Nephew and road trip gone bad

  • Thread starter Thread starter holyrood
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Of course, this kid is carrying a razor blade in his wallet and I’m wondering if there’s a drug issue starting or going on with him, too.
Yes. My thought was that he probably didn’t want to “room” with the girls in order to have sex, but so that he/they could collectively slip your supervisions in order to get loud, talk about crude things they can’t talk about around you, drink and/or do drugs. It was still a over the top to imply that you ought to think he was a gay pedophile who posed a danger to your two children. That was a jaw-dropper. The kid has no self-respect, apparently.
 
It makes a difference to fill in the facts that you did not in fact tolerate his unacceptable behavior. I never got the idea that you had obliged him on the sleeping arrangements, but wasn’t so sure you had not given him “guest” treatment on at least some of the other issues. Until you said the trip was for your daughter’s destination and this nasty relative was her hand-picked guest, it was not entirely clear why you wouldn’t have just cut the trip short! Obviously, though, he had you over a barrel, and he knew it. You were, as it turns out, hosting a group of your daughter’s friends, for your daughter’s benefit, and had to endure more than you’d like for her sake and the sake of her other guests.
The only real issues on the trip were the sleeping arrangements and who would sit in the front seat on that particular leg of the drive. He’s spent a great deal of time at my house over the years, sometimes for a week or ten days at a time, and he’s generally been pleasant to have around, which is why I didn’t think there should be any problem with this trip.

The thing I’m learning about boundaries is that there is no such thing as boundaries with an alcoholic family–or at least with mine. They will behave as they will and my choice is to put up with it or walk away. I chose walking away, because they made it clear they would not respect my boundaries but would call me names for having them.

I suspect a lot of this goes back to my nephew hearing them talk for years among themselves about all my supposed flaws. Nothing I can do about that. My mother has spent many years telling people all the things she thinks I’ve done wrong, and in many of those cases, when I hear the details, they aren’t even true. (Her summation of what really happened in my marriage, for example–despite the fact that even I didn’t know how bad it really was until the legal system forced him to show me our true financial situation–and my mother was not at that meeting with those lawyers seeing those statements. She just tells people I’m imagining things and that poor XH has done nothing at all!) I suspect THAT goes back to either a pre-existing personality disorder and/or the results of being in an abusive marriage herself for 50 years. 😦
I’m sorry you have to deal with this, though. It is a great disappointment when you come to realize that your family does not “have your back”, and turn out to be a source of trials and not a source of support, in spite of your best efforts. I’m sure we all extend our condolences! 😦
Thank you. I ask for prayers for this whole family. It’s tragic to watch it traveling down the generations despite all my efforts to get away from the yelling, screaming, swearing, animosity, and dysfunction. 😦
 
I suspect a lot of this goes back to my nephew hearing them talk for years among themselves about all my supposed flaws. Nothing I can do about that. My mother has spent many years telling people all the things she thinks I’ve done wrong, and in many of those cases, when I hear the details, they aren’t even true. (Her summation of what really happened in my marriage, for example–despite the fact that even I didn’t know how bad it really was until the legal system forced him to show me our true financial situation–and my mother was not at that meeting with those lawyers seeing those statements. She just tells people I’m imagining things and that poor XH has done nothing at all!) I suspect THAT goes back to either a pre-existing personality disorder and/or the results of being in an abusive marriage herself for 50 years. 😦
It does not take a personality disorder to commit the sins of rash judgment, calumny, or detraction. If one chooses to think and say the worst about someone else instead of to extend the charity required to give the benefit of the doubt about a situation about which one lacks full knowledge or to refrain from telling lies in order to make a situation appear other than one knows it to be or to know a real flaw and refuse to share knowledge of it with those who do not need to know it, then that is all it takes.

While someone with a mental illness may be incapable of doing better on a consistent basis and while someone with bad habits will probably fall now and again even when they start with the best of intentions, likewise someone with a full complement of mental faculties is fully capable of both committing the sins against the truth or and avoiding them. When we lie or commit detraction or rash judgment, the first place we ought to look for the reason is our own conscience, and not anywhere else.

But yes, addictions make liars and frauds and cover-ups, and have been known to bring down even a good character. When making the decision about who and who not to trust, it is wise not to trust the person who is still enslaved by their addiction, and when perhaps there has been alcohol involved, there is just one more reason to say, “there, but for the grace of God, go I.”

