I thought of doing songs like Sing a New Song, Christ Be Our Light and City of God for Entrance or closing on Saturday and Sunday at our church, (all were suggested and fit very well with the gospel reading) but of course, regular Christmas carols were suggested at
liturgy.com too. What is the cut off for Christmas carols, in your opinion? I certainly could do a mixture of both this weekend. The argument I get from some members would be, We do Sing a New Song, Christ Be Our Light and City of God all year, we should stick to carols for one more weekend, and other members say, Awww, we’ve sung most of the carols already, and Christmas is over anyway. Let’s move on.
I just want a good balance , kwIm? I’d like the different types of songs to fit in with a good flow.
We will do We Three Kings, though, that’s a given. I chose it for the offertory song because it reflects the gospel reading. Our pastor might ask me why I didn’t choose it for an entrance, and I just think an entrance song should be about- a. gathering b. singing c. praising God or d. all of these. We Three Kings to me belongs in the middle. We could do a carols like Joy To The World, or a hymn like Sing a New Song, I just haven’t made up my mind. Oh the decisions! And Father will be like, Stop worrying, it’s just a mass, you’ll sound fine. lol
I believe that the OCP selections should wait until after the Feast of the Baptism of the Lord (which is Sunday, January 9, 2011). The Christmas season in the Catholic Church does not end until that Sunday, and most people believe that it ends on Epiphany Sunday.
We Three Kings I believe is a definate must for Epiphany. It suits the Gospel very well and it seems like every Christian the world over would know this hymn. I too think it fits perfectly at the Preparation of the Gifts. I never thought it as a processional-style hymn.
For the Epiphany, this is what I suggest:
Processional: Hark! The Herald Angels Sing (This works very well because we are still in the Christmas season)
Preparation of the Gifts: We Three Kings (Perfect per the Gospel)
Communion: The First Noel (In verses 3-5, the Star of Bethlehem and the Wise Men are mentioned.)
Recessional: As With Gladness Men of Old (Mentions the gladness the Christ Child brings to those who awaited him, and mentions the Wise Men)
Some others you could do are “What Star Is This”. This hymn basically tells the story of the Wise Men. Another you could do is “What Child Is This”. It describes the Wise Men as well.
For the Baptism of the Lord on Sunday, January 9, 2011, the end of the Christmas season; Christmas carols are still very appropriate.
Suggestions:
Any Christmas carols would be suitable for this Sunday. It would be nice to get in the ones you haven’t been able to get in on Christmas, the Feast of the Holy Family, or Epiphany.
Some hymns about the Baptism of Christ: “When Jesus Comes to Be Baptized”, and “On Jordan’s Bank, the Baptist’s Cry”.
One hymn that is sort of a “must” for this Sunday is “Songs of Thankfulness and Praise”. It sums up the three manifestations of Christ: Christ born in Bethlehem, Christ revealed to the Magi, and Christ revealed at Jordan’s stream at his baptism.
Again, the Christmas season does not end until Sunday, January 9, 2011. Christmas carols are still appropriate and should be used.