Mormons ?

  • Thread starter Thread starter CatholicAlbo
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
They are not Christian. Their “Jesus” is not the incarnation of God. Their “Jesus” is Satan’s brother. Their “God” was once a flesh and blood man just like us, and all good Mormon men will be “gods” after death, ruling over another planet, having endless sex and producing endless “spirit babies” to occupy the bodies of the people on the planet they are given to rule over. It’s a complete heresy on all levels.
 
(The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints )
Are Mormons Christians ?
No, No, and No.

Christianity believes in One God which exists as a Trinity. Christians believe that Jesus is God in the flesh, who
came and died for our sins, though was sinless himself. Mormons do not believe such things, nor in many other
key tenants unique to Christianity. They belittle the Bible, belittle God, belittle Jesus and his sacrifice (because
for Mormons, Grace Alone is Heresy).

Mormons believe in many gods, that their god had a father god who has a father god
and so on. Mormons believe also that they can become gods. They place their BoM,
D&C, and PGP higher in authority than the Bible. Their prophets contradict the Bible
and even their first prophet Smith edited his own version of the Bible, which can NOT
be supported in any way to any prior manuscript.

For a while, believe it or not, Mormons even said that they were the only true Christians,
and that all other denominations were in fact not Christian (in the true sense), but rather
they all belonged to Babylon.

Mormons are not Christians.
 
Here is the short and plain answer, YES. We believe that Christ atoned for the sins of all men and that through him we are saved.
You don’t believe that Jesus’ atonement is enough to save you though. That is a heresy in
your religion. You also say that Jesus atoned for sin in the Garden, which is false too. He
was there praying for us and prayed that he not have to go through with the REAL atone–
ment, on the cross. Your religion also disparages the Cross, which is held in high esteem
even in the Bible. Speaking of which, you disparage the Bible as well.
Are we Trinitarians? NO. We believe in three distinct beings. The Father, the Son, and the Holy Ghost. "The Father has a body of flesh and bones as tangible as mans: the Son also; but the Holy Ghost has not a body of flesh and bones, but is a personage of Spirit. (D&C 130:22)
AND THAT AUTOMATICALLY ALSO Disqualifies Mormons from being Christian, as it is one
of the very doctrines that makes a person a Christian. Don’t believe in a God that is One Be-
ing who is Three Persons eternally, you’re not a Christian. Simple as that.
 
So “The Father” is some sort of entity that walks around somewhere in the universe with a “body of flesh and bones?” Huh? Now I REALLY don’t understand Mormons! :confused:
There is no difficulty here. God is precisely as he has appeared to every person who has ever seen him, an exaulted, perfected, person.
 
There is no difficulty here. God is precisely as he has appeared to every person who has ever seen him, an exaulted, perfected, person.
You see everybody, Mormons contradict the Bible:
And he (God) said, Thou canst not see my
face
; for Man shall not see me, and live.
– (Exodus 33:20)

Now to the King of Ages, immortal, invisible, the
only God
, be honour and glory for ever and ever.
Amen.
– (Timothy 1:17)

(Speaking of Jesus) Who is the image of the
invisible God, the firstborn of every creature:
– (Colossians 1:15)

No one has seen God at any time; the only-begotten Son,
who is in the bosom of the Father, he hath declared him.
– (John 1:18)

No man hath seen God at any time. If we love
one another, God abideth in us, and his charity is
perfected in us.
– (1 John 4:12)
Joseph Smith should have died when (or IF) he saw God the Father. God is
invisible. Any “appearance” God seems to make in the Old Testament is ac–
tually the pre-incarnate Christ.
 
I once obtained the Book of Mormons and a few other writings from the Library in order to figure out just what they do believe. The clincher for me was that “Adam is the god of THIS world”, and he populated it with “his” children, born of “his” wiveS. That finished my interest in Mormon theology, although I read all the books to understand it better. I admire many things about the Mormons, their emphasis on healthy living, their forbidding alcohol, (which would eliminate me, as I enjoy a glass of wine a couple times a month), they also forbid coffee as a “stimulant”, which means I wouldn’t get through one morning as a Mormon! They help one another, which is good, but forbid other races (particularly the Negro and Indian peoples) from high offices in their Temple hierarchy. They also don’t allow anyone who is not a dedicated Mormon into the inner sanctum of their Temple. This secrecy alone would make me nervous. They baptize for the dead, that’s why they have a geneology website, to get names of the dead who were not Mormons, then Mormons are baptized (over and over) in the names of each of the dead persons they obtain. They believe all souls are already created, and when the last soul becomes a human (on our particular planet), this planet will be “closed down”, the Mormons who die become “gods” of another planet, with several wives to help populate it and then repeat the process. Definitely not Christian.
 
This is also about the 5th Thread about the Mormons and whether they are Christians in the past 6 months. There is also a definitive answer on the Apologetics Forum by one of the Apologists who is also a Priest.
 
