Mexicans Are Good People

  • Thread starter Thread starter servant675
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

servant675

Guest
It is very important to remember that unlike Black Americans, bigotry against Mexican Americans is still not being fully addressed.

Amnesty should continue to be part of our approach when attempting to solve our immigration problems with Mexico. The contributions hard-working Mexican Americans make to our society easily wipe out any so-called “free benefits” legal or non-legal immigrants may obtain through local, state, and federal programs.

Unlike some other Americans, many Mexican Americans are good people who possess a deep faith in Almighty God. Therefore they deserve to be treated with compassion & respect. In addition, we should double or triple the number of immigrants allowed on an annual basis with our friends from Mexico.

We must not forget that it is only with great difficulty & through hard work at low-paying jobs few other Americans want that many Mexicans eventually become citizens of the United States. It truly a blessing that so many Mexicans seek the opportunities the USA offers, & we should be honored to receive them in greater numbers into our country.

Vincent Bemowski
CatholicMessagesUSA.com/
 
There is a grave and deep ignorance expressed when one confuses the mistreatment of the descendants of African slaves in the United States and the problem of illegal immigration.
 
Unlike some other Americans, many Mexican Americans are good people who possess a deep faith in Almighty God. Therefore they deserve to be treated with compassion & respect. In addition, we should double or triple the number of immigrants allowed on an annual basis with our friends from Mexico.
CatholicMessagesUSA.com/
Being American of Mexican descent, I giggled at the title of this post and curiosity drove me to click thru.

I was born in Texas as was my dad and I was born on the Air Force base he served at. My grandma could barely speak English. She worked hard in the cannery and bought two homes before I was 5. She had me in front of the rectory immediately after first communion to announce to the pastor he had a new altar boy. Daily mass for years. She would invite all her little old lady friends (Mexican) to come pray the rosary at her house (I lived with her during the week as the Catholic school was right down the street from her house) every nite. I led the rosary, the litanies, all of it, in Spanish that she taught me, cuz we spoke only English at home. I was maybe 2nd or 3rd grade. In later years I learned the only reason she invited them over was to show off her grandson leading the rosary in Spanish.

Today I am our parish’s RCIA leader and Stewarship leader in a mostly all white parish. I am in my 2nd year of Pastoral Ministry School and in the Diaconate program. God willing, I’m looking forward to a 2009 ordination. I love my parish, my pastor, my Church, my Lord. I thank God I am Catholic! I can tell you with absolute certainty that I am who I am - a devout Catholic American (of Mexican descent) due to the work of the Holy Spirit thru my grandma, who crossed the border to look for a better life for her family back in the 1930s after her husband, my grandpa died (just before my dad’s birth). They came illegally.

My neighbor, who bought the house next door several years ago, who speaks very little English, is the hardest working guy I’ll ever know. He and I connect well even if my Spanish is poor (I lost most of it over the years), because I grew up in the same devout Mexican Catholic culture he grew up in. I was his daughter’s confirmation sponsor last weekend and his wife was my son’s.

Many of the real estate and loan agents who work for me focus their attention on helping hard-working, tax paying Latinos buy homes and integrate into the American dream we all take (me too cuz I’m really, basically American) for granted.

To servant675, as the United Way commercial said, “I don’t know you but I love you”.

Ad Majorem Dei Gloriam! :amen:

David
 
By the way, when I was 16, I lied my way into a job at the same cannery my grandma worked at for years. I always ended up with gravy jobs cuz I was bilingual, a rareity. All management was white. I translated for them all day. I kid you not, as God is my witness, I watched many, many white people (mostly men) get hired and quit within a day two cuz it was just a lot of hard work and they simply didn’t want to work that hard.

So there’s no misunderstanding, I am American, a product of American culture. Most of the friends I have are white. They speak the same language I do. It’s where I am most comfortable.

It sure is a tough issue, the immigration problem. As an American, I just don’t want to have to pay any more for my fruits and vegetables, canned or fresh, than the next (white) guy. However, the only ones who will show up for work are, well, you know who.

We all know the history. We (yes, “we”, cuz I’m American) literally robbed what is today TX, NM, AZ, CA from Mexico and now want to keep the “natives” out.

