Obama Offends the Catholic Left

  • Thread starter Thread starter SpeakInSilence
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Which means that what is actually on the block are precisely the kind of social-justice services—education, health care, and aid to the needy—that liberal Catholics believe to be the most vital works of the church. For conservative Catholics, Obama merely confirmed their darkest suspicions; for liberals, it was a betrayal in full…
You have it right, in spades, for this Catholic liberal. 😦 😦
 
This past August, Health and Human Services secretary Kathleen Sebelius finally got around to explaining the administration’s interpretation of the phrase. Based on a recommendation from the Institute of Medicine, the administration would define “preventive health services” to include contraceptives, morning-after pills, and female sterilization. And they would interpret the “all insurers” section to include religious organizations, whatever their beliefs.
( my bold italics).

I would imagine that if the Obama administration had said before the vote on Obamacare that these kinds of “preventative medicine” would be forced on Catholic institutions, then Obamacare would likely have not passed. The only way they could pass it was to be intentionally vague about their true goals. These kind of deceptive, underhanded tactics are why I find the Obama administration quite scary - and dangerous in a way that previous Democrat administrations like Clinton or Carter weren’t.

IshiiRinging in my head are Nancy Pelosi’s words, “We have to pass the bill in order to see what’s in it.”

And the promise that it would not cover abortion. If it wouldn’t cover abortion, why was it so important to quash the Stupak amendment?

Over and over we were assured abortion would not be covered.

Yesterday on NPR morning edition, they said Plan B does not cause abortions.
Plan B could possibly thin the lining of the uterus, the womb, so the fertilized egg won’t attach to it and grow. **Scientists have no proof this actually happens, **but in theory, it could. That’s why some people are opposed to Plan B. White says the way Plan B works is still very different than what happens with the abortion pill, mifepristone.
But, from the manufacturer’s own website
How Plan B® One-Step Works
There are many misconceptions about emergency contraception, so it’s important for your patients to know that Plan B® One-Step **works similar to regular birth control pills; ** *it simply contains a larger dose of the hormone levonorgestrel. Plan B® One-Step works primarily by:
Code:
Preventing ovulation
Possibly preventing fertilization by altering tubal transport of sperm and/or egg
**Altering the endometrium, which may inhibit implantation
**
Plan B® One-Step is not effective once the process of implantation has begun. **It will not affect an existing pregnancy or harm a developing fetus.
**
Plan B® One-Step should be taken as soon as possible. When taken as directed, approximately seven out of eight women who would have gotten pregnant will not become pregnant after taking Plan B® One-Step. ++
*Admits birth control pills cause abortion.

As with 'marriage" what constitutes an abortion has been redefined as reproductive rights, Preventive care, and other euphemisms.
 
I think the slippery slope has gotten slipperier.

newyork.cbslocal.com/2012/02/06/catholic-league-poised-to-go-to-war-with-obama-over-mandatory-birth-control-payments/

Notice this comment *"But pro-choice groups said they will fight the church and fight for the right of employees of Catholic institutions to have birth control and other services paid for.

“The Catholic hierarchy seems to be playing a cynical game of chicken and they don’t seem to care that** the health and well being of millions of American woman are what’s at stake here***,” National Abortion Rights Action League President Andrea Miller said."
Notice the words in the quote "other services paid for."
I sometimes think that we have to fight another battle here. Doesn’t seem like we’re going to win the moral conscience rights battle. As unconstitutional as the mandate is, they’re clearly emphasizing that our concerns “must be weighed alongside the health and well-being of millions of women”. We need to fight this claim. We need to make them prove that contraceptives and the “other services” can reasonably be defined as health care. I know that battle seems insurmountable as well, given the fact that PP has ingrained that concept into society over the last 40 years, and has Roe v Wade on their side. But for the overwhelming majority of women, arguably well over 95%, there is nothing remotely health related about the use of contraception. At best, there may be 5% who can legitimately claim that a) they are in a rare category of women whose health could be severely at risk if they became pregnant, or b) experience severe pain during their cycle that contraceptives help alleviate; or perhaps c) could be psychologically at risk if becoming pregnant.