From this website, at catholic.com/quickquestions/what-does-the-catholic-church-say-about-the-practices-and-beliefs-of-mormonism

While individual Mormons may be persons of good conscience, Mormonism itself is a belief system that would reduce the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit from being the three Persons of the one, true, and infinite God to being three limited, finite deities among an uncounted multitude of deities, all of whom merely reshaped small parts of a preexisting cosmos.

Mormonism teaches that human beings may, by practicing the tenets of its faith, become gods and goddesses themselves, with their own planets full of people worshiping them.

While the Catholic Church would reject nothing that is true or good in Mormonism or any other world religion, Catholic theology would have to note that there is a tremendous amount in Mormonism that is neither true nor good. Further, because Mormonism presents itself as a form of Christianity yet is incompatible with the historic Christian faith, sound pastoral practice would need to warn the Christian faithful: Mormon theology is blasphemous, polytheistic, and cannot be considered on par with the theology of other Christian groups.
Best summation I have read in a long time. 👍
 
There is no difficulty here. God is precisely as he has appeared to every person who has ever seen him, an exaulted, perfected, person.
And who has seen the Father, Janderich? Only the Son.

And you can save throwing out verses that speak of Stephen seeing Jesus at “God’s right hand” and ask us to believe that the Father then has a “right hand”. Or that Moses saw the Father. I still find it hard to believe that one would actually use these as arguments, but they have been made before and are nothing short of silly.

But please tell me who has seen “the invisible God”?
 
Thank you all for your answers,god bless you all.
Dear brothers and sisters we mus pray for them! Separation of church is a BIG mistake!
 
Mormons are absolutely not Christian despite protestations to the contrary. Their beliefs on God the Father, Jesus Christ and the Holy Spirit are miles away from Christian beliefs. They use the same words but have an entirely different meaning. Even their recent prophets have been clear that the Mormon understanding of Jesus Christ is very different from Christian beliefs.

When I was Mormon, I incorrectly thought I was Christian, but that was because I didn’t really understand Christianity. Now that I understand Christianity, I can clearly see that Mormonism is not Christian.
Thank you for the answer! God bless you !
 
Short answer, YES. Despite their understanding of the Trinity, they still believe in the same Jesus Christ, fully God and Man, that died on the cross at Calvary for our sins that we do. They are fully 100% Christian.

Here is a verse from the Book of Mormon that confirms this: (2 Nephi 25:26)

“And we talk of Christ, we rejoice in Christ, we preach of Christ, we prophesy of Christ, and we write according to our prophecies, that our children may know to what source they may look for a remission of their sins.”
This is incorrect (also, you can’t say “despite their understanding of the Trinity”, then go on to say “they still believe in the same Jesus Christ, fully God and Man”. It doesn’t logically follow.). I believe I already addressed your incorrect viewpoint on this in another thread:

forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=841289&page=4

Latter-day Saints differ fundamentally in their understanding of the nature of Jesus Christ from orthodox Christianity. Indeed, someone already quoted an LDS leader stating that the Jesus Christ they speak of is not the same as the “traditional” Christ. A prime difference in this understanding is that Latter-day Saints believe that the Son is the literal firstborn spirit child of the Father (and Heavenly Mother). He was spiritually begotten at some point, as we all were (as literal spirit children of heavenly parents).
 
my place of employment has many Mormons. they definitely stick together and I feel like an outsider. they are nice enough, but I can’t help but have the feeling that they can’t allow themselves to get too close to other who are not Mormons. we also live in a neighborhood that many Mormon families live in and they are friendly, but you definitely get the feeling that they look at you as an outsider.

so it has been interesting to read on this thread about what they really believe.

do they think joseph smith was the last prophet then after mohammed? that is, if we believe mohammed was a prophet.

it sounds a lot like l ron hubbard material when you read about different planets, etc.
 
my place of employment has many Mormons. they definitely stick together and I feel like an outsider. they are nice enough, but I can’t help but have the feeling that they can’t allow themselves to get too close to other who are not Mormons. we also live in a neighborhood that many Mormon families live in and they are friendly, but you definitely get the feeling that they look at you as an outsider.

so it has been interesting to read on this thread about what they really believe.

do they think joseph smith was the last prophet then after mohammed? that is, if we believe mohammed was a prophet.

it sounds a lot like l ron hubbard material when you read about different planets, etc.
Mormons are taught there was a great apostasy after Christ and the apostles died (a total and complete falling away). They are taught they have the only true church and priesthood authority from Christ that was restored through the prophet Joseph Smith. They teach that the apostles Peter, James, and John appeared to Smith and gave him the authority. They teach that Joseph Smith saw God the Father and Jesus Christ as separate beings. Joesph Smith taught that God the Father has a body of flesh and bones and is a glorified being. Now that I’ve listened to other Christians, I see I am not a Christian. I was given a totally distorted idea of God and Jesus. Now I find out Jesus is God incarnate. There never was a pre-mortal life. Much of what we were taught creates distrust and inability to become close to those outside the church.

