many years for many of the reasons you mention. The one thing I couldn’t accept was all of the suffering and misery that I saw. How could there be a loving God?

One afternoon I was sitting alone and I thought about God and thought, This is your last chance (really, arrogant, right?), if you exist, how do you exist? Then I heard the still small voice. It said, “I am.” A light came on in my mind and I understood that God is and always has been. God is existence itself.

I can’t make you believe that. You have to truly feel it for yourself. Prayer is the best means to hear the voice of God. As for the Church. Well, to me Jesus is the Church. Unfortunately, there are some real wowsers out there who misrepresent how we are meant to live as Catholics and as Christians and highjack our faith to promote their own agendas. Jesus talks about that in scriptures and warns us about wolves in sheeps’ clothing.

I stopped posting on CAF for just that very reason. This is just a flying visit.

The love of God is the most beautiful comforting gift that you can have in your life. You have it now even if you’re not aware of it. Be open to it without trying to force it? Eventually, you’ll feel it.

God bless you,
Clare 🙂
 
I think it’s time for me to stop trying to be someone I’m not. I try and try to be a Catholic, but I fail anyway. I think it’s time to just admit that it’s just not something I believe in.
I don’t believe in a lot the dogma. I just don’t. I don’t like shutting my mind to things, but I realize there are parts of Catholicism that I just don’t believe. And the state of the church with all the scandals and hypocrisy, how could this be what God intended?
Even more general than my doubts about Catholicism, are my doubts about God. To me, God just seems so far away and unattainable. Everyone says we should look forward to eternity with God. I just don’t think I want eternity with someone I’ve never really come to know. I want be with my family and my friends forever. According to Catholicism, approximately none of them meet the standards to make it to heaven. Why would I want to go to heaven if I won’t know anyone there?
Sorry about the rant, but could anybody help to put my mind at ease? :confused:
I kind of know a little of what you are going through- I went through it myself about 14 years ago and just walked away from the Church until recently, and my reasons for doing so were quite similar to yours. My advice is to stop freaking out about these things because they are not as important as they seem, at least not when compared to the basic question of your faith in God Himself.
Let’s start with the scandals- none of this should surprise you. Human beings are sinners who constantly abuse their power and hurt other people- this does not become untrue for someone just because he has a collar. Evil is a fact of life and the hierarchy is as prone to it as anyone else- just think of the kind of madness that went on during the days of the Borgia and the De Medici Popes. The great strength of the Church is that inspite of all of the failings of its members, it still spreads the word of God far and wide, and for every sicko who did wrong there are thousands who faithfully serve their community. Another way to think of it like this- the majority cf abuse occurs within families or friends thereof but this is no reason to lose faith in the very idea of families, is it? But I do see where you are coming from- it sickened me and destroyed my faith when I was younger.
There are plenty of things about the Church that I don’t believe in either - some of the rules just seem to be really outmoded, inspired more by man than God, or just flat out nonsensical, but I can deal with them because none of them interfere with my core beliefs. I refuse to let myself get lost in the geeky minutae of doctrinal debate when there are so many more important things to consider. Just think of the golden rule and all that that implies- love God with all your heart and soul and love your neighbour as yourself. Just think of how deep that one little sentence is and how much much more important it is than whether we should have women priests or whether condoms are bad. I think when one’s faith is tested, as mine often is, it is better to focus on the basics rather than draining away all one’s energy on complex debates about less central issues.
I see what you mean about the family and their various sins but who is perfect? Every one sins. Whenever I think of things like that, I think of Christ on the cross asking forgiveness for the people were crucifying him as he ws actually being crucified. I think we can take it from that the the mercy of God is deeper than humans can comprehend. Don’t worry about it so much. How do we know the final judgement of God, or what passes between God and man in man’s last moments?
I think the real issue is what you said about God seeming far away and that if you felt closer to God and more sure in your faith, none of the above would matter. My advice is to go back to basics- ask for faith, talk to God, pray, read the Gospels and think about Jesus. My own faith came back at a time when I was very low and I just randomly begged God for help. He did not let me down. At first I felt like a total moron praying and even as I would pray I would call myself stupid for doing so. Then I went to Church and looked around at all the old people and said, “Am I out of my mind?”. But still I could not write it off, something drew me back. and i said to God, “somehow I still believe so please give me something…some sort of acknowledgement that this is not just me talking to myself like an idiot.” Gradually he did and after a while I would leave the mass/finish prayer with a sort of feeling or peace or well-being. It didn’t happen all the time but it did happen enough for me to know it is real. He also gave me forgiveness for one of the worst sins that a man could commit- I felt that forgiveness and it is a tangible and real thing. And because of the reality of what I experienced- the well-being after mass and prayer, the forgiveness, the new sense of purpose and hope-I no longer care if I get it all or if all the doctrine is easy to swallow, and I won’t let the twisted behavior of others distract me from the bigger truth. I will just focus on the simple things- pray to God, love my neighbour, go to Mass and read the word. That’s what worked for me. I hope some of it helps you in some way. Please don’t give up- God is there, He loves you and He will never abandon you.
 
