Must we believe this?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Annie_B
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
You were disagreeing with Church teaching. I was merely pointing out that you were doing so. No need to be defensive while one is being corrected.

That’s good that you ask for references to dogma.

But once dogma is presented authentically as dogma your disagreement with it needs to stop, your thinking needs to shift into how to change your thinking to accept that dogma.

Matters of Church discipline and theological conjecture are things we can “kick around”, but dogma is not a matter of disagreement, but only acceptance and self-change to suit the dogma.
You know, questioning is not evil and doesn’t equal dissent. She asked a question and wanted an answer so that she could be a better Catholic. Some of YOU have been nothing but R.U.D.E. and owe this poster an apology. What if the tone of your posts not only drove her from this site but from being Catholic??? Hmmmm??? Now, get off of your high horse, offer some helpful answers and BE POLITE. Speak the Truth in Love (Eph 4:15)
 
You know, questioning is not evil and doesn’t equal dissent. She asked a question and wanted an answer so that she could be a better Catholic. Some of YOU have been nothing but R.U.D.E. and owe this poster an apology. What if the tone of your posts not only drove her from this site but from being Catholic??? Hmmmm??? Now, get off of your high horse, offer some helpful answers and BE POLITE. Speak the Truth in Love (Eph 4:15)
:clapping: :clapping: :clapping: :amen: :clapping: :clapping: :clapping:
 
Annie B, I’ll take a wack at this and see if I can help you out. Earler you refered to Mt1:25 “And he knew her not till she brought forth her first born son: and he called his name Jesus.” Many people presume the word untill / till refers to the future. It dosn’t. Till/untill is reffering to what has transpired up to this point. But! Where most people miss understand is that till/untill does not infer the opposite then happens. For example most protestants believe that because here in Mt 1:25 that the*** “till”*** means that they did have marital relations after this point. But here is the problem with this logic IF it were true:
"24 Afterwards the end: when he shall have delivered up the kingdom to God and the Father: when he shall have brought to nought all principality and power and virtue. 25 For he must reign,* until *he hath put all his enemies under his feet. 26 And the enemy, death, shall be destroyed last: For he hath put all things under his feet. And whereas he saith" 1Cor 15:24-26
If **till or untill **did infact mean the opposite happens afterward Jesus will no longer be reigning after he puts all his enemies under his feet.
I’ll comt in my next post…
 
Annie B,

You are very wrong to believe that all the translations of the Bible are equal. You are getting your information from a book that has been translated by a known Anti-Catholic and he can make the words mean whatever he wants them to mean.

And you are fighting to defend your choice. Why is that?

You seem “shocked” at an idea that most Catholics take for granted (despite the debating on this thread). You state on your profile that you are Catholic.

How long have you been a Catholic? Surely you learned in studying to become a Catholic (if you are new to the faith) that Mary is considered to be a perpetual Virgin.

As one poster has said – it is certainly mentioned enough in our prayers.

And to the other posters who are saying that Mary conceived Jesus through the “operation” of the Holy Spirit - the Apostles Creed says conceived by the Holy Spirit and some newer versions say “by the power of the Holy Spirit.”
I never heard the “operation” version before these postings.

🤷 :grouphug:
 
Annie B,

You are very wrong to believe that all the translations of the Bible are equal. You are getting your information from a book that has been translated by a known Anti-Catholic and he can make the words mean whatever he wants them to mean.

And you are fighting to defend your choice. Why is that?

You seem “shocked” at an idea that most Catholics take for granted (despite the debating on this thread). You state on your profile that you are Catholic.

How long have you been a Catholic? Surely you learned in studying to become a Catholic (if you are new to the faith) that Mary is considered to be a perpetual Virgin.

As one poster has said – it is certainly mentioned enough in our prayers.

And to the other posters who are saying that Mary conceived Jesus through the “operation” of the Holy Spirit - the Apostles Creed says conceived by the Holy Spirit and some newer versions say “by the power of the Holy Spirit.”
I never heard the “operation” version before these postings.

