NPR: Unfit for Work

  • Thread starter Thread starter ComputerGeek25
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

ComputerGeek25

Guest
apps.npr.org/unfit-for-work/
In the past three decades, the number of Americans who are on disability has skyrocketed. The rise has come even as medical advances have allowed many more people to remain on the job, and new laws have banned workplace discrimination against the disabled. Every month, 14 million people now get a disability check from the government.
 
An ironic aspect of this is that those lawyers who rerpesent SSD claimants are really hurting for business because the government now just rubber stamps SSD applications through. People don’t need a lawyer to get their claim approved.
 
An ironic aspect of this is that those lawyers who rerpesent SSD claimants are really hurting for business because the government now just rubber stamps SSD applications through. People don’t need a lawyer to get their claim approved.
Maybe the lawyers should go on disability! 😃
 
Be very careful. In the UK the backlash against this type of situation is killing people. A program of reassessments to get people off disability benefits is making perverse decisions, and has totally unrealistic targets in terms of the percentage of claimants it is expected to declare fit for work.
On average 73 people a week are dying after being declared fit for work, and what appeals are able to be heard against their decisions have a massive success rate.

The result is massivley inhumane

A program to reform the US system must NOT be modeled on the one being use here in the UK.
 
Be very careful. In the UK the backlash against this type of situation is killing people. A program of reassessments to get people off disability benefits is making perverse decisions, and has totally unrealistic targets in terms of the percentage of claimants it is expected to declare fit for work.
On average 73 people a week are dying after being declared fit for work, and what appeals are able to be heard against their decisions have a massive success rate.

The result is massivley inhumane

A program to reform the US system must NOT be modeled on the one being use here in the UK.
I don’t deny that suffering happens, but the current system and fraud is hurting people that actually need help and does not ensure that help will be there for future generations. That is inhumane as well.
 
I have a disability, but I’m in grad school huffing it through.

That’s a VERY interesting analysis----more laws helping disabled folks yet more claims of disability.

I think the answer is obvious.
I think the analysis is very interesting as well.
 
An ironic aspect of this is that those lawyers who rerpesent SSD claimants are really hurting for business because the government now just rubber stamps SSD applications through. People don’t need a lawyer to get their claim approved.
They are busy filing work comp cases.
 
Be very careful. In the UK the backlash against this type of situation is killing people. A program of reassessments to get people off disability benefits is making perverse decisions, and has totally unrealistic targets in terms of the percentage of claimants it is expected to declare fit for work.
On average 73 people a week are dying after being declared fit for work, and what appeals are able to be heard against their decisions have a massive success rate.

The result is massivley inhumane

A program to reform the US system must NOT be modeled on the one being use here in the UK.
I don’t know anything about the UK system. But I will say this. I have a friend who is an occupational medicine physician. It is axiomatic among occupational physicians that people who are not working for whatever reason, but could be in the labor force, rapidly become deconditioned. A lot of work requires at least a specialized sort of athleticism gained over years of work. It might affect one complex of muscles, nerves and circulatory system only, but it is athleticism all the same. It rapidly goes away if one is not active in that, or a similar way. That’s one of the reasons why retirees who, for some reason, want to return or must return to the work force, find it more difficult to do than they anticipated.

When it comes to people whose work is mainly mental or a combination of physical and mental, there is a similar loss of ability.

So, allowing people onto disability who could actually work, and prolonged involuntary unemployment, are often very harmful to the potentially productive work force. Here in the U.S., when I see, for example this week’s labor participation report and learn that 500,000 people have simply dropped out of the labor force because they cant’ find work, I cringe because it seems doubtful to me that any significant number of them will ever return to work whether it becomes available later or not.

Undoubtedly the very first priority of the current administration in the U.S. should be creating conditions conducive to hiring. But this administration is doing the exact opposite.

So, the UK is not the only place with ill-favored governmental policies.
 
Yes, the usual precursor to a SSD filing.
Since it is illegal to check a person’s work comp history before hiring many have found it more profitable to simply go from job to job making work comp claims. In states like Oklahoma there is no limit on the number of back injuries a person can claim in a life time. 5% disability (standard payout awarded by judges on claims that everyone “knows” is bogus) is about $9500.
 