David
 
There is a grave and deep ignorance expressed when one confuses the mistreatment of the descendants of African slaves in the United States and the problem of illegal immigration.
I think he was speaking, really, of two issues - first of bigotry, then he spoke about the immigration issue. My sense is that he feels as tho bigotry is related to the contraversy over the immigration issue.

One is naive if one believe there is no bigotry against Latinos of the same flavor as the bigotry against African Americans and that this bigotry is at least partly the fuel for the immigration contraversy. And if one denies this it only means you are simply out of touch with reality. My 2 cents.

Ad Majorem Dei Gloriam

David
 
Thread caught my eye too!:yup:

I am an Amercian with a Latin flavor:D

America is a baby compared to Europe.
Europe let Christopher Columbus (Catholic) come over to the Western Hemisphere to explore and colonize in 1492. Before the Protestant Reformation.
And in Europe they have borders also. They have tried fences,walls (Berlin), soldiers, passports, and lots of other tactics to “control” the comings and goings of people. To no avail.
Europe is more than 2000 years old and they still haven’t “fixed” the “problem”.

What if you were a poor person who could not afford to pay for the paper work to move to a better place.

What if your children were starving, and there just is no work.

We have soldiers at posts along our borders.
Who have shot at these people. Both women and children. Many people have died in the heat,been treated poorly,scared,hungry and lost.And what do we do to help them?
We send our troops to Iraq and help those in need, and now the refugees will be arriving soon. but what about our neighbor?

Matthew 25:40
The King will answer and say to them, 'Truly I say to you, to the extent that you did it to one of these brothers of Mine, even the least of them, you did it to Me.'
 
There is a grave and deep ignorance expressed when one confuses the mistreatment of the descendants of African slaves in the United States and the problem of illegal immigration.
Dear Sir,

There is no “confusion.” Bigotry is bigotry, no matter what your race or nationality. But thank you for your interest in my article.

Servant675
 
God bless those abuelas, they are the ones bringing the children up in the Faith, getting them to CCD, nagging their parents to marry in the Church, making sure they get baptized and prepared for the sacraments, pushing them to stay in school, and perpetuating the Domestic Church which is the salient feature of family life in this culture. At least half my catechists are grandparents, and I deal with at least as many grandparents as parents as the primary person involved in the child’s religious education. They also make the tamales and taquitos sold that provide significant funding for our programs.
 
Vinny…and so are we citizens here in the good ole US of A…good people…if not for we,whom you malign so harshly you would be posting in German or Russian.or rather not at all…its always open season on the United States…plus Irish,Poles, and we Italo-Americans…Irish as drunks,Poles has stupidos…and we Italos as gangsters…I see the ruling class has started on the ole “victimization ploy” convince a group of folks nothing is ever their fault…they are just victims of a bigoted society…that is what has place several groups solidly into the demoncrate party…now the Latinos are getting the brainwashing…we three (Irish,Poles,Italos…never fell for that subliminal seduction so we are attacked constantly…and we are proud of that attack…for it proves we are Americans who believe in individual responsibility…oops…not a pc phrase…sorry…Nino
 
It is very important to remember that unlike Black Americans, bigotry against Mexican Americans is still not being fully addressed.

Amnesty should continue to be part of our approach when attempting to solve our immigration problems with Mexico. The contributions hard-working Mexican Americans make to our society easily wipe out any so-called “free benefits” legal or non-legal immigrants may obtain through local, state, and federal programs.

Unlike some other Americans, many Mexican Americans are good people who possess a deep faith in Almighty God. Therefore they deserve to be treated with compassion & respect. In addition, we should double or triple the number of immigrants allowed on an annual basis with our friends from Mexico.

We must not forget that it is only with great difficulty & through hard work at low-paying jobs few other Americans want that many Mexicans eventually become citizens of the United States. It truly a blessing that so many Mexicans seek the opportunities the USA offers, & we should be honored to receive them in greater numbers into our country.

