Mourdock Rape Comment Puts GOP on Defense

  • Thread starter Thread starter Mijoy2
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

Mijoy2

Guest
abcnews.go.com/Politics/OTUS/richard-mourdock-rape-comment-puts-romney-defense/story?id=17552263

(first a qualifier - My assumption is Mourdock meant the that baby was intended by God, not the rape that caused the pregnancy was intended by God).

I am having a problem with the integrity of the Republican party.

First it was Ryans’ not holding fast and true to his beliefs that abortion is abortion regarless of circumstance during the debate with Biden . He held to the platform stance of exceptions, yet I do not believe he personally supports these exceptions. Yet he lacked the courage to say so. Unless I am mistaken and he does support exceptions personally.

Now I do not see anywhere, a politician, when pressed on the matter of Mourdocks comments admitting they stand with Mourdocks comments. They all say that there are the exception clauses (rape and incest). At least the interviews I have witnessed

Can’t they see that this compromises the basic premise? I cannot understand the argument from either side when asked by the media about Mourdocks remarks during his debate question regarding rape and abortion… If I were of the pro-choice (being charitable) party I would sit back and wait till the pro-life party mentioned the exceptions, then I would pounce and ask, “if life begins at conception and abortion is the taking of an innocent life, then why do you support exceptions”? If I were of the pro-life party and the question came up I would simply say, “life begins at conception, to abort an innocent baby because of how they were concieved should not matter”. Abortion, plain and simple, should be no more a legal procedure then assisted suicide, Each are wrong.

The pro-life, party in my opinion, is looking the fool for taking a half stance on the matter and not stepping up to the plate. It is just too easy to shoot holes in their perspective.

If I were b eing interviewed and asked
 
Fake outrage is fake. You are speaking extemporaneously in a debate, and people will jump on everything you say. It was obvious what he was referring to, and believes God has a plan for that little life. Goodness can come out of tragedy. Anyone calling for blood isn’t worth your time.

That’s why I wouldn’t answer hypotheticals in a debate. it killed Dukakis, even moreso than his sourpuss face and wee-little height, and has no place in these debates. Romney was smart to blow by the moderator on that in the FP debate.

The man was expressing heartfelt pro-life convictions he holds, but even having those convictions is a lightning rod for the left. They loathe people like him. He had the gall to mention God AND being pro-life? Disgusting! That sort of morality has NO place in politics. Hence why you see all the fake outrage on here.

A simple “he could have worded it in a better way” would suffice. That’s the same reason I didn’t jump on BO for saying “4 deaths isn’t optimal.” The way the question was asked almost led to that answer.

As an adult, I have bigger fish to fry than playing gotcha word games with people. That sort of thing is for children, which is why they aren’t allowed to vote.
 
I’m agreed with He Man. This is an emotional response for many/all of them reacting this way. Reason doesn’t enter into the equation.
 
I am having a problem with the integrity of the Republican party…

The pro-life, party in my opinion, is looking the fool for taking a half stance on the matter and not stepping up to the plate. It is just too easy to shoot holes in their perspective.
Well, they are, after all, politicians and one needs to be very careful with words so as not to offend or lose a vote. The Reps used to be the party of integrity, but they have lost most of their conservative stance and what now, can really be believed? On the pro-life front however, we are to vote to lessen the evil. That makes the choice rather clear.
 
Well, they are, after all, politicians and one needs to be very careful with words so as not to offend or lose a vote. The Reps used to be the party of integrity, but they have lost most of their conservative stance and what now, can really be believed? On the pro-life front however, we are to vote to lessen the evil. That makes the choice rather clear.
Yes, they are politicians. Reminding me why I’d never want to be one even if I had the talent.

I think my point is more that the republican party, with it’s platform view of “exceptions” has dug it’s own hole ont his matter and now has to dance around the pressing interrogation… On one hand the argument is the truth that life begins at conception and all that goes with that. Such as every person (of which the baby is) has their inalienable right to life, liberty and pursuit of happiness and abortion is the taking of an innocent life…etc etc.

To attempt to satisfy the public “for votes” by compromising this belief opens the door to any journalist of any talent what so ever, to shoot holes in the basic premise. Which makes the politician look foolish because there simply is no good repsponce.

The party steps up to the plate,stares the pitcher in the eye, then refuses to swing the bat. It’s a losing battle.

Courage before votes - how is that for slogan 😉
 
The pro-life, party in my opinion, is looking the fool for taking a half stance on the matter and not stepping up to the plate. It is just too easy to shoot holes in their perspective.
The major political parties aren’t interested in championing a cause. They are interested in getting elected, and that means pandering to the public. Romney’s position, from a logical point of view, is incoherent. But it fits with the views of most pro-life Americans, those who favor greatly restricting or banning abortion.

I am not sure how Mourdock’s position will play in Indiana. But on a national level, it will lose many more votes than it will gain.

Romney has shown a great deal of courage in not distancing himself from Mourdock, given how close the presidential race is and how close we are to election day.
 
abcnews.go.com/Politics/OTUS/richard-mourdock-rape-comment-puts-romney-defense/story?id=17552263

(first a qualifier - My assumption is Mourdock meant the that baby was intended by God, not the rape that caused the pregnancy was intended by God).

I am having a problem with the integrity of the Republican party.

First it was Ryans’ not holding fast and true to his beliefs that abortion is abortion regarless of circumstance during the debate with Biden . He held to the platform stance of exceptions, yet I do not believe he personally supports these exceptions. Yet he lacked the courage to say so. Unless I am mistaken and he does support exceptions personally.

