My prayer life is so robotic

  • Thread starter Thread starter Student26
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

Student26

Guest
I have been saying a novena to the Sacred Heart and part of it involves regular recitation of the Our Father, the Hail Mary, and the Glory Be.

My problem is that the words have become so robotic. We Catholics are so used to saying these prayers that I feel I could be praying to the Spaghetti Monster (slight exaggeration).

The point though is surely this is wrong. We Catholics constantly recites prayers (rosary, novena, confession etc.) and I’m wondering whether they mean anything. I sometimes feel so resentful at having to say these prayers because I feel no emotion whatsoever when saying them.

I know that it’s important to pray the prayers of the Church and it is not dependent upon my own subjective emotional response…but we do share a personal relationship with God and I wonder: what must He think when He hears me repeating these prayers, resentful in my heart because they mean nothing to me.

Does Catholic culture devalue the significance of prayer by prescribing it so militantly?

Please help me!
 
Unless you are compelled by vows, you are under no obligation to privately pray in any particular manner. The Catholic Church recognizes many valid approaches to prayer besides novenas.

Maybe you should consider other forms of prayer.
 
Unless you are compelled by vows, you are under no obligation to privately pray in any particular manner. The Catholic Church recognizes many valid approaches to prayer besides novenas.

Maybe you should consider other forms of prayer.
This.

Rosaries, chaplets, et c. are private devotions and are not prescribed by the Church. It falls to the individual to pray them in a meaningful way. Do you have a spiritual director who can help you guide your prayer life? A talk with your priest may help.
 
St. Teresa of Avila, Doctor of the Church on prayer, wrote a lot about the Our Father prayer.

She says that when we think of the words as we say them, that vocal prayer can be instrumental in bringing us to the heights of prayer. The difference is not just saying the words in an offhand way, but in focusing on the words and the presence of God as you say them.
 
I have been saying a novena to the Sacred Heart and part of it involves regular recitation of the Our Father, the Hail Mary, and the Glory Be.

My problem is that the words have become so robotic. We Catholics are so used to saying these prayers that I feel I could be praying to the Spaghetti Monster (slight exaggeration).

The point though is surely this is wrong. We Catholics constantly recites prayers (rosary, novena, confession etc.) and I’m wondering whether they mean anything. I sometimes feel so resentful at having to say these prayers because I feel no emotion whatsoever when saying them.

I know that it’s important to pray the prayers of the Church and it is not dependent upon my own subjective emotional response…but we do share a personal relationship with God and I wonder: what must He think when He hears me repeating these prayers, resentful in my heart because they mean nothing to me.

Does Catholic culture devalue the significance of prayer by prescribing it so militantly?

Please help me!
The Rosary is a very powerful prayer. One should not look for “feelings” when praying. It may be dry, and cold, that does not mean it’s “fruitless” or not powerful. Prayer is all about faith.
Saying the Rosary is supposed to be a meditation on the Life of Christ. It’s not easy, but I would suggest not giving up on it, it takes practice. If only we knew the merit of saying this prayer we would never stop.
 
There are different type of prayer such as vocal - the Rosary etc and contemplative such as meditating on God presence and conversing casually but obviously respectfully.
Read a book on contemplative prayer , I’m not sure maybe St Teresa of Avilas way of perfection and Interior Castle. Or just google contemplative prayer
 
Have you tried prayer before our Lord in the Blessed Sacrament? Being in the True Presence of Christ can make all the difference in the world. Absolutely amazing things have happened through prayer before Him without words. As well, we are encouraged to pray in the spirit, which can take things to a new level.

It is a constant challenge, though.
 
Try incorporating some contemplation into your prayers. If you have a devotion to the Sacred Heart, then by all means, keep praying those prayers, but change it up a bit by contemplating a different facet of Christ’s love for us with each “Our Father” or “Hail Mary”. If you pray the Rosary, then you are probably familiar with the 20 mysteries of Christ’s life that are to be contemplated as you pray the prayers. The prayers allow you to enter into a deeper contemplation than you might be able to accomplish in silence because they keep your mind from wandering. Apply this same principle to your Sacred Heart Novena and by all means use as many or all of those mysteries to contemplate while you pray.

I love the Sacred Heart devotion, but there are many prayers that go with it. Try finding some new ones online to add to your prayer life. Here is a link with some beautiful prayers devoted to the Sacred Heart.

In addition to the Rosary, I like to pray the Divine Mercy Chaplet and contemplate the Passion of our Lord while I pray the prayers. Another prayer exercise I will do is to pray the psalms. Read the psalm and really meditate on it and how it could be applied to you. I actually pray with Scriptures a lot. Many saints have written excellent books on prayer (St. Teresa of Avila, already mentioned, is the Doctor of Prayer) so you could read up on what they have to say about their prayer life.