Still, judging a person unworthy of trust is a million miles from judging them unworthy as persons. The latter judgment is not our job, but the first one most definitely is.
 
You have learned your lesson now. He is just like the rest of them.

He would be banned from my house henceforth, were it me.
 
You have learned your lesson now. He is just like the rest of them.

He would be banned from my house henceforth, were it me.
She said he has a long history of being decent. I’d be inclined to let him back in, if he is ever inclined to apologize. I’d not let him in my house if he felt free to call me names when he got angry, though. There are boundary lines, yes.
 
She said he has a long history of being decent. I’d be inclined to let him back in, if he is ever inclined to apologize. I’d not let him in my house if he felt free to call me names when he got angry, though. There are boundary lines, yes.
I think one of my struggles here will be resentment against my mother. My XH’s aunt banned me from her home for years and I had no clue why. When I finally got answers, they were so bizarre as to leave me wondering if her age made her unaware she’d actually been talking to my voicemail. :confused: But my mother (see a pattern here? 😦 ) who wasn’t even there, who didn’t even know the woman, backed her up and told me I deserved it. I can guarantee I never did anything remotely like this to her. I say please and thank you to the dog, for Pete’s sake, I certainly don’t mistreat my husband’s elderly relatives.

Sadly, I doubt this will be an issue. I doubt he’ll ever apologize.
 
She said he has a long history of being decent. I’d be inclined to let him back in, if he is ever inclined to apologize. I’d not let him in my house if he felt free to call me names when he got angry, though. There are boundary lines, yes.
I would be disinclined to let any of them in, ever.

More time in purgatory for me, perhap. But at least it will be PEACEFUL.

🙂
 
I would be disinclined to let any of them in, ever.

More time in purgatory for me, perhap. But at least it will be PEACEFUL.

🙂
He’s made his bed, and she could not be blamed for letting him sleep in it. Still, this is the kind of thing that happens in families with typical levels of dysfunction, too–a “dysfunctional family” having been defined by the experts as any family with more than one person in it–and the offending party has been known to come around to a clear if not explicit admission that they were in the wrong. Sometimes they show their contrition by being particularly pleased to be accommodating to the person they have wronged, rather than having enough courage and humility to apologize outright, but I mean someone who clearly comes back with the tail between the legs, so to speak. He might try to make it up to her, in order to go back to acting decently. If she thinks it was a one-time slip of which he seems sufficiently ashamed not to repeat it, she might decide to give him a second chance.

Still, I don’t think charity demands invitations for abuse. She didn’t ask for anything but decent treatment, and she wouldn’t be out of line to insist that he at least apologize for the names he called her and promise never to repeat anything like it as a condition for coming into her home, since she herself does not stoop to calling anyone names like that no matter how mad she gets. She does deserve better.
 
I would be disinclined to let any of them in, ever.

More time in purgatory for me, perhap. But at least it will be PEACEFUL.

🙂
Just BTW, while we can only do what we can stand to do, I doubt the strategy that puts off any of our homework load on the hopes that it will be easier in Purgatory. 😉
 
I got a few more answers from my son. It seems the ‘greedy *****’ was because he THOUGHT I was charging him for things not used communally. For instance, I bought medical tape for my son, and rather than just ASK, rather than SAY what was on his mind, he demanded receipts to look for himself.

If anything, I think this only makes me angrier. I have had this boy in my house over and over throughout the years. My sister used to just leave them here…I’d come home from work and find they were here for the weekend. I was always happy to have them, never asked for anything in return. He said he wanted to go, I took him on good faith, I slept on the couch in the town home I got for us in this other city, I took them all out to a nice meal our first night there, a rather expensive one I treated them all to; I’ve lived my life with honesty and integrity–and yet his first assumption is to decide that I would charge him for my son’s medical tape! After all I’ve done for him, pardon the cliche, his first assumption is not only that I would be so petty as to charge him 1/8 of the cost of medical tape, but to also assume that if he asked me I would lie to him about it–and thus the need to see actual receipts.

I don’t believe ANYTHING in my character or previous actions over YEARS has given any justification for assuming such a thing. It makes me ask what’s the point in living with integrity and honor if it gets you nowhere…but I have a friend who keeps reminding me it matters to ME, and that I know the truth and can look in the mirror, and GOD knows the truth.
 
