NFP abused is sinful

  • Thread starter Thread starter tundra1
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
The Church has not given blanket permission to any married couple to use NFP in order to try avoiding children. It has said that for serious and grave reasons, a couple may use NFP to avoid children temporarliy, until the reasons are resolved.

If you think of a child as an accident or a mistake, that is the contraceptive mindset.

Pax Christi
Hi, the Church actually does not state that avoiding pregnancy must be temporary. It recognizes that some conditions may be permanent. A couple with a just reason (for which there is not list availble…it is for a couple to discern) may avoid pregnancy by tracking the woman’s cycles and abstaining from sex during the fertile period. The Church has stated that this method respects the bodies of the spouses and has many other benefits to the couple (see HV and CCC 2366-2379).

NFP can not be seen as part of a contraceptive mindset. And seeing a child as an accident is not a contracaptive thought. Here is a brief quote from a recent article that I will also post a link to:

"Thinking about contraception and NFP in this way, it is quite clear that there is no possible way in which natural family planning could entail a contraceptive mentality. There is nothing contraceptive about NFP, therefore it cannot induce a contraceptive mentality. While it is theoretically possible that NFP could be used in a bad way (and even in a sinful way), it cannot possibly be used in a contraceptive way.

We may speak of the dangers of a “selfish” mentality, or even of a “sinful” mentality, but we simply cannot speak of a “contraceptive” mentality when it comes to natural family planning. Words are important; they communicate either truth or falsehood. Hence it is false and harmful to claim that NFP entails the danger of inducing a contraceptive mentality." from here: catholicexchange.com/2011/11/07/137540/
 
Maybe or maybe not. Who knows what is wrong and what’s not in a relationship towards family planning.
Salvation should be discussed in a separate thread though.
Marriage is a sacrament. The sacraments are vehicles of Grace that help us get to heaven. One cannot separate sacramental marriage from salvation.
 
Marriage is a sacrament. The sacraments are vehicles of Grace that help us get to heaven. One cannot separate sacramental marriage from salvation.
Well, it seems it would be off topic here.
One’s salvation depends on many more things than just NFP.
 
Hi, the Church actually does not state that avoiding pregnancy must be temporary. It recognizes that some conditions may be permanent. A couple with a just reason (for which there is not list availble…it is for a couple to discern) may avoid pregnancy by tracking the woman’s cycles and abstaining from sex during the fertile period. The Church has stated that this method respects the bodies of the spouses and has many other benefits to the couple (see HV and CCC 2366-2379).

NFP can not be seen as part of a contraceptive mindset. And seeing a child as an accident is not a contracaptive thought. Here is a brief quote from a recent article that I will also post a link to:

"Thinking about contraception and NFP in this way, it is quite clear that there is no possible way in which natural family planning could entail a contraceptive mentality. There is nothing contraceptive about NFP, therefore it cannot induce a contraceptive mentality. While it is theoretically possible that NFP could be used in a bad way (and even in a sinful way), it cannot possibly be used in a contraceptive way.

We may speak of the dangers of a “selfish” mentality, or even of a “sinful” mentality, but we simply cannot speak of a “contraceptive” mentality when it comes to natural family planning. Words are important; they communicate either truth or falsehood. Hence it is false and harmful to claim that NFP entails the danger of inducing a contraceptive mentality." from here: catholicexchange.com/2011/11/07/137540/
Yes, I read the article. Someone had posted a link earlier in this thread. I respectfully disagree with the author’s conclusions. Perhaps we simply have different ideas of what “contraceptive mentality” means. If you have a sinful and selfish mindset (which the author agrees can happen) and that mindset drives you to try and reject the gift of children…that sounds exactly like a contraceptive mindset to me.

Pax
 
Yes, I read the article. Someone had posted a link earlier in this thread. I respectfully disagree with the author’s conclusions. Perhaps we simply have different ideas of what “contraceptive mentality” means. If you have a sinful and selfish mindset (which the author agrees can happen) and that mindset drives you to try and reject the gift of children…that sounds exactly like a contraceptive mindset to me.

Pax
It seems in a sense you are both correct. This is one of the biggest (if not the biggest) issues of NFP and Church’s teaching and it leaves many people scratching their heads.

Let me try a parallel. There is a green car. The Church say: “Under this circumstances by definition this car is BLUE.”

Some people accept the definition without any problem.
Some people will be confused.
Some people’s conscience will tell them that the car is really green.

