New Gender Options for Facebook Users

  • Thread starter Thread starter didymus
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

didymus

Guest
ABC News:
New Gender Options for Facebook Users
With a click of a cursor, Jay Brown in Cheverly, Md., went from Male to Trans Male. A few states away, Debon Garrigues of Asheville, N.C., switched from Male to Neutral. In San Francisco, Marilyn Roxie, formerly Female, chose three: Androgynous, Transgender and Genderqueer. Across the country Thursday, news swept through the transgender community that social media giant Facebook had added a customizable option with about 50 different terms people can use to identify their gender as well as three preferred pronoun choices: him, her or them. And one after another, they made their changes in a quiet revolution of sorts.
“For me, this is about much more than a button on a monitor,” Garrigues said. “This encourages people to think outside the binary spectrum. It means I don’t have to try to fit in the wrong boxes.”
For many others, the change went unnoticed — or too far.
“Of course Facebook is entitled to manage its wildly popular site as it sees fit, but here is the bottom line: It’s impossible to deny the biological reality that humanity is divided into two halves - male and female,” said Jeff Johnston, an issues analyst for Focus on the Family, an influential national religious organization based in Colorado Springs, Colo. “Those petitioning for the change insist that there are an infinite number of genders, but just saying it doesn’t make it so. That said, we have a great deal of compassion for those who reject their biological sex and believe they are the opposite sex.”
Facebook said the changes, shared with The Associated Press before the launch, initially cover the company’s 159 million monthly users in the U.S. and are aimed at giving people more choices in how they describe themselves, such as androgynous, bi-gender, intersex, gender fluid or transsexual.
Ai, ai-ai!
Stop the world, I want to get off.
 
And I’m told I don’t exist because I’m not on this website? Geesh, fine by me!
 
I could not find handsome highly heterosexual hunk in the options so just had to give up.
 
Just one more of many reasons I am glad I removed my profile from that site.
 
My advice? If you choose to be on this social-media site it is best not to give out too much information - a skeletal profile may be the best option.
Joke Alert!😃 I think that they should have an inanimate object option like LEGGO or rolling stone w or w/o moss for example.
 
ABC News:

Ai, ai-ai!
Stop the world, I want to get off.
I know. There are lots of days when my prayer is, “Lord, let me leave this world soon. It makes me sick.” However, we each need to do our part in bringing the light of Christ to others before we can leave. :rolleyes:
 
Just one more of many reasons I am glad I removed my profile from that site.
Try as I might I tried to delete myself of Facebook 3 years ago, could not do it, and 3 years on I am still getting messages from that which I just ignore, and delete, will have to get an IT guy to take it off as its beginning to annoy me.
 
I could not find handsome highly heterosexual hunk in the options so just had to give up.
:rotfl: :rotfl: :rotfl:

Feel your pain, sir - I was unable to find “Amazingly Gorgeous Gal Who Looks 23” either 😛
Try as I might I tried to delete myself of Facebook 3 years ago, could not do it, and 3 years on I am still getting messages from that which I just ignore, and delete, will have to get an IT guy to take it off as its beginning to annoy me.
What methods did you try to get rid of it? I recommend scrubbing one’s profile as much as possible through the Activity Log, leaving all groups and “unfriending” all people - and leaving it that way for awhile. Then there is “Deactivating” vs. true Deletion. In the case of the latter, you cannot log back in for a period of time or it will just treat it as a deactivation.

As for the 58 “gender options,” I think it’s mostly hype. Unless I’m just a complete ignoramus in those matters, which I could be, but most of them looked like repetitions or hair-splittings. :rolleyes: Could even a person who’s really into this alternative gender craze memorize all 58 of them?🤷
 
I miss the time when it was a simple matter of “looking under the tail” 😦
 
Try as I might I tried to delete myself of Facebook 3 years ago, could not do it, and 3 years on I am still getting messages from that which I just ignore, and delete, will have to get an IT guy to take it off as its beginning to annoy me.
All you have to do is delete everything from your account including friends, change your email to something rediculous like “bearhasfootrotwhileeatingcheese@_______” followed by changing your password to something you will never remember and you are done. Useless account with no information. That’s if they don’t let you remove it.
 
Is there an option to select all of them at the same time? If not, I wonder if that’s a “rights” violation.😃
 
What’s so wrong about this? We now know that gender is not binary as we long thought, but an array of four continuous variables: assigned gender upon birth (what the doctor puts down upon birth), sexual orientation (whether you’re attracted to male or female), gender identity (what you consider yourself), and gender expression (what you portray to others).

So yes, there is room for about 50 different gender ideas.

We now know that parts of India and Germany are recognizing a third gender.
 
Just post some comments stating that homosexuals, transexuals and transvestites are living in mortal sin; homosexuals are mentally ill, etc. You will be banned soon enough.
 