🤷 :grouphug:
I NEVER stated that all translations are equal! I said that many are similar and also stated that I was NOT reading ANY footnotes/comments. And yes - I AM Catholic. However, if your definition of Catholic means that questions are not allowed, then I am not that kind of Catholic! And, not that it should matter, but ~technically~ I have been Catholic for over 45 years. If you knew me at all from my posts, you would know that I have recently “come home” to the Catholic church after MANY years and churches away. Apparently I am not as bright as you or I would have known from all the prayers about Mary. Hey - wait a minute - perpetual virginity was not my exact question! I asked if we must belive this as a matter of church doctrine.

Annie
 
OK - this time I really am leaving…at least leaving this thread. I appreciate all those who have sincerely tried to help without judgement.

Annie

PS - ADAM: I do appreciate your explanation - it DID help!
Annie
 
…Also
“23 Therefore Michol the daughter of Saul had no child to the day of her death.” 2Sam 6:23 Instead of “to” there are some translations that use “till / untill” If the opposite happened after “till” Michol started having kids after she died. (I’m not trying to be a smug with you I’m just pointing out the “if this were true” side of this understand of till meaning the opposite happens afterward.)

*“12 Let no man despise thy youth: but be thou an example of the faithful, in word, in conversation, in charity, in faith, in chastity. 13 Till I come, attend unto reading, to exhortation and to doctrine.” *1Tim 4:12-13 If this were true Timothy would never “attend unto reading, to exhortation and to doctrine” after St. Paul arrived

“I charge (you) before God, who gives life to all things, and before Christ Jesus, who gave testimony under Pontius Pilate for the noble confession, to keep the commandment without stain or reproach until the appearance of our Lord Jesus Christ” 1Tim 6:13-14

Also: Psa 72:7 , Psa 94:13, Son 3:4
There are many more
 
Annie B,

You are very wrong to believe that all the translations of the Bible are equal. You are getting your information from a book that has been translated by a known Anti-Catholic and he can make the words mean whatever he wants them to mean.

And you are fighting to defend your choice. Why is that?

You seem “shocked” at an idea that most Catholics take for granted (despite the debating on this thread). You state on your profile that you are Catholic.

How long have you been a Catholic? Surely you learned in studying to become a Catholic (if you are new to the faith) that Mary is considered to be a perpetual Virgin.

As one poster has said – it is certainly mentioned enough in our prayers.

And to the other posters who are saying that Mary conceived Jesus through the “operation” of the Holy Spirit - the Apostles Creed says conceived by the Holy Spirit and some newer versions say “by the power of the Holy Spirit.”
I never heard the “operation” version before these postings.

🤷 :grouphug:
"But with modesty and fear, having a good conscience:" 1pet 3:16
Smooth,… Real smooth.(sarcasm)
:clapping: :clapping: :clapping: :clapping:
 
Anytime anyone questions any doctrine/teaching of the RCC around here, it seems to turn into a heated debate…😦 Too many, it seems, seem to think that an honest question is a serious challenge to the RCC. This is SUPPOSED to be Catholic ANSWERS; some seem to feel that those seeking answers are truly defective Catholics…To those who are disturbed by the question I asked, I ask you this: Would it be better to not ask my question and continue in ignorance along a path that could lead me away from the RCC or is it better to ask the question and be brought to a place of understanding which will keep me on the right path? Also, I should not have needed to explain my background to get an answer…The answer should be the same answer, answered in LOVE, no matter what church I may or may not belong to!

I really appreciate all the supportive responses that I have had here. The non-supportive, I do not appreciate as much:p I think I have more than enough information to chew on for a while…

Annie
**I have to agree with Annie here.

The fact that she had the faith and good sense to come here to get her info speaks far greater volumes than what Bible translation she was using, especially since virtually every translation that I am aware of uses the word “until” or some similar form of it.

Please give anyone** who posts a question here the benefit of the doubt until such time as they prove themselves unworthy of it, and even then respond in charity and respect **.

