C
CopticChristian
Guest
Mark,Grace & Peace!
A few things:
So in the end, your message sounds like this: “Same-sex attracted folks are okay because they’re not homosexuals (!?!), but really they’re not okay because other apostolic churches clearly think they are homosexuals and while I agree with making a distinction between same-sex attracted folks and homosexuals, I also like to agree with the other apostolic churches because the catechism considers them valid churches.” Consequently, it’s hard to know what it is you’re actually saying beyond all of the pedantry, and the ideological gobbledy-gook which has little to do with Catholic orthodoxy and more to do with whatever psycho-social/political ax you have to grind.
- This original post represents the kookiest film review I think I’ve ever read.
- Coptic, you continue to want to redefine the word “homosexual” to refer only to same-sex attracted people who are sexually active. You can make the claim that that’s how the catechism understands the word, but you’d be wrong–as Dex pointed out, the catechism refers to “homosexual persons” in a context which suggests that both sexually active and non-sexually active same-sex attracted people are called to chastity. This is in keeping with the generally accepted meaning of the word: that it refers to people (regardless of their sexual activity) who are attracted to members of the same-sex. Both a homosexual Christian and, specifically, a homosexual Catholic are both possibilities according to the catechism–whether or not you can get beyond your own ideological preconceptions and accept that remains to be seen.
- On a related note, you provide a caveat intended to assure those who are same-sex attracted and not sexually active that you’re not talking about them when you use the word “homosexual.” Then you reference the teachings of other apostolic churches and their leaders that would consider your caveat to be making a worthless and sin-approving distinction. The Eastern and Coptic Churches have only recently begun thinking about making the distinction the RCC makes and which you attempt to make here–and the documents you quote (from two to three decades ago) certainly would not even countenance such a distinction.
Under the Mercy,
Mark
All is Grace and Mercy! Deo Gratias!
Concerning the film review…I am not Roger Ebert and I don’t work for the Sun Times…
So in a few words you don’t agree.