Need advice - Divorce, children

  • Thread starter Thread starter felmus
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
F

felmus

Guest
There is a married woman (no religion) married to a non-practicing Catholic; they have been married for 5 years.

He changed immediately after the wedding (he was trying to be a different man before, then he “relaxed”; he “relaxed” even more when she got pregnant.). He has a drinking problem (though he thinks he doesn’t); there is little or no attraction between them (they barely talk); he goes to his separate room at night to watch TV and drink; she does the chores and housework and works to make most of the money. In the past the drinking was out of control, her life was miserable and things almost turned physical, but this past year it has been “under control”. He is not a very good father, and puts little or no effort into the marriage; she tries to talk to him and he says he is “too tired” or doesn’t want to “be bothered”; he routinely threatens (in a half-joking way) to divorce her if she asks him to do something to help around the house.

She has fallen in love with another man: a Catholic, who says he would marry her if she got divorced (and a declaration of nullity), but until that happens, they can only be friends. The problem is that she has an (almost) 3 year old daughter. She asked for my advice: stick it out in a bad situation so that the child is not traumatized by divorce, or get out before other children are involved and go to the Catholic man who loves her?

I thought she should give her husband a time frame to improve and leave him if he refuses, but this doesn’t take into account the traumatizing of the child that would occur regardless of his improvement or lack thereof. Children want their parents together regardless, right? How does one discern what is best for the child? I don’t know. Does anyone with experience of a similar situation have any advice?
 
I think you should not be involved in this situation. Are you the Catholic man this woman has fallen in love with? I sure hope not.

I was going to say “Send her to her priest” but then I remembered you said she has no religion. I think that’s probably the worst aspect of this post.

I would suggest that they get counseling and that you pray that they can have a good marriage with some work at it.
 
I think there are three separate questions here (at least):

Can your friend ever hope that her husband will treat her with respect and fulfil his role in the marriage?

Are the children better off being in a household with two adults, or is the risk of an alcoholic and ‘almost’ physically abusive father more likely to traumatize them?

Should your friend pursue this emotional attachment to another man while waiting for an annulment?

From the information provided, nobody can give you an answer to questions 1 and 2, but with regard to question 3, any marriage is to be presumed valid until an annulment tribunal rules otherwise. That means your friend has to regard herself as married, and not be seeking emotional fulfilment from another man unless and until that annulment is granted. If he is really such a ‘good Catholic’, he will respect that, and not put her in the way of temptation.

I realize that she is not Catholic, and so may not much care what a tribunal says or what the Church teaches, but moral points aside, I think it will help your friend to gain some emotional clarity if she thinks of these issues separately - is the marriage she has now reparable/tolerable, are the children safe - that is the question to devote herself to, along with her husband, perhaps also a marriage counsellor, in isolation from any temptation of marrying another.
 
I would be very wary of any “Catholic” who professes interest in a married person.

This woman and her husband need to go to counseling. If the situation cannot be remedied, she may need to obtain a legal separation due to her husband’s alleged abusiveness.
 
I think you should not be involved in this situation. Are you the Catholic man this woman has fallen in love with? I sure hope not.

.
I don’t mean to be offensive, but that is the first thing I thought of too. OP-Please dont take offense to that.
 
No offense taken. I can see why you would think that — it reads that way, for one thing.

At any rate, I gave my advice to seek counseling. It was not taken well, and so I don’t think I need further (name removed by moderator)ut. Thanks anyway.
 
No offense taken. I can see why you would think that — it reads that way, for one thing.

At any rate, I gave my advice to seek counseling. It was not taken well, and so I don’t think I need further (name removed by moderator)ut. Thanks anyway.
Your a good man for seeing it that way, thank you.

Prayers for you.
 
Does the husband’s drinking have anything to do with his wife “falling in love with another man”?

This is a complicated situation. Be a good friend, suggest counseling and let them work it out.
 
I would recommend marriage and individual counseling. Since she already has an alcoholic and abusive husband, I would not trust her judgment in picking her next husband.

As a child of an alcoholic, abusive dad, I use to pray daily that my mom would divorce my dad. I love my dad but my childhood was awful.
 
I would recommend marriage and individual counseling. Since she already has an alcoholic and abusive husband, I would not trust her judgment in picking her next husband.

As a child of an alcoholic, abusive dad, I use to pray daily that my mom would divorce my dad. I love my dad but my childhood was awful.
My children’s stress level has gone down so much since DH (alcoholic) died…

They understand they are not to feel bad for feeling so much better without DH around.

OP, she should not be involved with anyone else.
 
As my friends have asked me over the years: So this guy is a proper role model of how to be a man to your kids???
 
So that people stop extrapolating: The man who loves her is only her friend and someone she works with. He made it very clear that she (and he) need to honor her marriage, and that their friendship can only be limited to that—he spoke with priests more than once about the situation; he isn’t a Catholic to be “wary of”; if anything he is ridiculously scrupulous and deathly afraid of doing anything wrong. I have never seen anything like it, honestly. Also, friendship is a basic human good, and she should not be further alienated from those friends of her’s that care about her, so I won’t tell them to stop being friends. She is not the type to come even close to committing adultery; I have never seen her do anything selfish; she always puts her daughter first. I only mentioned him because, if she got divorced, she would not be without help and support, for herself and her daughter…if that made any difference. Please don’t jump to estimations of people based on imagination.

I don’t know what will happen. It isn’t up to me. If I had to guess, I would say she will stay put and things will improve and she’ll be just fine. Just pray for them if you can.

Thank you.
 
Also, friendship is a basic human good, and she should not be further alienated from those friends of her’s that care about her, so I won’t tell them to stop being friends.
thank you for this felmus. I agree.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top