New Social Progress Index

  • Thread starter Thread starter Mickey_Finn
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

Mickey_Finn

Guest
Well, the report is in and the USA didn’t fair as well as you might think. Our GDP ranks us at #2But we score embarrassingly low in some very important categories.

New Zealand took top honors, our cousins to the north took 7th, and we grabbed the 16th spot
Behind Iceland, UK, even Ireland.

Compared to our immediate neighbors…
Canada: Rank 7th overall. Basic Human Needs -11th Foundations of Wellness-17th
USA: Ranked 16th overall Basic Human Needs - 23rd Foundations of Wellness 36th
Mexico: Ranked 54th overall Basic Human Needs - 66th Foundations of Wellness 72nd.

It’s interesting to note that we out spend everyone in health care but our results are not very pleasing. So, whats going wrong in the United States? How is it we rank 5th in opportunities and 36th in anything let alone the Foundations of Wellness? 🤷

links.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_Social_Progress_Index Nice format

reuters.com/article/2014/04/03/us-index-global-progress-idUSBREA3203R20140403

RESUCITO! youtube.com/watch?v=gLlQQig5gio
 
It would be interesting to find out their definition of ‘social progress’.
 
Not really surprising…

We have had a liberal democratic controlled government since 2009. We have been living with the promise of a “fundamentally changed America”…look what we got.

“We”, as a people, don’t outspend everyone in healthcare…the federal government is the largest healthcare customer in the world. For better results…get the government out of healthcare entirely and focus on governing.
 
Not really surprising…

We have had a liberal democratic controlled government since 2009. We have been living with the promise of a “fundamentally changed America”…look what we got.

“We”, as a people, don’t outspend everyone in healthcare…the federal government is the largest healthcare customer in the world. For better results…get the government out of healthcare entirely and focus on governing.
Certainly an interesting take on this topic. Here is a link to the current facts on Health spending. As I pointed out in another thread spending growth has slowed in the past few years.

cms.gov/Research-Statistics-Data-and-Systems/Statistics-Trends-and-Reports/NationalHealthExpendData/downloads/highlights.pdf

ATB
 
Certainly an interesting take on this topic. Here is a link to the current facts on Health spending. As I pointed out in another thread spending growth has slowed in the past few years.

cms.gov/Research-Statistics-Data-and-Systems/Statistics-Trends-and-Reports/NationalHealthExpendData/downloads/highlights.pdf

ATB
Interesting figures.

Here is a study that related directly to the reason health care costs are high:

The study investigated the attitudes of 211 focus group participants in Washington, D.C., and Santa Monica, Calif., toward weighing their own out-of-pocket costs as well as the costs borne by their insurer in medical decisions. The participants did not generally understand how insurance works and felt little personal responsibility for helping to solve the problem of rising health care costs. They were unlikely to accept a less expensive treatment option, even if it was nearly as effective as a more expensive choice.

kaiserhealthnews.org/Features/Insuring-Your-Health/2013/031213-Michelle-Andrews-on-consumers-not-wanting-cheaper-treatments.aspx

I maintain that when people pay for their own health care and providers are forced to compete costs will go down dramatically.
 
I am skeptical of any such index, announced by some obscure non-profit, and having no particular history.

Setting that aside, the reason the US ranks low in health and wellness may have little to do with our health care system. I suspect we rank low in this category because of our high level of obesity. Here are the factors which were measured for Health and Wellness:

Health and Wellness
• Life expectancy
• Non-communicable disease deaths between the ages of 30 and 70
• Obesity rate
• Outdoor air pollution attributable deaths
• Suicide rate
socialprogressimperative.org/system/resources/W1siZiIsIjIwMTQvMDQvMDIvMjAvMTkvNDQvMjcyL1NvY2lhbF9Qcm9ncmVzc19JbmRleF8yMDE0X01ldGhvZG9sb2dpY2FsX1JlcG9ydC5wZGYiXV0/Social%20Progress%20Index%202014%20Methodological%20Report.pdf
(see page 9)

Obesity is one of the five factors, outright. However, obesity would also figure into life expectancy and non-communicable disease deaths between the ages of 30 and 70.

Americans are notoriously fat. I think this is reflected in our low Health and Wellness rank. The amount of money we spend on health care is not so important. What we need to do with put down the fork and spoon, and be more physically active.
 
