Need some quick advice

  • Thread starter Thread starter Alterum
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
40.png
Lorrie:
I just can’t help but think that #1 they are not sinning. #2 its not your business. #3 if it bothers you that much then don’t hang out with them. No one is putting a gun to your head and making you stick around while they sleep. #4 its their life.

You haven’t mentioned not once that you witnessed them having sex, you are assuming things. Its as if you hang out late with them just so you can find out if they are sinning. I would be more concerned with my own thoughts and actions pertaining to this than the other peoples. Its a little odd and perverted.
Sheesh! This thread is certainly not going where I wanted it to go. I’ll just ask a priest about this.

Just to comment, though:
  1. They are sinning (I always thought this was a sin, anyway).
  2. I am under the impression that it is my business to point out to my friends - in as charitable a manner as possible - if they are doing something gravely wrong. Moreover, this situation repeats itself nearly every week, and I am there to see it.
  3. I will not be spending the nights there if a priest tells me that I shouldn’t.
Finally, I have NOT for a moment assumed that they have had sex. I do not stay up late with these people to found out if they are sinning; a bunch of friends and I stay up late every week, and we’ve been doing so before these two were boyfriend/girlfriend.

Well, I certainly didn’t think I’d be defending my own actions, but so be it. Again, I’m simply trying to do the right thing.

Thanks for all the advice.
 
In our group of friends, the common saying is “Kage does not watch a movie, the movie watches her”… When we get together for dinner and a movie at with friends, after dinner when we pop the movie into the DVD player – I will be sound asleep within 15 minutes of the movie starting. That is just me (and I have problems sleeping – unless I am on a sofa with a bunch of people in the room and a movie blaring over the speakers).

So, if I have crashed over on this end of the sofa and a man to whom I am NOT married is sitting on the couch, is that a sin? You would say “no”. Okay, how about if he falls asleep during the movie as well – now, is it a sin? No.

In the situation you describe, the two are dating the sin of scandal might come into play. The CCC defines this as “**2284 **Scandal is an attitude or behavior which leads another to do evil. The person who gives scandal becomes his neighbor’s tempter. He damages virtue and integrity; he may even draw his brother into spiritual death. Scandal is a grave offense if by deed or omission another is deliberately led into a grave offense.” So, in the situation you describe, if seeing these two sharing a bed led others to conclude that they were having sex outside of marriage and that it was okay because these two were doing it thereby going out and having pre-marital sex themselves – yes, that would make the action sin.

If these two were religious, they could be slipping into the “near occasion of sin” – playing with fire so to speak. Of course, you said they were not religious so the idea of sin might not ever cross their minds.

If this action tempts you into sin, by all means - avoid the situation.

The other thing to remember is that if these people are not religious, you can be a great example by showing them love. Maybe be the gentleman and offer to walk the young lady back to her own dorm room OR makie the suggestion you play the games in her room, and then the boys go back to their own room when it gets late.

Let them see the light coming from your life!
 
Alterum said:
1. They are sinning (I always thought this was a sin, anyway).

How is being fully clothed and sleeping in the same bed with the opposite sex a sin? Just curious.

I can see it being an open door to sin, but its not an actual sin until something happens.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top