Mt Hood Rescue effort over -- A lesson learned?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Catholic_Dude
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

Catholic_Dude

Guest
foxnews.com/story/0,2933,237740,00.html

As most know for about the past 2 weeks all we have seen and heard on tv is this search and rescue mission on Mt Hood for some lost climbers. Today there are articles that say the rescue effort is over and now its a “recovery” mission.

We need clear laws laid down about this type of nonsense and even more important what is needed is common sense. Its the same story over and over, some people think they are being cute by climbing mountains and it turns into a tragic situation which in the end costs/wastes tax dollars, news time and worst of all peoples lives.

There should be rules stating if you want to do dangerous things like go climbing up a mountain (worse yet during the stormy winter) THEN you must agree that no tax dollars or human effort can be used to help you out if you get stuck. Stop the wasting of tax dollars, stop putting rescue crews lives on the line, stop covering news like this as if its the only real news out there with nothing better to report.

Whats worse these guys go off doing these dangerous things KNOWING they have a family that needs them, how misdirected are people’s consciences when they have no problem putting themself in dangerous situations knowing if something happed their family would be in deep trouble.

The cost and consequences are simply too great for this to be treated as no big deal. Putting your life on the line needlessly is a sin and people need to recognize that.
 
foxnews.com/story/0,2933,237740,00.html

As most know for about the past 2 weeks all we have seen and heard on tv is this search and rescue mission on Mt Hood for some lost climbers. Today there are articles that say the rescue effort is over and now its a “recovery” mission.

We need clear laws laid down about this type of nonsense and even more important what is needed is common sense. Its the same story over and over, some people think they are being cute by climbing mountains and it turns into a tragic situation which in the end costs/wastes tax dollars, news time and worst of all peoples lives.
Please! More government regulation? You want mountaineers to register, get licensed, maybe? I’m sure that would cost more than S&R missions for the few who need it.
There should be rules stating if you want to do dangerous things like go climbing up a mountain (worse yet during the stormy winter) THEN you must agree that no tax dollars or human effort can be used to help you out if you get stuck. Stop the wasting of tax dollars, stop putting rescue crews lives on the line, stop covering news like this as if its the only real news out there with nothing better to report.
How about no rescue efforts if you choose to live in an area where there are chronic forest fires? Or no tax dollars if your house is destroyed by mudslides or earthquakes or floods?
Whats worse these guys go off doing these dangerous things KNOWING they have a family that needs them, how misdirected are people’s consciences when they have no problem putting themself in dangerous situations knowing if something happed their family would be in deep trouble.
These guys were not irresponsible. They were experienced climbers & took all the precautions they could. From what I understand the weather changed on them unexpectedly.
 
In the United States (and elsewhere) we have a tradition of the community banding together and organizing rescues of people in distress.

Sometimes the distress is caused by unexpected weather conditions. Sometimes it is caused by bad judgement. Sometimes, it is just an accident.

There are lifeboat societies, in which brave men and women provide the manpower to go out in terrible sea conditions to attempt to save the lives of people in foundering ships or in ship wrecks. There is no shortage of volunteers.

As I recall, there is even a Christian statement about one who gives up his life for his friends. Or who endangers his life in the course of helping his neighbor. Or, even, just giving someone a cold cup of water on a hot day.

Those searchers and rescuers at Mount Hood did all that they could.

Folks who go into extreme situations may be adventurers in one sense, but they may be pioneers in another sense.

They make us aware of the dangers and forces of natue and may give rise to efforts to improve safety and to improve knowledge … something other than handcuffing people to their houses.

Life is difficult. It always has been difficult and still is. We are blessed (or cursed) with a veneer of how easy life is. How pleasant it SHOULD be.

But that pleasantness is a very thin veneer.

It is so easy to equate success with entitlement. We sometimes feel that we are entitled to safety and pleasure. That safety and pleasure are the norm.

It don’t work that way.

Sometimes, I think that everyone should invest in and work for a few years as a farmer. Then you would learn about crops that fail the day before the harvest or late rains that rot the seeds or droughts that dry up the crops. Or critters that eat your crops. Or some bug that gets to your livestock. Or a heavy snow that collapses the roof on your equipment shed. Or a cold that freezes your water pipe. Or a wind that takes you as you walk from the house to the barn.

Never forget what is real and what is in the realm of wishes.

Pray CONSTANTLY to the Infinite God for direction and guidance, cash flow and work, and, in the end, forgiveness, grace and mercy.
 
I realize that you are mourning the loss of three young men with families and who should have had a whole lifetime ahead of them. You sound angry at them for taking an unnecessary risk that ended tragically. I had some of those same feelings, but I realized when the climber in the snow cave took pictures of the little supplies that they did take with them, that he was saying something. I am sure that at some point each one had these feelings. I am just praying for their families. The agonizing “What if” always lingers after a tragic accident. The volunteers were so brave and caring-God Bless them.
 
