No Silence For This Lamb

  • Thread starter Thread starter CopticChristian
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Grace & Peace!

A few things:
  1. This original post represents the kookiest film review I think I’ve ever read.
  2. Coptic, you continue to want to redefine the word “homosexual” to refer only to same-sex attracted people who are sexually active. You can make the claim that that’s how the catechism understands the word, but you’d be wrong–as Dex pointed out, the catechism refers to “homosexual persons” in a context which suggests that both sexually active and non-sexually active same-sex attracted people are called to chastity. This is in keeping with the generally accepted meaning of the word: that it refers to people (regardless of their sexual activity) who are attracted to members of the same-sex. Both a homosexual Christian and, specifically, a homosexual Catholic are both possibilities according to the catechism–whether or not you can get beyond your own ideological preconceptions and accept that remains to be seen.
  3. On a related note, you provide a caveat intended to assure those who are same-sex attracted and not sexually active that you’re not talking about them when you use the word “homosexual.” Then you reference the teachings of other apostolic churches and their leaders that would consider your caveat to be making a worthless and sin-approving distinction. The Eastern and Coptic Churches have only recently begun thinking about making the distinction the RCC makes and which you attempt to make here–and the documents you quote (from two to three decades ago) certainly would not even countenance such a distinction.
So in the end, your message sounds like this: “Same-sex attracted folks are okay because they’re not homosexuals (!?!), but really they’re not okay because other apostolic churches clearly think they are homosexuals and while I agree with making a distinction between same-sex attracted folks and homosexuals, I also like to agree with the other apostolic churches because the catechism considers them valid churches.” Consequently, it’s hard to know what it is you’re actually saying beyond all of the pedantry, and the ideological gobbledy-gook which has little to do with Catholic orthodoxy and more to do with whatever psycho-social/political ax you have to grind.

Under the Mercy,
Mark

All is Grace and Mercy! Deo Gratias!
Mark,

Concerning the film review…I am not Roger Ebert and I don’t work for the Sun Times…

So in a few words you don’t agree.🙂
 
Hmm what was that?
A bunch of dirty lies, conspiracy theories, anti-scientific nonsense and mad ravings from mr Coptic. As usual, nothing interesting 😉
Lana,

some find the truth interesting and others do not.🙂
 
I don’t really know why I’m posting here even more than usual, really, as this ‘Moral Theology’ section seems to be all about Catholic stuff that I shouldn’t really play a part in, but whatever. I’m a rebel.

I guess I agree with you, when I could understand what you were saying. I am a tad slow, but whenever you make a thread the stuff you talk about seems a little disorganised, if you don’t mind me saying so. But you seem to be claiming that homosexuals can probably change if they so desire, and should be allowed to pursue that desire. I agree. If you’re stating that people with homosexual desires can pursue heterosexual relationships and not cure their homosexuality, I’d feel even more inclined to agree, though I would question whether those people were living fulfilling lives. I don’t see the issue with the existence of counselling to make people comfortable with their homosexuality, either, and to ban or oppose it is not really any better than LGBT groups attempting to ban conversion therapy. I don’t really know what you’re on about during the first half of your post, but that doesn’t matter. I’m an idiot. I’d disagree that a homosexual is merely someone who engages in homosexual behaviour, though. It’s normally used to refer to someone with a ‘homosexual orientation’ which would be someone with a certain psychological/biological disposition which makes them attracted to members of the same-sex.

There is one question, however, that I’d really like to ask, and it’s something I’ve never been able to get an answer for. Why do you have such an interest in homosexuality? Do you have a homosexual relative or something?

I’m not trying to imply anything (I know some people may ask similar questions in order to imply that you’re a closeted homosexual or something) but I am genuinely intrigued as to why so many of your threads are about homosexuality.
Regular,

I don’t know why you are posting here either. I see the practice of medicine in the realm of disease as honest and truthful as well as helpful. I find it distasteful that the field of behavior has been harnessed by politics. It is not the same animal and unfortunately this, in my opinion causes harm…and as you recall

primum no nocere…

Where there is untruth there I be…in a house, in the yard, in a car, have not really thought of going into a closet…not much room in there…but there it is and there you are…🙂
 
Grace & Peace!
So in a few words you don’t agree.🙂
It’s hard to tell–I couldn’t figure out if you liked Silence of the Lambs or disliked it…

…much like it’s difficult to tell what you’re talking about when your message sounds like: “Same-sex attracted folks are okay because they’re not homosexuals (!?!), but really they’re not okay because other apostolic churches clearly think they are homosexuals and while I agree with making a distinction between same-sex attracted folks and homosexuals, I also like to agree with the other apostolic churches because the catechism considers them valid churches.”