However, all this being said, I feel the most important prayer of all, aside from the prayer of the Mass, is one where you don’t speak at all. Just be still and know that He is God. Come into His presence (especially in front of the Blessed Sacrament, but you can do this at home) and just LISTEN to what God might be saying to you. Rote prayers or intercessory prayers have their place, but the problem is that we can spend an hour talking to God and never taking any time to listen. All the organized prayers and chaplets should be leading you into a closer relationship with God; if you are feeling robotic, it is definitely time to change it up. Try some silent time with God, although if you haven’t done it before you’ll likely find that it takes practice. When I first started, I could barely go 5 seconds before my mind began to wander. But practice is key and of course, asking the Holy Spirit to help you pray as you ought is also key (see Romans 8:26)

I’ll bet you get some excellent suggestions here. There is such diversity in Catholic prayer, so many devotions and forms of spirituality. I tend to lean toward Carmelite spirituality, but you might find Benedictine or Ignatian are better for you. Benedictines, from what I understand, spend a lot of their prayer time praying the Divine Office – not so much the Rosary and other chaplets. Read up on the different Catholic orders and see if one appeals to you. I’m not suggesting you become a religious, I’m only saying that you might find a practice or spirituality that really moves you and you can pattern you prayer life accordingly.
 
Thank-you dear friends for these kind and helpful suggestions.

My Parish Priest recently mentioned this quote in a homily:

“Whereof one cannot speak, one must remain silent.”

I think it accurately describes the state of prayer for many of us. That sometimes words fail and we can only but interiorly adore God the Father Almighty and the beauty of Creation.
 
Have you tried prayer before our Lord in the Blessed Sacrament? Being in the True Presence of Christ can make all the difference in the world. Absolutely amazing things have happened through prayer before Him without words. As well, we are encouraged to pray in the spirit, which can take things to a new level.

It is a constant challenge, though.
Oh, yes. Great things have happened for me in my prayer life by doing this. Sometimes I just try to follow the example of St Catherine Laboure:

"Whenever I go to the chapel, I put myself in the presence of our good Lord, and I say to him, Lord I am here. Tell me what you would have me to do. If he gives me some task, I am content and I thank him. If he gives me nothing, I still thank him since I do not deserve to receive anything more than that. And then, I tell God everything that is in my heart. I tell him about my pains and joys, and then I listen. If you listen, God will also speak to you, for with the good Lord, you have to both speak and listen. God always speaks to you when you approach him plainly and simply. "
 
Hi Student26,
Yes, I know what you mean, it can get dry and repetitive. Or at least it can SEEM that way to us. But consider what God is hearing on His end. That you are making your attempt to talk to Him, in your own limited way. He knows where we are at and what we need, before we ask. He knows our limitations. That’s ok with Him.

When i pray these days, especially when i am tired, i ask God to accept my poor attempt at prayer, and to strengthen my faith thru His grace. I come to Him as a child, which is all any of us can hope to be before Him.

As a convert, the last thing i accepted was the reality of Our Lady’s role in my faith life. But a while back that reality came clear in a very abrupt and indeniable way. Since then She has been a wonderful aid to me in my faith and prayer life. Cannot say more here but will send you a PM.
 
So, it is not just the vocal, it is the spirtual meditations that center on God. Just focus on God, he will do the rest.
 
Yeah, I face the same issue quite often. My wife and I pray a daily Family Rosary and Divine Mercy Chaplet, along with a variety of other prayers, and it’s been difficult to keep focused over the past year. But we do it anyway. It’s devotion, and I trust that God will grant us His graces even if we don’t always perceive the benefits of prayer right away. Our ultimate goal is to please Him and one day get to heaven, and prayer, even that which seems robotic, is an important part of that journey.

“Pray without ceasing.” (1 Thessalonians 5:17)
 
Different forms of prayer are helpful at different times. As your mental and physical states change, so will your spiritual expression. You may try asking God for guidance in your prayer life and see where He leads you. So often, we have our own ideas of how we should pray and in doing so, we lock ourselves into a corner with nowhere to go. Believe that it is in your own best interest and His delight that you should progress in prayer. Anything else would be to deny all that your faith is built upon. If it is in your best interest and His delight, then why would He fail to answer that prayer?

And then follow Him wherever He leads you.
 
I have been saying a novena to the Sacred Heart and part of it involves regular recitation of the Our Father, the Hail Mary, and the Glory Be.

My problem is that the words have become so robotic. We Catholics are so used to saying these prayers that I feel I could be praying to the Spaghetti Monster (slight exaggeration).

The point though is surely this is wrong. We Catholics constantly recites prayers (rosary, novena, confession etc.) and I’m wondering whether they mean anything. I sometimes feel so resentful at having to say these prayers because I feel no emotion whatsoever when saying them.

