Ridgerunner,
My parents, having also learned lessons from the Depression, also stressed the importance of saving and paying cash for everything. During those Visa commercials in which one person slows down the line by using cash, or writing a check, instead of using the debit card, I cheer for the person who pays with cash.
I often wonder how much of the current economic pinch is really due to low wages and how much is due to overconsumption that is hard for people to recognize when it occurs. I think it’s very easy for people to look at the consumption around them and assume something “must be wrong with me” if they don’t match it. People often seem to try to remedy that through the use of credit. If a person has enough debt, it really doesn’t matter how much he makes, he’s still in trouble.
Part of my job includes doing real estate closings. Anymore, banks and mortgage companies “outsource” closings entirely and simply send the package to a title company. I’ll confess I peek at the loan applications that come with the packages. I am simply baffled at how many of those people can possibly make it, and yet they’re getting “prime” loans 99% of the time. (No wonder Fannie and Freddie are in trouble) Absolutely everybody has at least some card debt and auto debt. Almost never does the wife not work.
I don’t wish to romanticize Hispanics, and I realize I’m seeing the ones who “qualify”, not the ones who don’t. But they almost never have consumer debt other than the home mortgage. Some of them can’t even speak English; virtually none can speak it well, and virtually all work line jobs. Half the time or more, the wife doesn’t work outside the home. But, knowing what the local factories pay, I can readily calculate from their W-2s that there’s a lot of overtime being worked. (Shame on me for looking) Of course, they’re also buying more modest homes than are the “Anglos”. Very big buyers of “fixer uppers”. By my observation, they do fix them up, too. In my town, at least, you can drive through the older parts of town and tell which ones they own most of the time. They’re like an “urban renewal” project, but without government money to do it with.
I almost never see young “Anglo” couples buying “fixer uppers” or really old homes that sell, around here anyway, from about $30,000 for a real “fixer upper” to $80,000 for a really nice one. They are the typical buyers of the smallish new subdivision homes that start at about $160.000, but are mostly just under the $200,000 mark.
All of that is anecdotal, and I know it is. Still, I wonder a lot whether most Americans have come to conclude that “living modestly”, particularly when starting out, is somehow unworthy of human existence, particularly if it entails a substantial amount of weekend labor.
This current recession (if that’s what one wants to call it) is, in my opinion, not called a “credit crisis” for nothing.