Me, I liked Silence of the Lambs. Anthony Hopkins did a good job. Ditto Jodie Foster.

(Also, Doctor, it’s “primum non nocere.”)

Under the Mercy,
Mark

All is Grace and Mercy! Deo Gratias!
 
Grace & Peace!

It’s hard to tell–I couldn’t figure out if you liked Silence of the Lambs or disliked it…

…much like it’s difficult to tell what you’re talking about when your message sounds like: “Same-sex attracted folks are okay because they’re not homosexuals (!?!), but really they’re not okay because other apostolic churches clearly think they are homosexuals and while I agree with making a distinction between same-sex attracted folks and homosexuals, I also like to agree with the other apostolic churches because the catechism considers them valid churches.”

Me, I liked Silence of the Lambs. Anthony Hopkins did a good job. Ditto Jodie Foster.

(Also, Doctor, it’s “primum non nocere.”)

Under the Mercy,
Mark

All is Grace and Mercy! Deo Gratias!
Mark,

This posting is only about homosexuals in action…
NO COMMENTS ARE IN REFERENCE TO SAME SEX ATTRACTION, ALTHOUGH CHANGE IS POSSIBLE FOR SSA. HOMOSEXUALITY IS ADDRESSED AS DESIRES ACTED ON THAT ARE IMMORAL AND NOT NATURAL.
You are welcome to start a thread on a topic of your choosing…

sadly the Anglican community is split

albertmohler.com/2007/08/20/heresy-precedes-homosexuality/

Heresy Precedes Homosexuality
The mere fact that the Rt. Rev. Gene Robinson is the Episcopal Church’s first openly homosexual bishop ensures that he will be a media celebrity on both sides of the Atlantic.
And he says the following…
So I was very encouraged by that. One day when I was ranting and raving about how much of the Nicene Creed I didn’t believe, he said ‘well, when you’re in church, just say the parts of the creed you do agree with. Be silent for the others. We’re not asking you do so something against your integrity’
Here you will find a discussion concerning denying the Creed leading to …well read…

Yes, Hopkins did great…I was disappointed to later discover that agent Starling, Foster, is gay…truly sad for me…🙂
 
Homosexual tendencies come from false education, lack of normal sexual development, from habit, bad example, may be transitory and not incurable. There are some that believe that this tendency is innate and therefore justifies their acts. There is no possibility to give any moral justification to homosexual acts on any grounds because they are condemned in Scripture.
I’m not attempting to justify homosexual actions. Nowhere on this thread have I done so.

I simply take issue with your statement that it is not possible to simply be both a homosexual and a Christian (or Catholic) at the same time and I point out that this proposition is clearly contrary to the Catechism of the Catholic Church.

By your logic it would only be possible to be a Christian if one was entirely perfect and free from all faults and sins… and, as I’m sure you know, there was only one person who was perfect, and his name was Jesus. The rest of us have to make do with being somewhat faulty, but those faults don’t stop us or disqualify us from being Christians.
 
Grace & Peace!
This posting is only about homosexuals in action…
In action meaning…like, as paramedics? Or policemen? Or soldiers? Or maybe like a comic book or TV police procedural titled something along the lines of “Gordon Smith: Crime-Fighting Homosexual in Action!”

Because if you’re meaning “people who have sex with other people of the same sex”, referring to same-sex sexual activity, then maybe you should be clearer as there are some heterosexuals who engage in same-sex sexual activity (for a variety of reasons) but who are and remain heterosexuals. Maybe you’d be better served by the terms “men-who-have-sex-with-men” or “women-who-have-sex-with-women.” Because otherwise you’re just muddying the waters…particularly when you keep insisting that you don’t mean same-sex attracted folks when you talk about homosexuals, even though the term “homosexuals in action” suggests that there are “homosexuals not in action”…which contradicts your conviction that there’s no-such thing as a homosexual Christian.
sadly the Anglican community is split

albertmohler.com/2007/08/20/heresy-precedes-homosexuality/

Heresy Precedes Homosexuality
If this post is only about “homosexuals in action” what gives with the tangential reference to the parlous state of the Anglican Communion?

Is it that you’re now going to the Southern Baptists as opposed to the Eastern Orthodox for your theology?

(Also, what makes you think a Southern Baptist is disposed to being impartial when it comes to Anglicanism and heresy? And in what way is someone like Mohler, who inherently denies the episcopate and the three-fold order of ministry more broadly by virtue of his Baptist faith, entitled to hold court on holy orders in Anglicanism? Or, perhaps more pointedly and from a Roman Catholic perspective, what really can a material heretic have to say about heresy that’s not fundamentally ironic?)

