NBC: US sends more Predator drones to Libya

  • Thread starter Thread starter gilliam
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Any hope of a more democratic Arab world requires American involvement and leadership. The neo-con or neo-liberal vision of such a Middle East was rejected by Obama as he tried to make peace with the dictators first in Iran and then in his Cairo speech and then in his dealing with Syria.
Spasmodically and sporadically, he does seem to be coming around that it is in everybodies interests that American authority is seen to be taking effective action against despots such as Kaddaffi. Once the decision was made, half-measures and a timid response is unseemly.

Just do it.

And once it is done, warn that a Brotherhood theocracy will be no more tolerated than the last despot was. Communist, fascist, military or Islamist, a despot is a despot. This is not what America is fighting for.
 
BBC News - Libya conflict: Beginning of the end? - t.co/NIPBjXK

I don’t see the US having much of a role in a post Gaddafi Libya.
 
Any hope of a more democratic Arab world requires American involvement and leadership.
Any hope of a more democratic Arab world requires them to come into the 21st century, as opposed to staying stuck in the 7th as they are now.

You cannot build a modern democracy in these autocratic tribal-based Third World backwaters ruled by tyrannical dictators. It simply will not work. The leaders and people themselves have to move past the mindset of the Berber Maghreb before that can happen.
Just do it.
Every time we’ve tried it, we’ve always ended up with everybody on the planet screaming at us about being bullies, world policemen, warmongers, etc., etc., etc. ad infinitum et absurdum et nauseam. The world needs to make up its mind.
And once it is done, warn that a Brotherhood theocracy will be no more tolerated than the last despot was. Communist, fascist, military or Islamist, a despot is a despot. This is not what America is fighting for.
That’s swell. But in case you haven’t noticed, Uncle Sugar is bankrupt. We can’t afford the wars we’re tangled up in now, let alone getting involved in new ones. Is Canada prepared to finance these wars that the United States is expected to wage?
 
I remember when NATO agreed into intervene in the Libyan Conflict, I was so happy. Wasn’t this, after all, why organizations like the UN (NATO has no real business in Libya, but any port in a storm I guess. It isn’t as if China or Russia would let the UN intervene) exists: to stop bad men in power from doing bad things. How could the people of the Middle East do anything but applaud such a decision? When the Middle East took its great leap forward I thought there might be renewed ties, and dare I say it, some sense of friendship?

Well, it’s been a few months now and my sense of optimism is gone. Egypt has shown us the kind of future Christians in the area can expect. The new democracies of the Middle East aren’t proving to be much more functional than the old dictatorships. The National Transitional Council can do anything but complain that NATO isn’t doing enough. As if every single one of them wouldn’t be in exile or dead if the West hadn’t stepped. As for the actual people of the Middle East? It depends who you ask, but most people I’ve seen seem decry the NATO action. I guess most people who rather their countryman or fellow Arabs/Africans shot in the street ala Syria rather then face (I don’t know how many times I’ve heard this one) a Jewish plot.

Did the West do the right thing? Personally I don’t doubt that they did. Did the West do the practical thing especially given the state of worldwide finances and the very modest return many will see on their investment? Absolutely not.
 
Well I am sure glad our murdering Libyans is in defense of human rights and our homicidal activities are not picking sides only enforcing a no fly zone. Me thinks BP is behind all this and UK, US are out to repay BP execs for campaign contributions and the $20 Billion exhorted after the Deep Sea Horizon spill. Does anyone know where that money went? :mad:
 
I should also add I am glad this is not a war and is going to be over in a matter of weeks back in March or April…when did it start?
 
I should also add I am glad this is not a war and is going to be over in a matter of weeks back in March or April…when did it start?
Good heavens, don’t listen to anything Obama says…I doubt that the man himself believes half of the stuff that comes out of his own mouth. He simply blathers out whatever sounds good at the time if he figures it will help him get his own way.
 
Good heavens, don’t listen to anything Obama says
Why of course we have to believe the won, he won and is the first African American president ever. That mean we can in the words of Dr. King Jr. judge him on the content of his……………eh………er……well…… I don’t know but he isn’t going to be taken no one off the government plantation like Herman Cain said he wanted to.

He was in congress 2 years and voted against Bush running up the national debt and voted present a lot. Well the debt got bigger under him but it wasn’t his fault, besides his golf handicap is coming down along with the country’s credit rating but it was the Tea Party fault and Bush wrecked the economy and he is just fixing it the best he can. He has a secret plan he will let us know about real soon.

Bush started evil wars in Iran and the good war in Afghanistan and well there still going on but he is going to have the troops home in time to vote for him in next year. (And don’t talk about his bombing in Yemen and Pakistan he is fighting the war on terror). But he killed Osama Bin Laden.

So you’ll see……this is a non-lethal for Americans war that is not a war but enforcing a no fly zone murdering Libyans committing homicide to protect people from being killed.
That makes us the good guys. Because BO said so.
 
I remember when NATO agreed into intervene in the Libyan Conflict, I was so happy. Wasn’t this, after all, why organizations like the UN (NATO has no real business in Libya, but any port in a storm I guess. It isn’t as if China or Russia would let the UN intervene) exists: to stop bad men in power from doing bad things. How could the people of the Middle East do anything but applaud such a decision? . . .
The legal basis for NATO’s use of force against the Libyan military is a United Nations Security Council Resolution - without it NATO lacks legal authority for Operation Unified Protector.

You’re mostly right about why the UN exists, you’re mostly wrong to say they don’t do their job. The world is a far better place because of the United Nations.

Pax,
OA
 
And if the rebels win, what then?

I am afraid we have enabled Isamists in Egypt and now are doing the same thing in Lybia.
 
The legal basis for NATO’s use of force against the Libyan military is a United Nations Security Council Resolution - without it NATO lacks legal authority for Operation Unified Protector.

You’re mostly right about why the UN exists, you’re mostly wrong to say they don’t do their job. The world is a far better place because of the United Nations.

Pax,
OA
The US military is subject to the command of the US Congress, not the UN.
 
The US military is subject to the command of the US Congress, not the UN.
You must have misunderstood my post.

I said that the legal basis for hostilities was under UNSCR 1973, which refers to the basis under international law for a nation to resort to a use of forces, the jus ad bellum. And that basis in international law is one of the two exceptions (Articles 42, and 51) to the UN Charter Article 2(4) requirement that nations (or regional arrangements or agencies) not use force against each other.
All members shall refrain in their international relations from the threat or use of force against the territorial integrity or political independence of any state, or in any other manner inconsistent with the Purposes of the United Nations.
The legal basis for hostilities is first and foremost a matter of international law. A national government’s authorization to employ its military forces is a policy decision that’s governed by domestic law.

Pax,
OA
 
The new democracies of the Middle East aren’t proving to be much more functional than the old dictatorships.
I’m not aware of any new democracies in the Middle East. There are several countries that have been changing their laws, rewriting constitutions, or scheduling elections, and hopefully some of them will become democracies.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top