Vincent Bemowski
CatholicMessagesUSA.com/
  1. There are many Americans who would be happy to take those low paying jobs. Illegal aliens depress the wages to unjust levels, even then there are many poor americans who would take those jobs.
  2. While there may be many good Mexican Americans, they are also breaking the law. Rewarding breaking the law erodes the rule of law which keeps the peace. Not to mention we have some duty to obey just laws as Cathiolics and I have bever heard any argument that the Law is unjust to entering the country.
  3. The US does not know how to handle immigration to assimilate so many people into the country. There is enough cultural despair that we cannot even adopt English as the only language.
  4. While many illegal aliens may be good, many commit crimes such as DUI without insurance leaving devastatiuon in their wake.
  5. The tomato you buy at a low price is actually funded by the TAX payer due to the enormous drain on social services placed by unjustly paid workers who cannot get a living wage due to their status.
  6. Border security should be addressed first before creating further incentives for lawbreakers to come over. If amnesty is granted without controls in place then why have a law at all? No one believes the current proposals will stop the flow of illiegal aliens.
  7. Immigration policy should be set to assist the state not the immigrant. If the state beciomes stronger due to immigration more can be assimikated. Unfortunately, there is neither policy nor the will in place to properly assimilate people who are also unwilling (due to ther unwillingness to obey the American law) to become American (beyond fiscal entitlements), e.g. mexican flag waving rallies.
Finally, and most importantly for a Catholic forum, the question and the article propose a false supposition: That “good” people deserve American citizenship. American citizenship is not a reward for good behaviour. It is a luck of the draw of birth and membership into a culture, society and the greatest nation in the world. All people are in the image of God, but all have a fallen nature. Calling out a particular people as good is both a non-sequitur to the immigration issue and also bad theology: “Why do you call me good?”
 
God bless those abuelas, they are the ones bringing the children up in the Faith, getting them to CCD, nagging their parents to marry in the Church, making sure they get baptized and prepared for the sacraments, pushing them to stay in school, and perpetuating the Domestic Church which is the salient feature of family life in this culture. At least half my catechists are grandparents, and I deal with at least as many grandparents as parents as the primary person involved in the child’s religious education. They also make the tamales and taquitos sold that provide significant funding for our programs.
You are so right! My grandmother always talked about her Catholic faith and always told me to marry in the church and that Jesus is God and finish your sacraments. She lived 24 hours away and I rarely spoke to her on the phone. But the two weeks in the summer my dad would take us there and my grandmother would show me her Christian faith. And he would take us to Mass. He called her EVERY Sunday after Mass until she died. I always tell people when ever a compliment is made about me showing my children the way, that my grandma and my father (who Honors his mother) are the ones who I thank.
 
Thread caught my eye too!:yup:

I am an Amercian with a Latin flavor:D

America is a baby compared to Europe.
Europe let Christopher Columbus (Catholic) come over to the Western Hemisphere to explore and colonize in 1492. Before the Protestant Reformation.
And in Europe they have borders also. They have tried fences,walls (Berlin), soldiers, passports, and lots of other tactics to “control” the comings and goings of people. To no avail.
Europe is more than 2000 years old and they still haven’t “fixed” the “problem”.

What if you were a poor person who could not afford to pay for the paper work to move to a better place.

What if your children were starving, and there just is no work.

We have soldiers at posts along our borders.
Who have shot at these people. Both women and children. Many people have died in the heat,been treated poorly,scared,hungry and lost.And what do we do to help them?
We send our troops to Iraq and help those in need, and now the refugees will be arriving soon. but what about our neighbor?

Matthew 25:40
The King will answer and say to them, 'Truly I say to you, to the extent that you did it to one of these brothers of Mine, even the least of them, you did it to Me.'
The King may also ask them why they did not work in their own country for justice? WHo knows what the King will say for each individual’s situation? It is His to say. Will He condemn those parents who put their children at risk in an illegal activity and a dangerous gamble? Was there truly no other way? Who has culpability here? The mexican government? The corruption? Everyone, likr the illegal alien, who erodes the rule of law making Mexico less prosperous than She should be?

Governments do not have the benefit of omniscience and must try to make policies that help their citizens because there are still starving Americans, and those Americans who need low paying jobs at just rates A stronger AMERICA allows her to help more people, but if policies that should be well thought out are governed by sentimentality, no one, neither the illegal alien nor the American will be well served, as Chaos breed evil.

