More religiously conservative Protestants? More divorce, study finds

  • Thread starter Thread starter EmperorNapoleon
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
E

EmperorNapoleon

Guest
Divorce is higher among religiously conservative Protestants – and even drives up divorce rates for other people living around them, a new study finds.
The study, slated to be published in the American Journal of Sociology, tackles the “puzzling paradox” of why divorce is more common in religiously conservative “red” states. If religious conservatives believe firmly in the value of marriage, why is divorce especially high in places like Alabama and Arkansas?
Interesting results and I look forward to reading the study.
 
One theory I’ve heard is that these groups often tend to push people to marry younger, often with some vaguely spiritual language about “God’s choice for you” which often conceals what is simply infatuation. The result is young adults who are not prepared for marriage being married anyway.
 
Honestly, I’m not even sure what “religiously conservative Protestants” is supposed to mean. Conservative and Liberal and political categories. Orthodox and Heterodox (Heretical) are religious categories. Perhaps the article is talking about “Orthodox Protestants” but as all Protestants are Heterodox by definition there is no such creature as an “Orthodox Protestant” - its a logical contradiction and thus also meaningless. The whole thing reeks of a confusion in terms. 🤷
 
Interesting, but like all studies it needs to be looked at carefully. It’s fairly easy to set up studies to get specific results or to interpret study results to say what you want them to say.

From what I read in the article what the study really found was that poor people who marry young and start families early have a higher divorce rate. Not a huge revelation. The fact that those people are also “conservative Protestants” may, or may not, factor into this.

In order to show any kind of religious connection you would need to study two groups of people who married and started families early. One “conservative Protestant” and the other not. Then comparing the two would give you some idea if religion really had anything to do with it.

Also, “protestant” conservative or otherwise is not a homogenous group. Different protestant denominations vary widely in their teachings.

Generally I am skeptical of study results.
 
Interesting results and I look forward to reading the study.
Well, it was Luther who degraded marriage in the first place by insisting that it wasn’t a Sacrament, and his Reformer friends were quick to agree.

Everything else - quickie divorce, contraception, abortion, “trial marriage” and even gay marriage - flowed from that momentous and horrible decision.
 
Interesting results and I look forward to reading the study.
It makes sense to me.

I am a divorced former conservative Protestant. For my situation, and I would guess others it came down to two people who were very. "Religious " but had different interpretations of our authority the Bible. This caused many arguments. Everything from what is marriage to child discipline to what church to attend, to how to work through conflict.

Sola Scriptura fails again

Of course for me this was an underlying problem that caused many more significant ones that led to the implosion if the marriage.

😦
 
From what I read in the article what the study really found was that poor people who marry young and start families early have a higher divorce rate. Not a huge revelation. The fact that those people are also “conservative Protestants” may, or may not, factor into this.

In order to show any kind of religious connection you would need to study two groups of people who married and started families early. One “conservative Protestant” and the other not. Then comparing the two would give you some idea if religion really had anything to do with it.
I agree. Reading the article, it says that “secularized” areas have similarly high divorce rates.
 
Well, it was Luther who degraded marriage in the first place by insisting that it wasn’t a Sacrament, and his Reformer friends were quick to agree.

Everything else - quickie divorce, contraception, abortion, “trial marriage” and even gay marriage - flowed from that momentous and horrible decision.
A lot of that made it into Protestant Churches in the 20th Century. There’s a lot of reasons why.

Right-wing libertine commentator Glenn Beck notes that “progressives in the early 20th Century knew they’d never be able to push contraception unless they got the churches to go along with it. By the 60s, the RCC pretty much stood alone against contraception”.

Now, we are seeing more liberal churches embrace abortion and so-called gay “marriage”, I guess because literal Bible interpreters can’t find exact quotes from Jesus on the matter. :rolleyes:

It stems from a fundamental misunderstanding of Scripture and a lack of critical thinking of applying natural law. Even some Catholics are guilty of this in the marriage debate, I suspect. Some folks will not stray from Scripture’s exact wording to the bitter end.

I can only wonder if Jesus would have wanted that, and I have my doubts He did. 🤷

The short-cuts that some of the religions that are offshoots of the RCC are really starting to haunt them in many ways.

It just goes to show no one profits in the long run from personal selfishness.
 
It makes sense to me.

I am a divorced former conservative Protestant. For my situation, and I would guess others it came down to two people who were very. "Religious " but had different interpretations of our authority the Bible. This caused many arguments. Everything from what is marriage to child discipline to what church to attend, to how to work through conflict.

