P
Pulvis
Guest
Actually Charlotte has had a stable Catholic Presence for much longer than 25 years. It is the seat of one of the two dioceses in NC. Now the influx of northerners has greatly expanded the Catholic population, but the Catholic church has been there a long time.Depends how you define success. Is this church building in leaps and bounds? Is it heavily in debt in order to build physical locations? How about salvation?
Is it aiming for the short term, but forgetting the long term?
Look, relative to Catholicism and even the Diocese of LA or even a normal parish in the LA area, an-8000 weekly attendance church is hardly mega anything. It’s mega in protestant circles, an average medium sized parish relative to Catholicism.
Which begs the question - why? Manny isn’t a theologian, he isn’t well versed in the Scriptures, and doesn’t bring much to the Spiritual table. His talk does attract audiences, and $$ prior to a well-advertised fight. This seems to be the drive. Audience. $. And an ex-Cath turned protestant, in a ultra-Catholic city. No, they aren’t anti-Catholic
There are about 5M Roman and thousands of Eastern Catholics, not to mention Orthodox Churches in the LA area. The LA Diocese runs schools, hospitals, charities, and more. You are comparing one apple to the entire forest.
Sure, it is rapid changing to try and adapt to the popular culture however. Dying and not being relevant are pretty much the same thing all churches are fighting against.
An example - this church has a few pastors, few satellites, and lots of activities… good. It has 8,000 weekly attendance.
St. Mathew Catholic parish in Charlotte, North Carolina reported 30,000 individual members in 2012. That isn’t completely an anomaly in areas that never had Catholics prior to the last 25yrs.