You are reeally quick to bring down the Lord’s wrath on people who are doing their duty. Better look in a mirror first. Just friendly advice.
 
It is very important to remember that unlike Black Americans, bigotry against Mexican Americans is still not being fully addressed.

Sorry, but your statement is incorrect. Bigotry against Mexican-Americans is not the same as desiring people to wait to come here legally. “Mexican-Americans” are already citizens of the US while “Mexicans” who come here illegally are not. The people who choose to come here illegally do not get the same protections under the laws. Mexican-Americans do have the same rights under the Constitution as other US citizens.

Amnesty should continue to be part of our approach when attempting to solve our immigration problems with Mexico.

You are trying to use Mexican-Americans as a selling point for illegal Mexicans who are here. Mexican-Americans pay taxes and buy insurance and do all of the other things that other US citizens do.

People who choose to sneak into the US and take the benefits such as having babies at our county hospitals or obtaining other medical care there without using insurance or paying for it cost far more than we could ever recoup in sales taxes from them. They do not have to pay income taxes because we have no way to get it from them if they simply claim sufficient numbers of dependents in order to be exempt while using a false SSN. They cost money to regular people by failing to have car insurance when they have an accident. The inability to get insurance is a direct consequence of their choice to come here illegally.

Unlike some other Americans, many Mexican Americans are good people who possess a deep faith in Almighty God. Therefore they deserve to be treated with compassion & respect. In addition, we should double or triple the number of immigrants allowed on an annual basis with our friends from Mexico.

I cannot believe how prejudiced this statement is. I know a lot of good people with strong faith in every racial group and a lot who have none. Treating someone with compassion and respect does not equal free pass on following the laws of this country. It could mean that I give you water, food and a free plane ride home for your entire family to wait until you can come here properly.

It does not matter what our “quota” is from Mexico if the people don’t respect the rule of law sufficiently to apply and wait their turn. I would rather have an increase in quota from a country where the people need to get out to avoid war and death rather than one where the people just want to make better wages. What about the Catholics in danger of death in Iraq, Haiti and Africa? Shouldn’t they come in first? The US cannot absorb unlimited numbers while failing to help our own poor. We still have Native Americans and others in desparate poverty.

We must not forget that it is only with great difficulty & through hard work at low-paying jobs few other Americans want that many Mexicans eventually become citizens of the United States. It truly a blessing that so many Mexicans seek the opportunities the USA offers, & we should be honored to receive them in greater numbers into our country.

I am honored to receive all immigrants who followed our laws to get here from any country. I have some recent legal immigrants in my family/close friends. I am not honored to let these offending countries (mainly from Mexico/Latin America because of their proximity) dump more than 10 million of their poorly educated citizens into our lap rather than deal with a problem that they created.

We are already dealing with the wave of amnesty from the 1980’s because those people who never attained education, transferable job skills or English proficiency are now qualifying for disability benefits since they cannot perform manual jobs any longer. They will draw far more in cash and medical benefits through Social Security disability programs than they ever put into the system. This is on top of whatever they eventualy get from Soc. Sec. retirement which is different program.

I am not honored that entry level/temporary jobs which used to give high school and college students (and our own poorly educated folks) a way to gain job experience and earn money have been taken up by illegal workers. My first job was for $1.25/hour doing seasonal work outdoors back in the heatwave of 1980, so please don’t tell me that no US citizen is willing to work hard in the scorching heat in a low paying job. My guy friends used to tar roofs in the Oklahoma heat every summer to earn money for clothes and college, but the young people now cannot get those jobs because unscrupulous employers prefer to hire illegal workers who they know cannot complain about poor treatment.

Vincent Bemowski
CatholicMessagesUSA.com/
 
It is very important to remember that unlike Black Americans, bigotry against Mexican Americans is still not being fully addressed.

Illegal is illegal = against the law. They do not belong here. Let them follow the LEGAL route that so many PRODUCTIVE Mexican Americans have done.

