On the Queen's Diamond Jubilee

  • Thread starter Thread starter Terry_Washingto
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
T

Terry_Washingto

Guest
Sixty glorious years on the throne- God Bless Your Majesty! In practice I will take things pretty much easily, maybe have a steak, french fries and a pint of cider on June 5(by happy coincidence our patron saint(Boniface)'s feast day but that’s about it, but I won’t be joining any street parties.
As always we read whinges by the likes of Socialist Worker, the Morning Star and the Guardian about the inherent unfairness of why one being should by accident of birth get to have all that wealth and prestige, but it’s easy to forget that Britain devoid of the Monarchy would be,as Tony Parsons in today’s Daily Mirror(www.dailymirror. co.uk, June 2, 2012) be an infinitely drabber and meaner place than it is now-closer in spirit to North Korea or Cuba I daresay- significantly both nations although ostensibly Communist are virtual dynasties anyway. Also conveniently overlooked is that the Queen(and to a lesser extent the other Royals even the curmudgeonly Duke of Edinburgh) WORKS for a living-check her appointment schedule and long after she would have been entitled to a pension and a free Travelcard had she been anything other than the Sovereign?
No I am neither a fanatical monarchist OR a fanatical republican(history and personal experience have taught me all too well of the perils of being a fanatical ANYTHING).
So what do YOU think?

Terry
 
Use Jubilee to restore moral values, says Anglican bishop
The Rt Rev Richard Chartres, the Bishop of London, said promiscuity, separation and divorce have reached epidemic proportions in Britain and that the Jubilee was an opportunity to think about the kind of environment being bequeathed to future generations.
He said although people were better off since the Queen’s accession to the throne in 1952, material progress had come at the expense of equality and communal life.
The pamphlet, called “In Jubilee then and now: A big idea for the 21st century”, has been sent to all MPs and is being widely distributed. In it Dr Chartres states: “As we celebrate the Jubilee of our justly popular monarch, we have an opportunity to ask some wider questions in the spirit of Jubilee, to pause, look back and ask where we are as a nation, and where we are going.”
telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/the_queens_diamond_jubilee/9307231/Use-Jubilee-to-restore-moral-values-says-bishop.html
 
Except you can’t blame the Queen for the pill:p

There’s not many people around who have her dedication and work ethic, or who could handle her schedule.

Apparently she costs the British people less than presidents of other democracies cost their countries, and she draws tourism. How many people pay to go to the USA to wave at Obama? 😃

She’s Canada’s head of state too, and costs us next to nothing:thumbsup:
 
Indeed, God Bless her.

Though I don’t consider her the legitimate monarch, I still wish her the best of luck and many years to go. Mostly because I dread the thought of having Prince William or Harry as King.
 
I think it’s been calculated that she costs us here in the UK about 75 pence a head per year . Call it a pound, as that was a few years ago. What’s that, about a dollar fifty?

Good value, as millions are raised by tourism.
 
We had recently gotten television and I remember watching her coronation. Even in fuzzy black and white I was impressed. I was young enough to be overjoyed that there really was a princess who could become queen.

Besides, she likes horses. 🙂
 
Indeed, God Bless her.

Though I don’t consider her the legitimate monarch, I still wish her the best of luck and many years to go. Mostly because I dread the thought of having Prince William or Harry as King.
why do you not consider her the legitimate monarch?

i she tied with queen victoria now for the number of years on the throne?
she definitely does have a good work ethic and a sense of duty - no one can deny that.
i wish her well and hope she will be able to remain on the throne for a few more years.
i wonder if she has ever had to do laundry or iron clothes or anything like that? what a life!

i think prince william would make a fine king. not so sure about charles or harry though.

anyhow, i think queen elizabeth ii is really something. i saw her on a boat on the Thames leading a flotilla. i hope she really enjoys her diamond jubilee!!
 
why do you not consider her the legitimate monarch?
I have two problems with the legitimacy of the House of Windsor:

I. When they revolted against good King James, they substituted the heretic William of Orange in. However that just isn’t how legitimacy works. Might doesn’t make Right, it never has! Illegitimacy should never be used just to make someone happy. Parliament said that since His Majesty, James II fled to Frnace, that he had abdicated. But that isn’t true, a King remains a King even on foreign soil.

Though I am not British, I recognize HRM Franz, Duke of Bavaria as the true British King, but I digress.