I understand that these were very experienced climbers that did not expect the conditions they encountered. I don’t believe this is a same situation where somebody drives through the police barracade into a flooded street - then gets stuck.

I feel really bad for the families.
 
Even if they were complete boneheads (and the evidence suggests that they knew what they were doing, but the weather turned unexpectedly), it would be a reflection on us if we didn’t go to their aid. OUR dignity as humans would thus be diminished, something the Church stridently opposes.

We should go after them. Our God, after all, leaves the ninety-nine safe in the fold and goes in search of the one lost.

May they rest in everlasting peace.
 
The problem with depending on laws in situations like this is that the most logical and simple way to prevent tragedies like this is to make it illegal to climb Mount Hood – or any other mountain. Is that what we want?

Do we want a society with no skydivers, SCUBA divers, race car drivers, backpackers, mountain climbers and so on?
 
'Dude you seem to have a problem with people who are adventurous, i.e. Steve Irwin. I get what you are trying to say, I think, about the cost, the seemingly avoidable heartache, etc. However, as Al Masseti suggested they are pioneers, too. If everyone played it safe there would have been a lot less progress, perhaps a lot more war and you wouldn’t be where you are right now. Unless you are a Native american you’d be in the Old County because your ancestors didn’t take a risk coming to America.

I personally enjoy activities like rappelling and white water rafting. I ride a motorcycle (but please don’t refer to me as he/him, thanks). I like adventure. It charges my batteries. I learn about myself and what I’m capable of doing. And then I go home and go to work a little richer for the experience. And a little more at peace.

People who take risks are ultimately more productive than people who don’t. Okay, I"m not that productive but that’s just me. These guys on Mount Hood as well as those who preceded them and those who will follow live life big. I wish I lived it as big as they did.
 
Here is a very interesting point of view.Search and Rescue: A Privilege for the Saved or Burden for Society?

My opinion is that, occasional money spent on rescues is okay. The government spends money on many unneccessary things, including unfruitful foreign military expeditions, ridiculous studies of the breeding habits of the dung beetle, and many other ludicrous endeavors.

The people employed in the efforts of rescue are making a living doing this, so the money is not a waste. They also gain experience by rescuing these people. I am thankful to live in a generous nation that will try to rescue lost climbers.

I believe the annoyance with this comes from people who generally don’t understand risk taking tendencies in some people and are critical of risk takers. They don’t mind, however, the government or insurence companies stepping in to take care of them when they suffer the results of their own risk taking activities such as stuffing themselves with transfats, being a couch potato, and then suffering a stroke or heart attack as a result.
 
Colorado has a good system – when you buy a hunting license, you pay a bit extra (about $2.50 as I recall) to help fund Search and Rescue. I’ve always thought that was a fine idea.

I must admit, however, to being a bit of a Haslerite. “Blondie” Hassler (who led the “Cockleshell Heroes” in the canoe attack on shipping in Bordeaux harbor in WWII) was quite a yachtsman (he organized the OSTAR – the Observer-Star Single-handed Trans Atlantic Race). He used to say yachtsmen should not carry radio transmitters because “We go to sea for our own pleasure, and we have no right to call on other men to risk their lives for us if we get in trouble.”

Perhaps it’s because I did so much skydiving – a parachutist who gets in trouble must get himself out. No one can save him.
 
“Life is either a daring adventure or nothing. To keep our faces toward change and behave like free spirits in the presence of fate is strength undefeatable.”

Helen Keller

“A ship in port is safe, but that’s not why ships are built.”

Grace Murray Hopper

“If you don’t risk anything, you risk even more.”

Erica Jong

“I don’t want to come to the end of my life and find that I have just lived the length of it. I want to have lived the width of it as well.”

Diane Ackerman
 
Amen.

What sort of people would we be if we never crossed unknown oceans to see what was on the other side, never climbed mountains, never ventured into space?
 
Whats worse these guys go off doing these dangerous things KNOWING they have a family that needs them, how misdirected are people’s consciences when they have no problem putting themselves in dangerous situations knowing if something happed their family would be in deep trouble.

The cost and consequences are simply too great for this to be treated as no big deal.** Putting your life on the line needlessly is a sin and people need to recognize that**.
Wow- this is an amazingly unkind post. :hmmm:

The best-laid plans of mice and men often go awry. Should we not help people when they get into trouble? Should we not have compassion for their families?

And what if a simple swim in the near-by pond turns deadly? Are we not to try and rescue you because we would be sinning?