(If you want to talk Anglican Communion, we can, I guess…but to be honest, I’m not that interested as I doubt our conversation would represent anything particularly new or fruitful.)

Under the Mercy,
Mark

All is Grace and Mercy! Deo Gratias!
 
I’m not attempting to justify homosexual actions. Nowhere on this thread have I done so.

I simply take issue with your statement that it is not possible to simply be both a homosexual and a Christian (or Catholic) at the same time and I point out that this proposition is clearly contrary to the Catechism of the Catholic Church.

By your logic it would only be possible to be a Christian if one was entirely perfect and free from all faults and sins… and, as I’m sure you know, there was only one person who was perfect, and his name was Jesus. The rest of us have to make do with being somewhat faulty, but those faults don’t stop us or disqualify us from being Christians.
Dex,

The Catechism says that there are various forms of Chastity…
The various forms of chastity
2348 All the baptized are called to chastity. The Christian has "put on Christ,"135 the model for all chastity. All Christ’s faithful are called to lead a chaste life in keeping with their particular states of life. At the moment of his Baptism, the Christian is pledged to lead his affective life in chastity.
2349 "People should cultivate [chastity] in the way that is suited to their state of life. Some profess virginity or consecrated celibacy which enables them to give themselves to God alone with an undivided heart in a remarkable manner. Others live in the way prescribed for all by the moral law, whether they are married or single."136 Married people are called to live conjugal chastity; others practice chastity in continence:
There are three forms of the virtue of chastity: the first is that of spouses, the second that of widows, and the third that of virgins. We do not praise any one of them to the exclusion of the others. . . . This is what makes for the richness of the discipline of the Church.137
2350 Those who are engaged to marry are called to live chastity in continence. They should see in this time of testing a discovery of mutual respect, an apprenticeship in fidelity, and the hope of receiving one another from God. They should reserve for marriage the expressions of affection that belong to married love. They will help each other grow in chastity.
There is nothing in the call to Chastity about whatever sin you may encounter…

So, Prostitutes, Fornicators, Lusters, Pornographers, Masturbaters and Homosexuals are called to Chastity and to add more information…there is no impediment of those that were Homosexual, called to Chastity…and since there is no behavior…there is only a person…
2359 Homosexual persons are called to chastity. By the virtues of self-mastery that teach them inner freedom, at times by the support of disinterested friendship, by prayer and sacramental grace, they can and should gradually and resolutely approach Christian perfection.
You are familiar with William Glasser, M.D., Choice Theory…all we can do is behave…and all our behaving is surrounding relationships…If we, as all sinners, approach Christian perfection by our actions, aided by grace and virtue…then we are a new creation…not once a Homosexual always a Homosexual…and if needed there are a multitude of reports by Psyhoanalysts, Behaviorists, Sex Therapists, Group Therapists, Hypnotherapists, Religous groups and even reports of Spontaneus change…Psychotherapy literature alone has over a dozen reports of change…

and The One Catholic Church teaches…
In the pastoral ministry, in order to form an adequate judgment in concrete cases, the habitual behavior of people will be considered in its totality, not only with regard to the individual’s practice of charity and of justice but also with regard to the individual’s care in observing the particular precepts of chastity. In particular, one will have to examine whether the individual is using the necessary means, both natural and supernatural, which Christian asceticism from its long experience recommends for overcoming the passions and progressing in virtue.
Those natural means may be availing oneself to proper motivated Psychological counseling that best suits the individual to accomplish change…

and according to CBT, we are not our behavior…so anyone that performed Homosexual acts is not necessarily a Homosexual, they just performed Homosexual acts as there is no such entity distinct from male and female He created them…

There is no such thing as a Homosexual…there are people that perform Homosexual acts and therefore once you stop…you no longer perform Masturbation, Pornography, Lust, Rape, Incest, Homosexual acts…because you become a new creation in Christ…or The Lamb of God died for nothing…
 
Grace & Peace!

In action meaning…like, as paramedics? Or policemen? Or soldiers? Or maybe like a comic book or TV police procedural titled something along the lines of “Gordon Smith: Crime-Fighting Homosexual in Action!”

Because if you’re meaning “people who have sex with other people of the same sex”, referring to same-sex sexual activity, then maybe you should be clearer as there are some heterosexuals who engage in same-sex sexual activity (for a variety of reasons) but who are and remain heterosexuals. Maybe you’d be better served by the terms “men-who-have-sex-with-men” or “women-who-have-sex-with-women.” Because otherwise you’re just muddying the waters…particularly when you keep insisting that you don’t mean same-sex attracted folks when you talk about homosexuals, even though the term “homosexuals in action” suggests that there are “homosexuals not in action”…which contradicts your conviction that there’s no-such thing as a homosexual Christian.