Since it is illegal to check a person’s work comp history before hiring many have found it more profitable to simply go from job to job making work comp claims. In states like Oklahoma there is no limit on the number of back injuries a person can claim in a life time. 5% disability (standard payout awarded by judges on claims that everyone “knows” is bogus) is about $9500.
I was amused by this.

I have a lawyer friend who defends workers’ compensation cases, and he tells the story that he was over in the WC court one day and a couple of other attorneys in another case were arguing over what was the “proper” rating for something or other in front of the judge. One of them said he shouldn’t have to pay anything because the claimant had fully recovered and had no disability at all from the injury.

My friend then commented to the two lawyers, right in front of the judge: “Oh no, you have it wrong, the proper rating for Nothing At All is 5% of the body part.” The judge looked up with a shocked look on his face, but then started laughing. The judge, of course, didn’t deny that it was true.

The lawyers settled for 5% of whatever body part it was.

I am informed that a person can be “permanently and totally disabled” more than once. Fellow gets injured and is awarded permanent total disability, then goes to work in some other line of work, gets injured and gets permanent total disability again. He keeps them both. He goes and gets SSD, and he keeps them all, though there can be a minor setoff in the government’s favor, but not in the insurers’ favor.
 
I am informed that a person can be “permanently and totally disabled” more than once. Fellow gets injured and is awarded permanent total disability, then goes to work in some other line of work, gets injured and gets permanent total disability again. He keeps them both. He goes and gets SSD, and he keeps them all, though there can be a minor setoff in the government’s favor, but not in the insurers’ favor.
The issue we run into is the “back injury” can happen several times - even at the same time. We recently dealt with an individual who had 26 “injuries” (various body parts) that had permantly and partially disabled him. He was 29. Average claim was $17,000.
 
The issue we run into is the “back injury” can happen several times - even at the same time. We recently dealt with an individual who had 26 “injuries” (various body parts) that had permantly and partially disabled him. He was 29. Average claim was $17,000.
Dollars to donuts he got on SSD as well.
 
Since it is illegal to check a person’s work comp history before hiring many have found it more profitable to simply go from job to job making work comp claims. In states like Oklahoma there is no limit on the number of back injuries a person can claim in a life time. 5% disability (standard payout awarded by judges on claims that everyone “knows” is bogus) is about $9500.
I can’t find it now but I know there was a bill working it’s way threw the system here in Oklahoma that was supposed to have toughened up the workers comp laws. I think it passed but I’m not 100% sure of that. Like I said I can’t seem to find any news of it.

I know when I went though workers comp I was told by my attorney to be careful of what kind of activities I did out in public so the company wouldn’t be given a reason to stop paying me. The company tried that anyway before I even had surgery. 🤷 I’m sure that kind of thing has a lot to do with why so many people become inactive.

Going though workers comp, in my experience, is a long and drawn out process. In my case it took a whole year from the time I was injured to the time I was actually able to go back to work.
 
I don’t know anything about the UK system. But I will say this. I have a friend who is an occupational medicine physician. It is axiomatic among occupational physicians that people who are not working for whatever reason, but could be in the labor force, rapidly become deconditioned. A lot of work requires at least a specialized sort of athleticism gained over years of work. It might affect one complex of muscles, nerves and circulatory system only, but it is athleticism all the same. It rapidly goes away if one is not active in that, or a similar way. That’s one of the reasons why retirees who, for some reason, want to return or must return to the work force, find it more difficult to do than they anticipated.

When it comes to people whose work is mainly mental or a combination of physical and mental, there is a similar loss of ability.

So, allowing people onto disability who could actually work, and prolonged involuntary unemployment, are often very harmful to the potentially productive work force. Here in the U.S., when I see, for example this week’s labor participation report and learn that 500,000 people have simply dropped out of the labor force because they cant’ find work, I cringe because it seems doubtful to me that any significant number of them will ever return to work whether it becomes available later or not.

Undoubtedly the very first priority of the current administration in the U.S. should be creating conditions conducive to hiring. But this administration is doing the exact opposite.

So, the UK is not the only place with ill-favored governmental policies.
I have carpal tunnel in both hands ( was classified as bilateral carpal tunnel) and when it was all said and done during my time on workers comp I was classified as a PPD and considered to be 25% disabled. For those who don’t know PPD stands for Partial Permanent Disability. Was told by the specialist I saw that I shouldn’t be lifting anything more than 5 lbs.:bigyikes: Ummm ya, that’s really going to happen.:whacky: Both of my kids weighed more than 5 lbs at birth. I ended up settling with my company when they refused to bring me back to work and got a job in a completely different line of work afterward.