If anything, I think this only makes me angrier. I have had this boy in my house over and over throughout the years. (…) After all I’ve done for him, pardon the cliche, his first assumption is not only that I would be so petty as to charge him 1/8 of the cost of medical tape, but to also assume that if he asked me I would lie to him about it–and thus the need to see actual receipts.
I can tell that this really hurt you. I’m so sorry you have been continually disappointed by your family members.

It is a shame that the boy has turned out like this, but there is nothing you can do. It seems that he is following in the steps of his relatives. Just pray that he changes and grows up to be a decent person. You have tried being a good influence and someone he can come to, but he has no respect for you. It is a good lesson to say ‘enough, I’m not putting up with this.’ Maybe he has not heard that at home.
 
I can tell that this really hurt you. I’m so sorry you have been continually disappointed by your family members.

It is a shame that the boy has turned out like this, but there is nothing you can do. It seems that he is following in the steps of his relatives. Just pray that he changes and grows up to be a decent person. You have tried being a good influence and someone he can come to, but he has no respect for you. It is a good lesson to say ‘enough, I’m not putting up with this.’ Maybe he has not heard that at home.
Thank you. I suppose in a day or two, I’ll be able to do that. I have been well and easily able to pray for my parents. Right now, I’m still angrier than I’ve been in years. 😦
 
See, the thing about the medical tape (what was that, $3?) is exactly why it’s not a good idea to do to-the-dollar accounting for this kind of situation. You wind up having conversations like, “I don’t even LIKE corn chips. Why am I getting charged for the corn chips?” when the person saying it snarfed up all the trail mix.

Here’s another suggestion. Sit nephew down (or email him) and say, “I’m sorry that we didn’t figure this out before the trip, because it sounds like there have been a lot of misunderstandings and hurt feelings. Let’s start by penciling out how much you would have spent on the trip if you had been travelling by yourself and then let’s look at the receipts and count up the total trip expenses (minus medical tape, etc.), divided by the number of people on the trip.” If in doubt, look up federal per diems given for food expenses for federal workers who are travelling. Do the math right in front of him and ask for the money (in an even, respectful tone), pointing out how much he saved on hotel and transportation. Go ahead and use your credit card receipts, too, if the items are clearly relevant. If you were spending $50 at a gas station or $100 at Safeway, the odds are that you were purchasing gas and groceries.

At this point, as I understand it, you haven’t given him a dollar figure yet. Give him the dollar figure. If he quibbles, tell him (as somebody upthread suggested), “I didn’t realize that you were having money problems. You should have mentioned that earlier. What do you think you can afford to pay of the money you owe me for the trip?” And then leave it there. The main problem here, I think, is not damaging your relationship with your daughter over this.

There are several billion people on the planet who would treat you better than your family members have been treating you. Spend more time with those people.
 
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
For every trip/holiday/time ‘away’ Jesus’ beautiful Heart flowed through me to ensure that I paid for every one of my family members and my Children’s friends (many of those over the years) regardless of their financial situation (all of their food, accommodation and travel expenses) with most of my wages going into these little trips away over a 10 year period; the Glory and Honour are all Yours Dear God our Heavenly Father now and for Eternity.

Jesus says: “Always give to those who ask”. Your Nephew asked and you have given; however if your Nephew is taking advantage of your generosity and not been friendly and easy to get along and ruining the trip; ask him to go home earlier by bus or rail; finishing the trip with your Children.
 
See, the thing about the medical tape (what was that, $3?) is exactly why it’s not a good idea to do to-the-dollar accounting for this kind of situation. You wind up having conversations like, “I don’t even LIKE corn chips. Why am I getting charged for the corn chips?” when the person saying it snarfed up all the trail mix.
Agreed.
Here’s another suggestion. Sit nephew down (or email him) and say, “I’m sorry that we didn’t figure this out before the trip, because it sounds like there have been a lot of misunderstandings and hurt feelings. Let’s start by penciling out how much you would have spent on the trip if you had been travelling by yourself and then let’s look at the receipts and count up the total trip expenses (minus medical tape, etc.), divided by the number of people on the trip.” …
At this point, as I understand it, you haven’t given him a dollar figure yet. Give him the dollar figure. If he quibbles…
I first gave him a rough estimate. He asked Saturday night for a dollar amount. I went through my credit card statements online and wrote it up for him (spent an hour doing it), stating clearly what each purchase was for–breakfast cereal, fruit at street vendor. I left it for him Sunday morning, and when I came home from Mass, he didn’t ask questions, just informed me I needed to leave receipts on the table for him and I didn’t. I pointed out that while I’m running all over NYC with 7 kids in tow and in and out of subways and buses and a full loaded car, some of those receipts got lost in the chaos. I could see where it was going, that he was going to claim if I didn’t have a receipt, maybe I was fudging on numbers and he wasn’t going to pay.