How will I know when I feel God? I’ve been trying for years, but I still don’t know how. I just feel lost. Will God accept me if I do my best, even if it’s not very good? I’m worried about messing life up. Is God upset that I just don’t know what to do and that I’m not sure if I like His plans?
 
But hey, sometimes I think it may just beat being a self-righteous holy roller. :rolleyes:
That’s what Jesus thought, too.

The thing about life is, it doesn’t have a lot of “set ways.” It’s messy and complex and you need to do the very best you can as often as you can because you are going to mess up. Trust in the outrageous mercy of God thru His Son. I think you’re fine.
 
How will I know when I feel God? I’ve been trying for years, but I still don’t know how. I just feel lost. Will God accept me if I do my best, even if it’s not very good? I’m worried about messing life up. Is God upset that I just don’t know what to do and that I’m not sure if I like His plans?
God doesn’t expect anything from you except that you try your best, He doesn’t expect for you to be perfect, but just to reach for perfection, and He showed us that it’s okay to fall, as He fell many times during His passion, just so long as you get back up and keep trying,

don’t worry about “messing life up”, you just do what you can, learn and grow, you are here on this earth to learn to love God, that is why God gives us all this time, because it doesn’t happen over night, you just have to be patient with yourself and move forward despite your imperfections…and it’s not that you have to accept yourself as a sinner, but instead you have to accept yourself as a weak creature totally dependent on God…and that’s what God accepts you as, a weak creature…so when you are afraid you might sin, or when you want to grow in holiness and don’t know how, that’s when you must see yourself as you are, accept it, and act accordingly…which means always and only seeking Gods help, and never relying on yourself for anything.

God knows you better than you know yourself, and loves you more than anyone could, so why be afraid? He died for you after all, and if you were the only sinner in existence, He still would have suffered and died just for you…so don’t be afraid, He loves you, you just need to trust in His mercy, He loves you more than He hates your sins, and He is always willing to forgive you…

i don’t know myself if i’ve ever “felt” God…i can say there are times i think i did, but i don’t rely on anything like that, because it’s not about what we get from God that matters, but what we give to Him…that is how love should be, when two people truly love each other, they don’t worry about what they get from the other, but only what to give…and sure that’s not an easy point to reach, and i don’t claim to have a degree of love like that, but like i said, all that matters is that you try, and that’s all God wants, because as long as we are reaching our hand out to Him, He can grab it, and lead us.

i also just want to apologize for my last post, i wasn’t aware how devout you were already trying to be, i assumed i was talking to someone more ignorant in the faith, but i know i was wrong so i apologize, and i hope this time my words might help more.

so that’s all, take care.
 
But hey, sometimes I think it may just beat being a self-righteous holy roller. :rolleyes:
I got accused of being a self-righteous holy roller just for showing up to Church once a week and sitting in the back pew.