Amnesty should continue to be part of our approach when attempting to solve our immigration problems with Mexico. The contributions hard-working Mexican Americans make to our society easily wipe out any so-called “free benefits” legal or non-legal immigrants may obtain through local, state, and federal programs.

Uh, really? I don’t think so. How many free births and government benefits do these people get compared to the taxes (none) they pay. If they are illegal, they don’t have a social security number. No number, no taxes collected. This is wrong. Let’s talk about insurance next. They don’t carry insurance. Yet they are involved in accidents. Guess who pays? It’s not them!

Unlike some other Americans, many Mexican Americans are good people who possess a deep faith in Almighty God. Therefore they deserve to be treated with compassion & respect. In addition, we should double or triple the number of immigrants allowed on an annual basis with our friends from Mexico.

What a statement! Many Americans are quite faithful. Many Mexicans are quite faithful. Many Americans are not faithful. Many Mexicans are not faithful. They must EARN respect like anyone else. Double or triple??? Are you nuts! (obviously, yes).

We must not forget that it is only with great difficulty & through hard work at low-paying jobs few other Americans want that many Mexicans eventually become citizens of the United States. It truly a blessing that so many Mexicans seek the opportunities the USA offers, & we should be honored to receive them in greater numbers into our country.

As the parent of high school kids, I can tell you jobs are in high demand. They have difficulty getting those jobs because of the illegals. “honored to receive them”?? Yup, you’re nuts.

Let me tell you about the Mexicans working on roofing jobs in our neighborhood – they blast music LOUDLY so moms with toddlers must close their windows during naptime. They cat call at women going for walks. They take a break about every 30 minutes. They leave their garbage on the lawns to blow away. They are unpleasant to be around and make the neighborhood feel slimy while they are here. Why are are they hired ? Because their company gave the lowest roofing bids. Why do you think this company could give such low bids? Think about it.

In nearly every root of prejudice and bigotry, there is a grain of truth I have seen these people to be lazy and slimy.

Now I oppose this to the legal immigrants (families at our church who have been here LEGALLY for many years.) They live in nice houses, hold down respectable jobs, do NOT cat call, actually throw away garbage, and live like human beings. They care about the neighborhood becaue they pay taxes. They drive carefully because they have insurance.

No, we definitely do NOT need more illegal immigrants (unless you agree to have them all live at your house - then go for it).


Vincent Bemowski
CatholicMessagesUSA.com/
 
There are good Mexicans and bad Mexicans, just as there are good and bad people from every country in the world. If your point was to say that it is alright for Mexicans to come here illegally and take low paying jobs, thus keeping them low paying, you are just plain wrong.
 
Thread caught my eye too!:yup:

I am an Amercian with a Latin flavor:D

America is a baby compared to Europe.
Europe let Christopher Columbus (Catholic) come over to the Western Hemisphere to explore and colonize in 1492. Before the Protestant Reformation.
And in Europe they have borders also. They have tried fences,walls (Berlin), soldiers, passports, and lots of other tactics to “control” the comings and goings of people. To no avail.
Europe is more than 2000 years old and they still haven’t “fixed” the “problem”.

What if you were a poor person who could not afford to pay for the paper work to move to a better place.

What if your children were starving, and there just is no work.

We have soldiers at posts along our borders.
Who have shot at these people. Both women and children. Many people have died in the heat,been treated poorly,scared,hungry and lost.And what do we do to help them?
We send our troops to Iraq and help those in need, and now the refugees will be arriving soon. but what about our neighbor?

Matthew 25:40
The King will answer and say to them, 'Truly I say to you, to the extent that you did it to one of these brothers of Mine, even the least of them, you did it to Me.'
Try getting into Switzerland without a passport, the Berlin wall worked very well thank you.
 
This discussion has inspired my to write an essay on the matter. This is a first draft so bear with my grammar and style.