Charity**

Guidelines for Posting in the Apologetics Forum

Respect for the Reputation of Persons

Thank you all for your operation
Sincerely,
 
To the OP:

It most certainly is NOT a crime to ask questions. Forgive us at CAF if we made you feel unwelcome. I fear that sometimes we suspect the worst in a poster, assuming there is an ulterior motive, rather than assuming that the question is an eagerness to get to the truth.

Here is the truth as I understand it and I would really recommend you access the Catechism for to verify my info and to find more info on the subject. Yes, as Catholics we are to believe in all the proclaimed dogma’s of the Church. In doing so, we are accepting the authority of the Church to lead us in doctrinal matters. I should say that blind belief isn’t really expected. You SHOULD ask questions on things you don’t understand. In fact (this is my opinion) you would be remiss if you did not ask questions. However, we have to be obedient to the teaching and accept it as truth, even if we don’t understand every detail. When I don’t quite understand every detail of a church teaching, I assume that the fault lies with my understanding, because I know that the Church has been given the Spirit to guide in truth, has been given the authority of binding and loosing and has been given the authority over the sheep and lambs of the Lord.

Some other tidbits that might be helpful. The Church has never been ‘based on the Bible’ per se. The Magesterial teaching of the Church is based both on Scripture and on Tradition. However, you can see elements pertaining to the perpetual virginity of Mary if you understand typology in Scripture.

Read up on the Ark of the Covenent and you will see many links with Mary and can then understand Mary as the Ark of the New Covenent. In the Old Testament, you will see that the Ark carried the written word of God, some manna (bread from heaven) and the rod of Aaron (who represented the priesthood). Mary carried in her womb the Word of God, the true Bread from heaven, and the High Priest, Prophet and King, Jesus Christ. The Ark was made of the purest gold at God’s command. Mary is pure by the Immaculate Conception. ONLY the high priest was able to touch the Ark, if anyone else touched the Ark they would die. Does this necessarily “prove” that Joseph never touched Mary (in a sexual way). No, there is no proof given. Only a support to the notion that that the holy Ark of the (New) Covenant was not to be defiled.

Regarding the brothers listed in Scripture, there is no evidence to support that they were children of Mary. The word “brothers” was very loosely used back then. For example, when Jesus told Mary Magdalene to go tell His brothers He had risen, where did she go? To the disciples. Abraham and Lot are called brothers in Gen 14:14 (in many Bible versions) but it is clear from scripture that Lot was his nephew.

Hope that helps!
 
I have to agree with Annie here.

The fact that she had the faith and good sense to come here to get her info speaks far greater volumes than what Bible translation she was using, especially since virtually every translation that I am aware of uses the word “until” or some similar form of it.

Please give anyone
who posts a question here the benefit of the doubt until such time as they prove themselves unworthy of it, and even then respond in charity and respect .

Charity

Guidelines for Posting in the Apologetics Forum

Respect for the Reputation of Persons

Thank you all for your operation
Sincerely,
:amen: :blessyou:
 
You know, questioning is not evil and doesn’t equal dissent. She asked a question and wanted an answer so that she could be a better Catholic. Some of YOU have been nothing but R.U.D.E. and owe this poster an apology. What if the tone of your posts not only drove her from this site but from being Catholic??? Hmmmm??? Now, get off of your high horse, offer some helpful answers and BE POLITE. Speak the Truth in Love (Eph 4:15)
I’d really LOVE for anyone to show me where I was rude.

Can you do that for me?
 
I’d really LOVE for anyone to show me where I was rude.

Can you do that for me?
cats&dogs you arent rude, you and I just sometimes get so excited about our faith sometimes we need to be more gentle with people is all. You are very smart and dedicated in the faith, but sometimes we just have to find different ways to express ourself is all. But I kniw your heart is in it.
 
I’d really LOVE for anyone to show me where I was rude.