Sola Scriptura fails again

Of course for me this was an underlying problem that caused many more significant ones that led to the implosion if the marriage.

😦
Looking at the provided map, if you’re in LA, you’d be in a county with the lowest rate of “conservative Protestants”, but a higher divorce rate…so the link would not be religion in your area.
 
Well, it was Luther who degraded marriage in the first place by insisting that it wasn’t a Sacrament, and his Reformer friends were quick to agree.

Everything else - quickie divorce, contraception, abortion, “trial marriage” and even gay marriage - flowed from that momentous and horrible decision.
Did you read the article?

“Pharmacies might not give out emergency contraception. Schools might teach abstinence only” according to Glass, creating a culture with earlier and poorer marriages among conservative Protestants, with the latter two factors implicated in higher divorce rates.
 
Right-wing libertine commentator Glenn Beck notes that “progressives in the early 20th Century knew they’d never be able to push contraception unless they got the churches to go along with it. By the 60s, the RCC pretty much stood alone against contraception”.
Bahaha. Leave it to Beck to ignore many thousands of years of contraceptive usage and try to frame it as machination of 20th century liberals.
 
A lot of that made it into Protestant Churches in the 20th Century. There’s a lot of reasons why.

Right-wing libertine commentator Glenn Beck notes that “progressives in the early 20th Century knew they’d never be able to push contraception unless they got the churches to go along with it. By the 60s, the RCC pretty much stood alone against contraception”.
Sorry to be a pedant, but isn’t Beck libertarian rather than libertine?
Now, we are seeing more liberal churches embrace abortion and so-called gay “marriage”, I guess because literal Bible interpreters can’t find exact quotes from Jesus on the matter. :rolleyes:
It stems from a fundamental misunderstanding of Scripture and a lack of critical thinking of applying natural law. Even some Catholics are guilty of this in the marriage debate, I suspect. Some folks will not stray from Scripture’s exact wording to the bitter end.
I can only wonder if Jesus would have wanted that, and I have my doubts He did. 🤷
The short-cuts that some of the religions that are offshoots of the RCC are really starting to haunt them in many ways.
It just goes to show no one profits in the long run from personal selfishness.
Well said.

Natural Law, Tradition, and the Church’s Magisterium are powerful weapons in the fight for marriage, and Protestants would do well to embrace them. (Of course, that would make them Catholics, but that would also be good!) 👍
 
Did you read the article?

“Pharmacies might not give out emergency contraception. Schools might teach abstinence only” according to Glass, creating a culture with earlier and poorer marriages among conservative Protestants, with the latter two factors implicated in higher divorce rates.
Glass’s interpretation is speculative, and based on secular ideals. But the fact that divorce rates are higher can admit of other explanations. I respectfully submit that one such explanation is the lower value placed on marriage in Protestant theology. Catholics (and I mean practising, orthodox Catholics) have Tradition, Castii Connubi, Humanae Vitae and The Theology of the Body. Evangelicals have - uh - “I Take Thee, Rebecca” by Ravi Zacharias and “Making Love” by Tim and Beverly LaHaye. There’s a world of difference between the two.
 
Glass’s interpretation is speculative, and based on secular ideals. But the fact that divorce rates are higher can admit of other explanations. I respectfully submit that one such explanation is the lower value placed on marriage in Protestant theology. Catholics (and I mean practising, orthodox Catholics) have Tradition, Castii Connubi, Humanae Vitae and The Theology of the Body. Evangelicals have - uh - “I Take Thee, Rebecca” by Ravi Zacharias and “Making Love” by Tim and Beverly LaHaye. There’s a world of difference between the two.
I’m not sure about that. I grew up in the very conservative wing of protestantism. While the theology is generally not as deep, I never saw the devaluing of marriage in that way. Rather, what tended to happen was that marriage, and often marriage at a fairly young age, was considered the right path for everyone. Attending an evangelical protestant school, men and women who weren’t engaged or in a serious relationship by the end of college were assumed to be at the very least desperate for a partner, if not possibly have something wrong with them.

The pressure was to marry, and to marry young. As a result, I saw a lot of marriages take place quickly, when the couple might have known each other for only a year, sometimes even less. It was also unquestioned that everyone needed to marry. The concept of celibacy was completely foreign; there were only married people and people looking to get married. Divorce was a dirty little secret - sometimes even in cases where it really was needed to protect a partner or children. Marriage and family was seen as almost a necessity of Christian life, to the point where in many cases no unmarried person could have any leadership role in a church.

The result? People who were never called to marriage marrying anyway, young people marrying out of youthful infatuation, and a culture that often glorified infatuation as a sign of God’s blessing.
 
