NJ Defeats Stem Cell Measure on Ballot

  • Thread starter Thread starter GladCatholic
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
G

GladCatholic

Guest
NJ voters defeated the stem cell measure on the ballot. This is the first defeat (there were two this election) on a ballot question since 1990. The governor lobbied hard for the passing of this measure. The interpretative question failed to mention embryonic stem cell research and cloning. The failure to include relevant wording in the interpretative statement wound up in court where a judge decided against revising the text. This is a huge step forward, although it’s probably certain it was defeated because it would’ve resulted in a tax increase.

nj.com/news/ledger/index.ssf?/base/news-12/119441839995980.xml&coll=1

GladCatholic
 
Expect them now to go to the courts to overturn the will of the people :rolleyes:
 
I shouldn’t be shocked by this, but notice how this is being interpreted by some of the supporters of this initiative. They are basically stating that the voters want this, but it didn’t pass strictly because of the fear of higher taxes:

philly.com/inquirer/politics/20071107_Stem-cell__tax-relief_initiatives_defeated_in_N_J_.html

I also agree with the OP that the interpretation on the ballot was very misleading. However, my local diocese (Trenton) did a good job in guiding Catholics on this one.

God Bless,
Gary
 
I’m from NJ, and specifically voted “no” because of the unclear wording. I am all FOR stem cell research. I am NOT for HUMAN embryonic stem cell research.

Frankly, I would surprised that the voters were subtle enough to discern the language problem and (with our property taxes) would go with the interpretation that the people just don’t want higher taxes: no way, no how, not for NUTTIN’
 
Im from Nj also–Bishop Smith did do a great job in getting out the word. I agree re: the wording. if it said adult stem cell research, I don’t think there would be an issue. I am glad it did not pass as is.
 
👍

Let’s pray that as people learn more about the differences with different forms of stem cell research & problems with embryonic stem cell research that we’ll see more of this. With more positive funding and support for non-embryonic stem cell research.
 
I’m from NJ, and specifically voted “no” because of the unclear wording. I am all FOR stem cell research. I am NOT for HUMAN embryonic stem cell research.

Frankly, I would surprised that the voters were subtle enough to discern the language problem and (with our property taxes) would go with the interpretation that the people just don’t want higher taxes: no way, no how, not for NUTTIN’
I agree that the voters were not “subtle enough to discern the language problem”–I think they voted this way specifically because of the resultant tax increase. Our Diocese, Camden, also did a great job in getting the word out. Fact is, I highly doubt it was defeated because of NJ’s “high moral ground.”

GladCatholic
 
I agree that the voters were not “subtle enough to discern the language problem”–I think they voted this way specifically because of the resultant tax increase. Our Diocese, Camden, also did a great job in getting the word out. Fact is, I highly doubt it was defeated because of NJ’s “high moral ground.”

GladCatholic
Up in the Diocese of Newark, they did a good job getting the message out also. At least to those who took the time to listen.

BTW: Mort Smith was once pastor of my parish. 👍
 
Fact is, I highly doubt it was defeated because of NJ’s “high moral ground.”
Glad,
While I partially agree with your statement, I don’t feel it would have been defeated without the efforts of the various dioceses.

God Bless,
Gary
 
Glad,
While I partially agree with your statement, I don’t feel it would have been defeated without the efforts of the various dioceses.

God Bless,
Gary
Probably, because the margin wasn’t that great, so I do believe a minority of people affected the outcome.

GladCatholic
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top