What do you do?
AFAIK, the Church teaches that you are supposed to follow your conscience.
It’s between God and you.

BY DEFINITION the NFP is not contraceptive.
 
It seems in a sense you are both correct. This is one of the biggest (if not the biggest) issues of NFP and Church’s teaching and it leaves many people scratching their heads.

Let me try a parallel. There is a green car. The Church say: “Under this circumstances by definition this car is BLUE.”

Some people accept the definition without any problem.
Some people will be confused.
Some people’s conscience will tell them that the car is really green.

What do you do?
AFAIK, the Church teaches that you are supposed to follow your conscience.
It’s between God and you.

BY DEFINITION the NFP is not contraceptive.
Actually, the Church would not teach that a green car is blue, because that would not be the Truth.
I read the article as well, and well, it just seems like the only conclusion I can get from it is that he does not think we should use the term contraceptive mentality, not that it doesn’t exist, but that it would be a misnomer to use it. Although I do think the name is fitting, I can see his point, it could confuse people into thinking NFP can be some sort of contraception, when that is very much incorrect. To me it is the difference between using NFP because you are open to being blessed with more vs using NFP in spite of it suggesting that you are open to more. The latter might throw a fit if they do get pregnant while using NFP and switch over to ABC or be mad at the Church for not “allowing” ABC etc.
 
Actually, the Church would not teach that a green car is blue, because that would not be the Truth.
I read the article as well, and well, it just seems like the only conclusion I can get from it is that he does not think we should use the term contraceptive mentality, not that it doesn’t exist, but that it would be a misnomer to use it. Although I do think the name is fitting, I can see his point, it could confuse people into thinking NFP can be some sort of contraception, when that is very much incorrect. To me it is the difference between using NFP because you are open to being blessed with more vs using NFP in spite of it suggesting that you are open to more. The latter might throw a fit if they do get pregnant while using NFP and switch over to ABC or be mad at the Church for not “allowing” ABC etc.
HV:
Neither the Church nor her doctrine is inconsistent when she considers it lawful for married people to take advantage of the infertile period but condemns as always unlawful the use of means which directly prevent conception, even when the reasons given for the later practice may appear to be upright and serious. In reality, these two cases are completely different. In the former the married couple rightly use a faculty provided them by nature. In the later they obstruct the natural development of the generative process.
The Church does not consider NFP as direct prevention of conception.
By this definition/law (whatever you want to call it) it is not contraceptive.

Can you stop people from thinking we are avoiding babies when we use NFP.
You can not and many people think here it is contraceptive.

These are the facts.
 
HV:

The Church does not consider NFP as direct prevention of conception.
By this definition/law (whatever you want to call it) it is not contraceptive.

Can you stop people from thinking we are avoiding babies when we use NFP.
You can not and many people think here it is contraceptive.

These are the facts.
I think the difference of opinion is in what “contraception/contraceptive” means. I have been very sick lately precluding any activity with my husband, does that mean I am avoiding pregnancy? I think what the church is saying is that not having sex is not contraception. Contraceptive instead means that we are preventing pregnancy while we are engaged in the marital act. If you are not engaged in the marital act you cannot be ‘contracepting.’
 
Are you sure what is Divine will?
Is the Divine will that you are supposed to follow Church’s Magisterium without any thinking?
The same Magisterium tells us that you may choose not to have babies. So what now?
*This is a question I have been quibbling with for about ten plus years now and it is still king of muddy and unclear so I am wondering if you and tohers could help me sort through some of it.
( I can not believe I am talking about this on a public forum.:o It just goes to show that one should never say never!)
Anyway, my first question is can you please help me understand what it means to be open to life?
I was raised with the understanding you did not worry about how you could or could not provide for the children God sent your way and therefore should do nothing to keep from having as many children as God wanted you to have. My father was huge into just trusting Divine Providence to provide for everything that would be needed. So even NFP was out of the question.
My husband was raised you did not have any more children than you could care or provide for. Mentally and physically and I will add spiritually.
I tried talking to a few people about this and doing my own research on it…personaly I would be perfectly happy to live the way I was raised…and it still nags at me and makes me wonder if I should push the issue with my husband and insist that he be more open to more children. I remember asking a priest about this a while back at one time and he had reminded me that God charge us with being good stewards of our children.
In reflecting on this I believe that is where my husband is coming from. He is just trying to be a good steward of his children that he does have, he does not believe he can be this with any more and is barely able to be a good stewards with the three that we have.