I am skeptical of any such index, announced by some obscure non-profit, and having no particular history.

Setting that aside, the reason the US ranks low in health and wellness may have little to do with our health care system. I suspect we rank low in this category because of our high level of obesity. Here are the factors which were measured for Health and Wellness:

Health and Wellness
• Life expectancy
• Non-communicable disease deaths between the ages of 30 and 70
• Obesity rate
• Outdoor air pollution attributable deaths
• Suicide rate
socialprogressimperative.org/system/resources/W1siZiIsIjIwMTQvMDQvMDIvMjAvMTkvNDQvMjcyL1NvY2lhbF9Qcm9ncmVzc19JbmRleF8yMDE0X01ldGhvZG9sb2dpY2FsX1JlcG9ydC5wZGYiXV0/Social%20Progress%20Index%202014%20Methodological%20Report.pdf
(see page 9)

Obesity is one of the five factors, outright. However, obesity would also figure into life expectancy and non-communicable disease deaths between the ages of 30 and 70.

Americans are notoriously fat. I think this is reflected in our low Health and Wellness rank. The amount of money we spend on health care is not so important. What we need to do with put down the fork and spoon, and be more physically active.
I think your on to something there. Obesity alone increases risk for all major heath concerns. Add to that the impact on productivity, we are working against ourselves with our American lifestyle. We are ranked 18 worldwide for obesity according to the CIA. cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/rankorder/2228rank.html
None of the nations above us did well on the Index either. 🤷

We have a lot of work to do.

ATB
 
I am skeptical of any such index, announced by some obscure non-profit, and having no particular history.

Setting that aside, the reason the US ranks low in health and wellness may have little to do with our health care system. I suspect we rank low in this category because of our high level of obesity. Here are the factors which were measured for Health and Wellness:

Health and Wellness
• Life expectancy
• Non-communicable disease deaths between the ages of 30 and 70
• Obesity rate
• Outdoor air pollution attributable deaths
• Suicide rate
socialprogressimperative.org/system/resources/W1siZiIsIjIwMTQvMDQvMDIvMjAvMTkvNDQvMjcyL1NvY2lhbF9Qcm9ncmVzc19JbmRleF8yMDE0X01ldGhvZG9sb2dpY2FsX1JlcG9ydC5wZGYiXV0/Social%20Progress%20Index%202014%20Methodological%20Report.pdf
(see page 9)

Obesity is one of the five factors, outright. However, obesity would also figure into life expectancy and non-communicable disease deaths between the ages of 30 and 70.

Americans are notoriously fat. I think this is reflected in our low Health and Wellness rank. The amount of money we spend on health care is not so important. What we need to do with put down the fork and spoon, and be more physically active.
And we need to close down all the fast food joints, NO ONE needs these places!
 
I knew a man who never smoked, never drank, always ate healthy food and exercised to stay in shape…guess what…he died.
 
I think as long as we allow massive immigration from nations where peoples’ health was impaired from birth onward, we’re going to spend a lot of money on healthcare and our results aren’t going to be optimal.

It was mildly amusing to see NZ so highly ranked. I plan to discuss that with the not-few New Zealanders who have come into my part of the country. I know one of the reasons why they immigrated (land is impossibly expensive in NZ) but I’m sure I don’t know all of the reasons.
 
I think as long as we allow massive immigration from nations where peoples’ health was impaired from birth onward, we’re going to spend a lot of money on healthcare and our results aren’t going to be optimal.

It was mildly amusing to see NZ so highly ranked. I plan to discuss that with the not-few New Zealanders who have come into my part of the country. I know one of the reasons why they immigrated (land is impossibly expensive in NZ) but I’m sure I don’t know all of the reasons.
Ridge, we’re to New Zealanders, what Mexico is to Canadiens. A cheap place to hide after they’ve made their money.

Honestly I don’t think the diseases which travelers carry here represent a significant expense. I agree with coatimundi, a lot of it is down to our life styles. Also the for profit nature of our system. If you compare the price of medicines here to any of the Nations which scored above us it’s pretty obvious we are over paying for these items. Poor lifestyles cause us to require more care, and to experience more health issues which require the more expensive medicines. The only barrier we have to care is the insurance we have or don’t have. If you have insurance they decide what they’ll cover, and won’t cover. This is for the general population. I assume wealthy folks can buy any insurance they please. If you are denied a prescription you of course have the option of purchasing it yourself. But for medical test the cost is prohibitive. Which explains why the insurance company didn’t want to pay either. 🙂 If you don’t have insurance you can foot the bill if you are able or do without.