I know that it’s important to pray the prayers of the Church and it is not dependent upon my own subjective emotional response…but we do share a personal relationship with God and I wonder: what must He think when He hears me repeating these prayers, resentful in my heart because they mean nothing to me.

Does Catholic culture devalue the significance of prayer by prescribing it so militantly?

Please help me!
Should we look for the consolations of God or the God of consolations?

Sometimes, maybe a lot of the time, God allows us dryness in prayer.
That is the time to step up and work at it and make it work.
That means if you have to force your concentration then do it.
Show Jesus you mean it when you say that you love him.

Purpose in prayer is important.

How about praying for someone close to you.

Mary suggested several times when appearing to people that they pray for two reasons:
those going to hell because they will unless someone prays for them,and
those in purgatory, which is an act of great mercy on your part.
Then offer your boredom in prayer for them. The intent ,not success, is what Jesus looks at.

Here is something from the diary of St. Faustina P342.
"Jesus gave me to understand how a soul should be faithful to prayer dispite torments,dryness, temptations, because oftentimes the realization of God’s great plans depend mainly on such prayer. If we do not persevere in such prayer, we frustrate what the Lord wanted to do thru us or within us. Let every soul remember these words: “And being in anguish, He prayed longer.”

Just a thought or two.
 
Oh, yes. Great things have happened for me in my prayer life by doing this. Sometimes I just try to follow the example of St Catherine Laboure:

"Whenever I go to the chapel, I put myself in the presence of our good Lord, and I say to him, Lord I am here. Tell me what you would have me to do. If he gives me some task, I am content and I thank him. If he gives me nothing, I still thank him since I do not deserve to receive anything more than that. And then, I tell God everything that is in my heart. I tell him about my pains and joys, and then I listen. If you listen, God will also speak to you, for with the good Lord, you have to both speak and listen. God always speaks to you when you approach him plainly and simply. "
Before I enter the chapel, I remind myself that I am coming into the presence of Greatness.
 
Vocal prayer is only one type of prayer. It can be useful in bringing one into meditative prayer and it should be used often for that purpose but try something else. I would suggest to stop the type of prayer you are used to doing, get Imitation of Christ or other similar books with meditations and pray along with that. Read Scripture, the Catechism, etc. Find some spiritual reading that you actually want to read. One of my favorite saints is Therese of Lisieux and I find myself reading Story of a Soul when I am having trouble in my spiritual life. Most importantly trust in the Lord and do everything with love. God bless
 
I have been saying a novena to the Sacred Heart and part of it involves regular recitation of the Our Father, the Hail Mary, and the Glory Be.

My problem is that the words have become so robotic. We Catholics are so used to saying these prayers that I feel I could be praying to the Spaghetti Monster (slight exaggeration).

The point though is surely this is wrong. We Catholics constantly recites prayers (rosary, novena, confession etc.) and I’m wondering whether they mean anything. I sometimes feel so resentful at having to say these prayers because I feel no emotion whatsoever when saying them.

I know that it’s important to pray the prayers of the Church and it is not dependent upon my own subjective emotional response…but we do share a personal relationship with God and I wonder: what must He think when He hears me repeating these prayers, resentful in my heart because they mean nothing to me.

Does Catholic culture devalue the significance of prayer by prescribing it so militantly?

Please help me!
St. Theresa mentions in her memoirs that she too had this problem or feeling of a problem.

It’s not “robotic”…it’s religious. Religion is the discipline to battle through and get passed the aridity and the temptation to stop our religious discipline in favor of more “nouveau” forms of prayer.

Militant is harsh but accurate. We are the church militant-praying for the church suffering so that, we all can make it to the church triumphant.

Try reading " Seeds of Contemplation" by Thomas Merton. I truly believe it will open up a new window in your life of prayer and your life of the spirit.
 
I have been saying a novena to the Sacred Heart and part of it involves regular recitation of the Our Father, the Hail Mary, and the Glory Be.

My problem is that the words have become so robotic. We Catholics are so used to saying these prayers that I feel I could be praying to the Spaghetti Monster (slight exaggeration).

The point though is surely this is wrong. We Catholics constantly recites prayers (rosary, novena, confession etc.) and I’m wondering whether they mean anything. I sometimes feel so resentful at having to say these prayers because I feel no emotion whatsoever when saying them.

I know that it’s important to pray the prayers of the Church and it is not dependent upon my own subjective emotional response…but we do share a personal relationship with God and I wonder: what must He think when He hears me repeating these prayers, resentful in my heart because they mean nothing to me.

Does Catholic culture devalue the significance of prayer by prescribing it so militantly?

Please help me!
At this point, you need to start learning to pray, contemplatively instead of by rote.

When you pray, pray to God who dwells within you, and go to the center of your being to pray in silence, as this is where you will be in his presence.

Jim
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top