The only way we are able to make ends meet or get the proper care and education for our children right now is through various government programs and what he makes at his full time job and doing lawn care on his days off. I am currently trying to find a job but with one vehicle now it has even put that on hold to some extent. I am still hopeful of trying to do something from home to help.

Anyway, to make a long story short, I see how hard having the three children is on us as a family. He does not get to spend much time with them or me because of all the hours he is working and how and what he can do with the children and me is very limited too because of finances and time. But we do what we can when we can. This is hard on the family, mentally, physically and spiritually, so this is the main reason we do not believe we can be good stewards of our children if we try to add any more to our family. This is why we try practicing NFP.

I, personally had always wanted to get married young and have a slew of children, now I tell myself God must have other plans for me…but I always have this nagging feeling that I am not trusting Him enough and because of this I am not open to life… the biggest question I have always had is if we are being selfish in our actions or not…
Since practicing NFP we did become pregnant. Miss-calculated or something. Anyway,…it did truly amazed me and was a wonderful and beautiful thing to experience, how calm and accepting my husband was with the reality of another child. He never once said anything to even hint at getting an abortion or that he did not want the baby. He has a wonderful way of just saying; “it is what it is” and just “dealing” with it. We did eventually miss-carry the child and I know it was not just me who was genuinely disappointed or saddened about it.
Since he was so accepting of the child I took it that he really was open to life but when I thought I might be pregnant a few months ago…one of the first things he said was that he wanted to go and get himself fixed…to ensure it did not happen again…he never did but it did scare me so I just asked him to please promise that he would talk to the priest at our church before he had the operation…
On another note, I have asked him if finances where different would it change his opinion of having more children or not and he said it would definitely make a difference…

So is any of this sinful? Are we being open to life?
 
I will say again, as I did in a much earlier post on this thread; there seems to be a big problem with terminology. IMO, we should not introduce terms like “contraceptive mentality” which are at best loosely defined,and at worst purely subjective.

The Church does not use these this term, rather it uses very clear and concise language:

From the CCC
2368 A particular aspect of this responsibility concerns the regulation of procreation. For just reasons, spouses may wish to space the births of their children. It is their duty to make certain that their desire is not motivated by selfishness but is in conformity with the generosity appropriate to responsible parenthood. Moreover, they should conform their behavior to the objective criteria of morality:
When it is a question of harmonizing married love with the responsible transmission of life, the morality of the behavior does not depend on sincere intention and evaluation of motives alone; but it must be determined by objective criteria, criteria drawn from the nature of the person and his acts criteria that respect the total meaning of mutual self-giving and human procreation in the context of true love; this is possible only if the virtue of married chastity is practiced with sincerity of heart
This can also be shown from the paragraph from HV that Jaaanosik just quoted with respect to artificial birth control (a problematic term also, IMO, as the definition of artificial is not always clear), rather it says “as always unlawful the use of means which directly prevent conception”.

The decision to use NFP should be based on purely objective criteria, ie it should be a clearly defined moral choice. This is best accomplished in consultation with a priest.
 
I think the difference of opinion is in what “contraception/contraceptive” means. I have been very sick lately precluding any activity with my husband, does that mean I am avoiding pregnancy? I think what the church is saying is that not having sex is not contraception. Contraceptive instead means that we are preventing pregnancy while we are engaged in the marital act. If you are not engaged in the marital act you cannot be ‘contracepting.’
I am glad you clarified this. It answers a question that has been nagging me.
 
I tried reading most of this thread however it has gotten very large 🙂 This may have been addressed already…

FH & I are going to use NFP for first year of marriage, our wedding night is on the predicted peak fertility of my cycle. We have decided not to abstain the night of the wedding, as we feel it would be against Our Lord’s plan.

Is this correct?
 
I tried reading most of this thread however it has gotten very large 🙂 This may have been addressed already…

FH & I are going to use NFP for first year of marriage, our wedding night is on the predicted peak fertility of my cycle. We have decided not to abstain the night of the wedding, as we feel it would be against Our Lord’s plan.

Is this correct?
You and your spouse may abstain if you prayerfully decide it is for the best, but you could also be open to a honeymoon baby, which brings many blessings, as I and a few other posters on this forum know.
 
It seems in a sense you are both correct. This is one of the biggest (if not the biggest) issues of NFP and Church’s teaching and it leaves many people scratching their heads.

Let me try a parallel. There is a green car. The Church say: “Under this circumstances by definition this car is BLUE.”