Try as I might I tried to delete myself of Facebook 3 years ago, could not do it, and 3 years on I am still getting messages from that which I just ignore, and delete, will have to get an IT guy to take it off as its beginning to annoy me.
I deleted my Facebook account using this link, and haven’t been bothered since:
facebook.com/help/224562897555674

The link was hard to find. Facebook makes it easy to deactivate your account, but that simply removes it from public view.
 
What’s so wrong about this? We now know that gender is not binary as we long thought, but an array of four continuous variables: assigned gender upon birth (what the doctor puts down upon birth), sexual orientation (whether you’re attracted to male or female), gender identity (what you consider yourself), and gender expression (what you portray to others).

So yes, there is room for about 50 different gender ideas.

We now know that parts of India and Germany are recognizing a third gender.
Gender is a property of certain words in some languages. Organisms have sexes. If one believes oneself to be female when one has male genitals, then one is mentally ill.
 
Gender is a property of certain words in some languages. Organisms have sexes. If one believes oneself to be female when one has male genitals, then one is mentally ill.
No, one is not. Virtually all evidence to date points towards the cause being brain differentiation in utero going wrong, leaving the person with a non-masculinized brain and masculine body, or the other way around. Additionally, the condition has been clinically observed since the early 20th century, and patients have always been described as sane/having no signs of delusions.

The ignorance regarding this condition seems to be endless, sadly. I wish people would at the very least try to seek a minimum of knowledge before speaking, but preconceptions seem to trump fact in this case. Thankfully, Holy Mother Church acts more prudently and has delayed any form of definitive judgement, precisely because the etiology of the condition is not yet definitively proved (though we know a lot more now than we did ten years ago).
 
No, one is not. Virtually all evidence to date points towards the cause being brain differentiation in utero going wrong, leaving the person with a non-masculinized brain and masculine body, or the other way around. Additionally, the condition has been clinically observed since the early 20th century, and patients have always been described as sane/having no signs of delusions.
While there are certain things which are generally different between the brains of men and women, there are no physical structures in the brain which mark it as 100% male or female.
The ignorance regarding this condition seems to be endless, sadly. I wish people would at the very least try to seek a minimum of knowledge before speaking, but preconceptions seem to trump fact in this case. Thankfully, Holy Mother Church acts more prudently and has delayed any form of definitive judgement, precisely because the etiology of the condition is not yet definitively proved (though we know a lot more now than we did ten years ago).
In any other situation which involves a denial of physical reality, a patient would be judged as insane. Is a man insane if he believes himself to be Napoleon, an ostrich, a snail, or a rocking chair? Of course, because those are a denial of concrete physical reality. If a patient has male genitals, how is he not insane if he believes himself to be female?
 
While there are certain things which are generally different between the brains of men and women, there are no physical structures in the brain which mark it as 100% male or female.
Which I didn’t say, either. There are always exceptions and degrees of feminization/masculinization. But the studies so far are clear - there are marked gender differences/traits in brains, and transsexual brains examined post mortem are markedly similar to the brains of their identified sex, and different from their birth sex. These studies are solid, and also supported by recent brain scan studies on live brains, the fact that transgender brains react psychologically well to cross-sex hormones (while cisgender brains do not), cognitive and other tests done on patients, etc.
In any other situation which involves a denial of physical reality, a patient would be judged as insane.
Indeed. But I have yet to meet a transgender person who denies physical reality. Every pre-op trans woman I’ve spoken to is perfectly clear about the fact that they have a penis, and the other way around. Actually they’re painfully aware of the fact.

The people I see denying physical reality here, are the ones who deny the possibility of brain mis-differentiation during pregnancy, or worse, the existence of brain gender traits at all (at least they’re in good company with radical feminists…). I do however prefer labeling them ignorant instead of insane, for the sake of friendliness and good tone 😉 .
Is a man insane if he believes himself to be Napoleon, an ostrich, a snail, or a rocking chair? Of course, because those are a denial of concrete physical reality. If a patient has male genitals, how is he not insane if he believes himself to be female?
As I said, a pre-op trans woman does not believe herself not to have a penis. If she did, she would indeed be insane. But she doesn’t. She believes herself to have a female brain, which is logically possible, and medically plausible.

In addition, your comparison is not applicable, and is also a poor attempt at ridicule. Being Napoleon, an ostrich, a snail, or a rocking chair is logically impossible. Brain-body gendering mismatch is not logically impossible.

Lastly, there’s a problem with the use of the term “female”. If by that, you simply mean “has ovaries and female plumbing”, if we ignore inconveniences like women born with internal testes or men with one gonad of each kind and so on, you are right. But if so, your definition is lacking at best. Not only does it fail to give any meaning in the case of intersex individuals born as women but with variations in their reproductive system, it also fails to take into account that most of us don’t think with our genitals. I am not my penis. I may not be my brain either, but at least the brain defines far more of me than my penis does. So if my brain is female, I am female.

I recommend you read up on what transgenderism actually is, what neurobiology actually says, and not least what the Church actually says on the matter.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top