Honestly, I’m not even sure what “religiously conservative Protestants” is supposed to mean. Conservative and Liberal and political categories. Orthodox and Heterodox (Heretical) are religious categories. Perhaps the article is talking about “Orthodox Protestants” but as all Protestants are Heterodox by definition there is no such creature as an “Orthodox Protestant” - its a logical contradiction and thus also meaningless. The whole thing reeks of a confusion in terms. 🤷
I disagree. While political terms are almost meaningless when it comes to the Catholic Church, I find it exceptionally well-applied to Protestant churches. As you put it, they have no orthodoxy, so their church doctrine pretty much falls under where their political beliefs are. Their religious beliefs almost stem FROM their political beliefs instead of the other way around, and it’s unfortunate. Anything that doesn’t agree with their beliefs can be changed, because obviously God wouldn’t ever inconvenience them!

I personally think it’s very easy to apply political definitions to most Protestant religions. For example, Southern Baptists are quite clearly hyper-conservative, and Pentecostals are so right-wing they’re off the political scale. UUs, on the other hand, are extraordinarily left-wing, whereas Methodists are closer to the Church (oppose same-sex “marriage,” hold Trinitarian beliefs, etc.) but still are more politically “liberal.”
 
It is not easy to make traditional values successful in today’s culture. Blue collar workers with traditional attitudes are now subjected to uncertain work, the stresses of children earlier in life, and less than optimal ways to deal with all these stressors.

Educated elites, more liberal in their values, marry other professionals from their own social class. It used to be doctors would marry nurses, and lawyers would marry their secretaries, and there would be a merging of different social classes as a result. Now doctors marry doctors, and lawyers marry lawyers, and accountants marry accountants, and the rich get richer and the poor get poorer.
This works out well for the educated, who get married later, have fewer children as a result, and have fewer money woes.
In blue collar America, things are not so easy. The desire to live according to a set of traditional values exists, but the ability to economically sustain those values of differentiated sexual roles that once were so useful in raising children are not there.

The problem is actually worse in traditionally Catholic and Orthodox countries such as Italy and Greece and Spain, where people are not getting married and having children at all. It is just too much work for women to maintain their traditional roles and step up to the plate professionally too, since one pay cheque is no longer enough. To break down, marriages must first exist.
Countries where men have opted to take on some of the more non-traditional roles of hands-on parenting, such as in northern Europe, have more success in these matters too.

When it comes to raising families in today’s two-income society, traditional values are not enough. Correct values are not enough either. Bringing traditional expectations into marriages where such expectations are not economically feasible is a recipe for failure.
 
I’m not sure about that. I grew up in the very conservative wing of protestantism. While the theology is generally not as deep, I never saw the devaluing of marriage in that way. Rather, what tended to happen was that marriage, and often marriage at a fairly young age, was considered the right path for everyone. Attending an evangelical protestant school, men and women who weren’t engaged or in a serious relationship by the end of college were assumed to be at the very least desperate for a partner, if not possibly have something wrong with them.

The pressure was to marry, and to marry young. As a result, I saw a lot of marriages take place quickly, when the couple might have known each other for only a year, sometimes even less. It was also unquestioned that everyone needed to marry. The concept of celibacy was completely foreign; there were only married people and people looking to get married. Divorce was a dirty little secret - sometimes even in cases where it really was needed to protect a partner or children. Marriage and family was seen as almost a necessity of Christian life, to the point where in many cases no unmarried person could have any leadership role in a church.

The result? People who were never called to marriage marrying anyway, young people marrying out of youthful infatuation, and a culture that often glorified infatuation as a sign of God’s blessing.
This is a very good post. 👍 Perhaps I was hasty and wrong in ascribing it all to theology - social and cultural factors outside religion can play a major role. (And I’m fully aware that several Catholic couples dissent from Church teaching on marriage, even if they don’t divorce.)
 
  1. *]Correct me if am I wrong but did Jennifer Glass who did the study write the following article? It says:
    Abstinence-only education, restrictions on the availability of birth control and abortion, support for marriage as the resolution of unexpected pregnancies, and distrust of secular education (especially higher education) among the populace in religiously conservative counties work to create an environment where young people of every religious belief – or none – tend not to pursue higher education or job training, and instead to engage in early marriage and child-bearing.
    contemporaryfamilies.org/impact-of-conservative-protestantism-on-regional-divorce-rates

    Doesn’t sound like she has an entirely objective view. She makes some strong claims as reasons that could be responsible for a higher divorce rate such as: ‘A third explanation offered before is that the dominance of religious conservatives in the South reflects a regional culture that also promotes relatively high rates of interpersonal violence – factors that destabilize marriage.’ Where does she get the view tht there could be high rates of interpersonal violence in the South? Where is the evidence?