There have been times I have wondered, out of curiosity, if I could get on disability. Never checked into though because we didn’t need it.
 
It is from discussions about disability assistance like what we’re seeing on this thread that brings a stigma to the whole concept of BEING NEEDY. Yes, there is fraud – there will probably always be some fraud – but in general people NEED this help, and it doesn’t add up to much. I have met too many homeless people in my city, because their disabilities are genuine, they’re unable to find work that they can physically or medically do, and their disability income is inadequate for them to find housing. Their lifespans are being shortened because their needs are inadequately met. And they are ashamed of their poverty and neediness. They’re tired of the looks they get, or at least perceive they get. In fact they’re tired most of the time, period. They deserve our compassion, our prayers, our assistance, our support, and not flippant judgments and disregard.
 
I have carpal tunnel in both hands ( was classified as bilateral carpal tunnel) and when it was all said and done during my time on workers comp I was classified as a PPD and considered to be 25% disabled. For those who don’t know PPD stands for Partial Permanent Disability. Was told by the specialist I saw that I shouldn’t be lifting anything more than 5 lbs.:bigyikes: Ummm ya, that’s really going to happen.:whacky: Both of my kids weighed more than 5 lbs at birth. I ended up settling with my company when they refused to bring me back to work and got a job in a completely different line of work afterward.

There have been times I have wondered, out of curiosity, if I could get on disability. Never checked into though because we didn’t need it.
I do not question you or your bona fides, but 25% body as a whole (I assume) disability for bilateral CTS is pretty strong. That would be an absolutely catastrophic outcome for bilateral CTS in Missouri.

But a permanent 5 lb restriction is weird. Maybe that’s justified, but it takes more force than that just to turn the average door knob, and considerably more than that to open a car door. (I have a good friend who is an occ med physician, and we talk a lot.). I can easily picture a hand specialist saying one should not engage in repetitive, forceful hand tasks that are “machine driven” (which most hand-intensive jobs are). As my friend explains it, CT surgery does not really “cure” the condition, and it can return without a lot of trouble. As hard as it must have seemed, your former employer probably did you a favor in not putting you back into what surely was repetitive, forceful hand work.

Personally, I think I would consult with another physician about your lifting restrictions before I decided I couldn’t do things that I might well be able to do without harm. The really important thing is not so much the poundage or even the motion itself, but the “work/rest” cycle. My friend gave me a copy of a study done by the Mayo clinic, and it defined the “recovery period” between the motion and the next cycle. It was very interesting. “Machine driven” hand work tends not to allow a sufficient “rest cycle”. Lots of other hand work does.
 
There was a very long piece that aired on “This American Life” a few weeks ago. It focused on a town in Alabama (I think) 25% of whose residents are on disability.
 
There was a very long piece that aired on “This American Life” a few weeks ago. It focused on a town in Alabama (I think) 25% of whose residents are on disability.
One would have to know how that came to be, but it is not greatly surprising to hear of it.

Perhaps one of the great tragedies of our time is the fact that there are a number of people who could be productive and thus better serving both themselves and the society but aren’t because of long term unemployment and deconditioning resulting from it.

In my opinion, it’s a terrible thing for a nation; like a profligate heir who wastes an inheritance gained by a diligent ancestor and then wonders why wealth is hard to come by once it’s gone. This country once had a high employment rate relative to that of other developed countries. Now it’s approaching the labor participation rate of countries that are on the wane, and is actually lower now than that of Germany, for example.

In my opinion, that is due to the horribly misplaced priorities of an administration that found itself with a recession and, in the face of it, decided to focus its efforts on disruptive social and redistributive changes rather than on recovery. As a consequence, we are now in the fifth year of declining labor participation. People wonder why it is that there is an increasing gap between “classes” of people economically. That’s precisely because the more one depends on work for one’s resources as opposed to capital, the greater does the gap grow when employment is low. The gap is always smallest at full employment.

What people also fail to realize is that “transfer payments” always come out of labor’s share of national income. People rail against “the rich” and demand more transfer payments, never realizing that labor, not capital, is paying for it. Some politicians encourage the misperception to further their own interests.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top