If this post is only about “homosexuals in action” what gives with the tangential reference to the parlous state of the Anglican Communion?

Is it that you’re now going to the Southern Baptists as opposed to the Eastern Orthodox for your theology?

(Also, what makes you think a Southern Baptist is disposed to being impartial when it comes to Anglicanism and heresy? And in what way is someone like Mohler, who inherently denies the episcopate and the three-fold order of ministry more broadly by virtue of his Baptist faith, entitled to hold court on holy orders in Anglicanism? Or, perhaps more pointedly and from a Roman Catholic perspective, what really can a material heretic have to say about heresy that’s not fundamentally ironic?)

(If you want to talk Anglican Communion, we can, I guess…but to be honest, I’m not that interested as I doubt our conversation would represent anything particularly new or fruitful.)

Under the Mercy,
Mark

All is Grace and Mercy! Deo Gratias!
Mark,

Let us have clarity…
When considering Lesbian and Gay these are homosexuals. When considering GID as noted above these too are homosexuals. Bisexuals are in limbo. Are they born that way, formed by society or are they Homosexuals in transition? A homosexual is a homosexual. The bottom line is Homosexuality by whatever name you call it is immoral and unnatural.
Male and female He created them…as the Catechism that Dex has referred to teaches…
Therefore God gave them over in the lusts of their hearts to impurity, so that their bodies would be dishonored among them. 25For they exchanged the truth of God for a lie, and worshiped and served the creature rather than the Creator, who is blessed forever. Amen.
26For this reason God gave them over to degrading passions; for their women exchanged the natural function for that which is unnatural, 27and in the same way also the men abandoned the natural function of the woman and burned in their desire toward one another, men with men committing indecent acts and receiving in their own persons the due penalty of their error.
They are welcome back…all they have to do is repent…pretty simple…
 
Oh no, here we go again. The heteromafia is hard at work again promoting their heteroagenda.
 
Oh no, here we go again. The heteromafia is hard at work again promoting their heteroagenda.
Veritas,

You may want to rethink this notion of hetormafia and heteroagenda…it started with the Jews…

catholiceducation.org/articles/homosexuality/ho0003.html
**Judaism’s Sexual Revolution: Why Judaism Rejected Homosexuality
DENNIS PRAGER**
When Judaism demanded that all sexual activity be channeled into marriage, it changed the world. The Torah’s prohibition of non-marital sex quite simply made the creation of Western civilization possible
The revolutionary nature of Judaism’s prohibiting all forms of non-marital sex was nowhere more radical, more challenging to the prevailing assumptions of mankind, than with regard to homosexuality. Indeed, Judaism may be said to have invented the notion of homosexuality, for in the ancient world sexuality was not divided between heterosexuality and homosexuality. That division was the Bible’s doing. Before the Bible, the world divided sexuality between penetrator (active partner) and penetrated (passive partner).
As Martha Nussbaum, professor of philosophy at Brown University, recently wrote, the ancients were no more concerned with people’s gender preference than people today are with others’ eating preferences:
Ancient categories of sexual experience differed considerably from our own… The central distinction in sexual morality was the distinction between active and passive roles. The gender of the object… is not in itself morally problematic. Boys and women are very often treated interchangeably as objects of [male] desire. What is socially important is to penetrate rather than to be penetrated. Sex is understood fundamentally not as interaction, but as a doing of some thing to someone…
Judaism changed all this. It rendered the “gender of the object” very “morally problematic”; it declared that no one is “interchangeable” sexually. And as a result, it ensured that sex would in fact be “fundamentally interaction” and not simply “a doing of something to someone”.
It would appear that this Judeo-Christian concept of rejection of Homosexuality made Western Civilization possible and accepting it may be a cause of the undoing of Western Civilization as we know it…🙂
 
Grace & Peace!
Let us have clarity…
That would be nice…but you’re doing a very poor job of providing it when you quote highly reflexive passage from your strange movie review.

Here’s that passage once more:
"CopticChristian:
When considering Lesbian and Gay these are homosexuals. When considering GID as noted above these too are homosexuals. Bisexuals are in limbo. Are they born that way, formed by society or are they Homosexuals in transition? A homosexual is a homosexual. The bottom line is Homosexuality by whatever name you call it is immoral and unnatural.
So…let’s see what this paragraph tells us: Lesbian folks and gay folks are homosexuals. Also homosexuals are people with gender-identity disorder as discussed in your previous paragraphs. You discuss gender-identity disorder in terms of children who exhibit the disorder–so children with gender-identity disorder are also homosexual, including the 25% of GID kids who eventually self-identify as heterosexual. Bisexuals are a mystery, but they could actually just be homosexuals, only who knows. But in the end, what it all comes down to is that homosexuals are homosexuals.