    It does note in the article though that ‘people who live in conservative religious counties have a higher risk of divorce even when they are not affiliated with a conservative religious group.’

    Multiple studies have concluded that marrying as a virgin significantly lowers your divorce rate, and cohabitation increases the rate of divorce. I do not think the OP study looked at premarital sex rates or cohabitation rates before marriage.
    When a man is married as a virgin, his divorce rate is 63 percent lower than a non-virgin. For women, it’s 76 percent lower. Edward O. Laumann, et al., The Social Organization of Sexuality: Sexual Practices in the United States (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1994), 503.
    chastity.com/seminars/statistics/statistics

    That statistic comes from most self declared comprehensive survey published in 1994:

    press.uchicago.edu/ucp/books/book/chicago/S/bo3626005.html

    Different studies:

    Study: Definite Link between Premarital Sex, Cohabitation, and Divorce
    KAHN AND LONDON, 1991
    Data from the National Survey of Family Growth indicate that “women who are sexually active prior to marriage faced considerably higher risk of marital disruption than women who were virgin brides.” These scholars explain that even when controlling for various differentials between virginal and non-virginal groups – such as socio-economics, family background as well as attitudinal and value differences – “non-virgins still face a much higher risk of divorce than virgins.” [1]
    bpnews.net/BPFirstPerson.asp?ID=35210

    *]I saw a person comment that in liberal states there may be higher rates of cohabitation, and less marriage thus less divorce. If there are not equal rates of marriage between the states, then how can a comparison fairly be made between certain states having higher divorce rates than others?

    *]I am not sure what this study classes as ‘conservative Protestants.’ There are many Protestant denominations and some are against divorce and some allow divorce.
 
  1. *]Correct me if am I wrong but did Jennifer Glass who did the study write the following article? It says:
    Abstinence-only education, restrictions on the availability of birth control and abortion, support for marriage as the resolution of unexpected pregnancies, and distrust of secular education (especially higher education) among the populace in religiously conservative counties work to create an environment where young people of every religious belief – or none – tend not to pursue higher education or job training, and instead to engage in early marriage and child-bearing.
    contemporaryfamilies.org/impact-of-conservative-protestantism-on-regional-divorce-rates

    What does that comment say about her views on things? I am not saying the study is skewed because she seems to be against abstience-only education etc. She makes some strong claims as reasons that could be responsible for a higher divorce rate such as: ‘A third explanation offered before is that the dominance of religious conservatives in the South reflects a regional culture that also promotes relatively high rates of interpersonal violence – factors that destabilize marriage.’ Where does she get the view that there could be high rates of interpersonal violence in the South? Where is the evidence?

    It does note in the article though that ‘people who live in conservative religious counties have a higher risk of divorce even when they are not affiliated with a conservative religious group.’

    Multiple studies have concluded that marrying as a virgin significantly lowers your divorce rate, and cohabitation increases the rate of divorce. I do not think the OP study looked at premarital sex rates or cohabitation rates before marriage.
    When a man is married as a virgin, his divorce rate is 63 percent lower than a non-virgin. For women, it’s 76 percent lower. Edward O. Laumann, et al., The Social Organization of Sexuality: Sexual Practices in the United States (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1994), 503.
    chastity.com/seminars/statistics/statistics

    That statistic comes from most self declared comprehensive survey published in 1994:

    press.uchicago.edu/ucp/books/book/chicago/S/bo3626005.html

    Different studies:

    Study: Definite Link between Premarital Sex, Cohabitation, and Divorce
    KAHN AND LONDON, 1991
    Data from the National Survey of Family Growth indicate that “women who are sexually active prior to marriage faced considerably higher risk of marital disruption than women who were virgin brides.” These scholars explain that even when controlling for various differentials between virginal and non-virginal groups – such as socio-economics, family background as well as attitudinal and value differences – “non-virgins still face a much higher risk of divorce than virgins.” [1]
    bpnews.net/BPFirstPerson.asp?ID=35210

    *]I saw a person comment that in liberal states there may be higher rates of cohabitation, and less marriage thus less divorce. If there are not equal rates of marriage between the states, then how can a comparison fairly be made between certain states having higher divorce rates than others?

    *]I am not sure what this study classes as ‘conservative Protestants.’ There are many Protestant denominations and some are against divorce and some allow divorce.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top