F
felmus
Guest
There is a married woman (no religion) married to a non-practicing Catholic; they have been married for 5 years.
He changed immediately after the wedding (he was trying to be a different man before, then he “relaxed”; he “relaxed” even more when she got pregnant.). He has a drinking problem (though he thinks he doesn’t); there is little or no attraction between them (they barely talk); he goes to his separate room at night to watch TV and drink; she does the chores and housework and works to make most of the money. In the past the drinking was out of control, her life was miserable and things almost turned physical, but this past year it has been “under control”. He is not a very good father, and puts little or no effort into the marriage; she tries to talk to him and he says he is “too tired” or doesn’t want to “be bothered”; he routinely threatens (in a half-joking way) to divorce her if she asks him to do something to help around the house.
She has fallen in love with another man: a Catholic, who says he would marry her if she got divorced (and a declaration of nullity), but until that happens, they can only be friends. The problem is that she has an (almost) 3 year old daughter. She asked for my advice: stick it out in a bad situation so that the child is not traumatized by divorce, or get out before other children are involved and go to the Catholic man who loves her?
I thought she should give her husband a time frame to improve and leave him if he refuses, but this doesn’t take into account the traumatizing of the child that would occur regardless of his improvement or lack thereof. Children want their parents together regardless, right? How does one discern what is best for the child? I don’t know. Does anyone with experience of a similar situation have any advice?
He changed immediately after the wedding (he was trying to be a different man before, then he “relaxed”; he “relaxed” even more when she got pregnant.). He has a drinking problem (though he thinks he doesn’t); there is little or no attraction between them (they barely talk); he goes to his separate room at night to watch TV and drink; she does the chores and housework and works to make most of the money. In the past the drinking was out of control, her life was miserable and things almost turned physical, but this past year it has been “under control”. He is not a very good father, and puts little or no effort into the marriage; she tries to talk to him and he says he is “too tired” or doesn’t want to “be bothered”; he routinely threatens (in a half-joking way) to divorce her if she asks him to do something to help around the house.
She has fallen in love with another man: a Catholic, who says he would marry her if she got divorced (and a declaration of nullity), but until that happens, they can only be friends. The problem is that she has an (almost) 3 year old daughter. She asked for my advice: stick it out in a bad situation so that the child is not traumatized by divorce, or get out before other children are involved and go to the Catholic man who loves her?
I thought she should give her husband a time frame to improve and leave him if he refuses, but this doesn’t take into account the traumatizing of the child that would occur regardless of his improvement or lack thereof. Children want their parents together regardless, right? How does one discern what is best for the child? I don’t know. Does anyone with experience of a similar situation have any advice?