So, I think if we could somehow shine a bright enough spotlight on the fact that, for nearly all women who use contraception, it is NOT for health related reasons, the administration wouldn’t have much solid ground to stand on when attempting to defend their position to impose this mandate.

Because their defense, just like the predominant defense of the pro-choice crowd, is that all of these evils are classified as reproductive HEALTH CARE.

I say, “prove it”. Show us the numbers that legitimately use contraceptives, get sterilizations, and/or abortions** for the sake of their HEALTH**. Show us exactly how their health deteriorates if unable to use these “services”. I guarantee that number is so small as to be nearly undetectable. Help me if I am I off-base with this. Please.
 
I say, “prove it”. Show us the numbers that legitimately use contraceptives, get sterilizations, and/or abortions** for the sake of their HEALTH**. Show us exactly how their health deteriorates if unable to use these “services”. I guarantee that number is so small as to be nearly undetectable. Help me if I am I off-base with this. Please.
Excellent observation.
 
Nevertheless, both Hitler and Stalin killed millions of Catholics, among many others.
When? When did they do that? First day in office? Office? Yes, let’s not forget, Hitler was elected!
There’s no comparing him with those monsters. He’s not having concentration camps or extermination camps or re-education camps built. He hasn’t opened gas chambers with which to kill Catholics. He hasn’t had Catholic and Protestant churches shut down, priests and ministers arrested and “disappeared,” and to the best of my knowledge, no clergy have been put against the wall for the firing squads. And, Christians of all stripes and Jews as well can oppose him without risking an unmarked shallow grave. (And please, don’t say, “just wait unitl 2013 to see all that happen.”)

He’s no friend of Catholicism to be sure, but it weakens your case when you make such comparisons.
Monsters? Do forum rules allow us to make uncharitable remarks, such as that example of name calling, about politicians, such as Hitler or Stalin? You would be one of the first to go running to the moderator if someone called Obama a monster. Can you play by the rules?

Now, when did Hitler or Stalin build concentration camps or extermination camps or re-education camps? When did they open gas chambers with which to kill Catholics? When did they have Catholic and Protestant churches shut down, priests and ministers arrested, clergy put against the wall for the firing squads?

Ahh, I see! It took far less than the first year of their second term in office, so we should be just fine!

Here’s a chance for you to make a strong case.
 
When? When did they do that? First day in office? Office? Yes, let’s not forget, Hitler was elected!
That excused his actions subsequently?
Monsters? Do forum rules allow us to make uncharitable remarks, such as that example of name calling, about politicians, such as Hitler or Stalin?
I believe that the Moderators will give me a pass for calling Hitler and Stalin monsters.
You would be one of the first to go running to the moderator if someone called Obama a monster. Can you play by the rules?
Nonsense.
Now, when did Hitler or Stalin build concentration camps or extermination camps or re-education camps? When did they open gas chambers with which to kill Catholics? When did they have Catholic and Protestant churches shut down, priests and ministers arrested, clergy put against the wall for the firing squads?
You deny all that. I’ll leave it to others on the Forum to decide if I have been unfair to those two.
 
When? When did they do that? First day in office? Office? Yes, let’s not forget, Hitler was elected!

Monsters? Do forum rules allow us to make uncharitable remarks, such as that example of name calling, about politicians, such as Hitler or Stalin? You would be one of the first to go running to the moderator if someone called Obama a monster. Can you play by the rules?

Now, when did Hitler or Stalin build concentration camps or extermination camps or re-education camps? When did they open gas chambers with which to kill Catholics? When did they have Catholic and Protestant churches shut down, priests and ministers arrested, clergy put against the wall for the firing squads?

Ahh, I see! It took far less than the first year of their second term in office, so we should be just fine!

Here’s a chance for you to make a strong case.
I’m a little confused by this post. Is it your intent to defend Hitler and Stalin? If so, I would recommend two books:

“The Black Book of Communism: Crimes, Terror, Repression,” Edited by Mark Kramer,
and “Bloodlands: Europe Between Hitler and Stalin,” by Timothy Snyder.
 
T

You deny all that. I’ll leave it to others on the Forum to decide if I have been unfair to those two.
When? When did they do that? First day in office? Office? Yes, let’s not forget, Hitler was elected!