So, an insurance company is acting as the gate keeper to our healthcare system. Most Physicians are trained to check with your insurance before they prescribe treatment. Which protects you from showing up for a test and being asked for your credit card. I’ve had the hospital call me ahead of time to tell me what by out of pocket is going to be for an MRI.

ATB
 
Ridge, we’re to New Zealanders, what Mexico is to Canadiens. A cheap place to hide after they’ve made their money.

Honestly I don’t think the diseases which travelers carry here represent a significant expense. I agree with coatimundi, a lot of it is down to our life styles. Also the for profit nature of our system. If you compare the price of medicines here to any of the Nations which scored above us it’s pretty obvious we are over paying for these items. Poor lifestyles cause us to require more care, and to experience more health issues which require the more expensive medicines. The only barrier we have to care is the insurance we have or don’t have. If you have insurance they decide what they’ll cover, and won’t cover. This is for the general population. I assume wealthy folks can buy any insurance they please. If you are denied a prescription you of course have the option of purchasing it yourself. But for medical test the cost is prohibitive. Which explains why the insurance company didn’t want to pay either. 🙂 If you don’t have insurance you can foot the bill if you are able or do without.

So, an insurance company is acting as the gate keeper to our healthcare system. Most Physicians are trained to check with your insurance before they prescribe treatment. Which protects you from showing up for a test and being asked for your credit card. I’ve had the hospital call me ahead of time to tell me what by out of pocket is going to be for an MRI.

ATB
Of the Kiwis I know here, some are wealthy and some are not. They’re here because this part of the U.S. is in the “green fescue” belt and also in the “Bermuda belt”; ideal for raising livestock (kind of a complicated subject, and another story entirely), and because land is incomparably less expensive here than it is in NZ. I have heard them say you can’t buy land in NZ and make livestock work out financially. Only those who already own it can do anything with it, and the quantity of useable land is pretty limited besides.

I would disagree with you about the health conditions of many of our recent immigrants. I know medical people who treat them, and there are a number of serious health problems. One of them is antibiotic-resistant bacterial strains they brought with them. Why antibiotic resistant? Because in their home countries you can buy the most powerful antibiotics (just as one example) imaginable over the counter without prescription. And they use them to self-treat all sorts of things they’re not designed for, don’t take the proper regimen when they are the proper thing, and don’t know how to deal with drug interactions. The health toll of that alone is very significant.

In much of Latin America, the diets are poor from birth, the diseases and parasites people deal with can cause lasting problems when they’re young, and because of utterly mistaken notions about what to do if you have “X” symptoms. Those people bring those things with them. Sometime it would be interesting for you to look at the “traditional” diseases in the back of the DSM. It will make your jaw drop to see what some people believe about medicine and what they do about medical conditions. Did you self-diagnose “Impacho”? Well, the remedy is to take Cipro or whatever else you think might work, and stop cheating on your spouse.

Any health provider who deals with recent immigrants from relatively primitive places will tell you the neglect of serious conditions is appalling. You have high blood pressure? Well, you’re less of a man if you chain yourself to medicine every day. You have diabetes? Well, that’s what “white” doctors tell you so they can sell you medicine and keep you coming back and change your diet to something you won’t like.

Many immigrants have been exposed to very serious environmental hazards, sometimes over a long period. Most of the first world is pretty clean of such stuff, however little environmentalists think so. But in much of the world, environmental hazards are pervasive and serious, and people are exposed to heavy metals, incredible air pollution, even radiation.

As to overpaying for medicines, there’s some truth to it, though not totally so. I have, in connection with part of my occupation, had occasion to investigate foreign-produced drugs. Most of the cheap ones are analogues; some even made by the same pharmaceutical companies that make our own. There are differences, more often than not; some of them significant, some only more or less convenient. And they’re very often made in places one might question, even when they’re made by a first world pharmaceutical company. Dig into some of those Canadian mail order drugs and you’ll find that a lot of them are made in places like India, Thailand or even Vietnam, no matter who the company is. Maybe it’s wise to trust your heart to statins made in Bangladesh. Maybe not so much.