Can you do that for me?
You’re whole tone to the OP has been condescending (“stop questioning, just assent”). It’s not sinful to question and try to understand Church teachings. Yes, ultimately, to remain fully Catholic you must assent your will to the Church’s, however, there is no harm in someone, esp someone searching, asking questions and handling those questions with love and charity instead of charging in with guns a blazing. This was a simple question that was turned into a heated debate for no reason…people assumed she was being argumentative for the fun of it and it’s ALWAYS dangerous to assume…
Preach the Gospel always, and when neccessary, use words (St Francis)
 
The only thing I’m considering is that there appear to be only two ways by which women become pregnant:
  1. The biological way.
  2. The non-biological operation of the Holy Spirit.
Exactly. And since it is not biological and does not involve sexual relations, there is nothing unchaste about Mary then going on and having sexual relations with her lawful husband Joseph. There is absolutely no unfaithfulness to the Holy Spirit involved, and to suggest that there is is both heretical and blasphemous.
Once again, I’m terribly sorry that you misinterpreted what I said.
You are saying that the non-biological operation of the Holy Spirit constitutes “relations” with Mary, in such a manner that if she then had relations with her lawful husband Joseph she would be behaving unchastely. Now either defend this position or retract it. You have proven totally unable to defend it, and have retreated behind “have a nice day.” Feel free to say it again, but know that if you do you are admitting that you can’t actually defend your heretical and irrational position.

Edwin
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by CatsAndDogs View Post
I’d really LOVE for anyone to show me where I was rude.

Can you do that for me?

You’re whole tone to the OP has been condescending (“stop questioning, just assent”).
I never say don’t ASK QUESTIONS. I always say that if a matter is finally discovered to be a dogmatic truth, that that truth MUST be assented to.

The “conflict” occurs when something is made quite clear that it is a dogma, and yet the “questioner” refuses to accept it as what it is.

I’m not here to convince anyone of anything, as I’m amazingly bad at doing that. I’m simply here to point to those dogmas we’re bound to assent to, and occasionally giving my opinion on some theological (derivation FROM some dogmatic truth) idea while being explicit in telling others that that is ONLY my opinion.
It’s not sinful to question and try to understand Church teachings. Yes, ultimately, to remain fully Catholic you must assent your will to the Church’s, however, there is no harm in someone, esp someone searching, asking questions and handling those questions with love and charity instead of charging in with guns a blazing.
Once again, show me where my “guns were blazing”? 🙂
This was a simple question that was turned into a heated debate for no reason…people assumed she was being argumentative for the fun of it and it’s ALWAYS dangerous to assume…
Preach the Gospel always, and when neccessary, use words (St Francis)
The “heat” came from WHERE again?

May I suggest the sequence:
  • *) A question was asked about a possible dogma (“must we believe this”).
  • *) The question was answered that it needed to be believed because it is a dogma.
  • *) The consequences of that dogma brought up a few other questions.
  • *) The answers to those questions prompted this statement from the OP:“As much as some Catholics here would like to believe, not all Catholics accept blindly the Church’s interpretation of scripture. We use it as a guideline and then use the brain that God gave us to form our opinion.”
  • *) Then it became necessary to inform the OP what “dogma” means: “A thing to be accepted without dissent.”
  • *) Which the OP overreacted to as if it were a personal affront, which precipitated the “heatedness” of the discussion.
The “heat” came from the OP, and all attempts (short of incorrectly placing the origin of the “heat” to those not responsible for it) to cool down the OP were spurned by the OP.

If Catholics making simple statements of dogma creates “heated overreaction” in the OP, then perhaps the OP is in need of being a bit more charitable?
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by CatsAndDogs View Post

The only thing I’m considering is that there appear to be only two ways by which women become pregnant:
  1. The biological way.
  2. The non-biological operation of the Holy Spirit.
Exactly. And since it is not biological and does not involve sexual relations, there is nothing unchaste about Mary then going on and having sexual relations with her lawful husband Joseph.
I happen to think that having a child by one person (don’t you love the mystery of the Holy Trinity!?) and then having “physical relations” with the possibility of having children with another person (or persons) is an unchaste situation.

But, you’re welcome to your opinion, of course! 🙂
There is absolutely no unfaithfulness to the Holy Spirit involved, and to suggest that there is is both heretical and blasphemous.
So, to have two children from two living fathers is (or could be) the result of chaste behavior?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top