So I tried to cut the escalating conversation short and just said, “You can either contribute or I can take you to your grandparents.” Made it clear I was letting the money go and not going to fight about it. He kept pushing about the receipts, saying he’d LOVE to contribute but he can’t because I had not ‘met his terms.’ To claim as a 20 year old who did NOTHING to help plan this trip or contribute to it, who slept in a bed while I took the couch to tell me I need to ‘meet his terms’ pretty much ended it for me. What gall.

By the way, he doesn’t have a car or a license. His arrival for this trip was by greyhound. He texted me to let me know when I could pick him up downtown. I texted back that I couldn’t, as I was at work. His response was that I could pick him up when I finished work. I was shocked that with 2 jobs and 9 children, he would assume I had nothing better to do when I ‘finish’ work (as if that ever happens) than drive downtown for him. I told him to look up a bus schedule to the suburbs and he did.

Sorry. I’m still angry. I have not been this angry in years. 😦 But in short, yes, I gave him the dollar amount he requested, he quibbled, I tried to cut it short, and he launched into name-calling and abuse.
 
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
For every trip/holiday/time ‘away’ Jesus’ beautiful Heart flowed through me to ensure that I paid for every one of my family members and my Children’s friends (many of those over the years) regardless of their financial situation (all of their food, accommodation and travel expenses) …

Jesus says: “Always give to those who ask”. Your Nephew asked and you have given; however if your Nephew is taking advantage of your generosity and not been friendly and easy to get along and ruining the trip; ask him to go home earlier by bus or rail; finishing the trip with your Children.
Thank you. I can tell how mad I still am because I first took it as a lecture that I should just hand him anything :o but you’re right, he asked, I gave. He took advantage and that will be the end of it. But I will try to just remember, he asked and I gave, and leave it at that in my heart.

I think part of what hurts and is upsetting is that given family dynamics, I know he’s going to give his spin on this story to my parents and his mother, claiming that I was somehow trying to cheat him and they’re going to cluck and sympathize with him and add it to their arsenal. My daughter is already on the bandwagon insisting I ought to have given him all the receipts (never mind that it’s almost impossible to keep track of every receipt in the given situation.)
 
“I first gave him a rough estimate. He asked Saturday night for a dollar amount. I went through my credit card statements online and wrote it up for him (spent an hour doing it), stating clearly what each purchase was for–breakfast cereal, fruit at street vendor. I left it for him Sunday morning, and when I came home from Mass, he didn’t ask questions, just informed me I needed to leave receipts on the table for him and I didn’t. I pointed out that while I’m running all over NYC with 7 kids in tow and in and out of subways and buses and a full loaded car, some of those receipts got lost in the chaos. I could see where it was going, that he was going to claim if I didn’t have a receipt, maybe I was fudging on numbers and he wasn’t going to pay.”

Oh my goodness. I didn’t realize it was NYC. You have my deepest sympathy. I have been there very briefly and I know what it’s like–you start bleeding money as soon as you enter the city limits, and it doesn’t stop until you leave. And that was just me and my husband–with 8 people, it must have been ruinously expensive, even doing the economy version that it sounds like you guys were doing.

Of course you don’t have all the receipts, and it’s nutty to expect you to have them. Do street vendors even give receipts all the time? It’s also unacceptable to expect receipts without announcing that well in advance.

“So I tried to cut the escalating conversation short and just said, “You can either contribute or I can take you to your grandparents.””

That’s fair, but I don’t think you’ll be able to get the money now, after putting it like that. He probably figures that you’ve now given him permission not to contribute.

Try to let this go, but don’t ever let it happen again.
 
Thank you. I can tell how mad I still am because I first took it as a lecture that I should just hand him anything :o but you’re right, he asked, I gave. He took advantage and that will be the end of it. But I will try to just remember, he asked and I gave, and leave it at that in my heart.