Now, when did Hitler or Stalin build concentration camps or extermination camps or re-education camps? When did they open gas chambers with which to kill Catholics? When did they have Catholic and Protestant churches shut down, priests and ministers arrested, clergy put against the wall for the firing squads?

**Ahh, I see! It took far less than the first year of their second term in office, so we should be just fine! **

Here’s a chance for you to make a strong case.
I think he meant it took Hitler quite a few years of being in office before he put he fully realized his dream.
 
I’m a little confused by this post. Is it your intent to defend Hitler and Stalin? If so, I would recommend two books:

“The Black Book of Communism: Crimes, Terror, Repression,” Edited by Mark Kramer,
and “Bloodlands: Europe Between Hitler and Stalin,” by Timothy Snyder.
Naw, you’re not confused, you just need to think about it for another minute, in light of Rich’s post.

We’re not allowed to say, “wait until 2013”, so I guess if he didn’t do it by now, he won’t, because Hitler built the camps in a day.

It doesn’t matter if the logic is faulty. The end justifies the means.

Not to me.
 
That excused his actions subsequently?
By your logic, it appears so.
I believe that the Moderators will give me a pass for calling Hitler and Stalin monsters.
You uncharitably accuse the moderators of some sort of selective enforcement of the rules. If we can’t call Obama a monster, we shouldn’t be able to call any politician a monster. Just because Rich Olszewski says so is a lousy reason.
Nonsense.
Playing by the rules is not nonsense to me.
You deny all that. I’ll leave it to others on the Forum to decide if I have been unfair to those two.
You skew my words, so let’s leave it to the others. I see qui got the drift.
 
By your logic, it appears so.
Cite the post where I approved of Hitler or Stalin.
You uncharitably accuse the moderators of some sort of selective enforcement of the rules.
Cite the post.
If we can’t call Obama a monster, we shouldn’t be able to call any politician a monster.
Are you saying that Hitler and Stalin were just politicians?
Just because Rich Olszewski says so is a lousy reason.
Actually, the best reason I can think of.
Playing by the rules is not nonsense to me.
Good for you.
You skew my words, so let’s leave it to the others.
Read my posts. I skewed nothing. I see JimG was also confused by your post.
 
I think he meant it took Hitler quite a few years of being in office before he put he fully realized his dream.
He was realizing a dream, Christine? Not quite the words I would have used to describe Hitler’s intentions and actions.

If that is what that poster meant, I think he could have said so himself.
 
Cite the post where I approved of Hitler or Stalin
There’s no comparing him with those monsters. He’s not having concentration camps or extermination camps or re-education camps built. He hasn’t opened gas chambers with which to kill Catholics. He hasn’t had Catholic and Protestant churches shut down, priests and ministers arrested and “disappeared,” and to the best of my knowledge, no clergy have been put against the wall for the firing squads. And, Christians of all stripes and Jews as well can oppose him without risking an unmarked shallow grave. (And please, don’t say, “just wait unitl 2013 to see all that happen.”).

He’s no friend of Catholicism to be sure, but it weakens your case when you make such comparisons.
Cite the post.
I believe that the Moderators will give me a pass for calling Hitler and Stalin monsters
Are you saying that Hitler and Stalin were just politicians?
If I wanted to say that they were just politicians, I would have done so. I didn’t. But they were politicians. Obama is a politician. No name calling means no name calling. It doesn’t mean no name calling, unless you’re Rich Olszewski. It doesn’t mean no name calling of those on Rich Olszewski’s list of approved politicians.
Actually, the best reason I can think of.
You are advocating hypocrisy and double standards here on CAF. Keep going. Let’s see how far you can go to defend Obama.
Good for you.
What do we say of you since you do not play by the rules?
Read my posts. I skewed nothing. I see JimG was also confused by your post.
I read your post. You skewed my words. You said I denied something I didn’t deny. It appears you were purposely evasive of my question because you knew where it was going. Jim was not accusatory. You were. He admitted he was confused, so as not to make a false assumption. Hopefully I cleared that up for him. Why did qui understand perfectly? Lack of bias?

The point of the whole conversation is that we should be able to see where history is going to repeat itself again. We will be doomed to repeat our mistakes that we did not learn from. Never again will be again and again.

And that’s DEFINITELY on topic.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top