II. Parliament recently passed that law of succession. That a girl born before a boy could succeed the throne in spite of her brother. I’m sorry, but I cannot reconcile that with hundreds of years of one way. Her brother will be the true heir apparant regardless.

Now don’t even get me STARTED on France! 😛

~ Pius :knight1:
 
Now don’t even get me STARTED on France! 😛
Actually, I am curious about your views on this. I’d imagine you would go with Prince Louis Alphonse (Bourbon) or Prince Charles-Philippe (Orleans). I’d go with Prince Jean-Christophe (Bonaparte).
 
Actually, I am curious about your views on this. I’d imagine you would go with Prince Louis Alphonse (Bourbon) or Prince Charles-Philippe (Orleans). I’d go with Prince Jean-Christophe (Bonaparte).
You would be correct. I “side” with HRM Louis XX, the Legitimist Pretender. I have a deep admiration for the Bourbon’s.

I myself am descended from an defunct and illegitimate Noble family that I am reluctant to name as I haven’t quite substantiated the history so I wont make any claims as of yet. 😉
 
I have two problems with the legitimacy of the House of Windsor:

I. When they revolted against good King James, they substituted the heretic William of Orange in. However that just isn’t how legitimacy works. Might doesn’t make Right, it never has! Illegitimacy should never be used just to make someone happy. Parliament said that since His Majesty, James II fled to Frnace, that he had abdicated. But that isn’t true, a King remains a King even on foreign soil.
Of course might makes right, this is politics we’re talking about. Usually it’s whoever wins a war gets to be king and that’s the end of it (see: William the Conqueror who himself was illegitimate, and Alfred the Great and his line because otherwise it would have been Daneland).

Also, it was largely established (speaking of the British constitution is debatable because most of it is unwritten convention) at the time that true sovereignty rested with Parliament above all. Charles II was established as the monarch by invitation of Parliament, and England had effectively been a constitutional monarchy since the Magna Carta in the 13th century.

People liked to pretend about heredity and everything, but the truth is that the sovereign is whoever people recognize and whoever had the authority to rule. If James II wanted to remain king he should have raised his own army and fought for it as was the standard of the time (see: English Civil War), because just going away in the standard of the time is effectively abdicating.

Anyways, God Save the Queen. :cool:
 
Of course might makes right, this is politics we’re talking about.
Certainly not! The populace never makes legitimacy.
Usually it’s whoever wins a war gets to be king and that’s the end of it (see: William the Conqueror who himself was illegitimate, and Alfred the Great and his line because otherwise it would have been Daneland).
It must be remembered that William obtained the support of the Holy Father, Supreme Pontiff and Vicar of Christ. With that, he was legitimate and was coronated as such.
People liked to pretend about heredity and everything, but the truth is that the sovereign is whoever people recognize and whoever had the authority to rule. If James II wanted to remain king he should have raised his own army and fought for it as was the standard of the time (see: English Civil War), because just going away in the standard of the time is effectively abdicating.
He did fight back. He raised an army in Ireland and attempted to raise a Royal Revolution. This utterly flopped at the Battle of the Boyne. The same battle that the Orange Order (named after William of Orange) taunt Catholics with every July 1st. After that he fled to France, plotting his return till he expired. The Irish referred to him as Seamus an Chaca, I’d translate but its slightly indecent, so I’ll refrain 😃
Anyways, God Save the Queen. :cool:
And may God help the King over the Water!
 
For all our British friends, Beethoven’s Seven Variations on God Save the Queen.

I read that it was commissioned by some businessmen from Glasgow (Glasgovians?) and I figured he must have been glad to have a cash customer.
But Ludwig must have had an Anglophile streak, he also did variations on “Rule Britannia” and Wellington’s victory.
 
For all our British friends, Beethoven’s Seven Variations on God Save the Queen.

I read that it was commissioned by some businessmen from Glasgow (Glasgovians?) and I figured he must have been glad to have a cash customer.
But Ludwig must have had an Anglophile streak, he also did variations on “Rule Britannia” and Wellington’s victory.
Glaswegians 😉

And it was probably a royalist streak - not to mention being fond of British mythology as well as Nordic/Germanic. Tristan and Isolde was based on British myth, as was Parsifal (=Percival of Holy Grail/King Arthur fame).
 