And somebody is going to be the “gatekeeper” for treatment no matter what. People aren’t too fond of insurance companies doing it. But one has to ask oneself whether they really and truly expect the government to do a better job of it. The only healthcare system in this country that is NOT actually operated by insurance companies is VA and, well, that isn’t a system to write home about.
 
Of the Kiwis I know here, some are wealthy and some are not. They’re here because this part of the U.S. is in the “green fescue” belt and also in the “Bermuda belt”; ideal for raising livestock (kind of a complicated subject, and another story entirely), and because land is incomparably less expensive here than it is in NZ. I have heard them say you can’t buy land in NZ and make livestock work out financially. Only those who already own it can do anything with it, and the quantity of useable land is pretty limited besides.

I would disagree with you about the health conditions of many of our recent immigrants. I know medical people who treat them, and there are a number of serious health problems. One of them is antibiotic-resistant bacterial strains they brought with them. Why antibiotic resistant? Because in their home countries you can buy the most powerful antibiotics (just as one example) imaginable over the counter without prescription. And they use them to self-treat all sorts of things they’re not designed for, don’t take the proper regimen when they are the proper thing, and don’t know how to deal with drug interactions. The health toll of that alone is very significant.

In much of Latin America, the diets are poor from birth, the diseases and parasites people deal with can cause lasting problems when they’re young, and because of utterly mistaken notions about what to do if you have “X” symptoms. Those people bring those things with them. Sometime it would be interesting for you to look at the “traditional” diseases in the back of the DSM. It will make your jaw drop to see what some people believe about medicine and what they do about medical conditions. Did you self-diagnose “Impacho”? Well, the remedy is to take Cipro or whatever else you think might work, and stop cheating on your spouse.

Any health provider who deals with recent immigrants from relatively primitive places will tell you the neglect of serious conditions is appalling. You have high blood pressure? Well, you’re less of a man if you chain yourself to medicine every day. You have diabetes? Well, that’s what “white” doctors tell you so they can sell you medicine and keep you coming back and change your diet to something you won’t like.

Many immigrants have been exposed to very serious environmental hazards, sometimes over a long period. Most of the first world is pretty clean of such stuff, however little environmentalists think so. But in much of the world, environmental hazards are pervasive and serious, and people are exposed to heavy metals, incredible air pollution, even radiation.

As to overpaying for medicines, there’s some truth to it, though not totally so. I have, in connection with part of my occupation, had occasion to investigate foreign-produced drugs. Most of the cheap ones are analogues; some even made by the same pharmaceutical companies that make our own. There are differences, more often than not; some of them significant, some only more or less convenient. And they’re very often made in places one might question, even when they’re made by a first world pharmaceutical company. Dig into some of those Canadian mail order drugs and you’ll find that a lot of them are made in places like India, Thailand or even Vietnam, no matter who the company is. Maybe it’s wise to trust your heart to statins made in Bangladesh. Maybe not so much.

And somebody is going to be the “gatekeeper” for treatment no matter what. People aren’t too fond of insurance companies doing it. But one has to ask oneself whether they really and truly expect the government to do a better job of it. The only healthcare system in this country that is NOT actually operated by insurance companies is VA and, well, that isn’t a system to write home about.
These are some of the customary dodges. Immigrants, and the Federal programs. Most people know that medicare is the most cost efficient health insurance program in our nation. If the laws were less demanding of quick payment. They could really address fraud problems. But that fight is for another day.

I’m sorry you’ve had a bad experience with the VA. For my fathers care we both like the team approach, and honesty of the staff. We realize the VA is very different compared to say the University Hospital, or Detroit Medical Center. But the facilities are modern and the care is great. Though I should point out that some of his medicines do come from a third world nation. Ireland. :irish3:

ATB
 
These are some of the customary dodges. Immigrants, and the Federal programs. Most people know that medicare is the most cost efficient health insurance program in our nation. If the laws were less demanding of quick payment. They could really address fraud problems. But that fight is for another day.

I’m sorry you’ve had a bad experience with the VA. For my fathers care we both like the team approach, and honesty of the staff. We realize the VA is very different compared to say the University Hospital, or Detroit Medical Center. But the facilities are modern and the care is great. Though I should point out that some of his medicines do come from a third world nation. Ireland. :irish3:

ATB
Never did I say I oppose immigration. But anybody who is familiar with illegal immigrants knows very well that they bring all kinds of health problems with them and that they self-treat with powerful medicines they don’t know how to use. I said that only with reference to the usual charge that the American healthcare system was (it’s on the way out) more exensive and less successful than that of other countries. Other countries do not treat illegals at all. We do, and very expensively for a number of reasons; poor underlying health being one of them.