The question I levy is, are you Americans before you are Catholic, or Catholic before you are Americans? Your brotherhood between your fellow Catholics should be far stronger than your brotherhood between your fellow Americans. I, for one, am just a 15 year old Catholic partly of Irish blood who bravely or foolishly enough is an idealist in the sense that I believe what ever is true and good should be unselfishly spread throughout the world. Once I held patriotism and the U. S. of A. as the highest thing through out the world and was deeply saddened and in fact angered when there was little no patriotism in the people around me. It is then that my faith truly took root and understood the aforementioned truth that we are more connected with our fellow Catholics then we are with a agnostic blood relative. That as a light to re-look at history is essential to understand this whole “problem.” Oh as a just little side point of reference, it is in truth a fact that Catholics must thank God for the civil war or else we’d be living in a Catholic persecuting America as it was right up to the civil war. But enough of this off topic talk on Catholics in America and let us take a trip down memory lane and look at the way Mexico got to be the way it is.

On December 2, 1823 a certain Monroe, with the aid of his Secretary of State, a certain John Quincy Adams, delivered a doctrine declaring an attempt to help Catholic Spain retain Latin America would be taken as “as the manifestation of unfriendly dispositions towards the United States.” (As a side note the belief that the Spanish government was tyrannical is part of the Black Legend which was mainly propagated by Protestant England to prove that the one real defender of Catholicism was just a bunch of barbarians. To anyone who wishes proof in support of the Black Legend PM and I will give it to you in a large and inarguable amount). Anyways, the threat of England is probably what more prevented Spain’s holding Latin America but the U.S. (quote the Catholic historian Anne Carroll) “played a real part in the success of those revolutions by encouraging their leaders and supporting them in their belief that a liberal republic was the best practical government when they were faced with practical experience to the contrary.”
Anyways Iturbide marched into Mexico City September 27, 1821. He promised the world but delivered a military dictatorship. The next year the people couldn’t stand him and created a liberal republic which was reeked with violence and created economic decay. More over the Catholic missions set up by Father Sierra and the Franciscans were taken away and their lands confiscated.
Now fast forward to Andrew Jackson who commissioned a certain Houston with a secret mission to look at the possibility of gaining Texas for the United States. Now admissibly Santa Anna was becoming increasing dictatorial (he was among the framers of the new liberal republic), but I seriously doubt Jefferson had Mexico’s best interests at heart.
Let’s skip ahead to a certain James K. Polk, who had run his entire campaign on an expansionist platform. Newspapers stirred up hatred in Americans and recruiting centers had lectures against Americans, primarily against their Catholic religion. It’s interesting to note here that a number of Irish, French, and Polish Catholics joined the Mexican Army as St. Patrick Battalion. Of course, when the tenacious fighters were finally defeated and captured, the American Army had them all shot without trial but that’s just a side note. Anyways Polk wanted a treaty so he helped the exiled dictator Santa Anna retake Mexico. Polk should have known not to take the word of a dictator, and thus fighting continued. To skip all the gory details, by the time a treaty could be called upon the Mexican government couldn’t even convene in Mexico City. The treaty ended up taking 40 percent Mexico’s land before the war and causing the economy to spiral into decay. (That figure doesn’t take into account Texas. So ultimately the figure rests that U.S. took half of Mexico between 1830 to1850). It is also interesting to note that the U.S. did not protect the rights of those in the territory taken by the U.S. who should according to the treaty should have “legally “received American Citizenship.
Continued in Next Post.
 