I have two problems with the legitimacy of the House of Windsor:

I. When they revolted against good King James, they substituted the heretic William of Orange in. However that just isn’t how legitimacy works. Might doesn’t make Right, it never has! Illegitimacy should never be used just to make someone happy. Parliament said that since His Majesty, James II fled to Frnace, that he had abdicated. But that isn’t true, a King remains a King even on foreign soil.

Though I am not British, I recognize HRM Franz, Duke of Bavaria as the true British King, but I digress.

II. Parliament recently passed that law of succession. That a girl born before a boy could succeed the throne in spite of her brother. I’m sorry, but I cannot reconcile that with hundreds of years of one way. Her brother will be the true heir apparant regardless.

Now don’t even get me STARTED on France! 😛

~ Pius :knight1:
who is or was, HRM Franz, Duke of Bavaria and why do you recognize him as the true British King?
why do you not think William would be a good king?
do you think the monarchy will remain in england for generations to come?
 
Certainly not! The populace never makes legitimacy.
:rotfl:

Oh, you were actually serious about that. I guess you don’t believe in the legitimacies of republics then.

You must be one of those people who actually still believes in the Divine Right of Kings.
It must be remembered that William obtained the support of the Holy Father, Supreme Pontiff and Vicar of Christ. With that, he was legitimate and was coronated as such.
Ah, so might does make right as long as you have the Pope’s support.

I guess the nation of Italy is not legitimate then, since the Italian unification was spearheaded by the Kingdom of Sardinia and seized the Papal States by force. Except of course when legitimacy was retconned with a dictator whose legitimacy was actually questionable, but the action itself begs the question because to negotiate with another country is to recognize it’s legitimacy (you can’t negotiate treaties with a non-sovereign nation, simply by definition). So legitimacy was recognized prior to the treaty, and therefore excludes the need for explicit Papal recognition. Logic is great.
He did fight back. He raised an army in Ireland and attempted to raise a Royal Revolution. This utterly flopped at the Battle of the Boyne. The same battle that the Orange Order (named after William of Orange) taunt Catholics with every July 1st. After that he fled to France, plotting his return till he expired. The Irish referred to him as Seamus an Chaca, I’d translate but its slightly indecent, so I’ll refrain 😃
Exactly, and lost.

The trick is that you can really only have sovereignty as long as you can keep it and use it. If you can’t maintain control then you are not a sovereign. That’s basic social contract.
 
Interesting. I am not a supporter of monarchies in general. And I think I’m in good company - look at God’s reaction in the Old Testament when the people of Israel ask for a king to replace their judges. 🤷
 
who is or was, HRM Franz, Duke of Bavaria and why do you recognize him as the true British King?
Franz, Duke of Bavaria is the hereditary Duke of Bavaria. The Stuart line of Kings went on through a number of dynasties. Currently it is held within the House of Wittelsbach and as such, Franz is the head of that House. Naturally since the Stuart line was wrongly deposed, he is the true King while Elizabeth II is a “usurper” of sorts. A Duchess of Hanover on the English Throne.
why do you not think William would be a good king
I’m not a fan of Princess Diana, and a lot of people see her in William. William spent a night sleeping with the homeless under a bridge. For Heaven’s sake, he’s a Prince! That somewhat defies noblesse oblige.
do you think the monarchy will remain in england for generations to come?
Yes, most certainly. And though I don’t recognize Elizabeth II as Queen, she is a better thought than socialism or a fickle and ever changing republic.

Also, to Curlycool89 - I can’t respond right now, I’ll respond sometime tomorrow afternoon.
 
Franz, Duke of Bavaria is the hereditary Duke of Bavaria. The Stuart line of Kings went on through a number of dynasties. Currently it is held within the House of Wittelsbach and as such, Franz is the head of that House. Naturally since the Stuart line was wrongly deposed, he is the true King while Elizabeth II is a “usurper” of sorts. A Duchess of Hanover on the English Throne.

I’m not a fan of Princess Diana, and a lot of people see her in William. William spent a night sleeping with the homeless under a bridge. For Heaven’s sake, he’s a Prince! That somewhat defies noblesse oblige.

Yes, most certainly. And though I don’t recognize Elizabeth II as Queen, she is a better thought than socialism or a fickle and ever changing republic.

Also, to Curlycool89 - I can’t respond right now, I’ll respond sometime tomorrow afternoon.
Thanks for the laugh:thumbsup:

I presume you meant to be funny:p
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top