Now I do not see anywhere, a politician, when pressed on the matter of Mourdocks comments admitting they stand with Mourdocks comments. They all say that there are the exception clauses (rape and incest). At least the interviews I have witnessed

Can’t they see that this compromises the basic premise? I cannot understand the argument from either side when asked by the media about Mourdocks remarks during his debate question regarding rape and abortion… If I were of the pro-choice (being charitable) party I would sit back and wait till the pro-life party mentioned the exceptions, then I would pounce and ask, “if life begins at conception and abortion is the taking of an innocent life, then why do you support exceptions”? If I were of the pro-life party and the question came up I would simply say, “life begins at conception, to abort an innocent baby because of how they were concieved should not matter”. Abortion, plain and simple, should be no more a legal procedure then assisted suicide, Each are wrong.

The pro-life, party in my opinion, is looking the fool for taking a half stance on the matter and not stepping up to the plate. It is just too easy to shoot holes in their perspective.

If I were b eing interviewed and asked
LOL!!

You state you have problems with the “integrity of the Republican party”, well what is integrity then? Lying and falsifying about the murders of Americans in Benghazi?? Not defending them? Is that integrity? How about voting against the Born Alive Infant Protection Act, BAIPA as Obama voted against 4 times. Allowing babies who survive abortion to be left to die. Do you call that integrity? Can you judge that? Your perspective seems to have some holes in it.
 
On March 23 I attended the first rally for religious liberty in Fort Wayne. Mr Mourdock sent a statement of support with his apology for not attending in person. He had a really good excuse–he was personally attending the rally in Indianapolis at the same time. His primary opponent, Senator Richard Lugar ignored the rally and Joe Donnelly, the Democratic Party candidate seems to ignore the issue, although he claims to be a pro-life Catholic with a fairly good pro-life record. He voted for the Obamacare package that made the HHS mandate possible and continues to back it.

The Democrats in Indiana are so far behind in polls that they will seize any possible slip to pull out a win. The Democrat candidate for governor is being called an embarassment even by my friends who are strong UAW members.
 
abcnews.go.com/Politics/OTUS/richard-mourdock-rape-comment-puts-romney-defense/story?id=17552263

(first a qualifier - My assumption is Mourdock meant the that baby was intended by God, not the rape that caused the pregnancy was intended by God).

I am having a problem with the integrity of the Republican party.

First it was Ryans’ not holding fast and true to his beliefs that abortion is abortion regarless of circumstance during the debate with Biden . He held to the platform stance of exceptions, yet I do not believe he personally supports these exceptions. Yet he lacked the courage to say so. Unless I am mistaken and he does support exceptions personally…
During the debate, Ryan explained his beliefs, and that they were backed up by science. He then explained that he would be working on the party platform.

Sometimes we have to work on issues step-by-step. When people really think about the issue, they will start to see that the exceptions make no sense, but altho Americans have come to accept that abortion is not a good thing and should have restrictions, they have not yet reached the point where they understand that *all *abortion is totally wrong.

There are arguments for both sides of the question of how to handle this politically: whether to accept only understanding of and working towards abortion as an intrinsic evil which must be completely banned, or working towards stopping as many abortions as possible and continuing to educate and push until all abortions are banned. The Church accepts either position as valid.
 
LOL!!

You state you have problems with the “integrity of the Republican party”, well what is integrity then? Lying and falsifying about the murders of Americans in Benghazi?? Not defending them? Is that integrity? How about voting against the Born Alive Infant Protection Act, BAIPA as Obama voted against 4 times. Allowing babies who survive abortion to be left to die. Do you call that integrity? Can you judge that? Your perspective seems to have some holes in it.
BroomWagon,

My perspctive (nor my poiint for that matter) was not in any way shape opr form, a comparative one. Nor was it a knock on the republican party. It was simply a point. One that apparently many republicans share.
 
During the debate, Ryan explained his beliefs, and that they were backed up by science. He then explained that he would be working on the party platform.

Sometimes we have to work on issues step-by-step. When people really think about the issue, they will start to see that the exceptions make no sense, but altho Americans have come to accept that abortion is not a good thing and should have restrictions, they have not yet reached the point where they understand that *all *abortion is totally wrong.

There are arguments for both sides of the question of how to handle this politically: whether to accept only understanding of and working towards abortion as an intrinsic evil which must be completely banned, or working towards stopping as many abortions as possible and continuing to educate and push until all abortions are banned. The Church accepts either position as valid.
And we should not forget Ryan said he believed life begins at conception at the debate… that is still a statement. I would have to read the exact wording anyway.

But some people will want to vote for the likes of Biden’s and Obama’s views no matter what.
 
I think I am allowed to bump this where I did not make the last post (perhaps). But this I find terribly troublesome.

Watching Piers Morgan tonight voice the opinion that the perspective that abortion is a religious conviction (his religous conviction if he were to know his faith) that is warped (certainly mistaken) I find almost defeating. Mr. Catholic Morgan’s voice is certainly much louder then mine could ever be.

I’d think these forums would be screaming from their proverbial keyboards about this. But…I do not find other threads voicing this point. And this thread fell by the wayside. So, this is an attempt to bring it back.

The last attempt. 🤷

Where is Mr Mourdocks support? All he said was, effectively, life (innocent life) begins at conception. Mr. Morgan disagrees.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top