Where would our country be without some adventurers. OK - so it’s not your gig, but let’s not disrespect the dead by putting them down and calling them names. Shame. Let’s also hope and pray that their family members and friends do not read this thread.

All I can say is Blessed be the rescue workers.
 
Amen.

What sort of people would we be if we never crossed unknown oceans to see what was on the other side, never climbed mountains, never ventured into space?
Gee Vern, we are rarely on the same side of a debate.

Merry Christmas!

Nohome
 
The problem with depending on laws in situations like this is that the most logical and simple way to prevent tragedies like this is to make it illegal to climb Mount Hood – or any other mountain. Is that what we want?

Do we want a society with no skydivers, SCUBA divers, race car drivers, backpackers, mountain climbers and so on?
The general concept of the solution I propose is that they sign some sort of form indicating that no tax dollars or humans will be provided for their rescue should such an even arise.
Here is a very interesting point of view.Search and Rescue: A Privilege for the Saved or Burden for Society?

My opinion is that, occasional money spent on rescues is okay. The government spends money on many unneccessary things, including unfruitful foreign military expeditions, ridiculous studies of the breeding habits of the dung beetle, and many other ludicrous endeavors.

The people employed in the efforts of rescue are making a living doing this, so the money is not a waste. They also gain experience by rescuing these people. I am thankful to live in a generous nation that will try to rescue lost climbers.

I believe the annoyance with this comes from people who generally don’t understand risk taking tendencies in some people and are critical of risk takers. They don’t mind, however, the government or insurence companies stepping in to take care of them when they suffer the results of their own risk taking activities such as stuffing themselves with transfats, being a couch potato, and then suffering a stroke or heart attack as a result.
Good articles. You make some solid points here for the financial aspect as well.
Wow- this is an amazingly unkind post. :hmmm:

The best-laid plans of mice and men often go awry. Should we not help people when they get into trouble? Should we not have compassion for their families?

And what if a simple swim in the near-by pond turns deadly? Are we not to try and rescue you because we would be sinning?

Where would our country be without some adventurers. OK - so it’s not your gig, but let’s not disrespect the dead by putting them down and calling them names. Shame. Let’s also hope and pray that their family members and friends do not read this thread.

All I can say is Blessed be the rescue workers.
A simple swim is not the same as an “extreme” sport. People need to be taught that they have a duty in life to their family and going off on high risk activities is simply irresponsible and should be at least verbally condemned by secular and religious authorites.
 
At what point can we refuse a call for help, because of the distressed person’s actions? Can we let a motorcyclist die because he didn’t wear a helmet? Is a smoker to be denied cancer treatment?

I say I am a Hasslerite – perhaps because as a skydiver and SCUBA diver I was involved in sports were one is largely dependent on himself – but can I refuse a call for help? Is that a Catholic position?

And if it is, where does it end? Are people who live in crime-ridden neighborhoods to be denied police protection?
 
I don’t want to sound unsympathetic for these poor guys and their families because I truly feel heartbroken that none made it out alive.

But, I’m not understanding where this threat is going about - comparing these guys to astronauts, explorers, etc. I just don’t get it.

They didn’t set out to find something that’s never been found or go somewhere that’s never been gone to before. They weren’t heros. They were just guys that made a poor and tragic decision to climb a mountain during a bad blizzard.

As someone who has relatives involved in the planning and coordinating of search and rescue missions like this, I can understand OPs reaction about the costs involved. They can be outrageous. And in a lot of cases, where there is illegal conduct like going past warning signs to a dangerous location, there should be some financial responsibility brought on the person at fault. But to be civilized, means that we have a responsibility to help our fellow man in danger - regardless of whether its their fault or not.
 
I don’t want to sound unsympathetic for these poor guys and their families because I truly feel heartbroken that none made it out alive.

But, I’m not understanding where this threat is going about - comparing these guys to astronauts, explorers, etc. I just don’t get it.

They didn’t set out to find something that’s never been found or go somewhere that’s never been gone to before. They weren’t heros. They were just guys that made a poor and tragic decision to climb a mountain during a bad blizzard.

As someone who has relatives involved in the planning and coordinating of search and rescue missions like this, I can understand OPs reaction about the costs involved. They can be outrageous. And in a lot of cases, where there is illegal conduct like going past warning signs to a dangerous location, there should be some financial responsibility brought on the person at fault. But to be civilized, means that we have a responsibility to help our fellow man in danger - regardless of whether its their fault or not.
Yes, yes, and by the same standard, if an overweight person, or smoker, has a stroke or heart attack brought on by his risk taking activities of sitting on the couch and eating junkfood, then why should Medicare or Insurence pay for him? Why would someone who supposedly cares about his family smoke, or overeat junkfood, when the possible outcomes are so well documented?

Do you realize how much greater cost to society is this type of risky behavior?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top