X
Xantippe
Guest
Great. The kid’s financial aid gets assessed based on the parents’ ability to help, they refuse to help at all, and the kid gets stuck with whole burden–both his share and their share.I think there are provisions for those kinds of situations. A student in foster care would probably be considered an orphan because parental rights are affected. The state has custody of the child.
I know other kids who have dire situations who get a lot of one on one help with the FAFSA and get a lot of financial aid.
I think the list was created to end people trying to buck the system. I know a few decades ago kids would move out of their homes for a year, get jobs, have their parents not claim them on taxes, and file independent. You can still do that, but you have to be 24 years old, which is exactly past the age that most students are done with undergraduate work. Also, a student is not going to get any special treatment by saying their parents don’t want to help them. A high percentage of parents look at the cost of college and say they can’t help, then the students whine because they think every other student/family has it easier than they do. In the end, the parents do not have to provide higher education for their kids, just like they don’t have to pay for anything else they deemed too expensive, like let’s say being on the swim team in high school. They get to decide for themselves what they are going to pay for. Even if the parents won’t pay, though, the household income needs to be reported.
College prices are set based on the assumption of a reasonably helpful family–they aren’t set on the assumption that middle class and upper middle class parents boot their kids out the door permanently at 18. A young adult with a high school diploma is just barely capable of supporting himself on his earnings–to expect that he will both support himself and pay 100% for college is ridiculous, especially if he’s coming out of a family that can afford nice things. Furthermore, if he takes out loans (which a young person in that position frequently does), he will be that much more burdened when attempting the various other tasks of young adulthood: finding jobs, marrying, and raising children of his own. Student loans don’t disappear just because you have a family now, and your spouse may well have student loans of her own. (The average graduate with student loans now finishes with $35k in student loan debt–and a lot of those people had help from family. If two average indebted graduates marry, that’s $70k just in student loan debt)
People complain about today’s late marriages, but I think it’s virtually miraculous that the median couple is able to marry even in their late 20s, given all the financial obstacles they face.
Parents who don’t make a reasonable effort to put their children on track for a profession that can support a family are failing at parenthood.
(I understand not helping with college if there’s serious misbehavior going on, but that wasn’t in your example–you just mentioned it as being “too expensive.”)