My first confession since leaving catholicism

  • Thread starter Thread starter uglygal
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Its exactly as I told you. The confession was empty, I walked to the confessional and as I got there he came out. I asked him if I could have confession and he abruptly said, no confession is over, and walked past me. Though according to the bulletin it was still confession hour and it was not in the last minutes. But according to him I was late and therefore no confession. My impression was that he had been at the confession, no one came for a while and he decided to leave but as he did I came along and he told me no confession because he had decided to leave.
 
I’m not going to go back to that priest or parish … I think I will try another one that neighbors ours - it apparently has a very good, humble and young priest.
 
I’m not going to go back to that priest or parish … I think I will try another one that neighbors ours - it apparently has a very good, humble and young priest.
God bless you for continuing to try. At this point, many others would just give up in a huff. I found that the youngest, least experienced priest in my parish was the very best in confession. I hope you find the same thing. Often the young ones are relying more on the Holy Spirit than their own experience and wisdom.

Betsy
 
Dear OP,

I went to Confession today before the Saturday Vigil Mass and had one of the best experiences I had in Confession. I hope your next Confession will be similar. Many parishes are having evening Reconciliation Services this Advent. You might try attending one of those. Sometimes, making an appointment is best if you might like some extra time though.

I also recommend getting there early, before the Confession time is ready to start. That way you have plenty of time and won`t feel rushed. I know this is not always possible though.

God is our priority so please keep trying until you find the right priest to best meet your needs. I will keep you in my prayers.

Sincerely,

Maria1212
 
God bless you for continuing to try. At this point, many others would just give up in a huff. I found that the youngest, least experienced priest in my parish was the very best in confession. I hope you find the same thing. Often the young ones are relying more on the Holy Spirit than their own experience and wisdom.

Betsy
I went to confession with one priest right after he was ordained - it was a frustrating experience. I left feeling that he didn’t have a clue. I was bad about going to the same priest all the time after that then decided that whoever is available was who God wanted me to go to. When I later went to the same priest, I felt more comfortable and felt he had more of a clue. :cool:
 
I went to confession with one priest right after he was ordained - it was a frustrating experience. I left feeling that he didn’t have a clue. I was bad about going to the same priest all the time after that then decided that whoever is available was who God wanted me to go to. When I later went to the same priest, I felt more comfortable and felt he had more of a clue. :cool:
just a reminder to those who don’t know or sometimes forget, that confession during the ordinary hours when other people are waiting, should be straight forward - confession, absolution, done, and out. the Sacrament has been completed - you are forgiven. there’s no need to chit-chat or talk about your problems.

as for advice, guidance, spiritual direction, consoling, etc., that should be done either outside of confession, at a confession appointment, during spiritual direction, etc.

we shouldn’t base the quality of confession on how we feel afterwards, or whether or not the priest was of any help. it is a done deal promised by God, that once you are absolved, you are forgiven. feelings, although great at times, are not what it’s about. it’s supposed to be about you and forgiveness from God. advice is extra. otherwise people would stop doing it once they stop feeling good or when the priest doesn’t give good advice.

imagine being in the most difficult time of your life, at the lowest, your world is crumbling, and you are dying for just a simple kind word, but the priest goes through confession like a robot and doesn’t add anything else. you feel hurt, but how was he supposed to know? he only knows that he is there to provide the Sacrament for you, and he has. you can now seek guidance and consoling from either him or somewhere else after you have finished confession.

(sorry to single your post out, i’m not implying you do this).
 
What Johnnydigit said is true, but I would like to say that I have had some very accomidating and helpful Priest’s visit me in hospitals for confession and the Eucharist, see me minutes before Mass to reconcile me with the Lord, give advice and counseling to a despairing and confused soul, showing the love and mercy of the Lord to me as one of His own. They have done me alot of good and I’m a tough case with the experience’s I have had along with having ptsd among other problems. I have nothing but good things to say about our Priest’s. Tim
 
as for advice, guidance, spiritual direction, consoling, etc., that should be done either outside of confession, at a confession appointment, during spiritual direction, etc.
There are, however, some priests who go ahead and do these things in confession without being asked. Mine, for one. I tell my sins straight out, without asking any questions or adding any commentary, and he talks with me about each one, giving advice and encouragement. I’m quite sure he does this for everyone, by the way the line moves. And his is always the longest line. Unless he is celebrating the Saturday evening Mass, he stays until everyone in his line is taken care of, sometimes through the Gospel.