But the American healthcare system is being dismantled very rapidly anyway, so from now on those who praise foreign systems are going to have to make a moving comparison.

I take it you are unaware that VA is the ONLY health system that’s actually administered by the government. The government contracts with private insurance companies to administer the rest of them in all aspects other than policy and fraud.

I am aware that VA hospitals and clinics vary a great deal from place to place. Some are quite good. Some are not good at all.

Some medications that are SAID to come from Britain are actually made in the third world if you dig into it. Possibly the same is true of those said to have been made in Ireland. I have not had occasion to run across that.

And Americans are free to buy imported medications. Some do, but most don’t.
 
Never did I say I oppose immigration. But anybody who is familiar with illegal immigrants knows very well that they bring all kinds of health problems with them and that they self-treat with powerful medicines they don’t know how to use. I said that only with reference to the usual charge that the American healthcare system was (it’s on the way out) more exensive and less successful than that of other countries. Other countries do not treat illegals at all. We do, and very expensively for a number of reasons; poor underlying health being one of them.

But the American healthcare system is being dismantled very rapidly anyway, so from now on those who praise foreign systems are going to have to make a moving comparison.

I take it you are unaware that VA is the ONLY health system that’s actually administered by the government. The government contracts with private insurance companies to administer the rest of them in all aspects other than policy and fraud.

I am aware that VA hospitals and clinics vary a great deal from place to place. Some are quite good. Some are not good at all.

Some medications that are SAID to come from Britain are actually made in the third world if you dig into it. Possibly the same is true of those said to have been made in Ireland. I have not had occasion to run across that.

And Americans are free to buy imported medications. Some do, but most don’t.
I’m not sure if you are attempting to defend something or just tossing out thoughts here. You seem to be throwing up your hands when you say our system is being dismantled anyway. So, we’ll move on.

How do you explain our poor ranking on something we both seem to enjoy Internet access? To start with, I find Internet access necessary for doing my job. It is much more efficient time wise to look up a code or MSDS on line than to thumb through a book. Not too mention books are expensive and are generally only pertinent for a few years. So why is it that only one in five Americans has access to this? Is it cost, or something to do with how the various companies are managed?

ATB

.
 
I’m not sure if you are attempting to defend something or just tossing out thoughts here. You seem to be throwing up your hands when you say our system is being dismantled anyway. So, we’ll move on.

How do you explain our poor ranking on something we both seem to enjoy Internet access? To start with, I find Internet access necessary for doing my job. It is much more efficient time wise to look up a code or MSDS on line than to thumb through a book. Not too mention books are expensive and are generally only pertinent for a few years. So why is it that only one in five Americans has access to this? Is it cost, or something to do with how the various companies are managed?

ATB

.
I don’t know what you’re saying in your second paragraph. Perhaps you could clarify.

I do believe the American healthcare system, as it was, is being dismantled. There are arguments made that it deserved to be dismantled. But I don’t think anyone can really argue that it isn’t being changed profoundly; and not just by obamacare, though Obamacare is a big factor.
 
I don’t know what you’re saying in your second paragraph. Perhaps you could clarify.

I do believe the American healthcare system, as it was, is being dismantled. There are arguments made that it deserved to be dismantled. But I don’t think anyone can really argue that it isn’t being changed profoundly; and not just by obamacare, though Obamacare is a big factor.
One of the categories we ranked surprisingly low on was internet access. I was wondering how you might explain that. As I recall, we invented the Internet (with Al Gores help of course).

Dismantling is not changing profoundly? 🙂
 
One of the categories we ranked surprisingly low on was internet access. I was wondering how you might explain that. As I recall, we invented the Internet (with Al Gores help of course).

Dismantling is not changing profoundly? 🙂
I have no idea why internet access in the U.S. is low compared to some other countries if, indeed, it’s true. I can hazard a guess that there are a fair number of pretty remote places in the U.S. where people live, but where access might not be all that great. I don’t know, though whether “internet access” in this context means “not available” or “didn’t hook on, but could have”
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top