Or, in simpler terms: A homosexual is a presumably sexually active lesbian person or gay person, or a child who is hopefully not sexually active and who may in fact be heterosexual, or maybe a bisexual person too who may or may not be sexually active, who knows. And the best we can say about these homosexuals is that they’re homosexuals.

What clarity do you imagine you’re providing here? You stated in your bolded caveat that you’re not talking about same-sex attracted people (who are, presumably celibate) when you use the term homosexual, but you clearly are talking about a particular group of children when you use the term homosexual (and maybe also bisexuals, too, but who knows).

You are defining homosexuals and homosexuality so inconsistently that it’s virtually impossible to know what you’re actually saying.

You have a problem with understanding that your uses of the word “homosexual” are largely inconsistent with how most people understand the word. Moreover, you’ve apparently not yet personally settled on a consistent usage of the word and, furthermore, have yet to appreciate that your belligerence regarding the word, coupled with your inconsistency and lack of clarity contribute to misapprehensions and mis-communications which are completely unedifying, apart from being abjectly surreal on a host of levels, including the moral,the medical, the metaphorical and the grammatical.
Male and female He created them…as the Catechism that Dex has referred to teaches…
You realize that what you quoted is an out-of-context section of Paul’s intro to his letter to the Romans and not the catechism. Since we seem to be theology hopping in this thread from Orthodox to Baptists, I recommend to you “Paul Among Jews and Gentiles” by Krister Stendahl, a Swedish Lutheran Bishop, on what Paul is up to in his epistles.

(And yes, male and female created he them, but remember too that Paul states that in Christ there is no male nor female. Perhaps maleness and femaleness will all pass away in the eschaton, or maybe they’re just things that we can only perceive through a glass darkly at this point in the collective human adventure.)
They are welcome back…all they have to do is repent…pretty simple…
Who are welcome back: the gentile Romans about whom (and to whom) Paul was writing?

(Also, with regard to your assertion that the Judeo-Christian rejection of homosexuality made Western Civilization possible, there are a number of issues, only a few of which are: 1) it’s facile and insupportable; 2) you cannot reject something of which you do not or cannot conceive–if, as Praeger states, the ancient world had no concept of homosexuality, it would need to be invented in order to be rejected; 3) you would make a better case for a rejection of Paganism writ large as what made Western Civilization possible, though Edward Gibbon would disagree, at least in principle; 4) the stone the builders reject has a tendency to become the cornerstone–in terms of Western culture and civilization, witness the number of homosexuals who have helped define it; 5) there’s an argument to be made that civilization (Western or otherwise) is perhaps not all that good for us, or is, at the very least, not deserving of too much praise; and what praise it does deserve is in spite of itself–as a fallen human construct infected with and reflective of original sin, it is built on, by and for death.)

Under the Mercy,
Mark

All is Grace and Mercy! Deo Gratias!
 
Grace & Peace!

That would be nice…but you’re doing a very poor job of providing it when you quote highly reflexive passage from your strange movie review.

(And yes, male and female created he them, but remember too that Paul states that in Christ there is no male nor female.

Under the Mercy,
Mark

All is Grace and Mercy! Deo Gratias!
Mark,
So…let’s see what this paragraph tells us: Lesbian folks and gay folks are homosexuals. Also homosexuals are people with gender-identity disorder as discussed in your previous paragraphs. You discuss gender-identity disorder in terms of children who exhibit the disorder–so children with gender-identity disorder are also homosexual, including the 25% of GID kids who eventually self-identify as heterosexual. Bisexuals are a mystery, but they could actually just be homosexuals, only who knows. But in the end, what it all comes down to is that homosexuals are homosexuals.
This appears to be consistent.
Or, in simpler terms: A homosexual is a presumably sexually active lesbian person or gay person, or a child who is hopefully not sexually active and who may in fact be heterosexual, or maybe a bisexual person too who may or may not be sexually active, who knows. And the best we can say about these homosexuals is that they’re homosexuals.
What clarity do you imagine you’re providing here? You stated in your bolded caveat that you’re not talking about same-sex attracted people (who are, presumably celibate) when you use the term homosexual, but you clearly are talking about a particular group of children when you use the term homosexual (and maybe also bisexuals, too, but who knows).
You are defining homosexuals and homosexuality so inconsistently that it’s virtually impossible to know what you’re actually saying.
You have a problem with understanding that your uses of the word “homosexual” are largely inconsistent with how most people understand the word. Moreover, you’ve apparently not yet personally settled on a consistent usage of the word and, furthermore, have yet to appreciate that your belligerence regarding the word, coupled with your inconsistency and lack of clarity contribute to misapprehensions and mis-communications which are completely unedifying, apart from being abjectly surreal on a host of levels, including the moral,the medical, the metaphorical and the grammatical.
Yes, I define as I believe it is appropriate to define and you have the perogative to accept or reject the definition or engage in discussion within that definition.
You realize that what you quoted is an out-of-context section of Paul’s intro to his letter to the Romans and not the catechism. Since we seem to be theology hopping in this thread from Orthodox to Baptists, I recommend to you “Paul Among Jews and Gentiles” by Krister Stendahl, a Swedish Lutheran Bishop, on what Paul is up to in his epistles.
I posted Paul’s statement in context from the letter to the Romans in post #20 and #29 that are Catechetical teachings. You may or may not know that.
(And yes, male and female created he them, but remember too that Paul states that in Christ there is no male nor female. Perhaps maleness and femaleness will all pass away in the eschaton, or maybe they’re just things that we can only perceive through a glass darkly at this point in the collective human adventure.)
Perfect. So, you do grasp the concept that when Homosexuals stop sinning and acting immorally they are no longer Homoexuals identified by their behavior.👍
Who are welcome back: the gentile Romans about whom (and to whom) Paul was writing?
Those that Paul describes as turning their back on God