Betsy
 
There are, however, some priests who go ahead and do these things in confession without being asked. Mine, for one. I tell my sins straight out, without asking any questions or adding any commentary, and he talks with me about each one, giving advice and encouragement.
 
There are, however, some priests who go ahead and do these things in confession without being asked. Mine, for one. I tell my sins straight out, without asking any questions or adding any commentary, and he talks with me about each one, giving advice and encouragement. I’m quite sure he does this for everyone, by the way the line moves. And his is always the longest line. Unless he is celebrating the Saturday evening Mass, he stays until everyone in his line is taken care of, sometimes through the Gospel.

Betsy
yep. unfortunately, some people take it for granted and criticize those priests who don’t. they then associate the confessional with guidance and expect to get it, often when the line is long and many people don’t even get the chance to receive the Sacrament. when priests do tell people to just go in and out, the people get offended and so many priests are too intimidated to educate the people. pray for us…

btw, the best confessions i’ve had were at monasteries or with priests from religious orders. they get really deep and often are not on a time constraint. we then have a wonderful meal, go for a walk, go to Mass, or i go snowboarding nearby. if only people would take advantage of the precious gifts our Church has…
 
yep. unfortunately, some people take it for granted and criticize those priests who don’t.
After a while, one gets to know which priests are chatty and which are not. Then, you choose. Until recently, at our parish, we had Fr. R, who never said anything beyond your penance and absolution, and Fr. B, who counsels everyone. If you didn’t want to talk, you went to Fr. R. If you did, it was Fr. B for you.

I don’t think it’s wrong to give some counsel in a regular Saturday afternoon Confession session. After all, most people don’t go on retreats or to monasteries where they can have those long, deep Confessions. And most of them won’t call up the rectory to make an appointment for counseling, either. So that leaves their regular Confessions as opportunities for spiritual care. A lot of care can be given in 2, 3 or even 5 minutes. If the need is beyond that, the priest can invite the penitent to come back at another time so the line isn’t held up for 10 or 15 minutes or more for a long discussion.

Practically speaking, most people today do not have a very good foundation in their faith, and are particularly confused with regard to morals. Just look at the kinds of questions that come up here on CAF. Regardless of the fact that people should have better formation, many don’t, and they shouldn’t be left to their own devices when it comes to confessing their sins. WWJD?

Betsy
 
I’m not going to go back to that priest or parish … I think I will try another one that neighbors ours - it apparently has a very good, humble and young priest.
I just have a couple questions.

If you are not Christian why are you trying to go to confession? I am confused.

Why do you so very easily put up a wall? So much anger and defense. Why wouldn’t you go back and try to talk to him first? If you are turning Christian that is the Christian thing to do.
Love and forgive. Hopefully there was a big misunderstanding.
 
I am sorry to hear that you had a bad experience at confession. Please do not let this cause you not to go to confession anymore. I will say a prayer for you.
 
I just have a couple questions.

If you are not Christian why are you trying to go to confession? I am confused.

Why do you so very easily put up a wall? So much anger and defense. Why wouldn’t you go back and try to talk to him first? If you are turning Christian that is the Christian thing to do.
Love and forgive. Hopefully there was a big misunderstanding.
I imagine the OP was once Catholic, left the Church and began to call herself a non-christian, and now wishes to return to the Church.

In her possibly fragile condition, another encounter with a priest who may really be a(n) [insert unflattering term here] may not be what she needs right now. Perhaps she is wise to seek out someone who will be more open to her. Loving and forgiving may well come later for her.

Betsy
 
Gal,

You have my prayers. I think that you should do three things. First, find a legitimate Catholic (or at least Christian) counciler to work though your past. The abuse is not your fault. You should not beat yourself up. Second, find a good spiritual director and confessor. These people should be understanding and helpful. Third, know that many people on here only want the best for you and your soul. We want you healed and whole so that you can be the best Gal you can. I have prayed for you since the first time I commented on your question about hell. If you have a true love of God, you need to develop a good love for yourself and others based upon it.

God bless you, Gal.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top