I just figured, in for a penny, in for a pound - if I’m going to get called it, I might as well be it. 🤷 😃
 
@Emerald Wings: I guess you’re right, I just need to be more patient and realize that faith in a lifelong journey. And no worries about my last post, I may have written as though I didn’t know very much about the faith. 🙂
@jmcrae: I guess by those standards we both are. 😉
 
Irish Eyes - You’ve gotten a lot of great suggestions here, and I hope you will follow up on some of them. You list your religion as Truth Seeker, and I believe you really are. Our Lord has told us, knock and it shall be opened, seek and you shall find. We have to be willing to ask hard questions, and also be willing to accept the hard answers.

The Catholic Church teaches that we live in a fallen world, that as result of our first parents’ sin, we are all born cut off from God. Just as a baby inherits physical diseases, such as AIDS, from his parents, we have all inherited a deadly spiritual disease from our first parents which the Church calls original sin. Our Creator could have left all of us that way, He doesn’t owe salvation to any of us. But instead, he left the perfection and beauty of heaven, took on the nature of man, and literally poured out his blood to buy us back from Satan. Eph 2:4-5 says: “But God, being rich in mercy, because of the great love with which he loved us, even when we were dead in our trespasses, made us alive together with Christ.”

Before you make any major decisions, just go to Church and spend time with Christ in the Tabernacle. You don’t even have to say anything. Just be in His Presence. Meditate on the Crucifix. Just look at your Creator hanging on the Cross - one who was totally innocent, yet literally taking on the sins of the world and dying for us. I love the medidation from St. Francis’ Way of the Cross for the 12th Station when Jesus dies:
Behold Jesus crucified! Behold His wounds, received for love of you! His whole appearance betokens love: His head is bent to kiss you; His arms are extended to embrace you; His Heart is open to receive you. O superabundance of love, Jesus, the Son of God, dies upon the cross, that man may live and be delivered from everlasting death!
Read some of the saints. It doesn’t matter who you pick out. St. Francis, St. Augustine, the Little Flower. And please, please, pray to our Blessed Mother. She cares more for you than you can ever know. All of the people I know in the Church who have stuck it out year after year have had a great devotion to Mary. If you go to her, you will have all the answers you need.

It is vitally important that you pray, even if it’s just saying I feel lost and don’t know what to do.

I have one question for you. If you do go, where are you going?

God bless you.
 
@A Catholic: Thanks for the insight. One of things I struggle with is trying to understand that why is everything I do wrong my fault? I know I must deal with my choices, but why must I answer to God for them? My life was God’s idea. Why is it okay that I get sent away to eternal torture if I’m not good enough? I never asked to be born, that was God’s idea.
 
How will I know when I feel God? I’ve been trying for years, but I still don’t know how. I just feel lost.
In a way you already have felt Him - if you have ever felt love for or from another person, then you already know something of Him, because love is part of His nature. But I don’t think faith is always some sort of feeling- sometimes it is a strong feeling, sometimes it is an inner-certainty, sometimes it feels like nothing at all for a while, and sometimes simply the very longing to know and feel God is faith. Find Him through prayer, the Bible and the Sacrements, and let your priest guide you. If you are regularly nourished from prayer and scripture, then my guess is that at some point you will notice something- it might be a change in your mental state, it might be you being a better person, it might be a sense of calm, but you will notice something . Also, do not forget the Virgin Mary- she often guides people to God. What you remind me of is a good striker who hasn’t scored a goal in a while and has lost his confidence. Usually he just needs one lucky break for his bad run to end. I think that if you pray, you will not go unanswered.
Will God accept me if I do my best, even if it’s not very good? I’m worried about messing life up. Is God upset that I just don’t know what to do and that I’m not sure if I like His plans?
No one can know for sure how God will judge us but consider what we do know: some of His greatest servants were the ones who doubted (Thomas) Him, denied Him (Peter), persecuted His followers (Paul), and in the Bible we know that Jesus was full of compassion for whores and criminals.I sincerely doubt that if God could love these people, that he will abandon you just because you have reasonable and normal doubts or because you are having a crisis of faith that hits most of us at some point. Stop being so harsh on yourself, my friend- give it your best and trust in God’s mercy. Go back to the basics- prayer, the Gospels, someone to talk to- and see what happens. All I know is that I found God again just by asking for him- He did the rest. I will include you in my prayers so that He may help you too.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top