Some people accept the definition without any problem.
Some people will be confused.
Some people’s conscience will tell them that the car is really green.

What do you do?
AFAIK, the Church teaches that you are supposed to follow your conscience.
It’s between God and you.

BY DEFINITION the NFP is not contraceptive.
The Church is clear that we are bound to form our consciences to be in comformity with the absolute Truth of Holy Mother Church and to follow our well formed conscience.

We are not Jimmeny Cricket Christians who just follow every whim of a malformed conscience.

Relativism is very dangerous.
 
Actually, the Church would not teach that a green car is blue, because that would not be the Truth.
I read the article as well, and well, it just seems like the only conclusion I can get from it is that he does not think we should use the term contraceptive mentality, not that it doesn’t exist, but that it would be a misnomer to use it. Although I do think the name is fitting, I can see his point, it could confuse people into thinking NFP can be some sort of contraception, when that is very much incorrect. To me it is the difference between using NFP because you are open to being blessed with more vs using NFP in spite of it suggesting that you are open to more. The latter might throw a fit if they do get pregnant while using NFP and switch over to ABC or be mad at the Church for not “allowing” ABC etc.
Yes, I see what you are getting to. This kinda fits in with what Dan Daly and tafan posted as well, and I agree with that. (I must admit I read the article with a slight bias in that my wife and I were recently accused by a family member of “removing fecundity from the marital act” by practicing NFP. ) 🤷
 
It seems in a sense you are both correct. This is one of the biggest (if not the biggest) issues of NFP and Church’s teaching and it leaves many people scratching their heads.

Let me try a parallel. There is a green car. The Church say: “Under this circumstances by definition this car is BLUE.”

Some people accept the definition without any problem.
Some people will be confused.
Some people’s conscience will tell them that the car is really green.

What do you do?
AFAIK, the Church teaches that you are supposed to follow your conscience.
It’s between God and you.

BY DEFINITION the NFP is not contraceptive.
I disagree.

What does contraceptive mean? Against conception. So if NFP is used to deliberately try avoiding conception, it would by definition be contraceptive. The Church seems to agree with this, as recent documents state that the Church is against “artificial contraception”. That terminology naturally implies that there is some form of “natural contraception”.

Pax Christi
 
I disagree.

What does contraceptive mean? Against conception. So if NFP is used to deliberately try avoiding conception, it would by definition be contraceptive. The Church seems to agree with this, as recent documents state that the Church is against “artificial contraception”. That terminology naturally implies that there is some form of “natural contraception”.

Pax Christi
As jilly4ski pointed out. If you don’t have sex you are not contracepting.
You are not DIRECTLY preventing conception.
If you are happy to see it differently that’s fine.
 
I disagree.

What does contraceptive mean? Against conception. So if NFP is used to deliberately try avoiding conception, it would by definition be contraceptive. The Church seems to agree with this, as recent documents state that the Church is against “artificial contraception”. That terminology naturally implies that there is some form of “natural contraception”.

Pax Christi
So, my husband and I must have sex every night, or else we are contracepting. Is that what you believe?
 
So, my husband and I must have sex every night, or else we are contracepting. Is that what you believe?
That would be one way for a spouse to have more sex. If you don’t have sex, you are contracepting, which is a sin. You will go to Hell if you don’t have sex now! 😛

I could see that taking off.
 
I disagree.

What does contraceptive mean? Against conception. So if NFP is used to deliberately try avoiding conception, it would by definition be contraceptive. The Church seems to agree with this, as recent documents state that the Church is against “artificial contraception”. That terminology naturally implies that there is some form of “natural contraception”.

Pax Christi
No, I don’t think we can assume that the Church implies that there is a “natural contraception”. No where in any Church document or tradition is there anything that suggests such.

Also, NFP doesn’t fit the “against conception” definition because there is not an act taking place to go against conception. There is simply avoidance of an act. Is conception avoided by avoiding an act…yes. But you can’t say that act was contraceptive because the act never took place. You can’t “deliberately frustrate” (as the Church puts it) an act that isn’t taking place.

And for that reason, NFP is not contraception. If NFP is used selfishly, it is an act of selfishness, not of contraception, because you can point to the selfishness of avoiding children without a good reason…but you cannot point to the contraceptive nature of something that never took place.

There now…I believe I finally understand what that author was trying to say (now that my head is cleared). I agree with that article. 🙂

-ahs
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top