I think part of what hurts and is upsetting is that given family dynamics, I know he’s going to give his spin on this story to my parents and his mother, claiming that I was somehow trying to cheat him and they’re going to cluck and sympathize with him and add it to their arsenal. My daughter is already on the bandwagon insisting I ought to have given him all the receipts (never mind that it’s almost impossible to keep track of every receipt in the given situation.)
He’s going to ruin your “reputation” with someone who wouldn’t grant you the good reputation that you already deserve. That is not the same kind of loss as ruining your reputation with someone with better judgment or someone who controls your life in some way.

He’s acting like a man with a very small heart and a tight fist. That’s hard to know, but unless he comes to his senses and apologizes, that is something you ought not forget.
 
“I think part of what hurts and is upsetting is that given family dynamics, I know he’s going to give his spin on this story to my parents and his mother, claiming that I was somehow trying to cheat him and they’re going to cluck and sympathize with him and add it to their arsenal.”

I think you need to prepare a short, factual answer for if anybody brings it up. Something like, “I spent $400 for Nephew to go to NYC with us and he hasn’t paid me back.”

And then don’t allow yourself to say anything more about the details or to be drawn into further discussion.

“My daughter is already on the bandwagon insisting I ought to have given him all the receipts (never mind that it’s almost impossible to keep track of every receipt in the given situation.)”

That’s the one I would worry about–your relationship with your daughter. Keep it short with her, too, but you might want to add something like, “Sweetie, I know you and Cousin George did receipts when you were roommates and it worked great for you, but it’s relatively simple for two people living together to split the tab for joint purchases of toilet paper and soap. There’s just one or two pieces of paper a week to keep track of for relatively small amounts of money. This was a big, complicated trip in the big city with 8 people and several large purchases over the course of each day, plus lots of medium purchases. I have some receipts plus credit card bills and that’s all I’ve got.” And show her the receipts and credit card bills so she understands how much money is involved.

Bear in mind that when your nephew is so mistrustful of you, that is partly a reflection on the people he has grown up with. It may simply be his experience that older adult relative can’t be trusted and aren’t worthy of respect.
 
“I think part of what hurts and is upsetting is that given family dynamics, I know he’s going to give his spin on this story to my parents and his mother, claiming that I was somehow trying to cheat him and they’re going to cluck and sympathize with him and add it to their arsenal.”

I think you need to prepare a short, factual answer for if anybody brings it up. Something like, “I spent $400 for Nephew to go to NYC with us and he hasn’t paid me back.”

And then don’t allow yourself to say anything more about the details or to be drawn into further discussion.

“My daughter is already on the bandwagon insisting I ought to have given him all the receipts (never mind that it’s almost impossible to keep track of every receipt in the given situation.)”

That’s the one I would worry about–your relationship with your daughter. Keep it short with her, too, but you might want to add something like, “Sweetie, I know you and Cousin George did receipts when you were roommates and it worked great for you, but it’s relatively simple for two people living together to split the tab for joint purchases of toilet paper and soap. There’s just one or two pieces of paper a week to keep track of for relatively small amounts of money. This was a big, complicated trip in the big city with 8 people and several large purchases over the course of each day, plus lots of medium purchases. I have some receipts plus credit card bills and that’s all I’ve got.” And show her the receipts and credit card bills so she understands how much money is involved.

Bear in mind that when your nephew is so mistrustful of you, that is partly a reflection on the people he has grown up with. It may simply be his experience that older adult relative can’t be trusted and aren’t worthy of respect.
The other possibility is to ask him what he thinks he owes. It is not as if he’s some HR person who won’t reimburse because he wasn’t on the trip to witness the consumption himself. He was in the car, he slept in the bed, he ate the food. I don’t see how he can disagree that he owes something. Even if he comes up with a certain number of cents per mile and some low-ball estimate of the meals and lodging he didn’t pay for, it would be something!

But again, if anyone I knew agreed to pay expenses and then got home to find their host was refusing to show receipts because she intended to pay for everything after all, they’d try to estimate what they owed in order to offer to pay something. If he was trying in good faith to be fair, he would have offered to pay something. As it is, he’s just being cheap. Again: I can’t imagine why the daughter is sticking up for someone who is sticking her mother after the mother did him a favor. It makes you shake your head.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top