Migrant crisis: Germany to start temporary border controls

  • Thread starter Thread starter Kaninchen
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I wonder if it has something to do with refugees hearing about Germany taking in hundreds of thousands -then fears of a resulting mass migration there by more than what was expected.
 
I wonder if it has something to do with refugees hearing about Germany taking in hundreds of thousands -then fears of a resulting mass migration there by more than what was expected.
Last week they were talking about taking huge numbers.

It could well be that the realisation that other EU members were not going to accept what the Germans thought should be their ‘share’ of refugees has caused something of a re-think.
 
The point to emphasise is that these are temporary border controls to be kept in place until there is an EU wide concerted policy agreed upon. Germany cannot take all of the 800,000 people who are yet to make a beeline for her. The Germans desire that other EU nations abide by the rules and make it clear that while migrants can come, there is right to ‘choose’ their host country.

Schengen explicitly allows for temporary suspensions in moments of grave security crisis, which this certainly is, so this should not be read as an infringement of the Schengen zone.

The rules make it clear that refugees should apply for asylum in the country where they first arrive. While I agree that this is wretched for the migrants themselves at present, it is obviously not sustainable in the long-term for every refugee to make a beeline for Germany, nor is this strictly lawful under the Dublin regulation:

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dublin_Regulation

I feel very sorry for the migrants but I cannot fault the German authorities either. They are facing a flood of suffering humanity that is of biblical proportions.
 
I feel very sorry for the migrants but I cannot fault the German authorities either. They are facing a flood of suffering humanity that is of biblical proportions.
The problem is that people involved - in the camps or en route - have not been given a clear message by the Germans who seem to be making policy (for themselves and eventually everybody else) “on the hoof”.

It would have been far better for it to have been “err, well, um . . .” from the start.
 
The problem is that people involved - in the camps or en route - have not been given a clear message by the Germans who seem to be making policy (for themselves and eventually everybody else) “on the hoof”.

It would have been far better for it to have been “err, well, um . . .” from the start.
Agreed, I do think they started on the premise - or rather assumption - that the EU as a whole was going to divide the labour vis-a-vis the refugees and in accordance with the Dublin regulation. When this was unveiled as not happening, the dynamics changed very quickly.

Once they are assured that other EU countries will take their fair share and that this message has filtered down to the migrants themselves, the temporary border controls will be removed.

I agree that it’s a baleful situation and that a clear policy should have been enunciated from the get-go but I think it arose from a genuine misunderstanding on Germany’s part about the intentions of its EU peers.
 
Germany is to introduce temporary controls on its border with Austria to cope with the influx of migrants, the interior minister has said.

Thomas de Maiziere said refugees could “not choose” their host countries and called on other EU states to do more.

Trains between Germany and Austria have been suspended for 12 hours.

Germany’s vice-chancellor has said the country is “at the limit of its capabilities” as more than 13,000 migrants arrived in Munich on Saturday.

Germany expects 800,000 migrants to arrive this year.

bbc.com/news/world-europe-34239674
 
The problem is that people involved - in the camps or en route - have not been given a clear message by the Germans who seem to be making policy (for themselves and eventually everybody else) “on the hoof”.

It would have been far better for it to have been “err, well, um . . .” from the start.
Yes, but then they might have been criticized for delaying their welcome… would they have waited if the refugees had been Christian? European? … What are they worried about?
 
more than 13,000 migrants arrived in Munich on Saturday.
In one day. 13,000… I find that difficult to believe.

That’s the population of Liverpool every month. 12 new Liverpools a year.

.
 
That’s the population of Liverpool every month. 12 new Liverpools a year.
 
Agreed, I do think they started on the premise - or rather assumption - that the EU as a whole was going to divide the labour vis-a-vis the refugees and in accordance with the Dublin regulation. When this was unveiled as not happening, the dynamics changed very quickly.

Once they are assured that other EU countries will take their fair share and that this message has filtered down to the migrants themselves, the temporary border controls will be removed.

I agree that it’s a baleful situation and that a clear policy should have been enunciated from the get-go but I think it arose from a genuine misunderstanding on Germany’s part about the intentions of its EU peers.
What if the migrants just don’t want to live in certain EU nations?

"Slovakia’s Foreign Minister Miroslav Lajcak said at a joint news conference.

“Migrants don’t want to stay in Slovakia,” he said, indicating that Bratislava had only received 130 asylum applications up to the end of July. “How can we ensure that the people stay in Slovakia?”
channelnewsasia.com/mobile/world/poorer-eu-states-reject/2120832.html
 
What if the migrants just don’t want to live in certain EU nations?

"Slovakia’s Foreign Minister Miroslav Lajcak said at a joint news conference.

“Migrants don’t want to stay in Slovakia,” he said, indicating that Bratislava had only received 130 asylum applications up to the end of July. “How can we ensure that the people stay in Slovakia?”
channelnewsasia.com/mobile/world/poorer-eu-states-reject/2120832.html
If the rules are implemented (as I feel they need to be so that Germany will revoke the border controls and the crisis can be maintained) then the migrants will have no choice in the matter.

If they are fleeing persecution and the ravages of war, then they should be content in any EU nation since to join the EU a country has to have a high index level, a democratic political system with free elections, a free-market economy and so forth. Any EU country is leagues ahead of any nations in the Middle East or North Africa in terms of human rights, welfare, education, standard of living et al.

O.K. we all know that Slovakia and Slovenia, for instance, are never going to be as popular destinations as Western European nations like Britain, France, Germany, Belgium, the Netherlands, Sweden etc. but they will still be safe and have lives to live in Slovakia. Surely that is better than war-torn Syria, surely anything is better?

If they manage to go from being asylum seekers to full citizens of their host at some point in the future, then they will have EU citizenship by implication and have the right to freedom of movement like any other EU citizen. If they still desire to go to Germany or France then they will be perfectly free to do so at this later date.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top