But you say, that is 150 year ago, how does that play into today? The shaking effects are still felt in Mexico’s economy. And if you want to disregard that attempt to put a Catholic monarch on the Independent Mexican throne which was defeated by liberals suddenly having an onslaught of American Arms left over from the American Civil War, then we can progress to the post World War I president, the terrible Woodrow Wilson.
Wilson supported a revolutionary named Pancho Villa who killed poor and rich alike, stole, and managed to imprison or exile bishops and religious, and of course steal church property. The dictator in control at the time wasn’t a saint but he was expelled through Woodrow Wilson’s work. Now the revolutionaries in power knew nothing about government and couldn’t hold together a Constitutional convention so they started fighting amongst themselves. Then by 1920 Obregon was president another Catholic hater so it wasn’t surprising that within two years two bombs were set off on the property of the archbishop and another in front of the Guadalupe image seriously damaging the cathedral.
By 1924 the president of Mexico could be quoted in saying “I have a personal hatred for Christ.” That ended in the heightening of persecution. So before the years end (with the confirmation by the bishops that it was a just cause), Mexican Catholics prepared for revolt. But American Catholics turned a blind eye to the Mexicans who were in dire need of the money to be successful to throw off the government who was persecuting and killing Catholics left and right. Attempts to get funding and or weapons in the U.S. which had fallen so easily into the hands of the revolutionaries turned up nothing… Eventually a treaty was negotiated with the help of the American ambassador which the Mexican government preceded to break by executing the heroic defenders of their faith and they were still known to be in serious danger for their lives as late the 1950’s.
Now to speak of laws when a certain JP II visited Mexico in 1979 he proceeded to break two Mexican laws: 1) he wore clerical garb on the streets and 2) he a foreign priest offered Mass.
But now to my main points. First, the poor state of Mexico now is the direct result of American actions past and present. Second, we live in a protestant country, what ever is said Catholics are still hated amongst large amounts of the educated masses. Third, these are our fellow Catholics for Pete’s sake. Fourth, have not our own parents wronged them by not helping them when they called out in their time of need; is not there a debt to be paid.
When it comes down to the laws of the (arguably) sovereign nation are subservient to certain inalienable truths. The church alone will be constant, every action must be judged against her (if you want titles in support of that check the writings of our current pope). Society won’t be judged as a whole but the individual, if you must love your neighbor as yourself how much more should you care for your brother in faith. And finally, the greatest question that was ever a fact: Do we judge actions by God’s will; what he wants? Or do we judge them by the laws of the land; peer pressure extended on the national scale.

Semper in Deum.
 
So God wants us to break laws? Laws that are reasonable and just? We can break them because we’re Catholic?

And, let me make sure I read this, it is AMERICA’s fault Mexico is poor? Sorry, I’ll take individual responsibility over national self hate any day. Sorry, like sin, one generation, maybe two, then it’s your mess.

No Sale.

I like the fact that there is a strong Catholic culture, but you justify the fear mongering of anti-catholics when you give ILLEGAL alien law breakers a pass because they were baptised Catholic.

A nation is supposed to be just. If she cannot enforce reasonable laws how can she function? If she cannot (or will not) maintain her own cultural and linguistic identity from a massive influx of outside illegal immigration she is commiting suicide.

Finally, illegal immigration is simply slavery and promotes the continuation of unjust wages. The US needs to export a just standard of living, not import Mexico’s unjust standards. It is not that illegal immigrants make up a neccesary part of the work force; the plain fact is that the work force has been corrupted into an unjust system through the use of illegal workers cooperating with greedy corporations to prevent the free market and government policies in establishing just wages.

We should help. We should love one another as individuals and our nation in so far as it is prudent we should help. But a nation is not at the final judgement, a nation is not a sentient being. A nation is a corporate secular interest guided by self interest. If it can, like America, choose to do good, that is a glory to God and an honor to her citizens, but if a nation does good to her own detriment she will not be able to do good for long. Nations do not follow the way of the cross, you need a soul, a freewill and sentience to do that. Nations provide governance and governance without prudence spells needless misery for her citizens and all the others in the world who would benefit from America’s prudent management.

My 2 cents?
A prudent nation acts in a predictable and just fashion so that her citizens and others know what to expect and so are discouraged from behaving in unjust manners. Enforce the rule of law both on the illegal immigrants and on those who profit unjustly from them. Establish a wall, real or technological, so that the law becomes enforceable; then, export to Mexico justice and charity, and finally manage the problem of assimilation of all Americans, immigrants and the impoverished, into a living wage and a civic duty to return willingly a portion of what was given.
 
My heart breaks for those with less, those who must work harder than me.For those who see no hope in where and how they live.

I sit here at a computer in an air conditioned room. With running water and electricity and with a fridge full of food. I feel sad that many go without.

In my mind I know right from wrong. That rules are there for our safety. Without rules and laws there is only chaos. We were given The Ten Commandments and are told to obey authority.

I see places that people do not obey authority and there is chaos.Sadness and death.

I am greatful to God for all that He has blessed me with and for being able to have both a heart for compasion and a mind for reasoning.

I see how we must balance what we think with what we feel.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top