giving themselves over to …
lusts of their hearts to impurity, so that their bodies would be dishonored among them. 25For they exchanged the truth of God for a lie, and worshiped and served the creature rather than the Creator, who is blessed forever. Amen.
26For this reason God gave them over to degrading passions; for their women exchanged the natural function for that which is unnatural, 27and in the same way also the men abandoned the natural function of the woman and burned in their desire toward one another, men with men committing indecent acts and receiving in their own persons the due penalty of their error.
men with men, women exchanging their natural functions…kind of sounds pretty straight forward, no pun intended, to me…
(Also, with regard to your assertion that the Judeo-Christian rejection of homosexuality made Western Civilization possible, there are a number of issues, only a few of which are: 1) it’s facile and insupportable; 2) you cannot reject something of which you do not or cannot conceive–if, as Praeger states, the ancient world had no concept of homosexuality, it would need to be invented in order to be rejected; 3) you would make a better case for a rejection of Paganism writ large as what made Western Civilization possible, though Edward Gibbon would disagree, at least in principle; 4) the stone the builders reject has a tendency to become the cornerstone–in terms of Western culture and civilization, witness the number of homosexuals who have helped define it; 5) there’s an argument to be made that civilization (Western or otherwise) is perhaps not all that good for us, or is, at the very least, not deserving of too much praise; and what praise it does deserve is in spite of itself–as a fallen human construct infected with and reflective of original sin, it is built on, by and for death.)
This is too many words. Do not praise what you do not see valuable.🙂
 
:shrug:I don’t know why the same guys keep arguing. We have dealing with these same arguments over and over on the same type of threads. All I want to know is the person with homosexual inclinations, Same sex attractions, or what ever we want to call it being chaste, following the Catholic teachings on promoting Jesus and repenting from any sexual behavior that is immoral. I know the people who are arguing are all mostly SSA and what point is to anger each other on the differences, why not talk about what you have in common in your faith. Jesus. The sin of pride can take many forms and that one can bring any of us down.
Or is this some sort of fun your all having to see who can insult each other better. What do you all have to prove? I don’t know. It just seems you all should know your faith and be following it. If anyone disagrees with the Catholic teaching on homosexuality then they will be held responsible, you already been informed many times. Why keep beating a dead horse, unless it some kind of enjoyment. Just my observation.
God Bless
 
Grace & Peace!
This appears to be consistent.
It isn’t, Coptic.

You define people who have sex with other people of the same sex but do not have GID as homosexual, then you define GID children who have *not *had sex with anyone as homosexual, then you condemn the behaviors of homosexuals. What makes someone in one group a homosexual is their homosexual sexual behavior, but what makes the other group homosexual is apparently just GID. So homosexuality is both homosexual sexual behavior and GID, which is not a sexual behavior, particularly not in children.

How can you claim that any of that represents consistency unless you are completely and dysfunctionally delusional?
Yes, I define as I believe it is appropriate to define and you have the perogative to accept or reject the definition or engage in discussion within that definition.
This is a problem when it comes to actual communication, Coptic. It is impossible to engage in a discussion of a definition of a word if the word’s definition is serially inconsistent. Your position here is one of both relativism and solipsism.
Perfect. So, you do grasp the concept that when Homosexuals stop sinning and acting immorally they are no longer Homoexuals identified by their behavior.👍
That’s a non sequitur, Coptic. What you have written does not logically follow on from a belief that God created us both male and female though there is neither male nor female in Christ. What you have written follows on from your own personal brand of linguistic relativism.

