(continued)
(regarding my point that the mob certainly didn’t think Joseph was going to be convicted, since they took the law into their own…guns…)
Since when does mob rule have any logic behind it, whatsoever?
But you keep coming up with things to justify it, Rebecca. You keep defending it; you are it’s modern day cheerleader. Rah! Rah! BOOM…take THAT, you polygamist you! Sis! BOOM! And THAT, you taker apart of printing presses! YAY, YAY, YAY…How DARE the man actually attempt to defend himself against a mob of 200 men shooting his brother and the room 'to doll rags!" why, it’s obviously ALL HIS FAULT! I mean, gee, if he had only…what, NOT shot back AFTER the mob killed his brother, then all would have been well, and Hyrum would have arisen, the bullet magically disappearing out of his head and back into the gun that fired it, and the mob would have quietly gone back into the righteous night from which it came?
Rebecca, reasons for this there always are, just as there were REASONS for the MMM. But unlike the MMM, the REASONS for the murder of Joseph and Hyrum in Carthage, and for the murder of the people at Haun’s Mill, and the torture of Joseph (and the death of his son) did not include deaths at the hands of Mormons.
The reasons for the MMM did.
There is a very large difference between us, Rebecca. Even though I acknowledge reasons for both events; Carthage and the MMM, I condemn both; reasons are never justifications, any more than motives are justifications. One is as inexcusable as the other. You, however, will not admit that there were reasons for the MMM, and attempt to justify Carthage. You are letting your own biases embitter your views.
I am not justifying the hatred.
Yeah, you are.
I am not inline with your party line that he was a saint. He was not. He was a philandering conman.
…and you are justifying the death penalty at the hands of a mob as justification for his actions. Please look back at all my posts; I have never ONCE claimed that Joseph didn’t deserve his death because he was a saint or a prophet. I believe that he was a prophet, but that is actually irrelevant to my objection to what happened to him. Tell me, if it had been any other bigamist in that room, would you have considered the mob murder justified the way you do because it was Joseph Smith? If it had been anothe ‘con man,’ would you believe that the proper punishment for his crimes was death at the hands of a mob?
Something tells me that no, you wouldn’t. So…why do you think Joseph deserved it?
No, Rebecca, it’s not ME who is referring to Joseph’s claim to be a prophet. You are. I’m not claiming that Joseph was too good/saintly/whatever to have been treated this way. My claim is that NOBODY should be treated that way, and my quarrel is with those who think it was because they don’t like his religion.
How many times do I have to tell you? I do not believe murder is justified, for any reason. This includes the murder of JS.
At least one more time than you cheer for, justify and excuse the murderers, and at least one more time than you blame Joseph for his own murder. You are having some difficulty with that.
I agree. What I don’t agree with is that he was the wee lamb so innocent and white led to the slaughter. He was not. You also attempt to paint this black and white story, when the story is very complex. JS had a very direct hand in the building of the resentment against himself. Criminal and immoral actions that he painted as “religion”. It was a deception then. It is a deception now.
Like I said, you have to tell me that you do not believe murder is justified at least one more time than you attempt to justify it…or blame Joseph for it. You just don’t seem to be able to help yourself here…
JS was not a martyr. Martyrs are holy people who are pure before God. They die for the truth of Jesus Crucified. They are not adulterers who die as a result of their political ambitions and the desire to bed many women under a deceit they themselves name “plural marriage”.
A martyr is someone who is put to death because of his religious beliefs, or who suffers death rather than renounce his religious beliefs. Joseph Smith DID NOT HAVE TO GO TO CARTHAGE. He knew what would happen if he went, but he went anyway; he turned himself in. That makes him a martyr even in your sense of the word. However, what really makes him a martyr is that if the problem were only the printing press, or the fact that he had more than one wife, he wouldn’t have been in that situation; he was murdered because of his religion. YOU may not like that religion, but you cannot deny that it was his religion that was the reason he was killed.
Finally, there is no requirement that the Christian had to hold hamburger when walking into the lion’s den. Those people ran, they screamed, they hid–they tried to pull the animals away from their loved ones…Paul pulled many legal shenanigans in order to avoid his own death…and was pretty successful for quite awhile. Are you going to tell me that these people were not martyrs?
Didn’t think so.