Joseph Smith was the first prophet in this dispensation since the restoration of the true church, to Mormons. Since him there is a continuing line of prophets just like there is a line of popes (but of course the popes never had a break since the time of Christ). The current prophet is Thomas S. Monson.

Yep, and there is the planet thing too. This is all the deep doctrine that I shouldn’t get into 😉

Mormons do not believe in Muhammad as prophet. They believe in the Biblical prophets and the prophets of the restored Mormon church.
 
From this website, at catholic.com/quickquestions/what-does-the-catholic-church-say-about-the-practices-and-beliefs-of-mormonism

While the Catholic Church would reject nothing that is true or good in Mormonism or any other world religion, Catholic theology would have to note that there is a tremendous amount in Mormonism that is neither true nor good. Further, because Mormonism presents itself as a form of Christianity yet is incompatible with the historic Christian faith, sound pastoral practice would need to warn the Christian faithful: Mormon theology is blasphemous, polytheistic, and cannot be considered on par with the theology of other Christian groups.
Agreed.
 
my place of employment has many Mormons. they definitely stick together and I feel like an outsider. they are nice enough, but I can’t help but have the feeling that they can’t allow themselves to get too close to other who are not Mormons. we also live in a neighborhood that many Mormon families live in and they are friendly, but you definitely get the feeling that they look at you as an outsider.

so it has been interesting to read on this thread about what they really believe.

do they think joseph smith was the last prophet then after mohammed? that is, if we believe mohammed was a prophet.

it sounds a lot like l ron hubbard material when you read about different planets, etc.
Having been Mormon and now not, I see what you are saying from both sides. It is true, there is an isolationism mindset. They will tell you it is not true, but then they are taught they have the “truth” and everyone else is being lead astray by Satan, so it foments distrust. My immediate family is the only non-Mormons on my side. When I announced my departure, I was censored - I was literally told to keep it to myself. Now they talk about Mormonism to a greater degree and I am expected to hold my tongue. As converts tend to do, I am on fire with love for The Lord and His church, but am incapable of addressing my family. It is a level of frustration that is quite irritating, particularly around holidays when I see them more. I keep drafting letters (which I never send) hoping to show them my life, me as a person, their two-faced attitudes, but I wave off as it turns into a novel. Some Mormons may not know their theology to the degree you’ve just read here, the “deeper” stuff mentioned above does not get a lot of press. That is sad also that you can’t hold a very effective conversation with most, cause the buck stops at their “testimony” - the subjective personal conviction that they are members of the “true” church. When facts, logic, reason, any of God’s gifts dispute/distract from their conviction, they will hit the “I Believe” button and claim you need to have faith, it’ll all make sense on the other side.
 
When facts, logic, reason, any of God’s gifts dispute/distract from their conviction, they will hit the “I Believe” button and claim you need to have faith, it’ll all make sense on the other side.
LOL! “We need to pass the bill to see what’s really in it.”
 
Here is the short and plain answer, YES. We believe that Christ atoned for the sins of all men and that through him we are saved.

Are we Trinitarians? NO. We believe in three distinct beings. The Father, the Son, and the Holy Ghost. "The Father has a body of flesh and bones as tangible as mans: the Son also; but the Holy Ghost has not a body of flesh and bones, but is a personage of Spirit. (D&C 130:22)
D&C was written after the scriptures were written though, so it’s a man-made protestant teaching. I’m not saying that to argue because I come from a Seventh-day Adventist protesatnt church myself, but even Ellen White had her own interpretation that was "wo"man-made. She’s just as much a protestant teacher as Smith was: not lower, not higher. I had to look at what came before Ellen White, before the protestant reformation, to discover the source of what doctrines were taught back to the apostles and the traditions carried on by their disciples (ante-nicene fathers book series). It’s really worth checking it out and see what they taught before Smith, Ellen White, and any other post-protestant teacher who have great new epiphanies. I discovered the early church fathers were indeed Catholic by doctrine. I had to learn to seek, anyway. I know what it is like. Christ still loves us all whether we’re Mormon, Seventh-day Adventist, Jehovah Witness, etc. If we humbly seek him, we will surely find him and his church he said would be here forever (SDA’s started in the 19th century, so that can’t be valid, for example). I still want to learn what mormons fully believe though to understand their doctrines more for educational value. I saw a few walking by lately, so maybe I’ll be able to grab them.
 
Yesterday, I was talking to an LDS friend of mine who is 86 years old. We have been friends now for over 40 years.

I said to her, after all we are all Christians, so I could see her response. She said no, LDS are above and beyond Christianity. They are the true believers, and for many years she was instructed to say they were not Christian, but LDS. I asked why then now, LDS want to be referred to as Christians, and she said it was because they feel they would not face so much discrimination that way.

Just thought that was an interesting idea from her.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top