You fail to grasp this concept: a person is a homosexual because they are same-sex attracted. A person is not a homosexual because they engage in homosexual sexual acts. They are a homosexual if they are same-sex attracted. A person can be homosexual and celibate. They can be homosexual and sexually active with a same-sex partner. A person can be homosexual and be sexually active with someone of the opposite sex. A person will not be homosexual if they are not same-sex attracted no matter what they do.

So when a homosexual stops sinning by God’s good grace, regardless of their sins, if they still experience same-sex attraction, they are still homosexual.

When someone says, “I’m a homosexual,” they are not identifying themselves by their behavior–they are acknowledging that they are attracted to other people of the same sex.

You are absolutely right that defining ourselves according to our behaviors can put us in some very sticky situations.

But it is appropriate to give others an understanding (however limited) of who we are (when giving such an understanding is needful or appropriate) by indicating the drift of our affections. And it’s also possible for others to come to an understanding of who we might be by observing clues in our behavior and deportment which may indicate the drift of our affections. We can say, “I’m the sort of person who likes the Clash!” And what that would mean is that we’re the sort of person who likes the Clash. But someone might infer that we’re the sort of person who likes the Clash when we have the habit of belting out “The Guns of Brixton” and “Lost in the Supermarket” and “London Calling” on a regular public basis.

Now, if we do have the habit of belting out “The Guns of Brixton” on a regular public basis, that doesn’t necessarily mean that we like singing loudly and in public or that our* identity* has suddenly become The Annoying Guy Who Sings Too Much and Too Loudly in Public (though that may, in fact, be how we are known), but it does mean that perhaps we are expressing our love of the Clash (and in particular “The Guns of Brixton”) inappropriately. But chances are after we’ve stopped our public singing habit, our love of the Clash will remain undiminished, even though our tendency to sing the Clash publicly may have completely waned or may be held completely in check.

You can say to someone, “I’m a homosexual,” and all that would mean is that you’re attracted to people of the same sex. You can observe someone flirting with a person of the same sex. You might come to any number of conclusions based on this observation including that the person you’ve observed is a homosexual and/or that the person you’ve observed is a serial flirter. And you can go up to that person and say, “I didn’t know you were a homosexual,” and they could say, “Yeah, I am, but I don’t usually flirt like that” or, “No, I just like flirting indiscriminately,” to which you could respond, “Okay, but flirting makes me uncomfortable, so, you know, please don’t flirt around me,” to which they might respond, “Okay.” But if they’re a homosexual? They’ll still be homosexual. And if they’re not homosexual? They’ll (rather predictably) remain not homosexual.
This is too many words.
Only because you’re unwilling to engage or understand.

Under the Mercy,
Mark

All is Grace and Mercy! Deo Gratias!
 
Bring people to Christ, let Christ lead them from sin. Once you “see” God you will see your sins in stark contrast to Him and He will help you. All of the chastisment or whatever you call it is only pushing people away. God==>Morality NOT Morality===>God

All of this admonisment comes off as prideful to me.
 
Grace & Peace!

It isn’t, Coptic.

You are absolutely right that defining ourselves according to our behaviors can put us in some very sticky situations.

Only because you’re unwilling to engage or understand.

Under the Mercy,
Mark

All is Grace and Mercy! Deo Gratias!
Mark,
You define people who have sex with other people of the same sex but do not have GID as homosexual, then you define GID children who have *not *had sex with anyone as homosexual, then you condemn the behaviors of homosexuals. What makes someone in one group a homosexual is their homosexual sexual behavior, but what makes the other group homosexual is apparently just GID. So homosexuality is both homosexual sexual behavior and GID, which is not a sexual behavior, particularly not in children.
Imagining you are something you are not with the desire, preference, wish to be something you are not and mutiliate your genitals is dysfunctional. The DSM is trying hard to normalize this as well, but Good Luck…it does not change what is.

We know that children with GID do not take this fantasy into adulthood 100% and we know that adults with GID can remit…finding one case means that there are more and knowing that one can change=not immutable, just like the claim of the Essentialists as it regards Homosexuality.
Compr Psychiatry. 2000 Jul-Aug;41(4):273-5.
Adult gender identity disorder can remit.
Marks I, Green R, Mataix-Cols D.
Source
Department of Experimental Psychopathology, Institute of Psychiatry, London, UK.
Abstract
A 4-year remission in a case of gender identity disorder (GID in DSM-IV, previously termed transsexualism) plus obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) prompted a search for further similar cases. Reports were reviewed for apparent remissions in adult GID. GID and paraphilias may wax and wane. This fluctuation can be in tandem with that of comorbid psychopathology or in response to sexual and other life events. Remission has been documented at up to 10 years. If evaluated over many years, GIDs and paraphilias can be less fixed than is often thought. The frequency of permanent remission may be underestimated, as such subjects may not consult clinicians. Implications for the clinician are that such subjects require a long trial period of cross-gender living prior to any surgical interventions.
GID are sick people with potentially more inclined mothers with personality disorders, co-morbid eating disorders, anxiety and depression. There is lots going on with these people that should be looked at.
That’s a non sequitur, Coptic. What you have written does not logically follow on from a belief that God created us both male and female though there is neither male nor female in Christ. What you have written follows on from your own personal brand of linguistic relativism.
You fail to grasp this concept: a person is a homosexual because they are same-sex attracted. A person is not a homosexual because they engage in homosexual sexual acts. They are a homosexual if they are same-sex attracted. A person can be homosexual and celibate. They can be homosexual and sexually active with a same-sex partner. A person can be homosexual and be sexually active with someone of the opposite sex. A person will not be homosexual if they are not same-sex attracted no matter what they do.
So when a homosexual stops sinning by God’s good grace, regardless of their sins, if they still experience same-sex attraction, they are still homosexual.
No, Prostitutes that turn to Christ may think occasionaly of returning to Prostitution but that does not make them a Prostitute while thinking of that…Pornagraphers that turn to Christ may think of the days of Pornography but that does not make them Pornographers and Homosexuals that turn to Christ may think of same sex attraction but that does not make them a Homosexual.
You can say to someone, “I’m a homosexual,” and all that would mean is that you’re attracted to people of the same sex. You can observe someone flirting with a person of the same sex. You might come to any number of conclusions based on this observation including that the person you’ve observed is a homosexual and/or that the person you’ve observed is a serial flirter. And you can go up to that person and say, “I didn’t know you were a homosexual,” and they could say, “Yeah, I am, but I don’t usually flirt like that” or, “No, I just like flirting indiscriminately,” to which you could respond, “Okay, but flirting makes me uncomfortable, so, you know, please don’t flirt around me,” to which they might respond, “Okay.” But if they’re a homosexual? They’ll still be homosexual. And if they’re not homosexual? They’ll (rather predictably) remain not homosexual.
If someone says that they are “whatever” it means that they identify by “whatever” it is that they believe it to be defined by. If I blurt out, I suck light bulbs and sit on watermelons, whatever that means to me is what it means to me and whatever anyone else believes it to be is what it means to them.
When someone says, “I’m a homosexual,” they are not identifying themselves by their behavior–they are acknowledging that they are attracted to other people of the same sex.
We disagree. Someone that identifies as Homosexual identifies based on whatever their social sphere leads them to believe it means. To me it means that they have acted on their belief that they are innately/immutably, of course wrongly, this thing called Homosexual.🙂
 
Yeah you missed our secret meeting…:rolleyes:
Heh. You missed the last conversation between Coptic and I, in which he denounced the homoheresy of the homosexualists promoting their homoagenda through a homomafia, and persisted as if throwing around these terms was perfectly charitable.
 
Mark,

Imagining you are something you are not with the desire, preference, wish to be something you are not and mutiliate your genitals is dysfunctional. The DSM is trying hard to normalize this as well, but Good Luck…it does not change what is.

We know that children with GID do not take this fantasy into adulthood 100% and we know that adults with GID can remit…finding one case means that there are more and knowing that one can change=not immutable, just like the claim of the Essentialists as it regards Homosexuality.

GID are sick people with potentially more inclined mothers with personality disorders, co-morbid eating disorders, anxiety and depression. There is lots going on with these people that should be looked at.

No, Prostitutes that turn to Christ may think occasionaly of returning to Prostitution but that does not make them a Prostitute while thinking of that…Pornagraphers that turn to Christ may think of the days of Pornography but that does not make them Pornographers and Homosexuals that turn to Christ may think of same sex attraction but that does not make them a Homosexual.

If someone says that they are “whatever” it means that they identify by “whatever” it is that they believe it to be defined by. If I blurt out, I suck light bulbs and sit on watermelons, whatever that means to me is what it means to me and whatever anyone else believes it to be is what it means to them.

We disagree. Someone that identifies as Homosexual identifies based on whatever their social sphere leads them to believe it means. To me it means that they have acted on their belief that they are innately/immutably, of course wrongly, this thing called Homosexual.🙂
I know you like to debate, coptic, but I think that some people are so married to their
political view points niether reason or common sence have little or no impact.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top